How Doom 4 Got Off Track

That was indeed the premise, and the premise was dead wrong; darkness is not scary, just annoying. It's lighting done properly that's scary, and Doom 3 did it so wrong. A year later, F.E.A.R was released and showed how to do lighting proper scary in ways that Doom 3 never was.

I couldn't get through Doom 3 for this reason- but F.E.A.R. was amazing.
 
I thought D3 was awesome but I do agree that the seemingly COMPLETE darkness eventually got more irritating than scary. FEAR nailed the whole lighting thing and making it scary. That game gave me chills almost the entire time I was playing it. Definitely more scary and eerie than D3 was but I still liked D3 for what it was and it still had its creep and scary spots.
 
I think id's days as a top tier developer are probably done. I'd like to see the company completely re-invent itself and stop focusing so highly on being competitive with other titles in the FPS genre, but I don't think that's going to happen with Willits at the design helm. He does good design, but he also overcomplicates things that should be simple. Rage was just too much game for id to handle. They had the technical prowess, but they don't know how to effectively manage projects of that scale: the six year development time is proof enough of that.

Curiously, I think what they may need to do to re-invent the company is to go back to their roots. Like John was quoted as saying, Doom was about two things: demons and shotguns. Those two elements alone can make a game. Heavily-scripted cinematic sequences and deep character interaction/development aren't id's forte, and they need to stop trying to out-CoD CoD. Rage was a solid game, but there was little to set it apart from others.

I'd like to see id internally move forward on major employee cuts and on a modernized re-release of Quake. Take a game that was successful; modernize the visuals and audio and really exploit some of the more interesting capabilities on the PC; do it on a deadline and on a tight budget. Just make it a really great experience for a little money, the way they were doing things back in the early- to mid-nineties. We know they were good at that, so take the company back toward that direction. Make simple, fun, uncomplicated games that don't try to compete with every other title in the genre in all the ways that've made the genre stale.
 
Doom 3 was fine, especially when it was released in what, 2003? It was awesome.

Rage is a fine game in some technical and gameplay aspects. But I just didn't feel a desire to play it. I started, and then the characters seemed somewhat dull. The story didn't draw me in. Doom3 had an initial draw which kept me interested. I'm talking about why Prey was so fun and I wanted to play it, vs Rage where I talk to the mechanic, go do this, blah blah. It had no "emotional excitement" I guess is what I am trying to describe. I just didn't care about the characters. Sleep over the weekend and I've forgotten about it. Prey, I couldn't stop playing, kinda like whats happening now with Bioshock Infinite.

I think Doom 4 could be great. A good story or some other factor needs to draw me in though. The Doom series has all been pretty good about this. The first doom also had a novelty for being the first 3d game that blew everything else including consoles away at the time, plus the crazy battles where you get swarmed. It had excitement.

Prey demo was perfect. I think I've replayed that game 4 times now. Crysis 1 was great. Some really memorable moments where I remember thinking "holy shit!" Far Cry, same thing.

Story, mood, the ambient music, the situation of your characters. Get these right and you have a hit. Get these wrong and the great technical aspects such as the awesome game engine aren't going to save your product.

I hope they try and save Doom 4.

Doom 3 sucked ass. Plain and simple. Dont forget that Far Cry also came out in 03 and it rocked. I still play Far Cry. Loved that game.
 
Doom 3 was very mediocre in its day. It was received similarly to rage is now. Far cry kick its ass so hard in every way in AI, graphics and its campaign and it was released months before.

Brutal doom provides a better experience then I could fathom a modern doom 4 "reboot" could.
 
Not talking about the critics. Critic's don't determine a games reception. Try looking back in some older forums for a real depiction.
I guess anonymous fanboys who troll metacritic and web boards, many of whom have never played the games they decimate or highly praise, are more trustworthy versus an average of many objective reviews. :rolleyes:

I do remember here and other boards I read. The same thing I mentioned applies. There were plenty of ATI fans who hated the game because ATI hardware couldn't do linear lookups quickly in one of the shaders (ATI eventually made a faster shader replacement in the driver to calculate an approximation instead of doing a lookup). And I was shocked to see how dark the rendering was on ATI hardware vs nvidia hardware, finally understanding what some people were talking about. There's a difference between shadows and black. nvidia was rendering shadows and I don't know what was going on with ATI back then.
 
People that have different opinions from yours are trolls. Critic's are as much of a hypemachine now as much as they were then. Many of those reviews express disappointment even though it was scored highly. I clearly remember doom 3 lasting me less then week and far cry I wasted a whole summer on.
 
John Carmack said:
"Doom means two things: demons and shotguns."

Well, I'm glad they killed the original "Call of Doom" concept. I just get the feeling Willits got in there and was like "we need more *jazz hands*[/]". I'm also glad ZiniMax knuckled down and stopped them from working on Rage 2... but it really sounds like developers are just not into it and maybe it's better if we don't see a mediocre Doom game, and wait until there are folks who are pumped about making one.
 
Doom 3 was epic, plain and simple. Not for gameplay mechanics but the atmosphere, the graphics, the timing of it (2004) all very much epic. Far Cry was epic as well!
 
This, right here. Until mods hit, Doom 3 was over the top dumb as hell. I'm on mars for shits sake. MARS, in a high tech space station, with amazing armor, over the top guns, and... a 5$ corner store flash light with a 0.5w bulb.. that I can only hold without my gun. That totally killed the entire theme for me.

I didn't really think D3 was anything to be too proud of either, but... watching John Carmack's keynote vids he was concerned about the flashlight killing frame rates. Perhaps he was thinking of a future console port, who knows. A lot (most all of us [H] readers) of people were able to tweak settings above the extreme settings by boosting the resolution right out of the box. Not sure if it was a porting dilemma or what but, in all reality the game looked pretty good at the time; that is IF could see it; indeed!!!!!!

Personally I think Id took a dump at Doom3, everyone bought it just because but I think there were some big time changes going on inside the operation. Yes, John Carmack has more side projects than a hooker on Main St, but he isn't solely responsible for what is happening. With the vast employment change since; say even Quake 3 (let alone Quake 1 and before) the company is changing, especially with all this bullshit cloud computing pressure and what have you. Yeah, Carmack is the guy to look up to as an employee, but he is a code guy. But on that same note, I'm not saying it's alright for him to wave "OK, ship Rage, it looks good!!" Because that IS his responsibility. Tough shit, I was a Quake 1/TF maniac back in the day and just hate to 'cut the cord' on one of my favorite gaming companies I have ever known. Never did buy Quake 4 though, guess I was broke and never heard any good reviews. I did play the demo though I guess and thought that sucked as well.

That's my 2 cents, and my last beer for the night as well.
 
Doom 4 needs to bring back all of the original monster designs; i.e., the cybernetic arachnid thingies and Barons. They also need to make it feel satanic like the original games.
 
Doom 3 was very enjoyable. It is the only game that could make me jump from something unexpected happening. Yes, it was sometimes too dark but it was the theme they wanted. Even with the duct tape mod the game was still awesome. The engine was a little blah, but the lighting effects and ambiance of the game was awesome.
 
The problem is that Carmack is ID and he is interested in motion headsets right now and maybe next generation engine tech (which isn't happening as 3d graphics is slowing down) So the plan was to create content and address complaints people pointed out in rage. (Low res textures etc) but Rage, while technology wise is amazing and rivals the complexity of operating systems, requires monumental artistic talent and contribution. I'm guessing lackluster talent and poor management led to the poor quality of doom4. And even if your artists suck you still have to pay them every week until you notice, with all that money Rage is sure to make
 
Doom 3 still has a lot of scare factor. The flashlight mod was one of the needed upgrades to the game. D3:R was even better. The Classic Doom mod is a must after playing through it. Main favorite weapons are the IPL, BFG9K, Chainsaw, Soul Cube. Quake 3 was a very good game. I also agree that id has been very lazy in the gaming scene. I bought RAGE when the price dropped to $19.99 dollars and I still think that it was overpriced.
Considering how buggy bethesda games are, we can all guess that Doom 4 will need a couple hundred patches for it to work right if it isn't completely broken at release.
 
Considering that Doom 3 was released around the same time as Half-Life 2 and UT2004, I'd saw that Doom 3 was definitely not the best FPS released that year.
 
Doom 3 still has a lot of scare factor. The flashlight mod was one of the needed upgrades to the game.

Yeah, the flashlight thing was really the only major issue with Doom 3. I thought it was a good game for what it was. I wish that one guy that made the super HD texture pack would have finished...he only ended up doing the last few levels or something.
 
I like how this man thinks, idc at the time I rarely heard anyone complain about the game like people are today, but man do I hate action movies that pull that shaky cam crap when i know some of these action stars can pull off the stunts themselves just fine.

EXACTLY. The worst part? Sometimes you have an AWESOME scene...that would be even MORE awesome if you could *see* WTF was going on. The Bourne versus Desh fight scene. It was AMAZING! (what little you could see of it). When shaky cam becomes a habit, even good directing and choreography gets flushed in the crapper.

Making a game too *dark* is the equivalent.
 
The Bourne versus Desh fight scene. It was AMAZING! (what little you could see of it). When shaky cam becomes a habit, even good directing and choreography gets flushed in the crapper.

It's funny you should mention that, that scene is the one I think of most often when I think of how shitty shaky-cam is in action sequences.
 
I really don't understand why so many people think Doom 3 was too dark. I could see absolutely fine most of the time without the flashlight. Then again, I play games with no lights on except a 25 watt red light so I don't get screen glare but can still see the keyboard a bit. Was everyone just afraid of turning off the lights or don't know how to up the gamma or something? I didn't find Doom 3 scary, as I don't see why a video game should scare anyone. It was a blast to play - still is - though I'll admit that I only play it with the shotgun modded to have a sane spread and decreased damage so that it's more like the original Doom shotgun and not "useless beyond point blank range". Still, I don't get the "it's too dark" complaints. Maybe Phoenix can see in the dark better than humans?
 
Come on people, at the time when Doom 3 came out, it was pretty much the best looking game out there and people were building systems to run it. It was scary as shit even when you knew when you pick up that ammo bait, something will jump out. Those baby monsters were freaky as hell too, made you want to find and kill all of them. I wouldn't say it was the best game as far as gameplay goes, but it definitely kicked a lot of ass at the time.

I'm still not sure where all the Rage bashing comes from either, I enjoyed the game despite its setbacks. It has probably the best atmosphere of most post-apocalyptic games I've played in a long time. I sure as hell enjoyed it being a fast paced shooter as well. I think they did a great job combining multiple genres into one, that's for sure! Level design was also very creative in that game. It was probably best 10 bucks I spent on a game in a while (got it on first big Steam sale).
 
I really don't understand why so many people think Doom 3 was too dark. I could see absolutely fine most of the time without the flashlight. Then again, I play games with no lights on except a 25 watt red light so I don't get screen glare but can still see the keyboard a bit. Was everyone just afraid of turning off the lights or don't know how to up the gamma or something? I didn't find Doom 3 scary, as I don't see why a video game should scare anyone. It was a blast to play - still is - though I'll admit that I only play it with the shotgun modded to have a sane spread and decreased damage so that it's more like the original Doom shotgun and not "useless beyond point blank range". Still, I don't get the "it's too dark" complaints. Maybe Phoenix can see in the dark better than humans?

Rooooxanne.
 
Kotaku further reports that Doom 4 is now planned for next-generation consoles but “the actual release date is up in the air.” The title reportedly began as a Call of Duty-style shooter but has since evolved past that. The team behind 2011’s Rage was allegedly working on Rage 2 but that project has since been canceled and the team has now joined Doom 4 development.

Can I get an epic... what the shit! :eek:
 
sad to see the demise of iD software...a once great cutting edge PC gaming developer
 
Back
Top