I've got an EVGA 5600 Ultra that's still working.I've had three EVGA cards since 2006. All have been fine and their warranty (once you register the card) is top notch. Sorry you had issues, but they are one of the best GPU companies around.
EVGA 8800 GTX worked flawlessly for 1 year before I sold it, also have an EVGA 9600 GT that's working fine the past year, too.
Oh well, I guess personal experience is everything.