Looking to get reliable external hard drive

darkhunter139

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Mar 7, 2008
Messages
6,173
I am looking to get an external hard drive to backup all the pictures from my lightroom catalog. I want it to be at least 1 TB and be pretty reliable. I was looking at the WD mybooks but the reviews dont look very great. Any suggestions?
 
I don't think any one brand of external drive is gonna be more reliable than another at this point... Seagate/WD sell the most of 'em, and they tend to have the longest warranties as well (2-3 years, 5 years on some models) so I'd just go w/whichever gives you the most capacity per $.

I think WD recently trimmed down their line and shuffled off a bunch of old premium models, I haven't seen the older thicker MyBooks at retail stores much... I keep seeing the cheaper My Book Essential line, which is cheaper but it also has a shorter warranty (only 2 yrs IIRC). I believe Seagate's FreeAgent Desk line all have 5 year warranties, FWIW.

Were you looking for a drive to leave at home or a 2.5" portable drive to take with you? The other option is getting an enclosure and a bare drive (each with it's own warranty) and putting the thing together yourself, takes all of 5 min. and it's often cheaper... Sometimes the pre-made retail enclosures due fail and if you rip it open to retrieve the drive inside you obviously void the warranty (but the alternative is sending the whole thing in and losing the backups + time).

The only downside to that is that many or most of the external DIY enclosures don't power down the drive as the pre-made ones do, so it's always running unless you power it down yourself. OTOH many of them come w/e-SATA which seems to be rarer these days amongst the pre-made externals (or they charge you a premium for it). There's even some solid DIY 2.5" enclosures w/e-SATA, I bought a nice aluminum one (made by Ultra) for $25 the other day (to house my netbook's current HD, upgrading it to a SSD).

As far as user reviews, you should take that kinda thing w/a grain of salt ('specially at Newegg and other high-volume retailers)... WD's drives often come w/pre-installed software for instance, which you can easily remove, but people that don't know better are bothered by it and you'll see a dozen negative reviews based off that fact alone.
 
Cool thanks for all the info, I am just looking for a drive to leave at home on my desk just in case my internal drive fails. Ill check out the DIY option what would be a good drive to pop in one of the enclosures?
 
A WD Green if you're concerned about power/heat, otherwise any WD Blue/Black is a good option really. Blue/Black drives run at 7,200 RPM, I think the Black drives have more cache (doesn't make much of a difference) and a longer warranty (5 yrs). 3.5" 1TB drives should be cheap, 2TB will probably carry a premium since they're the largest available right now.
 
Cool thanks, I think I will go with a WD Green drive. Will any enclosure pretty much due?
 
Cool thanks, I think I will go with a WD Green drive. Will any enclosure pretty much due?

Any external 3.5" drive that's going to be powered for more than a couple hours at a time should have an actively cooled enclosure.

If you're just going to use it occasionally for backups, pretty much anything will do.

BTW...I just wanted to commend you for your wise decision to purchase a roll-ur-own external drive.....Nice!
 
Back
Top