Kickstarter For A Third Alice Game?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
American McGee wants to know if there is interest in a third installment in the Alice franchise and, if so, would you back it via Kickstarter?

Alice Fans, Questions for you:
  1. If we could get the rights from EA, would you play "Alice 3?"
  2. If you'd play "Alice 3," would you back it on Kickstarter?
  3. If you said "yes" to those two things, make some noise - I'm trying to gauge interest in case I happen to discuss this with EA during GDC in 2 weeks. The more interest there is, the more seriously they'll take the conversation.
 
I thought the latest one sold well. Can't he use that money to make a new one?
 
I thought the latest one sold well. Can't he use that money to make a new one?

Since EA owns the rights I think he is trying to see if it is worth buying the rights from EA and how much they might charge

I think the developers who have lost their rights to publishers would be better off pursuing parallel or similar IPs (like Project Eternity or Torment) rather than buying the original IP back ... or looking for some of the quality abandonware out there
 
Considering EA has stated that if a franchise doesn't sell 5 million then it isn't worth continuing, I would find EA hardpressed to continue it. I mean, they killed Dead Space for the same reason.
 
Couldnt he just continue it on his own anyway? Through the Looking Glass is public domain as it is
 
If we could get the rights from EA, would you play "Alice 3?"

I don't think this is going to happen...he/they sold their souls to EA. The likelihood that EA will give it back is 0.

Hopefully more developer studios are watching and learning from the Sim City debacle.
 
If it happens, i hope it isn't as awful as Madness Returns. I really couldn't get into that, and I have the original Alice game still in 'vorpal blade' box; loved that one.
 
If EA is totally unrelated and it's not DRMed (other than maybe Steam, which at least isn't too obtrusive compared to EA's junk) then I would probably fund this if it were like $30.
 
I'll do it on two conditions:
- It's better than the second game.
- Rights, trademarks and property is taken away from EA's hands.

Last thing I want to see is a multiplayer version of Alice with multiple DLCs just to give me new weapons and new storylines to actually finish the game.
 
I loved the first Alice, the 2nd one was ok but didn't have that same level of flair that the 1st one did even though it was defiantly a beautiful game, and I would defiantly buy a 3rd Alice game if EA wasn't involved. However as I don't see that happening I don't see EA getting any more of my money.
 
I'll do it on two conditions:
- It's better than the second game.
- Rights, trademarks and property is taken away from EA's hands.

Last thing I want to see is a multiplayer version of Alice with multiple DLCs just to give me new weapons and new storylines to actually finish the game.
 
I thought the latest one sold well. Can't he use that money to make a new one?

I don't know exactly how the divide the revenue, but since they are making the game for EA (as EA funded and owns it), perhaps EA gets a huge cut of it (if not paying them per project and EA keep the rest)
 
If it happens, i hope it isn't as awful as Madness Returns. I really couldn't get into that, and I have the original Alice game still in 'vorpal blade' box; loved that one.

Just finished madness returns last night. The first half of the game was ok, loved the art direction. By the second half I just wanted it to be over (the last quarter of the game was painfully monotonous).

I think a new game based on through the looking glass could have potential if it goes back to the original's roots. I'd kick in ~$20 for something like that.
 
The more interest voiced = the more likely they will do Alice 3 themselves and offer Day 0 DLC.
 
So now its not just enough to have a hit game, the consumers have to pay for the next title, WTF?!? I mean its going to be great seeing American McGee name back on it, but still WTF?!?
 
If the third Alice didn't have the same bloody enemies and bosses showing up throughout the game, and was more like the first one...Then yes I would be interested.
 
Loved the first one. Bought the second, but it's in my backlog that I haven't got around to playing yet...
 
I don't know what it was about the second one...

I mean the enemies looked nice, if a little repetitive, the combat was ok, the level aesthetics were good, the design was ok...though all of the levels felt a little...short. It was just missing something. I think it was pacing. there were times when something nice happened, but it was over 5 seconds later. One problem might have been it was like the first game, but the first game was original, this one wasn't so much (though the first game did have really annoying jumping sections :D).

I don't really see any negative EA input. I mean there was Origin exclusive preorder outfits, but you can get those on steam by changing a txt file... but being produced by another developer probably wouldn't have changed anything TBH.
 
I will NEVER buy another EA game. PERIOD. If it comes out under another publisher, I will strongly consider a purchase, but if it comes out with an EA logo, no sale.
 
Loved the first game.
Abhored the second one. Consolitis to the max, and very repetitive gameplay = No fun.

I would maybe buy a 3rd game, but if it was anything like the 2nd, then EA can keep it.
I would NOT kickstart this, just because of how bad 2 was.
 
I love this idea. Make the fans bare all of the risks, and take 100% of the profits. Let the sucker fans do this, and fight for the right to pay the company a salary, and make it sound like Mcgee is doing everyone a favor.

So who's with me? Let's go pay for the rights for the whole fanchise, then hand it over to Fk'n mcgee for the sum of 0.00, and if we're lucky maybe we might get a 'free' copy of the game later on.

F U Mcgee.
 
Loved the first one, really liked the second. They really wrapped the story up with the second one, and I think a third would just be a rehash. If they really think they can pull it off, I would likely buy it. But it would be a wait and see, then wait some more for a deep discount, sort of game to me.

Then again, at this point HL3 would not be a day one buy for me, let alone a pre-order. The devs and pubs have taught me to wait.
 
With all due respect to American McGee, the Alice series has been the only thing going for him for some time. I played Scrapland a few years back and thought it was awful. Still, looking at his wiki he's been a level designer for some games with the best level design. Maybe he should take his talent to Naughty Dog?
 
Still, looking at his wiki he's been a level designer for some games with the best level design. Maybe he should take his talent to Naughty Dog?

So he can make levels for interactive movies? Good one, kid.
 
Played the first Alice, will have to wait for a sale on the second one. Keep hearing it was meh.


Posted from Hardforum.com App for Android
 
Utterly LOVED the first game, it was the perfect balance of creepy, disturbing, fun, and exciting.

Not played the second yet, didnt even hear it had been released. If it's a proper sequil with good plot and controls then sure I'd but it and possibly fund a kickstarter, but if it's as bad as what I'm reading here... maybe it's time to just bury it and start over with a new franchise idea... though I would love to see him making more games with the atmosphere of Alice.
 
Utterly LOVED the first game, it was the perfect balance of creepy, disturbing, fun, and exciting.

Not played the second yet, didnt even hear it had been released. If it's a proper sequil with good plot and controls then sure I'd but it and possibly fund a kickstarter, but if it's as bad as what I'm reading here... maybe it's time to just bury it and start over with a new franchise idea... though I would love to see him making more games with the atmosphere of Alice.

The second game was good, but not as great as the first one. My biggest issue was the camera and controls with the second game. It is a game of patience, literally.

The story was good and if you want to finish Alice's story and learn more about her past, I highly recommend you play it. You'll probably end up like me using the costume for Alice that allows you to see hidden platforms permanently because without it, it's near impossible to do some of the jumping puzzles especially when timed.

Again, if there is a third game, I just hope the following happens:
  • New original storyline OR based on Through the Looking Glass.
  • Gameplay and environments remain unique to the franchise.
  • Better controls and camera angles.
  • No day one DLCs or pre-order bonuses.
  • No DLCs that unlock extra weapons and outfits. I buy the game and everything is already in it. I play the game to unlock the extras even if there is a New Game+ to do so.
  • McGee manages to wrestle control and rights to the game AWAY from EA for the good of the franchise.
  • No always-on DRM and no multiplayer gameplay tacked on because EA or management it was a good idea.
 
Back
Top