iPad Usability Problems Revealed in New Report

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A new report says that the problems most people are having with the iPad stem from sucky, inconsistent apps, not actual hardware issues.

"There are no standards and no expectations." In many applications, users don't know where to go or what options they have. They don't know where they can click or touch, the report notes. Inconsistency in iPad apps is a major cause of the problem. How you do things in one app is not the same way you do similar things in other apps. The result is that users must play a guessing game to figure out how things work.
 
No real surprises there. With ~200,000+ apps on the App Store and more on the way, the actual percentage of well done and actually useful apps is probably less than a tenth of one single percent (< .1%) - probably even less.

Enough with the fart/beer/useless tilting/crap apps, devs... sheesh.
 
LOL! Bunch of newbies! These criticisms have been made of other large touch screen devices as well. Touch doesn't make things simpler necessarily, it does however make them different from most user's experiences. Most people just aren't used to large touch screen devices and don't understand open ended UIs and good apps are just hard to make under these conditions.
 
Wait, did the writer mention "There are no standards..." ??? Umm... this is about apple isn't it?
 
Wait, did the writer mention "There are no standards..." ??? Umm... this is about apple isn't it?

LOL! Seriously though I see this a lot on TPCs, it's just the nature of touch screen stuff. For instance with the Kindle Reader for the PC you flick horizontally to turn pages but in the Barnes & Noble Reader you flick vertically to do the same thing. In this case I'd say the B & N reader is the oddball but when you're used to this type of thing it's not a big deal.

It really is as much a user training issue as an app issue. It took me all of ten seconds to figure out the B & N reader because this type of thing is just common. Ok horizontal swipes don't work let's try vertical ones. Bingo.

Users do the same type of trial and error discovery ALL the time on the desktop and phone but large touch screens are just a bit different enough to need a new set of trial and error skills.
 
This is funny. Apple users are so used to paying a fortune to have the computer think for them that when they actually have to figure something out for thevselves they cant do it.

If the computer doesnt wipe thier ass they dont know what to do. They just get Steve Jobs shit all over themselves.
 
LOL! Seriously though I see this a lot on TPCs, it's just the nature of touch screen stuff. For instance with the Kindle Reader for the PC you flick horizontally to turn pages but in the Barnes & Noble Reader you flick vertically to do the same thing. In this case I'd say the B & N reader is the oddball but when you're used to this type of thing it's not a big deal.

It really is as much a user training issue as an app issue. It took me all of ten seconds to figure out the B & N reader because this type of thing is just common. Ok horizontal swipes don't work let's try vertical ones. Bingo.

Users do the same type of trial and error discovery ALL the time on the desktop and phone but large touch screens are just a bit different enough to need a new set of trial and error skills.

I disagree. I think this is more about lack of standards.

Something like Windows has a well-defined UI scheme. Minimize, maximize, close in the corner. File/Edit/etc menu bar at the top. Alt-F4 to close. Tab to go between fields in a form. Etc.

Each app has its own stuff like this, instead of a standard.

This is a limitation of the one-thousand-different-apps approach to using the internet...instead of a web browser.
 
I thought Apple reviewed or tested all apps for quality before releasing them to app store?
 
I disagree. I think this is more about lack of standards.

Something like Windows has a well-defined UI scheme. Minimize, maximize, close in the corner. File/Edit/etc menu bar at the top. Alt-F4 to close. Tab to go between fields in a form. Etc.

Each app has its own stuff like this, instead of a standard.

This is a limitation of the one-thousand-different-apps approach to using the internet...instead of a web browser.
Completely agree. It's hard to deny that touch screen and movement technologies have been abused in the name of creativity. UI standardization is not a bad thing for common tasks between similar applications (or functions). I shouldn't have to relearn how a browser works by installing Chrome. And Ctrl-B should bold my text no matter what word processor/spreadsheet/forum I use. Not everything is a game (and even then, I expect a certain standard set of controls within a genre).

Trial and error is a barrier to user adoption. Especially for a device that is putting itself forward as the ubiquitous future of computing.

I wonder if developers are coming up with all these schemes to get around the UI patents taken out by Apple and others. Unless the standards become open, you could get sued for letting users, say, blur graphics by shaking the device.
 
Eh, I think the problem lies in people's inability to RTFM. I have zero issue with my iPhone and it's apps. If I download an app, the first thing I do is learn how it works, not bitch at the phone because it doesn't work like the other apps.

I think it's a good thing that the touchscreen is so flexible you could program things in many possible ways, not just one way. It would be the same with touchscreen PC - we wouldn't want to be locked down to a standard. The only important thing is to make something touch-friendly.

This goes to any phones and tablet PCs. Not just the iPhone/Pad/Pod Touch.
 
I thought Apple reviewed or tested all apps for quality before releasing them to app store?

As I understand it, they have some automated testing tools to ensure the app will function properly, and they also check its functionality to ensure it doesn't replace or significantly overlap the core functions of the device that Apple provides.
 
I disagree. I think this is more about lack of standards.

Something like Windows has a well-defined UI scheme. Minimize, maximize, close in the corner. File/Edit/etc menu bar at the top. Alt-F4 to close. Tab to go between fields in a form. Etc.

Each app has its own stuff like this, instead of a standard.

This is a limitation of the one-thousand-different-apps approach to using the internet...instead of a web browser.

The thing is Windows was born out of the idea of creating a consistent UI where all apps had predictable and standard interfaces. But as time as gone on that idea seems to be less and less the the norm. Take Office 2010. That's TOTALLY ditched conventional UI and though the Ribbon is now standard in all the Office apps the Ribbon itself will probably be an odd ball for some time to come though Microsoft and other third parties are now implementing it in their apps.

Touch screen devices really have no UI consistency imperative and I'm not sure that it's necessary or even a good thing taken to an extreme. Indeed the beauty of a touch screen device is that apps are blank slates, no pun intended. You want to create simple and intuitive ways to accomplish the UI that fit for the task at hand, UI consistency BETWEEN apps shouldn't be important.

That said yeah there's bad stuff out there. In fact I just found an update for the B & N reader that actually adds better Windows 7 touch support and actually now navigates pages with horizontal flicks.

Touch screen UIs are simply more free form as they should be because of the nature of the interface. And the web? Talk about a million was to do the same thing, but when well done its not an issue though certain conventions are nice to have to to allow user experience to carry over.
 
I don't see this being any sort of problem at all for young people and nerds, but for old people that barely know how to check their email in the first place I can see the problem.

iPhone apps were always extremely consistent in functionality, but the larger screen allows for much more complicated applications and developers are experimenting with different layouts, etc.
 
These apps are not even internally consistent:
In the USA Today app, for example, the study found that touching a picture could produce five different results, ranging from nothing to linking to a more detailed page about the picture to popping up a set of navigation choices.
It's not a million ways to do the same thing as much as one action doing a million things. With the number of site-specific apps out there, remembering all the vagaries would drive me nuts.
 
The USA Today example is just a case of bad app design. I don't think there's much Apple can do about that.
 
The iPad's greatest strength is its ability to display amazing graphics.

This is the most amazing statement in the article--and is, unbelievably, the lead sentence.

"Amazing graphics"...? Compared to what? An iPhone, maybe? In terms of "graphics," these devices hardly register with me. It's difficult for me to imagine that a person who thinks the iPad's itty-bitty little screen produces "amazing graphics" is very familiar with current graphical display capability. Sure, I could see the description maybe from someone who was time-warped from decades-old CGA graphical displays to the iPad, but how likely is that?....:eek:
 
This is the most amazing statement in the article--and is, unbelievably, the lead sentence.

"Amazing graphics"...? Compared to what? An iPhone, maybe? In terms of "graphics," these devices hardly register with me. It's difficult for me to imagine that a person who thinks the iPad's itty-bitty little screen produces "amazing graphics" is very familiar with current graphical display capability. Sure, I could see the description maybe from someone who was time-warped from decades-old CGA graphical displays to the iPad, but how likely is that?....:eek:

Nice troll. Sorry, the IPS screen on the iPad is quite good. This is what the post you commented to was indicating. Really...find netbook or ultraportable with a screen as good as the iPad.....and keep the price within a few $100. Apple was smart putting lions share of the cost into the display.
 
This is really a shame. At one time Apple had, by far, the finest user interface guidelines in the business.

This may be another reason for their push to use Apple dev kits only.

Back in the old days if you didn't follow the standardized UIG your app was laughed, reviewed and scolded out of the market.
 
Nice troll. Sorry, the IPS screen on the iPad is quite good. This is what the post you commented to was indicating. Really...find netbook or ultraportable with a screen as good as the iPad.....and keep the price within a few $100. Apple was smart putting lions share of the cost into the display.

First, I wasn't commenting on another "post" in this thread, but rather took my quote directly from the article linked here--I thought I had made that obvious.

Second, I've often wondered as to why it is that whenever someone in a forum says something that someone else finds disagreeable, the "someone else" is always handy with a "troll" remark...? I am sorry but there just isn't anything about the iPad that appeals to me in the slightest. Not trollin', just stating my opinion.

I also find the iPad to be lacking in terms of an ultraportable and probably a netbook, too--but then, the iPad is neither an ultraportable or a netbook, is it?

Last, I appreciate your being kind enough to explain to me what the author intended to say, and I'm sure he appreciates your putting words into his mouth since obviously he couldn't find them. But I'm afraid you haven't changed my mind: "amazing" is absolutely the very last word I would use to describe iPad graphics. Of course, when I think of computer graphics these days, I tend to think in terms of screen real estate, resolution, and 3d, among several other things quite apart from IPS--but that's just me...;)
 
Yeah, if someone is using the word 'graphics' to describe the display that would seem fairly odd. If they want to say it has a nice display then they would normally just say that. Talking about the graphics is less about the display and more about the program pushing the polygons and the graphics card/CPU that is processing the data.
 
Sounds like Apple's apps approval process sucks donkey balls. Big surprise there.
 
Sounds like Apple's apps approval process sucks donkey balls. Big surprise there.

I just don't think people get just how hard doing touch is on a large screen and the devs are just as clueless as the users. How many of these devs have actually used a large touch screen device BEFORE the iPad? They are just as clueless as the end users right now but in time things will improve as both end users and devs gain experience with the platform.
 
which is why I think the HP slate will rule, once they get it out ... hopefully ...
 
Except the the slate was cancelled.

That's not been confirmed. My guess is that HP is reevaluating it's options since the purchase of Palm. I'm pretty sure they would LOVE to get a Windows 7 slate out if they can as it would be clearly different running a desktop OS versus all of the phone OS devices on the way. My guess is that they'd like to use something other than Atom CPU.
 
I just don't think people get just how hard doing touch is on a large screen and the devs are just as clueless as the users. How many of these devs have actually used a large touch screen device BEFORE the iPad? They are just as clueless as the end users right now but in time things will improve as both end users and devs gain experience with the platform.

Again, where is Apple in all this? It's their platform and their apps approval process. It's not exactly hard to tell them to make their touch interface on apps, same across the board.
 
Again, where is Apple in all this? It's their platform and their apps approval process. It's not exactly hard to tell them to make their touch interface on apps, same across the board.

Apple doesn't have any more experience with large touch screens than anyone else, plus they need quantity not quality at this time in the iPad's life cycle for bragging rights. Look we have 200,000 apps (though must suck)!

This is something that's just going to take time, there's no "magic" bullet.
 
Kind of goes against Apple's philosophy of quality. Not that it surprises me much. Apple's never been about quality. Just the appearance of such.
 
I disagree. I think this is more about lack of standards.

Something like Windows has a well-defined UI scheme. Minimize, maximize, close in the corner. File/Edit/etc menu bar at the top. Alt-F4 to close. Tab to go between fields in a form. Etc.

Each app has its own stuff like this, instead of a standard.

This is a limitation of the one-thousand-different-apps approach to using the internet...instead of a web browser.

Until Word 2007 and WMP came along and fucked all those standards over and eliminated normal menus :shrug:. I don't know which way desktop UI is going anywhere these days either.
 
Until Word 2007 and WMP came along and fucked all those standards over and eliminated normal menus :shrug:. I don't know which way desktop UI is going anywhere these days either.

The ironic thing here however is that the Ribbon is MUCH more touch friendly than conventional menus. Office 2010 on touch screen tablet PC easily rivals the iWork apps on the iPad. The iWork apps are obviously engineered from the ground up as touch screen apps and thus have much better fit and finish for a touch screen only interface but the Ribbon actually makes Office a bit easier to pick up for novice users as the Ribbon more clearly exposes Office functionality than the sparse iWork UI. Plus of course Office is far more powerful so even though the iWork apps have a more refined touch only interface the useabilty of the Ribbon and Office's much richer feature set easily put it on equal footing with the iWork suite in a touch only environment.
 
This argument is like saying "the PC is a bad platform because Realplayer is a piece of shit." 3rd party developers are free (for the most part) to develop interfaces the way they see fit. This does not reflect poorly on the device itself.

Apple's UI guidelines are just so people don't push out horribly broken interfaces. Apps don't all mesh perfectly with Apple's first-party apps, nor should they. Interface guidelines are just that... guidelines. There are a lot of unique and interesting apps that wouldn't be possible if everyone had to conform perfectly to some rigid UI specification.

As someone who develops iPhone / iPad apps for a living, I don't see what the fuss is about. Yes, there are a LOT of shitty apps. There are also a ton of apps in general. The bad ones are easy to delete.
 
I disagree. I think this is more about lack of standards.

Something like Windows has a well-defined UI scheme. Minimize, maximize, close in the corner. File/Edit/etc menu bar at the top. Alt-F4 to close. Tab to go between fields in a form. Etc.

Each app has its own stuff like this, instead of a standard.

This is a limitation of the one-thousand-different-apps approach to using the internet...instead of a web browser.

In some areas Windows still lacks though.. Taskbar/system tray icons anyone? Some you left click, some you right click, some you double click, some you hover over, etc.
 
In some areas Windows still lacks though.. Taskbar/system tray icons anyone? Some you left click, some you right click, some you double click, some you hover over, etc.

Actually there are plenty of task bar icons where you do all three and there's logic as to why they work that way.

I think that the issue being discussed here isn't so much consistency across different apps and functionality, it's more about ease of use within a particular app. As I mentioned earlier the iWork apps, while good, have a pretty obtuse UI. As much as the Ribbon in Office has been criticized it's actually much easier to find functions in it than the iWork apps. The Ribbon kind of describes what an Office app can do just by looking at it. In iWork apps you pretty much need to know where things are, the sparse UI just dosen't tell you much.
 
Actually there are plenty of task bar icons where you do all three and there's logic as to why they work that way.

I think that the issue being discussed here isn't so much consistency across different apps and functionality, it's more about ease of use within a particular app. As I mentioned earlier the iWork apps, while good, have a pretty obtuse UI. As much as the Ribbon in Office has been criticized it's actually much easier to find functions in it than the iWork apps. The Ribbon kind of describes what an Office app can do just by looking at it. In iWork apps you pretty much need to know where things are, the sparse UI just dosen't tell you much.
Actually, the article was more about between apps than within (although, yes, there are some poorly written apps). Each site has a different app with a different interface. Custom interactions are one thing, but not being able to scroll through text-based content or trigger links consistently? Ridiculous.

Two solutions:
1. Write the standards guide on how to code controls for common features and train developers. In time, touch screen behaviour will be as familiar to both developers and users as radio buttons and checkboxes are.
2. Include a personalization page in every app that let's you map functions to whatever actions you want. That way, you only ever need to RTFM once.

Users have UI expectations based on the type of content being displayed (text, video, order entry). Some of these developers seem to be going out of their way to prove them wrong, and that's just not good business. I realize there are games out there based on the premise of not knowing how the interface works. I don't imagine a lot of people play them, despite the fact that they're probably quite good.
 
Back
Top