MacBook Pro Declared 'Best Performing' Windows Laptop

eh probably true, better be when you pay twice the price for it compared to a dell or something of similar specs
 
one would think with all the self-proclaimed tech heads in the thread there would be some more craigslist savvy members who would be able to find current gen mbp's in the $600-850 price range.
 
one would think with all the self-proclaimed tech heads in the thread there would be some more craigslist savvy members who would be able to find current gen mbp's in the $600-850 price range.

If I am about to spend $850 on a laptop, I'd sure as hell want something with better specs than a Macbook.
 
fairly clear you have no idea what you're talking about at this point
 
Um, riiight.
Didn't know that Windows come pre-loaded on Macs?
Also, isn't there a lock on the system to prevent other OSes installations?

You. Turn your geek card in now. You fail at being [H]ard.
 
Well Duh! Its a Real Intel Laptop. But the hardware is the same as a PC laptop. Mackbook pro has Intel HD graphics LG DVD drive some of them. Kingston DDR3 Intel Chipset and CPU. Other Laptop fail because they don't build them with ceritifed chipsets or other hardware.

/facewall

You do realize there is no "un-certified" chipsets for Intel processors right? Or AMD processors for that matter...

Intel HD Graphics is built into the CPU. Every PC has that too.

Kingston DDR3 is just the same as Micron, or Samsung, or Hynix, or any other memory vendor. In fact, Apple doesn't even source from Kingston. They source from Hynix, Elpedia, and Samsung.

Most of the Macbooks now don't even have DVD burners in them. DVD burners are a dime a dozen.
 
http://hackaday.com/2013/04/22/connect-a-retina-display-to-a-regular-computer/
http://emerythacks.blogspot.com/2013/04/connecting-ipad-retina-lcd-to-pc.html

The "retina" LCD panel is LP097QX1-SPA1 manufactured by LG.
It's a 9.7" panel with a resolution of 2048x1536!
It's not exclusive to Apple, it can already be found in a couple of Chinese tablets.

The panel is also surprisingly cheap - I got mine on ebay for $55, shipped from China.


The FPC of the panel has 51 really tiny pins, and requires a special connector to mate with a PCB. You can find it online just by looking for "ipad3 lcd connector", but I've figured out that it's a Molex 502250-5191 connector. The cheapest I could find was $14 for two of them at aliexpress.

Cool, no? Besides all the C|NET BS.
 
So I can either pay $400-500 for a sensible Windows laptop that likely will be just as powerful as the MacBook or I can pay $1300+ for a MacBook with the only advantage being that I'll be paying almost $800 for a Retina display?

Wow , what a well written article :rolleyes:
 
That's funny, nobody seems to bother mentioning that the fans go crazy if you try running Windows in Boot Camp. It's also pretty much unusable on the Retina display unless you can bear an ugly upscaled UI.
 
one would think with all the self-proclaimed tech heads in the thread there would be some more craigslist savvy members who would be able to find current gen mbp's in the $600-850 price range.

Moot point. You can find the other laptops used as well, likely for a lower % considering Apple products hold value better.
 
Well Duh! Its a Real Intel Laptop. But the hardware is the same as a PC laptop. Mackbook pro has Intel HD graphics LG DVD drive some of them. Kingston DDR3 Intel Chipset and CPU. Other Laptop fail because they don't build them with ceritifed chipsets or other hardware.

I seriously hope you are trying to be sarcastic.

Or do you think that non-Mac laptops use countefeit hardware?
 
As an IT pro who slings a rMBP (when I need a mobile) for a living I wholeheartedly agree with this article. Funny how most of the posters who agree are also guys who use a computer to get food. The display alone is worth it when your staring at the thing for hours (I'll gladly pay the premium a retina display costs so as to not have migraines). Nice keyboards (not old thinkpad t series nice), awesome track pads and kick ass build quality. Well worth every penny I have paid for it and will keep buying them till Lenovo makes a T series with as nice a display.
 
itt, people who have owned/used mbp's and aren't poor...

and then there's everybody else.
 
What the hell is a Soluto score. I'm assuming the lower the better... in which case why is the 15" Retina so much worse than the 13" pro?
 
Are we really surprised at something like this posted on C|Net? Apple product comes out on top...amazing.:rolleyes:
 
its not really scary its partially true, the whole point of apples own custom "bios" EFI was to prevent easy installation on their hardware and make it seem to the uninformed that it wasn't just a PC with a different OS. In apple everything is different right? Bootcamp is just dual booting the thing we have been doing for years on any computer, but on a mac is bootcamp lol.
 
I know I'm going to get eaten alive for saying this, but as much as I love custom built Windows desktops, the situation with Windows notebooks right now is pretty dire. The build quality on most of them is absolutely atrocious. There's no attention to detail. They seem to e plagued with bizarre issues as if no one actually tested them in most cases. Apple is one of the only companies still building notebooks to any kind of standard. Also, the magsafe connector is such an awesome thing, I can't believe the PC OEMs didn't go to something similar ages ago. Busted DC jacks are so common on laptops.
 
I know I'm going to get eaten alive for saying this, but as much as I love custom built Windows desktops, the situation with Windows notebooks right now is pretty dire. The build quality on most of them is absolutely atrocious. There's no attention to detail. They seem to e plagued with bizarre issues as if no one actually tested them in most cases. Apple is one of the only companies still building notebooks to any kind of standard. Also, the magsafe connector is such an awesome thing, I can't believe the PC OEMs didn't go to something similar ages ago. Busted DC jacks are so common on laptops.

You get what you pay for?
 
We have a MBP. Very well engineered. (although HDD failed at <100 hours.)

However, I use a 18" laptop when I have to do work-work. Nothing like a full sized real keyboard and a big screen and more than 2 USB ports. More like a portable desktop, but that's what works best as a remote desktop.

For the price of the MBP15, you can get a lot more keyboard, more ports, more GPU, more ghz, and a full sized screen. Which is what you use to get work done.

If you are web browsing or watching videos, a $400 computer gets it done.

Apple makes a good product, but some fantasy that a 15" screen and goofy keyboard is better for getting work done is silly.
 
If I could get a 16:10 screen in a PC, I would. Until then, screw every single display maker besides apple. My next laptop will probably be a MBP. And I hate macs!
 
As an IT pro who slings a rMBP (when I need a mobile) for a living I wholeheartedly agree with this article. Funny how most of the posters who agree are also guys who use a computer to get food. The display alone is worth it when your staring at the thing for hours (I'll gladly pay the premium a retina display costs so as to not have migraines). Nice keyboards (not old thinkpad t series nice), awesome track pads and kick ass build quality. Well worth every penny I have paid for it and will keep buying them till Lenovo makes a T series with as nice a display.

Have you heard of Frankenpads (Thinkpad with transplanted LCD, sometimes CPU, mobo, etc?)

Let me tantalize you:

IMG_2116.jpg

T61p with 15" WUXGA (1900x1200) IPS display (granted, not the OS I would have chosen but...)

Lots of info can be found on thinkpads.com/forum/.

Also my post #49 in summary:
Connect A Retina display to a regular-computer
http://hackaday.com/2013/04/22/conne...ular-computer/
http://emerythacks.blogspot.com/2013...lcd-to-pc.html

$55 for 9.7" Retina plus $15 for converter, some soldering thanks to DisplayPort! Woot!


So I can either pay $400-500 for a sensible Windows laptop that likely will be just as powerful as the MacBook or I can pay $1300+ for a MacBook with the only advantage being that I'll be paying almost $800 for a Retina display?

Wow , what a well written article :rolleyes:

Well, when you're on a deadline and trying to be trendy... :)

Also since I'm too lazy to look up comparable laptops in the $700-800 range

thedailybeast.com - 5 Reasons I Hate My New MacBook Pro: A Geek’s Critique
 
I can agree with the article. Nothing beats the trackpad on Mac laptops. Also, if you want a high-res display, there's no other options. I do heavy programming work and the rMBP is a joy to work on.

And lol at the people saying they can buy a comparable Windows laptop (minus the retina display) for $400-500. Nothing with good build quality in that range, I'm sorry...

All in all, I sure haven't felt like I overpaid for my rMBP
 
ninjaturtle said:
Also, isn't there a lock on the system to prevent other OSes installations?

To be fair, every current Windows 8 certified laptop has a software version of this in the BIOS. It's called secure boot and is enabled by default. Makes the computer ignore anything other then Windows 8.
 
the only laptop in recent memory with a build Quality even close to the mbpro is the XPS Ultra books, the latitudes and precision series aren't bad either but also bulky, but by the time you configure one your close the same price as the mbpro and still no retina display

the 19x12 screen on the t61 above is still no where close to retina display @ 2880x1800...after using 2560x1440 for so long even the 1080p screens leave me wanting more space for productivity

As people have mentioned pretty much any laptops under 800 bucks or so these days are disposable plastic garbage for the most part, and when you do find a decent build in that range you need to upgrade to ssd, high res screen, decent graphics card which quickly places it much closer to the mbpro

even most of the IBM (Lenovo) models arent the well built tanks they were prior to the Lenovo takeover
 
To be fair, every current Windows 8 certified laptop has a software version of this in the BIOS. It's called secure boot and is enabled by default. Makes the computer ignore anything other then Windows 8.

That's an Intel thing as isn't software. It will ignore any OS that isn't signed with the right key, which at the moment only Microsoft and a few others have gone for. But you can usually (if the maker allows) just disable secure boot and install whatever.
 
Note: a 2880 pixel wide 15" == 1920 x 10" diagonal.

I'm sure it's great for watching movies (as long as they aren't 3D or Blueray), but when screen is set for max display room for multiple applications, Size Does Matter.

The normal font on a 2560 x 30" screen is pretty small. If I had a screen 1/2 the size, I'd have to bump the font size, losing real estate for multi-tasking.

I'd love a 2880 desktop screen, but I'm afraid it would be wasted for a notebook.
 
the 19x12 screen on the t61 above is still no where close to retina display @ 2880x1800...after using 2560x1440 for so long even the 1080p screens leave me wanting more space for productivity

Yea, 2880x1800 in a *thirteen-inch* screen! (If you are talking about the MBP featured in this article.) How can you put 13" and 2880x1800 together in the same sentence without busting out laughing?...;) "More space for productivity"...? With 13" you have *no space* to begin with! You could say it was 2k x 2k and you would still have no room, imo. Man, last time I used a 13" monitor was back in the mid-80's....I'll pass....

I tell you what isn't comparable...1920x1200 in a 28" monitor blows away 2880x1800 on a 13" (or 15"--not much difference there.)

This is perhaps slightly unfair since I loathe laptops and always have--all of them drastically compromise what I like about personal computing on the black-hole altar of battery life (doesn't matter who makes them)...but still, I cannot put 13" and "productivity" together in the same sentence, either.

And what is "Retina", anyway, except a marketing term with no technical definition? Steve Jobs (RIP) once said "Retina" had to be 300 ppi or greater (to correspond with 300 dpi printing on a dot matrix > decade ago, when you had to print @ 300 dpi to get smooth-edge lettering.) MBP Retina isn't actually "Retina" at all, it seems. But since Apple has decided that the term Retina actually has no meaning...why do people bother talking about it? Talking about migraine headaches--looking at a 13" screen all day would certainly give me the motha' of all migraines...! Ugh.
 
Have you heard of Frankenpads (Thinkpad with transplanted LCD, sometimes CPU, mobo, etc?)

Let me tantalize you:

IMG_2116.jpg

T61p with 15" WUXGA (1900x1200) IPS display (granted, not the OS I would have chosen but...)

Lots of info can be found on thinkpads.com/forum/.

Also my post #49 in summary:
Connect A Retina display to a regular-computer
http://hackaday.com/2013/04/22/conne...ular-computer/
http://emerythacks.blogspot.com/2013...lcd-to-pc.html

$55 for 9.7" Retina plus $15 for converter, some soldering thanks to DisplayPort! Woot!




Well, when you're on a deadline and trying to be trendy... :)

Also since I'm too lazy to look up comparable laptops in the $700-800 range

thedailybeast.com - 5 Reasons I Hate My New MacBook Pro: A Geek’s Critique

Shut up and take my money. All jokes aside I actually have a t61 kicking around with a toasted HDD I got in a trade. Think it has an abysmal 1280x800 display. God what a nice keyboard though. Time to do some research it seems.
 
I know I'm going to get eaten alive for saying this, but as much as I love custom built Windows desktops, the situation with Windows notebooks right now is pretty dire. The build quality on most of them is absolutely atrocious. There's no attention to detail. They seem to e plagued with bizarre issues as if no one actually tested them in most cases. Apple is one of the only companies still building notebooks to any kind of standard. Also, the magsafe connector is such an awesome thing, I can't believe the PC OEMs didn't go to something similar ages ago. Busted DC jacks are so common on laptops.

No, you just have to ignore the ones spouting off ignorance and accept the fact that they are ignorant and not nearly as good of techs as they believe they are.

I wouldn't use an iPhone, I wouldn't use a regular Mac and I certainly wouldn't use an iPad. Why? Because as a tech none of them do anything that is particularly valuable to me. However the fact of the matter is as a laptop the macbook pro is just vastly superior to basically anything offered PC wise. Why? Because it is the "ONLY" laptop that i can run OSX, Windows AND Linux all on at the same time and support users equally across all platforms. No regular PC can do that because you cannot install OSX on them. Now if you are in a pure Windows environment (getting pretty rare these days), then sure you can continue running only a PC. However for those of us who have to support mixed environments and aren't jaded assholes who refuse to help customers just because we are tech snobs, the Macbook at this time is untouchable. Also lets be honest, the power cord connector for the macbook is just flatly better.
 
I'll be honest, I used to slam Apple all the time but then the wife got a rMBP (two weeks ago). The laptop is just simply leaps and bounds better than anything else I have ever used. I have a Dell XPS ultrabook, and I have had netbooks, and even a Sager desktop replacement 17" monster while I was deployed.

The trackpad alone is just such an eye opening way of browsing which I never thought possible. I might not know what the hell I am doing in OSX yet, but damn if I can't fly through some safari windows.

The only way I can describe it is it's basically the best in every category other than gaming and price. Nothing comes close, its light, its strong and doesn't bend, its thin, best in class screen, probably the best battery life (certainly better than any of the laptops I have had).
 
They are wrong.

Because 15" > 13"

screen size is entirely dependent on the needs of the user. It has no bearing on scores - or it shouldn't. I would rather have a 13" laptop over a 15" one because it's much lighter and more portable. As a commuter on a train going 1.5 hours each way every day, a 13-inch laptop suits me better. Well, it did anyways - I use my Surface Pro now.
 
Back
Top