LGA 1156 Vs. 1366?

spincut

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jan 19, 2005
Messages
1,191
Ok I just have a rather brief question in this regard, because I haven't really studied much on motherboards for a bit now, I mean the last time I REALLY paid attention it wsa still socket 478 and Socket A :p . I do own a LGA 7xx board now, but yeah, I barely noticed that one come and go :p .

Anyway, my main curiosity is that the LGA1156 seemingly did away with the north bridge in favor of it doing it on board for the CPU, and according to Wikipedia, the LGA 1366, put in a limited functionality north bridge and took some of that functionality then off the CPU, with added pins for I guess memory channels?

So I guess my question is this, firstly, isn't it better to have all the functions on one CPU rather than having some of it on seperate slower north bridge? Even though the latter is the more powerful performance CPU socket?

Also, don't both have DDR3? So what are the extra pins for exactly?
 
I would go for the 1366 especially since the prices have dropped.

I wasn't asking for advice on which one to buy, I never mentioned at any time I was thinking about making a purchase, I literally was curious about the questions I asked.
 
Ok I just have a rather brief question in this regard, because I haven't really studied much on motherboards for a bit now, I mean the last time I REALLY paid attention it wsa still socket 478 and Socket A :p . I do own a LGA 7xx board now, but yeah, I barely noticed that one come and go :p .

Anyway, my main curiosity is that the LGA1156 seemingly did away with the north bridge in favor of it doing it on board for the CPU, and according to Wikipedia, the LGA 1366, put in a limited functionality north bridge and took some of that functionality then off the CPU, with added pins for I guess memory channels?

So I guess my question is this, firstly, isn't it better to have all the functions on one CPU rather than having some of it on seperate slower north bridge? Even though the latter is the more powerful performance CPU socket?

Also, don't both have DDR3? So what are the extra pins for exactly?

I can answer this. The LGA 1366 motherboards support Triple Channel DDR3 as LGA 1156 motherboads only support Dual Channel DDR3. A average user won't notice the difference, but in servers and workstations the extra memory bandwidth comes into play.
 
While both have DDR3 memory, 1366 can use 3 channels of it rather than 2 (that basically all other desktop chipsets use), hence the extra pins.

edit: dang, you got me.

Well, with regards to putting the PCIe controller on the actual chip rather than a northbridge, I think the difference is negligible. It was probably just an advancement that's present on 1156 as a result of it being newer than 1366, and will be present on future chips. There may have been concern that an on-chip (or was it on-die? I get them mixed up) controller would shorten the CPU's lifespan, but I think that concern has pretty much fizzled out.
 
Last edited:
LGA 1366, put in a limited functionality north bridge and took some of that functionality then off the CPU, with added pins for I guess memory channels?

So I guess my question is this, firstly, isn't it better to have all the functions on one CPU rather than having some of it on seperate slower north bridge? Even though the latter is the more powerful performance CPU socket?
I believe that it's a matter of physically having enough room on the chip for all those features. PCI-Express and DMI were taken off the 1366 to make room for tons of extra power connections (most of the extra pins in 1366 are power pins), the extra memory channel, and QPI. The IOH (mini-northbridge) in 1366 runs very hot when used for QPI on dual-CPU systems - perhaps temperature was a concern as well.

Some people did speculate that 1156 would have better graphics performance than 1366 because of the on-die controller, but that doesn't seem to show up in real-world tests.
 
Last edited:
the only thing you gain on s1156 with having most of the NB on the cpu is lower latencies going from CPU to mem and CPU to PCI-E.

When compared to s1366, the latencies going from NB to CPU are a little bit higher, but its really totally negligible.
 
1366 was the first socket used by nahelm chips and was designed to support both the single socket high end desktop market and the dual socket workstation/server market. It has three memory channels, two QPI links (though afaict desktop CPUs only use one) and support for the power requirements of high end processors (which means LOTs of power and graound pins). It marked intels move from the shared front side bus which was increasingly a bottleneck in mult-socket systems to point to point quickpath links.

1156 was a later socket designed for low-midrange desktop chips with more integration (doing away with the IO hub) and less total of everything (only two memory channels, only 16 lanes of fast PCIe)
 
Go with 1366,absolutly the fastest computer ive ever benn on..been building since 1996 and these are awsome systems...
 
Go with 1366,absolutly the fastest computer ive ever benn on..been building since 1996 and these are awsome systems...

I would have assumed that the computers you built prior to this would have been faster. Silly me. :p
 
If you're going to go with an Intel platform, I highly suggest the 1366 platform (and its successor when it arrives). This is the "high end" offering with all the advantages that others have stated, TriChannel RAM, PCIE lanes, chipsets that support both SLI/CrossFireX, the QPI, and exceptionally powerful processors.

1156 I feel is too expensive as a platform for the lesser performance compared to 1366. Those that don't want or cannot afford 1366, I suggest saving a TON of money and investing in AMD AM3, which is MUCH cheaper than Intel and still has solid performance, especially overclocked.
 
Lynnfield/1156 is the better gaming chip by benchmarks. I have had both platforms and cannot tell the difference . You can say the x58 has tri channel(which hasn't made a difference for me and in many programs) and more pci-e lanes, but the performance difference between x8 and x16 lanes is 1% or less. You only need x58 for tri-sli/x-fire or higher so you aren't limited to the x4 slot on P55, which reviews have shown to not bottleneck today's cards like once thought.

I bought my AsRock P55 Extreme and Xeon X3440 (i7 860) for $220 and couldn't be happier with the performance as it was the same exact as the many x58 boards I have gone through and the i7 920.
 
If you're going to go with an Intel platform, I highly suggest the 1366 platform (and its successor when it arrives). This is the "high end" offering with all the advantages that others have stated, TriChannel RAM, PCIE lanes, chipsets that support both SLI/CrossFireX, the QPI, and exceptionally powerful processors.

1156 I feel is too expensive as a platform for the lesser performance compared to 1366. Those that don't want or cannot afford 1366, I suggest saving a TON of money and investing in AMD AM3, which is MUCH cheaper than Intel and still has solid performance, especially overclocked.
Show me the performance difference between 1366 and 1156. Show me
 
The 1156 and 1366 have some differences, I myself have owned both and the performance differences are so minor it isn't even worth it for the average user to buy the 1366, a decent 1156 is cheaper to set up, hands down. NOW before this turns into a shit storm let me clarify. If you are going to use one or two video cards in Sli/Crossfire the performance is very little in terms a a couple of fps or around 2000pts on 3dmark06. The 1156 doesn't have a north bridge, this means ALOT less heat dumped off in the case makes you a happy gamer when your computer doesn't randomly take a shit off in BSOD Land in the middle of a death match or something that demanding and during this your attention is front and center to the point where this could seriously and adversely affect your attitude. :D Now in defense of the 1366 platform, If you are a cronic bench marker, got $2000+ wrapped up in 4 video cards alone don't start skimping on the motherboard and processor then. The X58 has 4 full 16X 2.0 lanes if not more depending on the motherboard. The only way you are going to get that off a P55 is if you get the P55 classified or the MSI Trinergy, (they either have the NF100 chip and/or Hydra chip to give you more lanes) so spending that kind of money is pointless because those Hydra and NF chips that makes this possible are even hotter than the X58 NB in most cases and the boards are ridiculously priced when a good X58 setup will do the same with less cash and heat on a setup like this. The upgrade path on the X58 is alot more room to upgrade processor wise, where as the 1156 is kinda limited, but still would keep you going for quite a while either way. Both yield some serious horse power. All this dual channel vs triple channel is BS. If you do alot of video encoding and photo shop you may notice it gets done like 2 seconds faster?!?!? :confused: I see mixed reviews on all this but real word differences, meh. Buy what will suit your needs and fit the budget and be happy with it. Both are damned good setups.
 
Show me the performance difference between 1366 and 1156. Show me

In real world tests, not artificial benchmarks.

I've build quite a few 1156 and 1366 systems. I've come to the conclusion that the default choice should be a 1156 system unless you specifically need one of the extras the 1366 system provides. For my personal computers, I actually downgraded from a 1366 to a 1156. The 1156 runs quite a bit cooler and it is easier to manage the heat that is produced.

The ONLY computers that I built that showed any difference between the socket types are the ones in our publications department. However are working with huge files within photoshop and Quark and need all the memory bandwidth they can get.
 
In real world tests, not artificial benchmarks.

I've build quite a few 1156 and 1366 systems. I've come to the conclusion that the default choice should be a 1156 system unless you specifically need one of the extras the 1366 system provides. For my personal computers, I actually downgraded from a 1366 to a 1156. The 1156 runs quite a bit cooler and it is easier to manage the heat that is produced.

The ONLY computers that I built that showed any difference between the socket types are the ones in our publications department. However are working with huge files within photoshop and Quark and need all the memory bandwidth they can get.

I did the same. The P55 motherboard I got hold of was nicer than the X58 board I had. And this i5-750 runs cooler @ 4Ghz than the 920 I had at the same speed, and I turned HT off to save heat.
 
I agreed with you guys.

Lynnfield/1156 is the better gaming chip by gaming benchmarks. I have had both platforms and cannot tell the difference. You can say the x58 has tri channel(which hasn't made a difference for me and in many programs) and more pci-e lanes, but the performance difference between x8 and x16 lanes is 1% or less. You only need x58 for tri-sli/x-fire or higher so you aren't limited to the x4 slot on P55, which reviews have shown to not bottleneck today's cards like once thought.

I bought my AsRock P55 Extreme and Xeon X3440 (i7 860) for $220 and couldn't be happier with the performance as it was the same exact as the many x58 boards I have gone through and the i7 920.
 
I've come to the conclusion that the default choice should be a 1156 system unless you specifically need one of the extras the 1366 system provides

IMHO agree. Unless you're specifically building for high-end SLI/X-fire or workstation purposes, the 1156 setup lets you invest some dollars elsewhere without really compromising on good overall performance. I keep recommending 1156 to anyone I know that is gonna roll with a mid/mid-high single GPU and isn't interested in running 5-6 VMs at once while rendering.
 
Back
Top