'Hurt Locker' Sharers: Expect Docs Like This

Status
Not open for further replies.
I heard far cry wasn't copyrighted in the US until mid January 2010. A lot of those dates are before. Doh
 
So If I rent out a house and say I live in another state and can only check on the property every few months and my tenants decide to start growing pot in the basement and they get booked I'm responsible for that?

owning and operating a rental property is hardly an accurate argument as there are different laws covering that and it is in no way even applicable. You would have a written contract/agreement with the tenants that you could/should have a clause in said agreement notifying them of their responsiblity of said property. If you had a written agreement with the "suspects" that the internet was included in their rent and that they are required to maintain resposible behaviors upon said network that you would be covered

So it still boils down to to my first reply to you

try again. but without the devil's advocate/strawman argument this time
 
That shouldn't be that much of an issue, even if the parents are paying the bills. Those 20 year old are adults not 12 year old children they can take full responsibility of their actions. I know if I was those parents I wouldn't be taking the fall for something my adult children did.
In a perfect world maybe unfortunately we don't live there. It seems that when accused of copyright infringement you are guilty until proven innocent. These organizations involved take advantage of this to extort money out of anyone they can. They know that they don't have to investigate because these organization's know it is cheaper to knuckle under to their robbery than try to fight it. So they go after the account holder no matter what the situation, is this fair NO WAY, is this the way it is unfortunately yes.
Farcry the movie haven't seen it but, everything I have heard about it makes me believe that they should be paying the pirates for downloading it and sending them a big thank you letter instead of suing them :D.
 
owning and operating a rental property is hardly an accurate argument as there are different laws covering that and it is in no way even applicable. You would have a written contract/agreement with the tenants that you could/should have a clause in said agreement notifying them of their responsiblity of said property. If you had a written agreement with the "suspects" that the internet was included in their rent and that they are required to maintain resposible behaviors upon said network that you would be covered

So it still boils down to to my first reply to you

try again. but without the devil's advocate/strawman argument this time

I wasn't trying to make a strawman argument:rolleyes: I was just curious and trying to educate myself.

Thanks for the reply!
 
The gun analogy doesn't make sense to me. Most states require at least a background check to buy a gun and some states require safety training. People who own guns know the risks, how to use them, and at least some proper safety precautions when it comes to handling and storage.

There are no mandated training courses before buying a wireless router. By default security features are turned off. There is no warning that people using your wifi can get you in trouble. Many people are tech illiterate and just don't understand the consequences.
That's why routers come with manuals. There's no need for advanced training, 'cause they're dead simple (especially those with push-button security configuration) and don't carry a risk of killing anyone.


Here are the section headings of the Linksys WRT54GS User Guide - Chapter 2: Wireless Security Checklist:
  1. Change the default wireless network name or SSID
  2. Change the default password
  3. Enable MAC address filtering
  4. Enable encryption
    General Network Security Guidelines
    Additional Security Tips
Granted, 1 and 3 are kinda crap, but there's no excuse not to follow the rest.
 
I've said it hundreds of times. I have no sympathy for the likes of the MPAA and Movie down loaders alike. I know I will (probably) never be sent an extortion letter because I don't DL movies and I secure my wireless connection.

This is a real problem. I was working on my Uncle's router settings the other day and his PC kept connecting to his neighbors wireless connection. Ok, so I removed that connection from the list and went about my business. Ten minutes later, when I had everything squared away, I did a site survey and noticed the neighbor had changed his SSID to "STAY OFF MY NET"

I walked next door and had a bit of a eye opening conversation with the neighbor about securing his network. Guy didn't know how to use his router, of course. He said it was secure and I must be hacking in. So I had to show him that his connection was unsecured from the factory.

Then I asked him why he thought it was secure if he never had to enter a password. He said he thought that when he changed the SSID, that it was the password.:rolleyes: I then asked him what he did with the disk that came with it, that said, Secure Easy Setup on it. He said he threw it away.

Sitting back watching this whole BS unfold over the years, I kind of feel like I'm watching two Chimps fight over a rotten banana.

People who abuse our legal system to extort money are evil and greedy. People who download movies over the internet illegally are stupid and greedy. As far as I'm concerned, they all need to jump into the nearest volcano.

I haven't come up with something for the tards that downloaded FarCry. I think maybe just watching that movie was punishment enough.:D
 
I think something that people might be forgetting is that when you use the free wifi provided by most coffee shops etc. you have to click through and accept their terms of use. This being the case, I'm sure they all have a clause in those terms of use that says you can't do anything illegal on their internet, and that if you do, they are not responsible or whatever. If you have unsecured wifi at home, you generally don't have that. Now, I think its sad that people are using unsecured wifi to anonymously download illegal material, but that is the state of society, and thus its necessary to secure your connections. Its ridiculous to me that those who own those routers can be charged fro the downloading, but with all that has happened recently, people should know what to expect. I still think that the company needs to prove that the person who owns the router actually did the downloading as it should still be innocent until proven guilty, but the owner should still be smart enough to know and secure his connection.
 
"...Harrison said his home network is unsecured and that he has no idea who might have shared the movie."
Well that is a problem. People really shouldn't operate unsecured wireless networks. Because that makes them targets for this type of mishap. Here's hoping Mr. Harrison isn't subjected to the MPAA's extortion, but that he finally wakes up and pays someone to secure his router!
 
I've said it hundreds of times. I have no sympathy for the likes of the MPAA and Movie down loaders alike. I know I will (probably) never be sent an extortion letter because I don't DL movies and I secure my wireless connection.

This is a real problem. I was working on my Uncle's router settings the other day and his PC kept connecting to his neighbors wireless connection. Ok, so I removed that connection from the list and went about my business. Ten minutes later, when I had everything squared away, I did a site survey and noticed the neighbor had changed his SSID to "STAY OFF MY NET"

I walked next door and had a bit of a eye opening conversation with the neighbor about securing his network. Guy didn't know how to use his router, of course. He said it was secure and I must be hacking in. So I had to show him that his connection was unsecured from the factory.

Then I asked him why he thought it was secure if he never had to enter a password. He said he thought that when he changed the SSID, that it was the password.:rolleyes: I then asked him what he did with the disk that came with it, that said, Secure Easy Setup on it. He said he threw it away.

Sitting back watching this whole BS unfold over the years, I kind of feel like I'm watching two Chimps fight over a rotten banana.

People who abuse our legal system to extort money are evil and greedy. People who download movies over the internet illegally are stupid and greedy. As far as I'm concerned, they all need to jump into the nearest volcano.

I haven't come up with something for the tards that downloaded FarCry. I think maybe just watching that movie was punishment enough.:D
Strange story. Was he able to figure out people were on his intranet or did you just happen to catch him during his install as he changed the SSID?
 
Very sad. Voltage is even worse than the RIAA/MPAA, and I didn't think that was possible!
 
Strange story. Was he able to figure out people were on his intranet or did you just happen to catch him during his install as he changed the SSID?

I don't know. I assume he knew what he was doing the whole time. He just didn't understand the seriousness behind having an open connection. Most people claim ignorance when, in fact, it is just laziness. I see it all the time. People ask me. "Will I have to re-enter the password when I go from one place to another?" When I tell them no, they say that's why the didn't secure it to begin with. Because they thought they would have to re-enter the password. Talk about lazy.
 
Did anyone else notice on the left picture, the sentence just before the second whited out block, the word "indentified?" Looks like they were in such a hurry to pump those letters out they forgot to psell heckc it... LOL
 
It is really said that anyone approves these actions. How can anyone be comfortable with people losing their money, possessions until the point of bankruptcy?

We can't spend all of our money in DVDs and CDs, because we also have to pay for food, water, electricity, clothes, gas, medicine, education, you know stuff that is a bit more important. And even after that, paying for a car, computer, internet, vacations, tvs, etc, comes first.

Now if you told me the producers of these films were working class or middle class people struggling in life, with kids in school or college, where the majority of your income goes to their education, I would be more empathetic towards them. Now do you think any assistant, cameraman, stunt will get any money from these lawsuits? No, but the people that already own big ass houses and porsches will.
 
Any lawyers in the house that could explain why something like this isn't considered extortion?
 
spelling error on page 6 of the photos... nice job law firm. "a file can be indentified with certainty"
 
I have a wireless router with my PC's wired in and only had my childrens Wii and I netbook I almost never use on the wireless. I had secured my network BUT the router crashed and reset itself to default opening up my wireless network for all to use for a couple of months. I didn't notice that the Wii was disconnected and that the router had been reset. Would I be held resposible for this if a scrupleless neighbor was downloading movies/music over it?

If so that seems ridiculous.

Another question is if I buy dvds and then convert the movies and move them to a HD to be played off a WDTV Live player can I get into trouble for that?

This seem ridiculous also but many things are becoming that way anymore.
 
I have a wireless router with my PC's wired in and only had my childrens Wii and I netbook I almost never use on the wireless. I had secured my network BUT the router crashed and reset itself to default opening up my wireless network for all to use for a couple of months. I didn't notice that the Wii was disconnected and that the router had been reset. Would I be held resposible for this if a scrupleless neighbor was downloading movies/music over it?

If so that seems ridiculous.

Another question is if I buy dvds and then convert the movies and move them to a HD to be played off a WDTV Live player can I get into trouble for that?

This seem ridiculous also but many things are becoming that way anymore.

It is your internet connection. You pay for it, and therefore are/should be responsible for it. That's my opinion, but if you could prove it wasn't you, I'm sure you could get off for that type of thing.
 
So, what's responsible enough then?

Everybody saying it's his fault for leaving it unsecured, how secure are you?
Are you running your own radius server?

Wep's easily cracked and there's lots of various ways to attack wpa-psk as well. If you're running an older router, you don't even have an option for wpa2 with AES. Should all those people be legally mandated to upgrade to new hardware?
 
So is there software to monitor my router for changes and shut it down if there are unauthorized changes or it resets? Can I sue the router maufacturer for it crashing if I was to be sued by RIAA or whom ever? Or would that be pointless.

Maybe we just need to make sure our networks are turned off when not in use and check the settings every time we decide to use them. Or maybe We could just stop using the tchnology altogether. No more internet downloading. I only download sofware updates anyway. They could send me a CD instead. End of pirating?

(I only buy or rent my movies, music, and software.)
 
Anyone that gets the settlement should pay it, seeing as how all of these cases that go to trial tend to end up with 6 or 7 figure judgements. It isn't right, but the justice system allows the jury to be stacked with people that don't use the Internet, even if the case hevily revolves around the Internet. From my experience on jury duty, older people are like 80% of the people that report in the first place. Sitting on a jury with these older people, I have seen them always want to return a guilty verdict, often admitting that they want to set an example.

I don't agree with these lawsuits however, as they haven't been shown to affect overall piracy rates. I boycotted the RIAA from the time they started the lawsuits until the announcement last year that they were not going to issue new ones. They also operate under the assumption that the people that downlaoded the material would have purchased it, which is simply not the case.

I will have to keep tabs of who the producers are issuing these and boycott their films as well. Luckily, it doesn't appear to be an action of the MPAA itself.
 
$1500 for the movie? hahah. fuck you.

I'll give you $10 to rent it. and I'm just being nice.
 
Since I'm not too sure how this would work.

If some one on the list downloaded it, but also owned the movie are they at fault?
 
I assume they are still only going after the Torrent Kiddies and not the Usenet Nerds?
 
I wonder....... Since they are sending all these notices out because people are not paying for the movie.... If I send them a check right off the bat for lets say $19.99 (the average cost of dvd at release), does that place me in the clear to still download it? I am paying them for the media afterall.....

Oh damn, then that means i am not paying taxes on said media, then I got the IRS to worry about.... much bigger dog to appease
 
$1500 to settle in a certain time or $2500 thereafter? Nice racket.

That is bullshit at it's finest right there, in addition to more living proof this country goes down the shitter more and more everyday.
 
  1. They aren't getting charged with murder so the analogy stands, regardless of its lethality.
  2. Ignorance is not an excuse, under the law.
  3. Depending on where you live, keeping an unsecured network may be considered negligence if it is used for illegal purposes.
Except the media companies have the ISP records--they have the proof. Defendants have to refute it.

They don't have proof. They only have a supposed IP.

Ignorance on the computer is commonplace for a technology so new. Why should he be held accountable except for "negligence"? There is absolutely no other reason other than supposed negligence. As for negligence, it's not like the man is laying prescription drugs around the house or setting up a bear trap in his yard. There is no unsuspecting party that gets accidentally injured. Instead, the third party is doing the illegal deed. There is no direct harm in his negligence. The pirate is the one pulling the trigger, whether he gets the internet from the home on the open network on the right, or on the open network on the left. Could even be a hacker for all we know. If your computer gets hacked (and it can happen no matter how careful you are), should you be held responsible for anything your computer does? "You're negligent for using mcafee, I'm suing you!"

That's right, the man isn't hurting anyone like he would be if he negligently left the medicine out for the kids to take. The copyright owner is hurt by the pirate. The pirate is the one to pull the trigger. Don't fault the tool. Should google be held accountable for all harm done?

That's why routers come with manuals. There's no need for advanced training, 'cause they're dead simple (especially those with push-button security configuration) and don't carry a risk of killing anyone.


Here are the section headings of the Linksys WRT54GS User Guide - Chapter 2: Wireless Security Checklist:
  1. Change the default wireless network name or SSID
  2. Change the default password
  3. Enable MAC address filtering
  4. Enable encryption
    General Network Security Guidelines
    Additional Security Tips
Granted, 1 and 3 are kinda crap, but there's no excuse not to follow the rest.

Sheesh man, easy for any one of us on HardForum, but some single mother or grandpa is lucky enough just getting it to work in the first place. When he finally gets it to work, that's enough for him. And if he ventured to try to put do the "password thing" he'll spend hours+ spinning his wheels. He should be warned about any liabilities if he doesn't "put the password on."
 
Meh. Allegedly, I have heard of people that every time they go into a walmart, bestbuy or related store, they hide all the copies of this particular movie in an attempt to drop the sales... allegedly.
 
Maybe someone with more legal experience could answer this question:

How long does one need to be connected/sharing a file in order to be sued for copyright infringement? I mean, if you're only connected for a couple of minutes that is most likely no where near enough time to send the entire file, only a small percentage of it (given most home connection upload speeds).

It would be pretty funny if the pirates got together and came up with a video/song/picture with a copyright owned by an anti-piracy group, bundled it with every pirated movie/game/software/music then sued the RIAA/MPAA/whoever for the pirated media for infringement when they are attempting to get IPs of people infringing on their copyrights.
 
I'd like to see someone go out and buy a bunch of dvd/bd movies off the shelf, taking care to keep their receipts and then go download divx version through bit torrent, without sharing it to others. Then let the letters fly in and show up in court with all of your legally purchased dvd's with receipts.
 
Maybe someone with more legal experience could answer this question:

How long does one need to be connected/sharing a file in order to be sued for copyright infringement? I mean, if you're only connected for a couple of minutes that is most likely no where near enough time to send the entire file, only a small percentage of it (given most home connection upload speeds).

From what I understand length of time means nothing. If you were connected and part of the particular swarm they were monitoring your IP will be there. The argument is very strong for the lawyers as once you are part of the swarm you are a "sharer" of the file in their eyes. Its just the nature of torrenting.
 
This isn't Germany. Routers don't equal loaded (loaded.. ha ironic) guns , they equal garden hoses. If I walk onto your lawn and strangle your wife with a garden hose, your mother in law can't sue you for negligence. If I buy a newspaper and choke a bitch out with it, do we arrest the paper boy?
 
It is your internet connection. You pay for it, and therefore are/should be responsible for it. That's my opinion, but if you could prove it wasn't you, I'm sure you could get off for that type of thing.

The burden of proof should NOT be on the defendants shoulders especially in a civil case, and if this is how you wish for our legal system to be then I feel bad for you. Its insane to think that an IP address was even enough to make these claims in the first place. Its unfortunate but the civil trial system we have in the US makes it too easy to be able to sue anyone. Its a clear example of the law "trying" to keep up with the digital era and falling short by adapting other IP laws to things in the digital world. If this was a civil case about pirated DVD being physically purchased and all they had on you was a fuzzy surveillance photo that might look like you but isn't really clear and they didn't physically catch you with the possession of the DVD it wouldn't even go to trial.
 
Sounds like extortion to me. There should be a class-action countersuit against these bozos.
They can't prove exactly what happened only that at some point a specific IP address was involved.
You can't expect the average consumer to know anything about securing their home network. Most people are happy just to get the internet wirelessly on their laptop. As much as I hate to admit it I have to cut folks some slack on this. These kinds of suits go after low hanging fruit.

Perhaps a boycott of these movies or their media releases afterward is in order in retaliation.
 
I have read some good replies on here but no one has mentioned one thing yet... If you buy a wireless router and leave it unsecured, then you are essentially broadcasting over the airwaves a tool to commit illegal acts... sure it is up to an individual to use it responsibly but often it is abused, obviously. If someone can be sued for someone elses' use of their internet, then there needs to be CLEAR warnings on the routers package. Perhaps box seal that if you break the seal then you understand the risks you are taking? Make them not work at all until you set a password? Something needs to be done further to get the message out!
 
I hope as many people as possible that downloaded this film are nailed with having to pay one way or another.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top