HardOCP ATI CrossFire Preview

FanATIc said:
You go do that empty head, go make a poll in the motherboard section. You'll get a rude awakening. People there love to OC. ATI boards are killer OC's. Did you even go there and see the comments about the boards leaked from Cebit? Nothing but praise. I certainly do love this first SLI Nforce4 motherboard, 6 months later im still forced to run in 2T when i overclock past a 230FSB.

Oh noez not SATA II, god forbid my HDs are running aweful on this shitty outdated SATA I
Is there anyway i can delete your posts out of the threads i read?

dude...if you want a second rate motherboard...go right ahead and get one...

P.S. None of these people seemed to have a problem overclocking their NF4 boards...so maybe it's just user error.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
Well the major problem is going to be nforce boards...that's the enthusiast board of choice...and you can bet your ass nVidia will do anything and everything to keep Crossfire from working on it...this is where ATi is really hurting...it's going to take years for them to break into the motherboard market...

Where are you people getting this?? :confused:
If Nvidia wanted to really screw ATI they have been missing the boat for several years now. Nforce 1-4..........Hello McFly? :)
ATI has built crossfire within the specs of PCI-E. It needs 2 x16 slots which are used to access main memory (x8 and x8 effective). If it doesn't work then the chipset designer has not implemented PCI-E correctly.
Nvidia did not invent/design PCI-E, therefore it is an open technology (maybe not the correct wording but you get the point). SLI is built within PCI-E specs. SLI works on "non-SLI" boards as long as you have drivers that Nvidia hasn't built system checks into.
The only way I could see Nvidia causing Crossfire problems is on "official SLI" boards.

Could you imagine the outcry of the enthusiast community if it was found that Nvidia was purposely causing problems for ATI video cards, not to mention it would be extremely unethical and more than likely illegal.


BTW...cool it down guys. No need for insulting each other. We're all adults here right? :D
 
wickedld9 said:
Where are you people getting this?? :confused:
If Nvidia wanted to really screw ATI they have been missing the boat for several years now. Nforce 1-4..........Hello McFly? :)
ATI has built crossfire within the specs of PCI-E. It needs 2 x16 slots which are used to access main memory (x8 and x8 effective). If it doesn't work then the chipset designer has not implemented PCI-E correctly.
Nvidia did not invent/design PCI-E, therefore it is an open technology (maybe not the correct wording but you get the point). SLI is built within PCI-E specs. SLI works on "non-SLI" boards as long as you have drivers that Nvidia hasn't built system checks into.
The only way I could see Nvidia causing Crossfire problems is on "official SLI" boards.

Could you imagine the outcry of the enthusiast community if it was found that Nvidia was purposely causing problems for ATI video cards, not to mention it would be extremely unethical and more than likely illegal.


BTW...cool it down guys. No need for insulting each other. We're all adults here right? :D

Well they successfully blocked their non-SLI nforce boards from running SLI via drivers (or so I heard, that could be wrong)...and I suspect they can do the same with ATi videocards...and if they need to bend the PCI-E spec a little to do so, I'm sure they will...nforce boards make up a huge part of the motherboard market...

I don't see how nvidia could resist dealing such a blow to ATi if it is at all possible...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
Well they successfully blocked their non-SLI nforce boards from running SLI via drivers (or so I heard, that could be wrong)...and I suspect they can do the same with ATi videocards...and if they need to bend the PCI-E spec a little to do so, I'm sure they will...nforce boards make up a huge part of the motherboard market...

I don't see how nvidia could resist dealing such a blow to ATi if it is at all possible...

But doing it through drivers can be easily bipassed..... simply dont update, you're not missing out on that much now.
 
Skrying said:
But doing it through drivers can be easily bipassed..... simply dont update, you're not missing out on that much now.

Hmm...well I'm sure whatever they do...we'll find a way to hack around it...but for system integrators and most users...it'll probably be a deal breaker...who knows though...nvidia may very well take the opposite approach and enable Crossfire ASAP...but considering how dirty the little war between ATi and Nvidia has gotten in the past...I just don't expect it...
 
I started to read through this thread but came to the quick realization that empty has "RUINED" it.

The board looks nice and overclocks like a champ but I will wait for the dual R520's.
 
Skrying said:
Ummm, what are you saying?

There is nothing at all in the northbridge from my understanding that lets Crossfire happen. That's why it will and is possible on other chipsets that support spliting the 16x PCIe slot into two 8x slots.

Secondly, ATI is already saying they are looking into making Crossfire work on Nvidia Nforce 4 SLI boards.

Another thing, Crossfire works with cards all the way down to the $200 X800s, and all the way to the X850XT PE's, so just as wide of range of cards works with Crossfire as with SLI.

You need to do a little reading and try to understand instead of interpeting to your liking.
Dude X800 is the top of the line,i have no idea what the hell you are talking about. Down to means X700,X600,X300. Face it Crossfire is going to be expensive,just like SLI with 2 6800 Ultra's.
 
CMAN said:
You need to do a little reading and try to understand instead of interpeting to your liking.
Dude X800 is the top of the line,i have no idea what the hell you are talking about. Down to means X700,X600,X300. Face it Crossfire is going to be expensive,just like SLI with 2 6800 Ultra's.

I wouldnt consider a $200 X800 top of the line, I'd call that middle ground. the X800 is ment to replace the X700XT that never came out. So, therefore Crossfire covers just as much ground as SLI.

Crossfire/SLI on low end cards is completely pointless in the first place.
 
With G70's coming out around the same time, ATI should have waited to implement this on their R520 line. Why buy a x800 crossfire when you can have a G70 SLI.

The article I read stated that ATI is working with NVIDIA to get crossfire working on the nForce platform. I would think that both SLI & Crossfire operate a little outside the PCIe spec and some sort of driver and or bios tweak is needed.

Crossfire is not out yet so who knows, but it looks like for now you will need a new ATI motherboard to run it until they hammer out the details with Intel and NVIDIA. SLI is also coming to Intel chipsets. So you can chose your poison soon.
 
^eMpTy^ said:
Rick, you know you're my favorite ATi fan...because you actually have a sense of humor...

Sorry if I thread crapped...all this Computex stuff has me all up in a !!!!!! tizzy...
No joke. Lets wait until the retail boards are tested before we say how bad it is and speculate on its feature set.

With the R520 MIA, don't be surprised if NV holds off on the G70.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
No joke. Lets wait until the retail boards are tested before we say how bad it is and speculate on its feature set.

With the R520 MIA, don't be surprised if NV holds off on the G70.

Well here's what I think about G70...nvidia held off on a refresh of the NV40 so they could beat ATi to the punch and release G70 ahead of R520...and then they'll quickly refresh G70 on 90nm and trump R520 when it's released...or atleast...if I were them...that's what I would do...

The show's not over yet...ATi can still announce R520 at computex...and if they do...all will be forgiven on my end...I just can't believe that they would launch Crossfire like this without R520...just doesn't make any sense...Dave over at B3D had similar sentiments...
 
fallguy said:
The same people putting down ATi, imagine that.

What can I say...I'm a !!!!!!...I admit it...I hate ATi for absolutely no reason...sue me
 
*sigh* only if this came out a fwe months ago... i wouldn't have bought my current setup... =(
 
don't waste your time/energy on buyer's remorse... just enjoy whatchooo got. :)
 
^eMpTy^ said:
The show's not over yet...ATi can still announce R520 at computex...and if they do...all will be forgiven on my end...I just can't believe that they would launch Crossfire like this without R520...just doesn't make any sense...Dave over at B3D had similar sentiments...
As much as I like ATI's offerings and will give them first look when purchasing, I have little faith in them releasing the R520 anytime soon. Something must be awfull wrong for it not to be at Comdex.
 
R1ckCa1n said:
As much as I like ATI's offerings and will give them first look when purchasing, I have little faith in them releasing the R520 anytime soon. Something must be awfull wrong for it not to be at Comdex.
Yeah I'm a kind of worried about that too (and no doing H.264 decoding doesn't really count in my book). I would have thought they'd atleast have demo r520 units running in Crossfire or something like that.

I am rather interested in NV's new IGP mobos though (that is if they can do component out).
 
CrimandEvil said:
Yeah I'm a kind of worried about that too (and no doing H.264 decoding doesn't really count in my book). I would have thought they'd atleast have demo r520 units running in Crossfire or something like that.

I am rather interested in NV's new IGP mobos though (that is if they can do component out).
I am also intrested in the New Nvidia Chipsets. I am hoping for a refresh to the NForce line. Maybe Nforce 4 platnium? Or even NForce 5.

I am hoping for something along the lines laying out the ground work for SLI 2 since they said it will change at the hardware level.

What I really want to see, if an NForce 4 Pro chipset on a Regular A64/X2 Motherboard.
 
Could someone explain to me why the pipelines would need to be disabled for a setup with cards that have different amounts of pipelines? I don't know the technical reasons.

Also, how much does cutting off the pipelines cost the performance of the card? If you just ran a straight up test of a single card with 16 pipelines and then disabled it down to 12, what would be the performance decrease?
 
I don't care about either company, although i like both, and i've used both types of cards for years with no problems. I use what's best for me and my budget at the time, not what the current flavor of the month is.
SLI/Crossfire is for the enthusiasts atm, not the general users. (though it will trickle down eventually i'd imagine) All this talk of ATI being "Late" isn't really all that important since my guess is that most of those who have SLI,ect; are the ones who didn't want to wait and who want the best right now, not later.
When it's time to upgrade (Hopefully soon..lol), i'll read these boards and other sites and make the best choice i can for what i want in my system, and for what i can afford. Not on who is better or how one can do 1-2 FPS faster than the other...
Just my .02
 
Dual Slave Cards? http://www.techreport.com/onearticle.x/8390

Curiously, the first thing DFI showed us was what they described as a pair of slave cards running together cooperatively. The DVI output to the LCD display was only hooked to one of the two video cards, and the system was running 3DMark05. I asked how the cards were sharing data, and the gent pointed to the north bridge chip between the two cards.
 
I guess this wasn't so "thrown together" as some people think since it looks like two regular cards can compose the image without the composite engine card, hrmmmmmm
 
The comment about Nvidia "blocking" ATI's Crossfire solution through drivers is quite a uneducated and moronic statement. First I don't think it's technically possible, and second it would actually be a HORRIBLE business move for Nvidia anyway. OEMs would shun them for forcing their hand to one card, not that there are many yet. Its all about giving the consumer choices else they take their business elsewhere. And most of us possessing something called common sense, want the option to get either brand in the future, depending what is the fastest or best deal going.
 
Its possible but I think they would eventualy get in some sort of trouble be it legal or something else.
 
Brent_Justice said:


So you dont need master cards at all to get the same effect? Just as long as they're following the same basic guidelines as SLI cards? The scores seem very nice. Where are all the people saying the bridge is required and that software render would cause it to be far insuperior?? Correct me if im wrong but you can do the same effect under SLI, it does not require the bridge but you take a small loss, right?


Why wouldnt ATI market this as well i wonder though? Maybe to cut confusion so people dont start buying mismatched slaves and thinking ones a master anyway?

Am i the only one who feels that this is so unrestricting compared to SLI that its stupid to even consider SLI now?

You can do 2 slaves, provided they are exact.
A master and a slave of any type, eg. X800-X800 X850-X850
3 Different render modes + Extreme SSAA

For early cards and drivers this is almost too good to be true. Then add to it the gains coming in Cat 5.6 Official due out June 6. Nvidia is about to walk smack into a brick wall. If the R520 is a hit they will be in major trouble.
 
Brent_Justice said:
i don't know, it's new news to me


Would appear ATI did alot more work on that northbridge then anyone knew. Has to be a rather complex peice of hardware to be so versatile. I highly doubt its a fluke. Though i guess we now know where the "needs a bridge" "doesnt need a bridge" comments came from.
 
killerD said:
The comment about Nvidia "blocking" ATI's Crossfire solution through drivers is quite a uneducated and moronic statement. First I don't think it's technically possible, and second it would actually be a HORRIBLE business move for Nvidia anyway. OEMs would shun them for forcing their hand to one card, not that there are many yet. Its all about giving the consumer choices else they take their business elsewhere. And most of us possessing something called common sense, want the option to get either brand in the future, depending what is the fastest or best deal going.

Funny that you think my statement was moronic and uneducated...cuz guess what!? I think your's is too...

It's absolutely technically possible. They've already stopped people from running SLi on non-SLi motherboards via drivers. If OEMs want Crossfire cards, they'll get Crossfire motherboards...why mix and match when you can sell a PC with the same brand name everywhere. OEMs wouldn't shun a god damned thing, they'd have one Crossfire system and one SLi system.

And nVidia doesn't give two shits about giving you options. They care about selling more cards. Often the two goals are aligned, but in this case not. If they can cut ATi off at the knees, the will absolutely do it. Hell they cut off their own motherboards and you think they won't do it to their arch enemy? Yeah, you have some AMAZING common sense there...good job.

I'm not saying it's going to happen, I'm just saying I give it a 75% chance.

Why do the ignorant ones always think they have "common sense"?
 
The article reads kinda funny, but I was left with the impression that the "dual slave" setup was running in AFR, in which case there would be no image recompositing, it would simply pass one full frame from one card to the other. And that could very well occur between the two PCI-E slots directly. Either way, I'm thinking this is a bit hokey...if it were that simple I'm absolutely positive ATi would stand up and say "HEY look what we can do!"...ya know?

QFT...on the front page...told ya it sounded hokey...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
Funny that you think my statement was moronic and uneducated...cuz guess what!? I think your's is too...


Are....its I think yours are....


^eMpTy^ said:
The article reads kinda funny, but I was left with the impression that the "dual slave" setup was running in AFR, in which case there would be no image recompositing, it would simply pass one full frame from one card to the other. And that could very well occur between the two PCI-E slots directly.

Either way, I'm thinking this is a bit hokey...if it were that simple I'm absolutely positive ATi would stand up and say "HEY look what we can do!"...ya know?


So, uh, I suppose a CrossFire master card with an image compositing engine isn't strictly necessary for multi-card acceleration. He said that you could hook up the monitor to the DVI output on the secondary slave card and see only half of the frames when the cards are rendering in alternate-frame mode, but I utterly failed to force him to show me out of foolish politeness. He also told me that the two cards must be an exact match in order to run in dual slave mode.

reads fine for me. He can hook the DVI up to the second card and what would happen on screen is that it would render every other frame only rather then both switching. It has to be run through the top slave card so the image can complete and communicate between the northbridge and both cards.

Im pretty sure AFR is what they have been using for 3Dmark05 otherwise im really impressed with supertiling. So as you can see from that bit of read, it works fine. The way your making it sound would mean that it doesnt work at all which it clearly does. Supertiling or AFR both cards need their info working in unison which they show happening. So they are indeed working in full glory.
 
FanATIc said:
Are....its I think yours are....

It's, not its.

I'm tired, what's your excuse?

Furthermore, I was referring to the "STATEMENT" which was SINGULAR...therefore it's (note the apostrophe) IS not ARE...

P.S. You're a super genius.
 
FanATIc said:
Am i the only one who feels that this is so unrestricting compared to SLI that its stupid to even consider SLI now?

I'll make the same comment I did the first time I saw a post of yours. You couldn't have picked a more fitting handle. :p
 
FanATIc said:
Are....its I think yours are....

reads fine for me. He can hook the DVI up to the second card and what would happen on screen is that it would render every other frame only rather then both switching. It has to be run through the top slave card so the image can complete and communicate between the northbridge and both cards.

Im pretty sure AFR is what they have been using for 3Dmark05 otherwise im really impressed with supertiling. So as you can see from that bit of read, it works fine. The way your making it sound would mean that it doesnt work at all which it clearly does. Supertiling or AFR both cards need their info working in unison which they show happening. So they are indeed working in full glory.

Right, he was guessing, thus the word "suppose".

I'm just saying, the term "recomposite" is usually applied to split frame, or super tiling. AFR is just a whole frame, no calculation necessary, just read it from somewhere and output it on the DVI port. It may be passing through the northbridge, but it makes more sense (i.e. it would be more compatible) for it to just pass from card to card via the un-used pci-e connections (which is how ATi has said it works all along, right?)...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
Right, he was guessing, thus the word "suppose".

I'm just saying, the term "recomposite" is usually applied to split frame, or super tiling. AFR is just a whole frame, no calculation necessary, just read it from somewhere and output it on the DVI port. It may be passing through the northbridge, but it makes more sense (i.e. it would be more compatible) for it to just pass from card to card via the un-used pci-e connections (which is how ATi has said it works all along, right?)...


Like i said, i believe SLI was workable without its bridge as well but in that case you'd take a minor loss. I dont see one here unless it changes down the line. Still though, with ATI saying you need a master and a slave, and now they have 2 slaves working in unison, i think it would be a big help to figure out a way to market this as well under the same guidelines as SLI. Its going to be alot easier to find cheap and more available slave cards then master cards. If the output is just as good whos to complain. As i said though, marketing this might be a slight nightmare with the general public.
 
FanATIc said:
Am i the only one who feels that this is so unrestricting compared to SLI that its stupid to even consider SLI now?

Nope, I totally agree. Throw R520 in the mix and I'm sold. As long as the drivers come out nice and stable, it's faster than dual G70s, and I don't have to use an ATi motherboard...

My only bitch with Crossfire right now, is that the x850s/x800s don't have FP blending and PS3.0, so they make a very unwise high-end videocard investment right now...everything else about Crossfire is just peachy...
 
FanATIc said:
Like i said, i believe SLI was workable without its bridge as well but in that case you'd take a minor loss. I dont see one here unless it changes down the line. Still though, with ATI saying you need a master and a slave, and now they have 2 slaves working in unison, i think it would be a big help to figure out a way to market this as well under the same guidelines as SLI. Its going to be alot easier to find cheap and more available slave cards then master cards. If the output is just as good whos to complain. As i said though, marketing this might be a slight nightmare with the general public.

Well the output won't be as good because you'll have very limited compatibility (which is no doubt why ATi is avoiding it) compared to master/slave Crossfire.
 
They can probably do it. But the thing is who wants to say that you need a master and a slave for full speed, but for a little less you can go slave/slave blah blah blah. Kinda how SLI would be without the bridge I guess you could say.

Still seems so much is simply a mystery to us all. Hopefully in a week or two we can finally get a few clear and clean cut facts instead of the useable marketing BS right now.
 
Back
Top