HardOCP ATI CrossFire Preview

^eMpTy^ said:
Brent, from your perspective...what's your take on the fact that you don't have samples yet? Do you know when you'll be getting one? Is it wierd to paper launch it like this at computex? Or is it normal to paper launch at a show then do a real launch later?

Its happened before.

FYI SLI was announced and previewed on June 27th 2004, and we did not have hardware until more than 5 months later in November. Our first published hardware preview with performance analysis was published on November 23rd 2004.
 
pandora's box said:
i do have a question though...

if the master card is a r520 card (sm3.0 etc...) and the slave card is a x800 card (sm2.0b) what happens when you play a sm3.0 game?

The master card is an X850 or X800 video card only right now.

X850 CrossFire Edition works with X850 series cards.

X800 CrossFire Edition works with X800 series cards.
 
Brent_Justice said:
Its happened before.

FYI SLI was announced and previewed on June 27th 2004, and we did not have hardware until more than 5 months later in November. Our first published hardware preview with performance analysis was published on November 23rd 2004.

That's a really good point...I suppose I'm just being impatient because they're almost a year behind nvidia's announcement...
 
Brent_Justice said:
Its happened before.

FYI SLI was announced and previewed on June 27th 2004, and we did not have hardware until more than 5 months later in November. Our first published hardware preview with performance analysis was published on November 23rd 2004.

correct me if im wrong but this was mostly because of the chipsets still needing work and Nvidia requiring the bridge chip to make PCI Express NV4X cores.

Since CrossFire is based on an already shipping chipset, and from what i have heard completed and working. As well as PCI Express cards are now in good availability, there wont be that period of delay....

It was also the only 939 PCI Express capable chipset. Alot of reasons for delay on nVidias part, ATI doesnt have that luxery in my opinion.
 
Brent_Justice said:
The master card is an X850 or X800 video card only right now.

X850 CrossFire Edition works with X850 series cards.

X800 CrossFire Edition works with X800 series cards.

I think it's safe to assume the R520 will not work with x800 cards...considering x850s can't even work with x800s...
 
FanATIc said:
correct me if im wrong but this was mostly because of the chipsets still needing work and Nvidia requiring the bridge chip to make PCI Express NV4X cores.

Since CrossFire is based on an already shipping chipset, and from what i have heard completed and working. As well as PCI Express cards are now in good availability, there wont be that period of delay....

It was also the only 939 PCI Express capable chipset. Alot of reasons for delay on nVidias part, ATI doesnt have that luxery in my opinion.

According to the preview at anand ATi is already hitting delays with their southbridge...not to mention the chipset is not already shipping...it's a new chipset to support dual cards...

If the whole thing was ready to go, there'd be performance numbers all over the place...I don't think ATi will let SLi keep the performance crown for one second longer than they have to...
 
^eMpTy^ said:
According to the preview at anand ATi is already hitting delays with their southbridge...not to mention the chipset is not already shipping...it's a new chipset to support dual cards...

If the whole thing was ready to go, there'd be performance numbers all over the place...I don't think ATi will let SLi keep the performance crown for one second longer than they have to...


Xpress200 is on all accounts exactly the same as the CrossFire boards, it IS shipping.

unless their goal isnt to make you get 300 totally useless FPS but actually give you quality??? :eek:
 
FanATIc said:
Xpress200 is on all accounts exactly the same as the CrossFire boards, it IS shipping.

unless their goal isnt to make you get 300 totally useless FPS but actually give you quality??? :eek:

ok...correct me if I'm wrong here...the crossfire edition has two peg x16 slots right? and the vanilla xpress200 doesn't...thus making them two different motherboards...right?

and the southbridge is broken...right?

Did you read the last page of anand's review?
 
hardwarephreak said:
It is funny though, as ATI criticized nvidia's hardware bridge between the cards as "ineligant". An external dongle just makes me cringe.

Too bad they didn't say not flexable enough. That would have made a good pun.



On another note, this review blows away what everyone was talking about ATi doing with GPU not mattering, X600, X700, etc. Sucks a bit. But that would have been a real pain.
 
Brent_Justice said:
7. Will CrossFire Edition cards work in an NForce 4 motherboard?

A. ATI is focused first on qualifying our chipsets with our GPUs. We’ll evaluate Nvidia solutions in the future.

Sooo i've been planning and researching like a tweaked hooker on 7th street for a few months now. I'm planning to purchase and build my 939 setup and i've planned to go with the single PCI-e (did i get that right?) 16x slot MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum board.

However if there is a good chance that this crossfire technology will work with the NF4 chipset in the future, than i'd be willing to pay an extra $30-$40 now, and go with the SLI version of that board. Just in case Crossfire becomes compatible down the road.

I dont want to wait any longer to build this system, i'll be doing it on the 6th, so i need to make some heavy decisions, quickly.

Is the hurdle a technical problem, or are they pretty sure they'll get it working on the nvidia chipset, given however many months they need?
 
fbiguy said:
Sooo i've been planning and researching like a tweaked hooker on 7th street for a few months now. I'm planning to purchase and build my 939 setup and i've planned to go with the single PCI-e (did i get that right?) 16x slot MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum board.

However if there is a good chance that this crossfire technology will work with the NF4 chipset in the future, than i'd be willing to pay an extra $30-$40 now, and go with the SLI version of that board. Just in case Crossfire becomes compatible down the road.

I dont want to wait any longer to build this system, i'll be doing it on the 6th, so i need to make some heavy decisions, quickly.

Is the hurdle a technical problem, or are they pretty sure they'll get it working on the nvidia chipset, given however many months they need?

it's probably all marketing...if ATi is smart they'll get their cards working on nforce motherboards (and if nvidia is smart they'll make it absolutely impossible)...
 
fbiguy said:
Sooo i've been planning and researching like a tweaked hooker on 7th street for a few months now. I'm planning to purchase and build my 939 setup and i've planned to go with the single PCI-e (did i get that right?) 16x slot MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum board.

However if there is a good chance that this crossfire technology will work with the NF4 chipset in the future, than i'd be willing to pay an extra $30-$40 now, and go with the SLI version of that board. Just in case Crossfire becomes compatible down the road.

I dont want to wait any longer to build this system, i'll be doing it on the 6th, so i need to make some heavy decisions, quickly.

Is the hurdle a technical problem, or are they pretty sure they'll get it working on the nvidia chipset, given however many months they need?

Get the SLI board, its only a bit more so you're not out much if it doesnt work and if it does work then its very well spent.
 
Brent_Justice said:
So all games (new and old) according to ATI will be receiving the performance benefit of CrossFire by default, with no interaction from the user.

I don't think that's entirely correct. The high level of compatiblity seems to come from the ability for the two cards to do 6xAA each in SuperAA mode which is an IQ and not a performance benefit. The other three modes will have the same compatiblity issues as current SLI.

Firingsquad said:
When we quizzed them about this, they indicated that they can boast support for so many titles because of SuperAA. In other words, they’re not claiming you’ll see a performance improvement in every game you play thanks to CrossFire, instead their solution allows you to crank up the AA to levels never seen before previously.

For Nvidia to compete with this, they will have to come up with some way to make their 16xS usable but that's doubtful.
 
trinibwoy said:
I don't think that's entirely correct. The high level of compatiblity seems to come from the ability for the two cards to do 6xAA each in SuperAA mode which is an IQ and not a performance benefit. The other three modes will have the same compatiblity issues as current SLI.

The default render mode with CrossFire enabled is SuperTile in ALL D3D titles and Scissor in ALL OGL titles, according to ATI.

In that case there should be a performance benefit in all titles that are video card bound at whatever game/resolution/aa/af settings etc...

In those games that are old and very CPU bound you obviously would not get a performance increase, so what CrossFire will allow you to do is to increase the AA settings up to a very high level, with which if you compared to a single video card should be running faster with two video cards.

One of the big pros in my opinion about ATI's CrossFire is the ability to operate in CrossFire mode (SuperTile or Scissor or AFR) in every game, new and old versus NV's SLI which to run in SLI (SFR or AFR) you need a game profile specifying what SLI mode to run in.
 
I'm a bit confused on how ATI's supertiling handles view frustum culling. Wouldn't supertiling require an extreme amount of clipping since so many polygons would cross the frustum of each card?
 
^eMpTy^ said:
ok...correct me if I'm wrong here...the crossfire edition has two peg x16 slots right? and the vanilla xpress200 doesn't...thus making them two different motherboards...right?

and the southbridge is broken...right?

Did you read the last page of anand's review?


I'v seen you blindly down playing and putting down CrossFire in three threads now that have reviews that say positive things. And you're doing it for no reason other then the fact that you own SLI and im very sure you dont want to be proven wrong on the hundreds of times you've said ATI wont release anything for a year or what ever. Anyone can check your post history if they have a week to waste.

Quoted from the dreaded doomed southbridge area on And

Luckily, ATI has partnered with ULi to offer working South Bridges that are compatible with ATI's CrossFire North Bridge. We've tested ULi's South Bridges and they seem to be problem-free, and our sentiments are echoed by many motherboard manufacturers who have decided to use ULi South Bridges with their ATI CrossFire motherboards.

ATI has left it completely up to the motherboard manufacturers as to which version they choose.

So im sorry, i dont see a problem. Did you read it beyond the title before questioning me if i did? Again, there is no problem with ATI's boards and they are ready to be released. And again, i dont see the difficulty in this, Xpress200 and CrossFire Xpress200 are using essentially the same chipsets. Yes, the boards have 2 PCIE slots, amazing, but it doesnt mean its not basically the same chipset. Notice how Nforce 4, all very very alike, are being used on 3 different versions of boards? Essentially the same chipset powering them, different motherboards, understand? Think of it like GPU core and how universal it can be used to support a wide arrange of varrying products.
 
Brent_Justice said:
Well there is obviously no way to know. SuperTiling is way better at load-balancing however.

BTW the E&S cards use SuperTiling.

yes - and you get the /super/ sampling (AA) along with that, also... right? or is that not specific to tile rendering? Anyways, that sounds very nice. I think that could be an exrtremely attractive selling point... amazing speed... _and_ IQ! :)
 
poopy said:
I'm a bit confused on how ATI's supertiling handles view frustum culling. Wouldn't supertiling require an extreme amount of clipping since so many polygons would cross the frustum of each card?

Is that over-fetching? I think that is the known big draw-back with TR. to the extent of the actual performance hit it yet to be seen.
 
Skrying said:
... It allows dual monitor ...
Dual Monitor support a for sure thing with Crossfire? That's great! I was confuzzled since Anandtech seems to show the output only coming from the crossfire card. Like it's the only output possible or something.
 
It sounds pretty cool but I would like to see some hard numbers before I "wet my panties" so to speak but it is rather interesting (even though I think it to be rather inelegant).

What I would like to know is WTF is happening with R520?

Okay I'm a bit confused on the no selector card thing. So ATI says that it is all done in BIOS so no need for a messy selector card like NV uses for SLI but what about this part in the Anand preview?
One of ATI's most interesting claims with their CrossFire solution is that you no longer need the selector card that is seen on nForce4 SLI motherboards. How is it that ATI is able to get around this requirement? Contrary to popular belief, it's not magic.

By default, the nForce4 SLI chipset sends all 16 PCI Express lanes from the North Bridge to the first PCI Express x16 slot on a nForce4 SLI motherboard.

Flipping the selector card the other way divides the PCI Express lanes and sends the first 8 lanes to the first slot and the remaining 8 lanes to the second slot.

ATI's MVP chipset works slightly differently; by default, the North Bridge sends 8 PCI Express lanes to each of the two PCI Express slots. If you have two cards installed, then this is the desired configuration. However, if you only have one card installed, in order to get a full PCI Express x16 slot, one of the following methods must be implemented by the motherboard manufacturer:
Option 1 - Terminator Card
Option 2 - SLI Selector Card
Option 3 - Selector ICs
 
FanATIc said:
ATI has left it completely up to the motherboard manufacturers as to which version they choose.

So im sorry, i dont see a problem. Did you read it beyond the title before questioning me if i did? Again, there is no problem with ATI's boards and they are ready to be released.
Thats rather funny cause Anand goes on:
While it's hardly talked about outside of Taiwan, ATI's South Bridge is quite buggy. The chip that is responsible for providing the motherboard's SATA and USB ports, as well as PCI slots is no where near final and many manufacturers are skeptical of ATI's ability to finish their own South Bridge in time. Note that ATI's own South Bridge does not support SATA-II or NCQ, regardless of actual bugs with the chip.

Luckily, ATI has partnered with ULi to offer working South Bridges that are compatible with ATI's CrossFire North Bridge. We've tested ULi's South Bridges and they seem to be problem-free, and our sentiments are echoed by many motherboard manufacturers who have decided to use ULi South Bridges with their ATI CrossFire motherboards.

However, ATI is pushing most of their partners to use ATI's own South Bridge despite its problems and is convinced that the problems will be sorted out in time. So a number of manufacturers at Computex are showing off CrossFire solutions with ATI's South Bridge, despite their complaints to us about the South Bridge.

At least this time around, it may be better for motherboard manufacturers to use ULi's South Bridge until ATI has had more time to get all of the kinks out of their solution. ULi's South Bridges have been in use for the past generation of ATI's chipsets thanks to issues with ATI's South Bridges, and so far we have not heard of any complaints.


ATI should be focused on the overall platform, not necessarily building up support for their South Bridge. Although we do think it is a bit embarrassing to have to turn to another chipset vendor to provide working South Bridges for your motherboard partners. It would be one thing if this were ATI's first chipset, but it most definitely is not.
 
FanATIc said:
I'v seen you blindly down playing and putting down CrossFire in three threads now that have reviews that say positive things. And you're doing it for no reason other then the fact that you own SLI and im very sure you dont want to be proven wrong on the hundreds of times you've said ATI wont release anything for a year or what ever. Anyone can check your post history if they have a week to waste.

Quoted from the dreaded doomed southbridge area on And

ATI has left it completely up to the motherboard manufacturers as to which version they choose.

So im sorry, i dont see a problem. Did you read it beyond the title before questioning me if i did? Again, there is no problem with ATI's boards and they are ready to be released. And again, i dont see the difficulty in this, Xpress200 and CrossFire Xpress200 are using essentially the same chipsets. Yes, the boards have 2 PCIE slots, amazing, but it doesnt mean its not basically the same chipset. Notice how Nforce 4, all very very alike, are being used on 3 different versions of boards? Essentially the same chipset powering them, different motherboards, understand? Think of it like GPU core and how universal it can be used to support a wide arrange of varrying products.

It took a few hours but I checked my post history and I see nothing resembling what you're talking about. Do me a favor and have a look and tell me what you find. See you in a week... :rolleyes:

BTW, I don't have, nor have I ever had an SLi rig...nor do I plan on getting one...but thanks for assuming...

And "Reviews are positive"? Anand's looks somewhat negative, so does B3D's...not negative about the technology, but negative about 1. Its timing and 2. The motherboard platform.

And so now the motherboards are "essentially" the same? Before it was "exactly" the same...backpedaling a bit are we?

The fact remains that not one single Crossfire motherboard is in production right now...you have absolutely no idea what if any problems they may be having...however, anand (who'd I would venture to guess has ever so slightly more insight on the situation than you do) seems to think there's a problem...

So I'm sorry if I'm not being positive enough about Crossfire for your taste's, but to me there seem to be a couple of problems with it...like who wants to use a buggy motherboard? and who wants to drop $700 to still be a pixel shader generation off and be slower than G70s?

But you go right ahead and lap up all the PR, I'm not trying to stop you...
 
Brent,

I currently have NVIDIA SLI which still does not allow you to enable VSYNC and hass issues with Widescreen monitors in games.

Can you PLEASE report on whether Crossfire does allow VSYNC to be enabled in games and if there are any issues with Widescreen monitor support.

If ATI has addressed these two issues I am definitely supporting Crossfire!
 
Why doesn't ATI just get their cards working on NF4 boards, for the time being atleast? Seems like a waste of time to me. Just get it to work on the NF4 boards and release it. Get your own board out later.
 
Didn't the early revisions of the current MSI ATI socket 939 motherboard have USB 2.0 problems due to ATI's south bridge?

It is clear that (1) ATI's crossfire was an afterthought due to the fact they needed a seperate chip to get it to work , (2) That the 520 is still far off since they are pimping Crossfire with 8XX cards and (3) HardOCP is always right. Actually, I learned number 3 last week- don't ever bother to question anything HardOCP writes- you guys should know better.
 
revenant said:
yes - and you get the /super/ sampling (AA) along with that, also... right? or is that not specific to tile rendering? Anyways, that sounds very nice. I think that could be an exrtremely attractive selling point... amazing speed... _and_ IQ! :)

SuperAA works in D3D and OGL so I believe it's independent of render mode.
 
fbiguy said:
Sooo i've been planning and researching like a tweaked hooker on 7th street for a few months now. I'm planning to purchase and build my 939 setup and i've planned to go with the single PCI-e (did i get that right?) 16x slot MSI K8N Neo4 Platinum board.

However if there is a good chance that this crossfire technology will work with the NF4 chipset in the future, than i'd be willing to pay an extra $30-$40 now, and go with the SLI version of that board. Just in case Crossfire becomes compatible down the road.

I dont want to wait any longer to build this system, i'll be doing it on the 6th, so i need to make some heavy decisions, quickly.

Is the hurdle a technical problem, or are they pretty sure they'll get it working on the nvidia chipset, given however many months they need?

Like it's been said here, I think it's only a matter of time before ATi gets Crossfire working on NF4 SLi boards. Anand says as much in his preview as well:

On the hardware side, ATI is launching a multi GPU solutions called CrossFire that can be added to any existing Radeon X800 or X850 graphics card when run in (to be verified) any motherboard with 2 physical x16 PCI Express slots.

It would certainly behoove them to get it working, especially with the southbridge issues they seem to be having. I'm in the same boat as you are for the system build, btw... waiting this long just might pay off after all....
 
I noticed several dual NVIDIA gpu cards at computex. I hope ATI can go this route as well. It seems with the cpu's all heading dual core, it's a logical step for the video cards to do something similar to keep up with demand.

I must say though I do hate the dongle on the crossfire cards, probably because I have a habit of hitting them or otherwise abusing them.

Lucky for me I'm not looking for a new computer for at least a year, so my next system should have a lot to look forward to. (dual core, dual gpu, dual bank accounts emptied, etc.)
 
kuyaglen said:
Nvidia has said that they've waited to introduce SLI on PCIe boards because AGP is simply
not able to provide the bandwidth needed for what they wanted...I think that ATI has came up
with the same feeling so no AGP for you...though it would cool to see a dual PCIe mobo and
and AGP slot to boot...running 6 monitors would be killer

The thing I think nVidia is gonna have to do is follow ATI's way of being able to use different
card GPU's and brands, and being able to enable it via a bios setting is more elegant than a
bridge board...

I've known people who had problems with SLI because even though the cards they were using
were the same type and brand...the board revisions were not the same so SLI wasn't able to work.

Those Crazy Canadians were able to see what was available and improve upon it...as a
good company should...now lets see how nVidia come back with their improvement most
likely next year.

Nicely done article...was easy for my brain to understand. :)

This statement isn't entirely correct. The A8N-SLi Premium doesn't require a PCI-E bridge connector on the motherboard, though you do still have the connector between the cards, which if you haven't noticed, ATi does the same thing. It just happens to be external.

The biggest improvment here is in driver implimentation. I don't think it will be much if any faster than Nvidia's solution. Though it is more refined. Since you get almost a 90% boost with SLi in the right conditions, ATi will probably see the same thing.

I do admit though that not screwing with drivers and driver profiles is a great thing. I would like for Nvidia to come up with something similar.
 
What I am jazzed about most is the "new AA" stuff. I have been an AA junkie every since I saw the V5 in action...
 
Diseaseboy said:
http://www.tweaktown.com/document.php?dType=article&dId=771

Very early benchmarks :) Seems comparable to SLI to me.

Personally I think it will scale the same way current 6800 series cards scale to ATi single card counterparts now. So the dual X850XT-PE solution will be the fastest solution until the next generation of cards hits.

Now, hopefully ATi can meet the demand. With the driver implimentation they've got for Crossfire, that will Force Nvidia to bring it up a notch for the 7800GTX.
 
Some have stated that ATI missed the mark, too little too late. I do not see it that way. As stated in the article, it gives US 1 million plus, (x800 & x850 owners) an upgrade option that was not available last week ;)
GJ ATI.
 
AintSkerd said:
Some have stated that ATI missed the mark, too little too late. I do not see it that way. As stated in the article, it gives US 1 million plus, (x800 & x850 owners) an upgrade option that was not available last week ;)
GJ ATI.

The reason people say that is simple. Alot of people who wanted to buy into that technology already went with SLi. You can also buy an SLi rig right now, you still can not buy the ATi hardware at this time. Its also rather late in this card generation to be releasing Crossfire. Some might believe that it would have been wiser to wait for R520. So that's what has been meant by missing the mark.
 
AintSkerd said:
Some have stated that ATI missed the mark, too little too late. I do not see it that way. As stated in the article, it gives US 1 million plus, (x800 & x850 owners) an upgrade option that was not available last week ;)
GJ ATI.

Not unless you have a new ATI crossfire motherboard (that's not out yet).
 
But they still have a market, yes?? 1 million plus potential customers and counting.....
The mobo will be available soon enough. Like I stated its an option, thats all.
 
AintSkerd said:
But they still have a market, yes?? 1 million plus potential customers and counting.....
The mobo will be available soon enough. Like I stated its an option, thats all.


highly doubt that is 1 million plus customers with a pci express x850 or x800 card. more than likely its mostly agp customers.


also remember how long it took for a decent nforce 4 sli motherboard to come out? 3 or 4 months. by the time ATi gets its motherboards out nvidia will be ready with G70.
 
For an afterthought it sure does seem put very well together, I would hate to be Nvidia if ATi didnt treat it as an afterthought. :p

Overall Crossfire has much much more details, it adds much more, it doesnt get rid of some must haves (namely dual monitor for me). Also, ATi is already saying they hope to get it to work on not only their chipset but the Nforce 4 too. If they are smart than they can do this and they'd easily prove a lot of naysayers off.

The only real problem ATi has is that they're releasing it very late. In fact I would go so far to say its a pretty bad sign about R520, or they are taking R520 back into the shop to do some more reworking and trying to buy time with Crossfire.

To touch on what PRIME1 said about having the dual cores with graphics cards. I personally believe that is a rather bad idea. I would rather not have my cards get amazingly long, I'm perfectly fine with grabbing two average size instead of one amazingly huge heat producing card of doom. Unlike CPUs, GPUs have much much more than can expand on for speed. The main reason for dual core CPUs is because Intel/AMD are having a hard time pushing Mhz any higher, ATI/Nvidia are not having the same problem to improve performance.
 
pandora's box said:
highly doubt that is 1 million plus customers with a pci express x850 or x800 card. more than likely its mostly agp customers.


also remember how long it took for a decent nforce 4 sli motherboard to come out? 3 or 4 months. by the time ATi gets its motherboards out nvidia will be ready with G70.

G70 is supposedly shipping to AIB partners in 2 weeks...at this rate G70 will be out before Crossfire...

So while there are a lot of users with x800 cards...most of them don't have PCI-E...and even if they did, most won't be dropping $600 to get a crossfire setup 2 months after G70 is out...

As much as SLi is a niche market, Crossfire will be even more so because it really doesn't give a sensible upgrade path since it's still using the same old PS2.0 hardware...Nvidia is about to release their second generation PS3.0 part...and ATi is trying to peddle yet another r300 refresh...
 
I really like the options that it presents,given the fact that some people already have the x800 or x850 cards. But as an interested party, first there are no motherboards yet. Second there are no real world reviews of how this performs, and last the company will soon bring out their new card (520??i believe) and where will that leave the guy who just bought the second cross-fire x850??? (ok,ok i can hear it now..... it will leave him with a really excellent machine.....but you know what I mean.) im not trying to start an argument here....I think this new technonogy looks really cool, but Id like to see how it works with some games first. :D
 
Back
Top