Keeping my music close

BioHazard.89

Limp Gawd
Joined
Feb 25, 2004
Messages
229
(Hey guys, I dropped of the tech bandwagon just before 64-bit was dropped and I've been trying to catch up the past few years in a few days.... haha)

I'm going to college in a few months and i'm trying to figure out a way to keep my music collection, 120gb and growing, close and still be able to update my iPods and Shuffles. Right now the collections kind of spread between a few machines, my MacBook that's going to school with me and a HTPC desktop that's kind of just around for a Windows environment. I don't have a problem setting up a RAID on my HTPC, putting all my music there and bringing that to school with me but I'm just wondering if there's a different solution... External hard drive to leave at my desk with my Mac? Leave the HTPC and home and some how connect to it to update my iPod from school? I was unfamiliar with NAS before entering this forum but I could give that a shot too....

Any Suggestions? Hardware and setups?

Thanks!
John-Michael
 
Personally for many years I just stored my entire music collection on a USB 2.0 external HDD. I had no problems. I vote that you consolidate all of your music onto an external drive (make a copy of it on another drive if you have room to be safe). You can bring that wherever you need to.

Syncing your IPOD over the net wouldn't be an option IMHO although I'm sure there is some creative way to make this happen, it would be a very slow process.

Stick with a simple external HDD solution and I think that will meet your needs just fine.
 
I concur. A single external drive with all of your music is the least complicated way of storing all your music
 
Just to play Devil's Advocate, and I know it requires a chunk of time a lot of people would rather use focused on some other task, but...

Back that music up on optical media, and soon. With verification for each and every burn, at half the burner's rated max speed, with excellent quality media like Verbatim.

I know, I know, I know it'll take time, hours to complete the process, but honestly I just don't trust only hard drives or any solution that's basically just one type of backup. I've got a music collection that I've been putting together since I bought my first CD (Dire Straits "Brothers In Arms") way back in 1985 through the past few months with a few choice additions. I don't buy new music CDs anymore brand new off the shelf: I buy them used in CD/DVD trading shops, thrift stores, etc, whenever the chance presents itself.

I then (over the past decades) converted them to FLAC format for backup purposes. I used to have BIN/CUE files for each of them but I prefer just using FLAC nowadays and have for the past 4 years or so. With a CD collection bordering on 2,900 physical discs (all in climate controlled storage), it's been a considerable expense to collect them and I prefer not to handle them constantly. Using FLAC format backed up to DVD+R I can keep my music "close" and listen to it whenever I want as it's all carefully organized, hand-tagged and hand-ripped by me personally.

Using FLAC also allows me a great deal of flexibility when it comes to conversions from FLAC to any audio format I want. I prefer mp3 overall just for its massive compatibility and playback ability on effectively every single DAP (Digital Audio Player) that's ever been created, but in many respects I think Ogg sounds better.

Regardless, I've got about 165 DVDs that have nothing but FLAC files on 'em, in a box sitting right here beside me. Far cry from trying to find space for 2,900+ jewel boxes, eh? :D

And here's the really funny part: the only mp3 player I even own anymore is a simple tiny RCA 256MB device I grabbed from Wal-Mart last year for $40. Has an SD card slot for expansion but I simply never use it. I just copy 50 or so mp3s on it and go. If it gets destroyed or lost, it's barely anything at all. Haven't lost any real music, and $40 gets me another one. Hell, they're practically disposable. :D And my headphones of choice are Koss KSC-75 earclips with a few choice mods from HeadFi.org's forums. They have a lifetime guarantee on 'em, and for about $65 total, you'd be astonished at just how good these devices sound working together.

Anyway, that's my recommendation. Back that collection up to optical media and verify it, slower burn speeds, on quality reliable media, and for the hell of it, use the advice the others presented as well and get a decent external hard drive for ease of use. A bunch of DVDs is a bit unwieldy, but having them around would be infinitely more desirable than having a hard drive die on you.

Consider the loss of a single DVD because of scratch; you'd lose about 4.5GB of music, max. Just a tiny percentage of your entire collection, right?

Now compare that to losing the entire hard drive with a hundred gigs or more of music - the entire collection possibly and then the prospect of having another form of backup becomes a far more appealing prospect.

Right? :D
 
CDs and DVDs can hardly be consider reliable medium any more.
Especially the new cheap ones. How do you guys thing they became so cheap?
IMO Blurays will be even worse when their time comes.

I heard of a recent study saying that most of todays CD/DVD roms will fail in ~5yrs, due to loosing their capability of retaining data information on their crappy layers.
 
i completely disagree with you joe why have 145 dvds surely a better option would be to just buy a 2nd hd? if one fails then buy a third always giving you dual backup much easier to manage
 
I concur. A single external drive with all of your music is the least complicated way of storing all your music

Drobo + Share? downside is its expensive, upside is its got redundancy (some sort of parity array, its a modified raid-5), its about as convenient as you can get both in what happens if you have a failure (pull one drive out, plug in a new one of any size), and in that it allows you to sync with any computer. You can put anything else on it too. good way to back stuff up.
 
I guess the concept of possibly losing a few files, a few gigs, is being lost against the possibility of losing thousands of files, hundreds if not thousands of gigs, but that's just me I guess. :D

I don't deal with cheap low cost hardware: I have a Plextor burner that I would trust over any other optical brand, and I only use Taiyo Yuden media which is arguably the best optical media you can buy. The music, videos, files, whatever it may be are valuable to me - if they weren't I wouldn't have them in the first place, so I wouldn't skimp on just any old $25 burner and those 100 packs of cheap shit blank media.

I did cover that aspect in my post by stating using quality media (Verbatim tends to use TY for their base more often than not) and by burning at less than maximum rated speed (that means for the drive as well as the media) and then verification of the burns afterward. I can't comprehend why people are snapping at me offering an alternative and highly effective secondary option. If you prefer to keep throwing all your shit on magnetic media, that's fine.

But I promise you: more often than not you're more than likely going to have an encounter with a failed hard drive someday. Could be tomorrow, could be next week, but sooner or later you (meaning whoever is reading this) will more than likely find yourself in a situation where you're going to lose data, and I don't mean a scratched DVD or two and a few gigs of data. You're going to find yourself in a situation where you're going to lose hundreds if not thousands of gigs of data and have absolutely no recourse because of it.

I've been working on PCs for decades, and I've seen what a catastrophic loss of data can do to some people, and I'm speaking from a personal perspective, not a commercial or business one.

In the recent past, I've had the displeasure of working on multi-hundred gigabyte hard drives that were considered "brand new" where people transferred hundreds of gigs of personal data, important stuff to them to be sure including video memories, images taken from events in their lives and the lives of families and friends, treasured music performances and recitals (school plays, concerts, etc). I had to be the one in the position of having to inform the owner of the hard drive that their data, all those treasured things, were pretty much gone forever because the drive in question had a bearing failure, or a head crash (I've had 3 of those in the past 6 months, too - honest too goodness physical contact between the heads and the platters, leaving nothing but destruction in their wake... or concentric scratches as the case may have been).

It's not a nice situation to be in, and after working on computers for so long I like to just lay it out to people whether they like it or not. My methodology mentioned above is also subject to potential catastrophic failure, of a sort. The apartment building I live in could go up in flames when I'm not around someday, who knows. Whenever I offer opinions or suggestions, most especially where data backup is concerned, well, they come from a lifetime of experience with backing up data, recovering it, and of course being in that position of telling someone their precious data is forever lost. I won't say it's like being a Doctor and telling a family member their loved one just died under my care, but hey, I feel like complete shit when I can't "fix" a machine or recover data.

Suffice to say I'm being longwinded again.

My suggestion is a valid one, and making a secondary option available for backups, done the right way with a little patience, is far superior than just "grab another hard drive" from a local computer shop. Just because most people nowadays prefer to do that because drives are getting so large and getting so cheap, put yourself in this position and think - and I mean really think about how you'd feel if it happened to you:

Lose a few gigs of data amongst hundreds if not thousands of gigs of data (just a percentage), or lose hundreds if not thousands of gigs of data (lose everything) - which one would be more "painful" if they both happened in the same circumstances?

When I pose that question to clients looking for a backup solution, prudence always wins out in the long run, and a secondary backup option is brought into the situation.

As for the cheap media thing, obviously I'm not nor did I recommend such a thing. Optical media is still superior in my belief to magnetic media even though at this point the capacity of optical is obviously falling way way behind. Blu-Ray and other formats are offering possibilities for the future, and more will appear given time, but even so I'll stick with what I've got now, knowing my data is about as safe as today's current state of technology allow it to be. Just for the record, I've got some CDs I burned on a 12x Plextor drive in 1999 that still read just fine, 100% accuracy with no errors, and I have some DVD media that reads just fine and it was burned in 2003.

So much for the "5 year lifespan" of optical media... ;)

'Nuff typed.
 
Just setup you home PC to Radmin into it :) Cake?
 
Joe - I actually use to do what you do. All my music is in FLAC format. I stopped backing up to DVD when my DVD count reached 40 DVDs. One thing I realised is it just takes too long to backup to DVD and keep it up to date. I am continually increasing my collection, usually pick up 2-3 CDs a week. So that is about 10 CDs a month compressed to FLAC is almost a DVD a month. I also refine my tag data of the older stuff that was ripped before I had access to nice metadata sources like I have now.

So now my setup is a decent backup server running backuppc. I have it setup to backup every day and it keeps about 5 months back. I also have a nightly cron that runs and does an integrity check of all my flac files. I do this because I have had in the past files get corrupted by bad tagging software. You will not notice this until you go to play the music and even if you back it up you may have a bad backup. This alerts me right away.

Now then that said I do still make DVD backups but not very often. I make a set once or twice a year now. It is for offsite storage.

P.S. Joe Brother's in Arms I think was my second CD. First was Talking Heads Stop Making Sense.
 
If you're going to put *that* much effort into it, you might just invest in a high-end tape system with multiple tape backups.

Tape has been a proven medium throughout the decades, and once you set it up should be relatively simple to create multiple backups. It's good enough for enterprise systems, and IMHO far more robust than optical media (even the good ones).
 
Joe makes some good points, and I agree to a certain extent (I lost my music collection a while ago, but 99% of it was recovered from backup). if you must do a backup, mak sure its OFFLINE and never ever use the other drive except for once every few weeks.

CDs and DVDs can hardly be consider reliable medium any more.
Especially the new cheap ones. How do you guys thing they became so cheap?
IMO Blurays will be even worse when their time comes.

I heard of a recent study saying that most of todays CD/DVD roms will fail in ~5yrs, due to loosing their capability of retaining data information on their crappy layers.

this is why I still have cd-rs full of napster vintage that have been sitting in my car for 8 years that play perfectly.
 
I've been tempted to go duplicate most of my content these past few years, but I simply never get around to it. Having said that, I still believe optical media is the best for my situation. I'd hate like hell to have to re-rip those CDs, that did take a significant amount of time over the years, but if I had to do it I would.

I have had some of my own hard drives choke and puke over the years, last time was maybe 4 years ago with a Maxtor 80GB I bought. Brand new, retail box, it lasted 7 days and the bearings went out so that data was lost forever (nothing of consequence at the time). Damned thing reminded me of the sounds that came from an IBM "DeathStar" drive, a 60GXP that I had around 2000 or so. Made the same clicking sounds, but before I could work out a backup strategy the sound turned into that dreaded screeching noise and wham, the bearings locked up tighter than a slant 6 that hadn't had an oil change in years.

So after all the work I've done in my so-called "career" (I'm long retired now, letting the "kids" handle things these days) I had to come up with the strategy I employ even now: small(ish) hard drives in my primary machine (a 250GB primary with a 160GB secondary), and if I find something that's worth downloading, after being placed on the 250GB primary, I'll copy it off to the 160GB and decide if it's worth permanent archiving which is done on DVD+R media with the Plex.

I haven't lost a file in over 7 years, not one, aside from the files on that Maxtor that choked and puked, so I guess my solution works for me. It does get a bit troublesome having a lot of DVD media around (and quite a few CDs as well), but I use paper sleeves exclusively and I can fit 40-50 CDs in the same space a stack of 10 jewel boxes would require.

Big hard drives are nice, but man... I can't imagine how freakin' peeved I'd be if I lost a few hundred gigs or more when something goes wrong. RAID for actual data redundancy is a good idea these days, but even those fail. And I tell ya, I hate working on large RAID recovery almost as much as losing data myself. :D
 
Big hard drives are nice, but man... I can't imagine how freakin' peeved I'd be if I lost a few hundred gigs or more when something goes wrong. RAID for actual data redundancy is a good idea these days, but even those fail. And I tell ya, I hate working on large RAID recovery almost as much as losing data myself. :D

Who needs RAID? imo if all you need is three drives. First is your boot drive. Second is backup 1 and third is backup 2. Neither backup drive stays in the system except to do a backup, which can be either a full system backup with ntbackup or just dragging and dropping "My Documents" onto it. Do that once a week or month. Problem solved. Two good quality hard drives that are taken care of will not fail at the same time. And you won't have to work on an organization system for all those tons of discs.
 
Two good quality hard drives that are taken care of will not fail at the same time

That's pretty ironic considering just yesterday - meaning Thursday - I did a restore job on a system that was just built on Monday that contained 2 Western Digital 500GB drives in it, both retail drives, both brand spankin' new, and they both died within about 90 mins of each other. The secondary drive (these were not used in a RAID situation, btw) in the machine blew its logic board and I really can't figure out how or why, and the primary drive had a head crash - a real physical head crash.

Luckily the system being new meant the owner didn't have anything on them that wasn't already on some other type of media (DVD, actually), but the sheer timing of your comment and this thread's leaning towards proper backup methodology prompted me to laugh for a few minutes pretty hard.

Murphy's Law exists for a reason, yanno... and unfortunately, because shit can go wrong it will, and right when you least expect or can reasonably tolerate it.
 
Joe - Not sure why you would not trust a proper backup system using harddisk for backup media. I have been in this game for a long time and have seen many drives fails. Also have seen controller cards fail trashy the data on the drives in the process. If you have a backup system you no longer have to even think about doing backups it just happens. I actually have my system email me a report once a week just so I know it is happening. Chances of losing 2 drives on 2 different systems at the same time is really low, the above person had a freak occurrence. Actually the above person probably got 2 drives from the same shipment that the delivery people use for street hockey.

RAID is not for backup! RAID is for uptime.

So my rule of thumb is backup to hard disk for local backups, use optical for offsite. However I am starting to consider using a harddisk for offsite because the time for transferring to DVD is getting to long.

Oh I have never lost any data either. I have had many a drive fail in systems both home and work and have not lost data. Even had RAID arrays fail due to controller issues too.
 
That's pretty ironic considering just yesterday - meaning Thursday - I did a restore job on a system that was just built on Monday that contained 2 Western Digital 500GB drives in it, both retail drives, both brand spankin' new, and they both died within about 90 mins of each other. The secondary drive (these were not used in a RAID situation, btw) in the machine blew its logic board and I really can't figure out how or why, and the primary drive had a head crash - a real physical head crash.

Luckily the system being new meant the owner didn't have anything on them that wasn't already on some other type of media (DVD, actually), but the sheer timing of your comment and this thread's leaning towards proper backup methodology prompted me to laugh for a few minutes pretty hard.

Murphy's Law exists for a reason, yanno... and unfortunately, because shit can go wrong it will, and right when you least expect or can reasonably tolerate it.

And your house could catch on fire and destroy all your DVDs. Did a failing hard drive touch you inappropriately or something?

Two hard drives failing within 90 minutes is very unlikely and makes me question whether or not that computer was even properly built in the first place. A hard drive "blew" its logic board? That's not a problem with a hard drive, that's a problem with whoever put that computer together not checking the power supply for proper voltages.

If you want "proper backup methodology", you use a serious RAID array or tape, not hundreds of DVDs. Go look at any business that maintains financial or medical records. How much do you want to bet it's not a stack of DVDs sitting on a shelf?
 
My friend told me a truly sad story when someone's RAID 5 went down, taking over 3TBs of valuable data with it. Everyone thinks, oh of course when one drive goes down only one goes down at a time right?

Well 1 went down, and the 2nd within minutes. Entire array destroyed.

Of course then my other friend joked he should had RAID 6, just for those cases. If anything, I'd probably only consider RAID 6 if I was going this route, but I'm not about to spend that much money on backups at this point.

In terms of HDs dying suddenly/early - isn't that infant-death syndrome? There's a reason I don't put anything valuable on a new HD until several days has passed.
 
My friend told me a truly sad story when someone's RAID 5 went down, taking over 3TBs of valuable data with it. Everyone thinks, oh of course when one drive goes down only one goes down at a time right?

Well 1 went down, and the 2nd within minutes. Entire array destroyed.

Of course then my other friend joked he should had RAID 6, just for those cases. If anything, I'd probably only consider RAID 6 if I was going this route, but I'm not about to spend that much money on backups at this point.

In terms of HDs dying suddenly/early - isn't that infant-death syndrome? There's a reason I don't put anything valuable on a new HD until several days has passed.

No what your friend needs is backups not RAID6. RAID is NOT backups. NEVER EVER CONSIDER RAID as a REPLACEMENT for BACKUPS!
 
Yeah that's what I got from it. Some reason he was simply building a collection on his RAID box. It was also his first time using Linux :(
 
No what your friend needs is backups not RAID6. RAID is NOT backups. NEVER EVER CONSIDER RAID as a REPLACEMENT for BACKUPS!

+2

RAID can still fail. Multiple drive failures, controller failures, power failures, corruption, etc.

As someone said earlier, RAID is for uptime, not for backups. RAID lets you keep using your drives when one fails, backups let you keep a second copy of your data.

Which reminds me, I need to do some backups when I get home today! ;)
 
Why would you ever bother to back up a huge music collection to optical media? It's not any less prone to errors (when backing up or thru wear/decay) than hard drives are, if anything it's more fragile in that regard... And it's certainly more time consuming.

If you just want some degree of redundancy then just get one of those compact RAID1 external enclosures, the likelihood that three drives (your main and the two mirrored backups) would die is pretty far off... If you're really paranoid just go with two separate external drives and keep one off-site, or use an online backup service. I don't see any upside to optical media backups. Point is, having a couple drives for backup >>> having a couple hundred optical discs for backup, in every way... Possibly even cost in the long-run. You'd have to re-burn all those discs every few years if you were really serious about keeping them forever. Hard drives fail, but are easy to manage (can be automated for the most part), CD/DVD's decay and are a pita to shuffle thru and organize... It's much easier to just have several mirrored drives than anything else, and do nightly/weekly backups or w/e.

You just have to realize that a backup/external drive is not supposed to be your main media repository, but your actual backup to the main drive in your PC, or to your media player, or whatever. Ditto if you're gonna keep another drive for monthly off-site backups, etc. Either way it's still way less of a hassle and just as secure as using optical media, I don't see the rationale there at all.
 
Back
Top