Hard Drive Reliability Review For 2015

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Backblaze has published their latest report comparing the failure rate of drives from all major manufacturers. While the reliability of a drive is never guaranteed, it is interesting to see whether a company measures up to its reputation.

By the end of 2015, the Backblaze datacenter had 56,224 spinning hard drives containing customer data. These hard drives reside in 1,249 Backblaze Storage Pods. By comparison 2015 began with 39,690 drives running in 882 Storage Pods. We added 65 Petabytes of storage in 2015 give or take a Petabyte or two. Not only was 2015 a year of growth, it was also a year of drive upgrades and replacements. Let’s start with the current state of the hard drives in our datacenter as of the end of 2015 and then dig into the rest later on.
 
Most of my hard drive failures have been Seagates over the last 3-4 years. I've had 5 hard drives fail on me - all were Seagates.
Of course, my sample set is very small. Not too mention, I was using low end drives in a NAS. I've since switched to WD Reds. Knock on wood, none of these have failed yet.
 
I still got my WD RE3 1TB I bought used off ebay a couple years ago. It is an "Enterprise" (I'm still not entirely sure what that means) type HDD which people tend to say lasts longer. Currently its got over 45,000 power on hours. I've been a getting a nervous about that the last couple weeks here and have been looking to getting it replaced with a 2TB drive.

EDIT: We can edit posts now!! :D
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail
 
I really look forward to these.

Indeed it does seem WD has slipped and Seagate has gotten back in gear. HGST continues to dominate but is, of course, expensive.
 
That is really surprising.

WD is one of my more trusted hard drive brands.

I still think that Backblaze's setting isn't reflective of regular use, or even regular abuse. It's more like extreme over-the-top abuse.

I can't help but wonder if typical drive life out in the wild differs significantly from their results.

Now I know the argument "but all the brands are all abused, so the comparison is on even terms", and I understand that, but it is very possible that one brand lasts much longer if not abused than another, and if they are both abused they trade places. Their charts and tables also don't seem to make sense to me. In one table, the Seagate drives have by far the highest failure rate, but in the big colored bar chart, the WD drives get that honor. This report is at best poorly documented.

Over the last 15 years or so, I've used nothing but WD drives. In that time, I've had a couple of greens fail on me, but only after 5+ years of heavy abuse including using them for many years in radi without changing the wdidle settings, so it was expected.

For the last 2 years I've been running 12 WD Red 4TB drives 24/7 without a single problem. I know this is a tiny sample size, over a relatively short period of time, and not reflective of the population as a whole, but I am happy with them. I'd consider HGST drives if I got a good deal on them, but I won't be trusting Seagate any time soon.
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail

I don't have any of WD's newest drives but that has been my experience with them over the years too. I've had one "Blue" drive fail. Never had a Black or a 5400rpm of any color/name fail.

One of the drives with high failure rates on Backblaze has amazing user reviews too (which if anything tend to skew more negative): http://www.amazon.com/Red-Desktop-Hard-Disk-Drive/dp/B008JJLW4M

I'm still glad Backblaze releases these results, but I'm not sure how similar that environment/use case is to a typical home PC/NAS. I'll just stick to assuming all my HDDs will eventually fail and making backups. Counting on HDDs to be reliable can only end in tears.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
That is really surprising.

WD is one of my more trusted hard drive brands.

I still think that Backblaze's setting isn't reflective of regular use, or even regular abuse. It's more like extreme over-the-top abuse.

I can't help but wonder if typical drive life out in the wild differs significantly from their results.

Now I know the argument "but all the brands are all abused, so the comparison is on even terms", and I understand that, but it is very possible that one brand lasts much longer if not abused than another, and if they are both abused they trade places. Their charts and tables also don't seem to make sense to me. In one table, the Seagate drives have by far the highest failure rate, but in the big colored bar chart, the WD drives get that honor. This report is at best poorly documented.

Over the last 15 years or so, I've used nothing but WD drives. In that time, I've had a couple of greens fail on me, but only after 5+ years of heavy abuse including using them for many years in radi without changing the wdidle settings, so it was expected.

For the last 2 years I've been running 12 WD Red 4TB drives 24/7 without a single problem. I know this is a tiny sample size, over a relatively short period of time, and not reflective of the population as a whole, but I am happy with them. I'd consider HGST drives if I got a good deal on them, but I won't be trusting Seagate any time soon.

Their reports are like a 2/3 way house compared to most PC use.
Some of the serious wear to electronics (and mechanical devices) is from cold power ups and cooling down when powered off.
If someone uses their PC a lot with quite a few power downs and cooling, this would push other modes of failure higher.
Their reports serve as a decent base line.

My PC is left on permanently with no drive power saving.
Their reports directly target the way I use my PC, but even for machines that power down I recommend HGST now.
Because of this, I have purchased only HGST drives in the last few years, more recently only NAS versions.
 
I started using Seagate 8TB archive HDDs, recently. And 2 already failed from 10. That's terrible reliability, and they're slow ass as well. And yes I'm using them for archive purpose. Fill once then store off line. But two didn't even last long enough to be filled once.
 
From my sample size. Three Seagate failures and one wd...or maybe that was a matrox drive, either way that one was caused by a lightning strike.

I'll keep an eye on my new WDs.
 
I started using Seagate 8TB archive HDDs, recently. And 2 already failed from 10. That's terrible reliability, and they're slow ass as well. And yes I'm using them for archive purpose. Fill once then store off line. But two didn't even last long enough to be filled once.
I have same experience.
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail

I really look forward to these.

Indeed it does seem WD has slipped and Seagate has gotten back in gear. HGST continues to dominate but is, of course, expensive.

See I'm the opposite end -- I have mostly seagates for the past 5 years, and haven't had a single failure. Running an 8TB, a few 4TBs, and a handful of 3TB Seagate drives, and they have all been solid. Just comes down to a bit of luck I suppose.
 
Basically the reason we see such a large sampling of Seagates is "because they're cheap" and "maybe they'll scream into SMART before the end".

Not because they're more reliable in such torture chambers as a storage pod.

I'll stick with WD and HGST. They're reliable enough in torture situations like Backblaze pods, that the chances of them failing through normal use is infinitesimally small.
 
I was hoping to see results of the WD Red Pro 6tb model. All I have currently is SSD drives and these 6tb drives. I have no failures yet and the drives are great. It does look like the regular WD Red 6tb drives did OK and they are lesser quality models so I should be good
 
My 2TB WD Black has failed on me - twice. I just replaced it with a 2TB Seagate Barracuda, I'll see how it goes. But that chart shows WD having a lot higher failure rate than Seagate so it looks like I made the right choice. Seagate Barracuda was cheaper too but I still have 2 1TB WD Blacks in my PC and 1 Samsung 840pro SSD.
 
Last edited:
My 2TB WD Black has failed on me - twice. I just replaced it with a 2TB Seagate Barracuda, I'll see how it goes. But that chart shows WD having a lot higher failure rate than Seagate so it looks like I made the right choice. Seagate Barracuda was cheaper too but I still have 2 1TB WD Blacks in my PC and 1 SSD.

The newer Seagate drives appear to be the better ones so if its a newer model then you did make a good choice. If you've followed these Blackblaze reports for awhile the older Seagate drives were MUCH less reliable than the newer ones appear to be. Of course with your sample size of 1 you could end up with a drive failure after 3 days even if you bought HGST, which pretty much everyone agrees is probably the most reliable.

See I'm the opposite end -- I have mostly seagates for the past 5 years, and haven't had a single failure. Running an 8TB, a few 4TBs, and a handful of 3TB Seagate drives, and they have all been solid. Just comes down to a bit of luck I suppose.

Oh its all about luck. Even if you had 20 drives of the same model you wouldn't really be able to speak with any authority on their reliability. That's what's great about the Backblaze data, they literally use thousands of drives so they have a good sample size.
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail
I think the issue is that their 4TB drives had problems. I bought 4TB Seagates, because the reviews were far better than the WDs and they were cheaper too. It's only been 2 (maybe 3) years, since I bought the first one, but no problems so far. Before that I had all WDs (not counting SSDs) and went beyond their warranty, but I had at least 2 or 3 WDs die in warranty over the years. It's rare and normally happened in the first year.
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail

I was actually blown away with the results and had to read the entire article. They sampled the smallest number of WD drives (by far) and possibly purchased a lower performing batch since they claim to purchase all drives in large bulk quantities (which is the reason that significantly more Seagate was tested than any other brand). They have simple justification for the assumptions they are using, but the test samples are so out of whack I basically shrug it off.

I use WD in all our spinning drive SANs and we have yet to have one fail (knock on wood). Prior to my role at the company, they purchased workstations with Seagate hybrid drives and in November I had 3 fail, and am up to 6 now - that is in an organization of less than 55 workstations, with only 25 replaced... and they were all purchased 10/2014. These results are hard for me to believe...
 
Wow, talk about bias...

Despite their last round of testing showing massive Seagate failures:

Of the Seagate drives purchased in 2015, over 85% were 4TB Seagate drives.

So how do they calculate such high WD failure now?

The 1TB Western Digital drives performed well with many of the drives exceeding 6 years in service and a handful reaching 7 years before we replaced them. The cumulative annual failure rate was 5.74% in our environment, a solid performance.

We actually didn’t retire these 1TB WD drives – they just changed jobs. We now use many of them to “burn-in” Storage Pods once they are done being assembled. The 1TB size means the process runs quickly, but is still thorough. The burn-in process pounds the drives with reads and writes to exercise all the components of the system. In many ways this is much more taxing on the drives then life in an operational Storage Pod. Once the “burn-in” process is complete, the WD 1TB drives are removed and we put 4- or 6TB drives in the pods for the cushy job of storing customer data. On the other hand, the workhorse 1TB WD drives are returned to the shelf where they dutifully await the next “burn-in” session.

Kind of wondering what kind of discount Seagate is giving them to use less reliable drives and to basically smear the WD reliablilty numbers by pounding their WD drives and then counting them as failures...
 
I still think that Backblaze's setting isn't reflective of regular use, or even regular abuse. It's more like extreme over-the-top abuse.
See, this is what I'm starting to believe. I kind of wonder what regular world failure rates are like. I read stuff here and get HD failure paranoia; wondering when my current set of Seagates will crash and burn. Yet, nothing of the sort has happened. And I still have my old IBM scsi ultrastars from the year of the flood, which have lasted so long, I had to buy a newer card because I couldn't find drivers for the 2940 adaptec card it was attached to. Everything churning along fine. Doesn't really matter, though; the paranoia has made backups a part of life, and I even remind the people I know to do it too. So I guess the HD death knell headlines have had a positive affect, most likely on more people than just me.
 
See, this is what I'm starting to believe. I kind of wonder what regular world failure rates are like. I read stuff here and get HD failure paranoia; wondering when my current set of Seagates will crash and burn. Yet, nothing of the sort has happened. And I still have my old IBM scsi ultrastars from the year of the flood, which have lasted so long, I had to buy a newer card because I couldn't find drivers for the 2940 adaptec card it was attached to. Everything churning along fine. Doesn't really matter, though; the paranoia has made backups a part of life, and I even remind the people I know to do it too. So I guess the HD death knell headlines have had a positive affect, most likely on more people than just me.

I keep backups to protect against things like accidental deletions due to fat fingers, ransomware, etc.

Disk failure? That's what RAID (or in my case RAIDz2) is for.

I lost my entire music collection back in college when an ancient 15GB IDE drive slowly started having massive sector failures.

I don't want that to happen again.
 
This is the oldest drive I have in my machine.
crystaldiskinfo-WD2TB-EARS-Green-2-2016.jpg
 
I've only powered down the system 10 times since I installed it.
crystaldiskinfo-WD2TB-Black-2-2016.jpg
 
Wow, talk about bias...

Despite their last round of testing showing massive Seagate failures:

So how do they calculate such high WD failure now?

Kind of wondering what kind of discount Seagate is giving them to use less reliable drives and to basically smear the WD reliablilty numbers by pounding their WD drives and then counting them as failures...

They reported the percentage that failed, not the number of drives (at least not in the bar graph). I don't see the issue. I said it earlier, and I'll say it again, WD's 4TB Red drives had issues (at least they did early on). If you look on Newegg, the 4TB Red is rated lower than the Seagate. That's not the case for older Seagates, like the 3TB, which was notoriously unreliable.

Since I use both brands, and they're generally good, but again, the red 4TB drives had issues so I saw no reason to pay the slight premium.
 
I lost my entire music collection back in college when an ancient 15GB IDE drive slowly started having massive sector failures.
I don't want that to happen again.
That's what CDs are for...as well as the FLAC backups on DVD (though I havne't done that in 10 years).
 
They reported the percentage that failed, not the number of drives (at least not in the bar graph). I don't see the issue. I said it earlier, and I'll say it again, WD's 4TB Red drives had issues (at least they did early on). If you look on Newegg, the 4TB Red is rated lower than the Seagate. That's not the case for older Seagates, like the 3TB, which was notoriously unreliable.

Since I use both brands, and they're generally good, but again, the red 4TB drives had issues so I saw no reason to pay the slight premium.

Did you read the article? They ONLY take WD hard drives and torture test them repeatedly and then are surprised when as a percent of drives more WD's fail. That's basically the exact opposite of the scientific method.
 
Sorry,I can't take this article seriously. Seagate's problems are well known,and WD drives have served me well for years.
 
I still got my WD RE3 1TB I bought used off ebay a couple years ago. It is an "Enterprise" (I'm still not entirely sure what that means) type HDD which people tend to say lasts longer. Currently its got over 45,000 power on hours. I've been a getting a nervous about that the last couple weeks here and have been looking to getting it replaced with a 2TB drive.

EDIT: We can edit posts now!! :D
I lost two RE3 1TB drives at about 3-4 years in my 4 drive RAID, always on file server. Not too happy about it considering they are mostly idle. But I was able to get some new at $80 so I stocked back up anyways.
 
For me personally, I've had one Seagate hard drive go bad on me directly (meaning my own personal hardware, not something I happen to be working with that belongs to a client/customer) in decades of using hard drives of all kinds. I have never had a Hitachi drive go bad on me, and that includes both the actual Hitachi drives from many years past as well as the HGST drives created with the merger of IBM's hard drive division), and they are still my preferred brand of hard drive. I even owned an infamous IBM 60GXP "DeathStar" drive many years ago, it worked great for over a decade then developed a few bad sectors but as of the last time I fired it up in the summer of 2014 it was still fully functional.

Western Digital, however, the hell with that company. I had a shoebox full of their drives sitting beside me for a long time, 13 drives of various sizes, and all of them showed a clean S.M.A.R.T. status (not trustworthy, to be honest) and yet the drives would not pass WD's own diagnostic testing process and steadily just became shit and nothing but shit so help me some higher power. I don't recommend their products, I won't touch them, and even in spite of them technically owning HGST at this point in time the HGST hardware is still made to a level of quality that WD itself pales when compared to.

Still don't own an SSD, not sure I will anytime soon. I'd love to have a big one just to have a more efficient computer that can actually keep up with me but so far I don't actually require it. I just noticed that news posting that Intel might announce a 10TB SSD soon but good lord, I can't imagine having that much data stored and then lose it all in one split second if the drive fails, especially if that sheer amount of data isn't backed up someplace else or spread out across multiple backup sources.

So for me it's Hitachi/HGST, Seagate, then nothing else I suppose. I wouldn't put out cash on anything but those two brands at this point in time. As for an SSD when I finally do buy one it'll probably be an Intel branded drive, perhaps a Samsung depending on the situation at that time.
 
Wow, Sooooo much butt hurt of the beloved WD camp in this thread.

I have only one thing to say. C'mon Amazon, Microsoft and Facebook, publish your drive failure numbers!
 
The article pretty much echoes my own experience in IT support.

Seagates -- I've seen way too many of the DM00x series drives fail to ever be comfortable with them again (at least in the near future). But, as the article mentions, close to 100% of them have failed relatively gracefully, with SMART warnings ahead of time (often by weeks), that have almost invariably let me recover the data off them. I've seen generally lower failure rates out of their laptop drives than their desktop drives though. The only Seagate I couldn't recover any data off of when it failed was in an external enclosure and actually had visible blackened areas on the drive's controller board around one of the IC's, the USB SATA bridge board in the enclosure was fried as well, and so was the USB port on the PC it was connected to, so it's really difficult to point a finger at what component was the real culprit behind the failure, but it was a nasty one (and it was an original Seagate external enclosure). Also, most of the Seagate's I have dealt with have not started having a lot of failures til close to the 3 year point, with a slight uptick beginning at about the 2 year point and then accelerating. For the first year or two though, they've generally been pretty reliable -- I just don't trust them long term.

Toshiba -- I have several in use and they have, for the most part, been pretty good. I've had a couple of the ACA 3TB series go TU recently though -- one was nice enough to give SMART warnings first, the other had so many bad sectors almost instantly that no significant data was recovered. I've also seen WAY too many of their laptop drives fail for comfort. I am reasonably comfortable with their desktop drives and have been using them quite a bit the last few years. Personally, their laptop drives though, I really just don't care for.

WD -- I use a ton of Red's, a few Purples in security DVR's, lots of Blue's in desktops, and several repurposed Green's with the idle timer disabled. So far, they've all had very good reliability, with the exception of a handful of Blues, a 2TB Green, and one Red -- and NONE of them gave ANY warning they were going to fail: they simply refused to start properly and generated error messages on every read, or in the case of the Red, the entire SATA bus would lock and the entire machine wouldn't start if it was even CONNECTED. So, good reliability, but failures have typically been total and catastrophic. Their Blue laptop drives I've dealt with have had slightly higher failure rates than Seagate's have, but not as bad as Toshiba's -- but they have, by and large, given SMART errors and failed gracefully.

HGST -- I've got a ton of their 2TB and 3TB desktop drives in use in data racks, desktops, and my own UnRAID server too. And, knock on wood, to this date I don't remember having seen a SINGLE failure. The older 7200rpm models tend to run insanely hot and, for the most part, they are the noisiest seeking drives I have -- and one NAS that is stuffed with them sounds like a bunch of crazed woodpeckers when it is under heavy load, the fans run on max most of the time, and the reported load on the UPS averages around 2x what it is does on a similar NAS that is loaded with WD Red's (which, admittedly, are newer model drives), but the bloody things just keep on chugging. Once they reach the 4 year mark, I generally like to retire them anyway just for peace of mind -- at which point I typically start using them for cold storage (e.g. offline backups of stuff).


I can't say for sure how well their recent model drives are going to hold up long term, but at least for the last several years, HGST was obviously doing something right compared to everyone else.
 
I have only one thing to say. C'mon Amazon, Microsoft and Facebook, publish your drive failure numbers!

I'd like this too.

Their figures are probably more realistic than Backblaze's air starved tight space torture tests.

But they are probably more responsible and don't use consumer drives, so their results would likely be less useful to us.
 
kind of surprised at the WD showing. in the 22 years that I have been building PCs I have had only 1 fail

WDs are the drives we're currently having issues with in our RAID boxes at the studio. One of the 4 drive raid box with 4 x 4TB WD Reds developed faults in two drives in one box at the same time. Not happy.
 
I've had WD 1tb blue for 6 years and it still runs well. However I feel Toshiba is the pick to go with now, picked up a 5tb 7200rpm and I love it
 
I've dealt with hundreds of bad drives from typical oem pcs the most common failures i see are still seagates even if they aren't the most popular drive for them. Toshiba is second with mostly laptop drives, could be due to sheer numbers being used. Most of the bad western digital drives i see were known bad runs of the green and red drives.
 
Back
Top