iPad Usability Problems Revealed in New Report

Actually there are plenty of task bar icons where you do all three and there's logic as to why they work that way.

I think that the issue being discussed here isn't so much consistency across different apps and functionality, it's more about ease of use within a particular app. As I mentioned earlier the iWork apps, while good, have a pretty obtuse UI. As much as the Ribbon in Office has been criticized it's actually much easier to find functions in it than the iWork apps. The Ribbon kind of describes what an Office app can do just by looking at it. In iWork apps you pretty much need to know where things are, the sparse UI just dosen't tell you much.

Sorry for the tangent.. I don't suppose you can explain the logic to me? I'm not trying to be a d!ck or be sarcastic, but as a computer user since the 80's that's had an Apple //e, C= 64, Amiga, various Mac's, IBM's, and even an Intellivision (ha! if you can call that a computer), I have yet to understand why some taskbar icons you click/double-click/right click/etc.
 
I think that despite whatever excuses Apple and its defenders want to use this shows that one of the few big advantages of having the peoples great walled garden of the workers isn't being implemented. The top 3 advantages I've heard for the Ipad/Iphone/Itouch UI are that they all have the same resolution (which is now changed by the Ipad, and the next Iphone by all signs) and that they can make sure that only the "good quality" apps are allowed. I would guess that more apps have been turned down because they are viewed as possibly hurting Apples business than for having bad UI. Oddly the third most used reason I have heard, at least vs Android is that it has a compass which I'm pretty sure the G1 actually had first.

Eh, I think the problem lies in people's inability to RTFM. I have zero issue with my iPhone and it's apps. If I download an app, the first thing I do is learn how it works, not bitch at the phone because it doesn't work like the other apps.

But how easy is this to do even? Its not like people are purchasing a product that comes with a nice boxed software package that comes with a paper manual, customer support phone numbers, and a cloth map. Every program n Xbox Live and even Xbox Community Games (community ran for the most part,other than fees and basic rules) has an easy and consistent way to know what each button does. I believe that everything on the Nintendo channel and virtual console has this requirement and this is from Nintendo, a company that is still a fan of friend codes.
-----
I'm not a fan of the Ribbon (Almost always install 2003 still, even though I have licenses for both)
or Apple (currently prefer Android) but I'm going to have to defend both here.
-----
when I think of computer graphics these days, I tend to think in terms of screen real estate, resolution, and 3d, among several other things quite apart from IPS

This is really getting into semantics. It would be the same as freaking out if the article said that the iPad has 8GB of memory or ram. While it may not be exactly correct you can infer what was meant. You can rip on the iPad for a lot of things but it has an IPS panel with fairly high ppi/dpi. Viewing angle is very important to using a tablet/slate device because you want to be able to move the device around and have it look nice both in portrait and landscape (a lot of small displays look really bad in portrait). Since most websites are (should be) designed to be able to displayed on a monitor with a resolution of 800x600 (Current Windows minimum) a display of 1024 x 768 means that almost any website is viewable in both modes.

Until Word 2007

This is at least fairly consistant when used in newer version of Windows like 7, as long as you remember to use alt to bring up the old school file menu and toolbar. Also in Office 2007 when you hit the Alt key it overlays the shortcut to each button which give a handy quick reference. The key items like open/close, min/max, save still function in a similar manner with common icons.
 
But how easy is this to do even? Its not like people are purchasing a product that comes with a nice boxed software package that comes with a paper manual, customer support phone numbers, and a cloth map. Every program n Xbox Live and even Xbox Community Games (community ran for the most part,other than fees and basic rules) has an easy and consistent way to know what each button does. I believe that everything on the Nintendo channel and virtual console has this requirement and this is from Nintendo, a company that is still a fan of friend codes.
-----
I'm not a fan of the Ribbon (Almost always install 2003 still, even though I have licenses for both)
or Apple (currently prefer Android) but I'm going to have to defend both here.
-----

For an iPhone, the proper question should be "how hard is it to do?" because it's not. Even a caveman can use an iPhone (sorry, Geico). No slight against the mentally ill, but if you can't figure out how to work an app on an iPhone (aside from the more difficult IT apps, such as RDP and VMWare apps), you're just a little slow in the head.
 
I have yet to understand why some taskbar icons you click/double-click/right click/etc.

I don't know what your referring to, at least in the case of windows. Every taskbar item I know a single click either selects that item or expands it. Right click is almost always gives you either the options to show/hide menus and buttons. On the top bar right click has given you the same almost never used commands for as long as I can remember (restore, minimize, etc) and single click drag to move and double click min/max.

In windows run apps has been 1 click or lasso to select, double click to open, and right click for more options. The only thing I can see as being confusing (but at least consistently confusing) is that by default single click opens a hyper link in a website or click an icon on a menu and double click runs an application, hover shows tooltips. Many beginners try to either single/double click everything.
 
For an iPhone, the proper question should be "how hard is it to do?" because it's not. Even a caveman can use an iPhone (sorry, Geico). No slight against the mentally ill, but if you can't figure out how to work an app on an iPhone (aside from the more difficult IT apps, such as RDP and VMWare apps), you're just a little slow in the head.

I've been studying UI for almost half my life now I wasn't being narcissistic enough to only be stating if I could could figure out a UI. I don't think many would argue that even a majority of Apple users are people that have a lot of experience using there devices (since they are so "innovative" how could they?) or are the type to be interested in problem solving or putting a lot of work/time into figuring out how to do something.

How do your baseless attacks against me, or the report that says otherwise (like bad test methodology, bad sampling methods, or some kind of conflicting interest by the people doing the report).

I am to believe that you are able to read an entire manual which you can't even read my paragraph that directly asked "how easy is it to find a manual/instructions" and think that instead I meant "how easy is it to use a program".

A person isn't expected to push every button on there controller when they download a game. In the case of a controller you have a finite amount of buttons that tend to work in a consistent way (purple button always confirms or pink button always goes back).

Apple proclaimed for years that expecting people to understand how to use a mouse with anything more than one button was too confusing. This would mean that they thought that it would be too unintuitive to expect people to try to remember what the left vs right button does. Apple claims there is no way to solve how to replace "hover" on a touch device when the first time I heard this complaint I could think of multiple ways this could be accomplished.

Millions of dollars and hours are put into researching how people interact with games, programs, and websites. Only a very small minority of current Apple App companies have or choose to invest the money into any kind of UI research.

Do Resident Evil 2, Resident Evil 4, Gears of War, and Halo play differently from each other when played with a controller with two analogs? How about a person plays them with mouse instead (all 4 have PC versions). Does Resident Evil 4 on Gamecube, PS2, PC, and Wii play differently and do a majority of reviews mention the controls in a review for each version or do the different reviews scores only reflect sound and graphics? How about Peggle on DS, 360, PC, Iphone, etc? If people in Halo, Modern Warfare 2 on PS3, 360, and PC were allowed to play against each other would they have the same experience and be on equal footing?

Can everyone you know consistently throw a fireball or sonic boom in Street Fighter, you only have to push down,down-towards, towards or hold back and then push forward and punch. How about if you don't tell them how to perform these 3-4 button commands or only tell them the instructions one time and ask them to do it a month later? These combinations have been around for over a decade and seen by millions why cant everyone do it?

With a touch interface without instructions its impossible to know if a squiggly mark or an L shape, and M shape, tap and hold, swipe left, perform any combination of these with 1,3,8 fingers, or infinite other possibilities are even being used. One of the top complaints about Flash, which Apple wants to make themselves out to be superior too, is that flash websites don't always work in a well known way (what do you mean I have to pull the switch down to open the drawer, then click on the map to select a location to see your pictures?).
 
I've been studying UI for almost half my life now I wasn't being narcissistic enough to only be stating if I could could figure out a UI. I don't think many would argue that even a majority of Apple users are people that have a lot of experience using there devices (since they are so "innovative" how could they?) or are the type to be interested in problem solving or putting a lot of work/time into figuring out how to do something.

How do your baseless attacks against me, or the report that says otherwise (like bad test methodology, bad sampling methods, or some kind of conflicting interest by the people doing the report).

I am to believe that you are able to read an entire manual which you can't even read my paragraph that directly asked "how easy is it to find a manual/instructions" and think that instead I meant "how easy is it to use a program".

A person isn't expected to push every button on there controller when they download a game. In the case of a controller you have a finite amount of buttons that tend to work in a consistent way (purple button always confirms or pink button always goes back).

Apple proclaimed for years that expecting people to understand how to use a mouse with anything more than one button was too confusing. This would mean that they thought that it would be too unintuitive to expect people to try to remember what the left vs right button does. Apple claims there is no way to solve how to replace "hover" on a touch device when the first time I heard this complaint I could think of multiple ways this could be accomplished.

Millions of dollars and hours are put into researching how people interact with games, programs, and websites. Only a very small minority of current Apple App companies have or choose to invest the money into any kind of UI research.

Do Resident Evil 2, Resident Evil 4, Gears of War, and Halo play differently from each other when played with a controller with two analogs? How about a person plays them with mouse instead (all 4 have PC versions). Does Resident Evil 4 on Gamecube, PS2, PC, and Wii play differently and do a majority of reviews mention the controls in a review for each version or do the different reviews scores only reflect sound and graphics? How about Peggle on DS, 360, PC, Iphone, etc? If people in Halo, Modern Warfare 2 on PS3, 360, and PC were allowed to play against each other would they have the same experience and be on equal footing?

Can everyone you know consistently throw a fireball or sonic boom in Street Fighter, you only have to push down,down-towards, towards or hold back and then push forward and punch. How about if you don't tell them how to perform these 3-4 button commands or only tell them the instructions one time and ask them to do it a month later? These combinations have been around for over a decade and seen by millions why cant everyone do it?

With a touch interface without instructions its impossible to know if a squiggly mark or an L shape, and M shape, tap and hold, swipe left, perform any combination of these with 1,3,8 fingers, or infinite other possibilities are even being used. One of the top complaints about Flash, which Apple wants to make themselves out to be superior too, is that flash websites don't always work in a well known way (what do you mean I have to pull the switch down to open the drawer, then click on the map to select a location to see your pictures?).

It's just an iPhone, not NORAD or NASA computers.
 
So the new Apple slogan is "It just works, as long as you are a NASA or NORAD scientist?" or "Think like how a NORAD or NASA scientist would". Perhaps you have a point though, since Android and Blackberry now both outsell Apple they can start to design devices only for hardcore fanboys again.

Thanks for ignoring every single example I posted and decided to make up your own story. I don't see how only NASA or NORAD computers would require a single screen or screenshot with the most used commands.

How did you manage to think that by comparing the Iphone store to Nintendo stores and Microsofts Xbox Live stores or with usuability for Flash, Internet, PS2, Gamecube, and PC games with Norad and NASA?

I'm pretty sure the Space Shuttle program still uses 386's by the way and even Mathew Broderick can hack into NORAD.
 
So the new Apple slogan is "It just works, as long as you are a NASA or NORAD scientist?" or "Think like how a NORAD or NASA scientist would". Perhaps you have a point though, since Android and Blackberry now both outsell Apple they can start to design devices only for hardcore fanboys again.

Thanks for ignoring every single example I posted and decided to make up your own story. I don't see how only NASA or NORAD computers would require a single screen or screenshot with the most used commands.

How did you manage to think that by comparing the Iphone store to Nintendo stores and Microsofts Xbox Live stores or with usuability for Flash, Internet, PS2, Gamecube, and PC games with Norad and NASA?

I'm pretty sure the Space Shuttle program still uses 386's by the way and even Mathew Broderick can hack into NORAD.

My point is that it does not take a rocket scientist or a thesis paper to figure out how to work an iPhone. It didn't become one of the most popular phone in the world by being inaccessible to its user base. You can use all sorts of game special moves combination examples you want, but it's not Apple's problem if you can't read the manual and learn to play the games. It's a game. It's supposed to be challenging. You're not supposed to just hit one button to execute super combo punch x10. If you can't hack it, then play something else.

This train of thought makes me upset because a lot of good MMOs had been dumbed down by people who complain about the depth of games. I loved the original SWG. I loved the original WoW. Now I can't stand to play it (I quit both years ago) because it's been dumbed down.

For non-game apps, there's nothing wrong with the iPhone's touch capability. Most apps have Help menus with short description on how to use them. So far I've never needed to use it because almost every app I've used are very transparent on how it works. If you don't want to read the help page, that's not anyone's problem but yours.

And for the record, the Space Shuttle started out with an Intel 8086 and is currently running on an 80386. So you get a cookie for that. :-P
 
Sorry for the tangent.. I don't suppose you can explain the logic to me? I'm not trying to be a d!ck or be sarcastic, but as a computer user since the 80's that's had an Apple //e, C= 64, Amiga, various Mac's, IBM's, and even an Intellivision (ha! if you can call that a computer), I have yet to understand why some taskbar icons you click/double-click/right click/etc.

It's a valid question and I'm not saying that its entirely consistent but in my obervations there are pretty recognizable patterns.

Double clicking a task bar icon usually leads to some IMMEDIATE action, like toggling an option on or off, no further interaction is necessary. Single clcking will often bring up a mini-dialog that presents the user some options, as in the base of the battery icon in Windows. The that situation a single click will bring up power options and links to change screen brightness on a laptop. And lastly right clicking will genrally display a context menu as is the case in Windows in general.

Once again I'm not saying that what I said is always the case but I find thispattern to be very prevelent.
 
This is really getting into semantics. It would be the same as freaking out if the article said that the iPad has 8GB of memory or ram. While it may not be exactly correct you can infer what was meant. You can rip on the iPad for a lot of things but it has an IPS panel with fairly high ppi/dpi. Viewing angle is very important to using a tablet/slate device because you want to be able to move the device around and have it look nice both in portrait and landscape (a lot of small displays look really bad in portrait). Since most websites are (should be) designed to be able to displayed on a monitor with a resolution of 800x600 (Current Windows minimum) a display of 1024 x 768 means that almost any website is viewable in both modes.

Then you go outside and you can't see a damn thing on the screen. Not to mention all the finger streaks from the touch inferface doesn't help at all.

I really hope these companies that come out with other slates will give us a stylus.
 
Then you go outside and you can't see a damn thing on the screen. Not to mention all the finger streaks from the touch inferface doesn't help at all.

I really hope these companies that come out with other slates will give us a stylus.

I agree with you entirely on this.

Which is why Apple can make all the claims they want but they have not created a replacement for the ebook reader.

I'm also a big fan of devices that can handle both touch and pressure sensitive stylus. They both have there uses. If I'm in my car and want to use my tablet as a GPS it can be a pain to hunt for a stylus to make a couple quick clicks or if I'm casually surfing the web I don't always want to be holding a stylus. On the other hand if I want to do handwriting, draw, be more accurate, or even zoom out the display nothing beats a stylus. This is a why I love the Dell XT we got my wife for school last year, and I dream of stealing it from her when she graduates. If Dell were to shrink that device down so they could fit most of the internals in the display and made it so that you could disconnect the keyboard like on some of the HP Tablet/Slate convertible it would be pretty much the perfect device. I bought a Dell X1 over 4 years ago (Samsung Rebadge) and if they would just make it so that screen could flip around, have an IPS panel and the same touch interface of the XT it would have been a great device for at least another 4.
 
Back
Top