Hard Drive Failures - Both in 3 weeks!

sanchez_1960

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 12, 2003
Messages
67
I have had two hard drives fail within the space of a couple of weeks.

I decorated my room in Feb and I moved the PC to the other room. Without thinking about it I put my AV speakers next to the PC. All was fine, but then 3 weeks ago my 250Gb started to corrupt all over the place and BSOD. Anyway, I managed to retreive all the data and then replaced the HD. Now on Friday my Raptor 74Gb started corrupting too!

Is it just coincidence or did putting those speakers near it knacker both? Surely if it did ruin them, they would have knackered straight away and not a delayed corruption! They were working fine for weeks!

When you put a Magnet to a HD, does it just wipe data or do you ruin the HD in the long term?

Asking mainly cuz I don't want to buy more HD's and find that my mobo or PSU is causing them to die!
 
It is not likely that the speakers being too close to your computer caused your hard drives to fail.
I think that you were just unlucky and got a couple of bad drives...
It will take a very strong magnet to corrupt your hard drives, hard drives have fairly strong magnets in them already...
Have you run a disk check utility on the drives yet?
Try that.
 
sounds weird. have you tried moving the hd's to another computer to test, changed sata ports, or swapping out sata cables?
 
Are they partitioned? Bad drives combined with intense head thrashing might be the cause- Just an idea.
 
yeah, they are both partitioned, what do you mean?

I tried the SATA replace thing and it did the same thing :(
 
This probably, almost definitely, isn't the case; but if both partitions are active a lot the drive head has to move between them really quickly if it's trying to read from both partitions. However, this sort of thing wont cause a hard drive failure this early on, i assume, so the issue probably lies elsewhere. I just thought it might be worth taking into consideration, though. Did both of the partitions see a lot of action before they died?
 
This probably, almost definitely, isn't the case
<snip>

Not saying it's not possible, but I really doubt that's the problem.. Drives are designed to be used, soooo...

My guess is bad luck.. and nothing more. The magnets in AV speakers are likely no where near strong enough to corrupt data.. And to the op.. if you use a magnet to wipe the data off of a drive, the drive will be useless as there are "servo tracks" written on the partition table of the disk that would be erased, rendering the drive dead......
 
Download SpinRite and run that on the drives. There really isn't much more to be said. You can get it from www.grc.com. It's from the same guy that makes Shields Up!...the firewall tester.
 
What kind of power supply do you have? A bad or poorly made power supply will screw up your hard drives.
 
funny you should say that! My NeoPower 480W died 2 weeks before the Hard Drives went!

What is even more strange now is that I ran SpinRite and it found 0 problems! I then did SpinRite's other feature which reads the HD data and rewrites everything. I booted up into Windows and then it bluescreened as normal. Windows Scandisk kept telling me I had minor errors it was fixing.

I decided to give it a shot and install Windows Vista that MS gave me and the drive seems fine now.

Whats wrong? Maybe it wasn't the HD? What do you think? I scandisked after installing Vista and no problems found? C'mon ideas :)
 
What power supply do you have now? The dead PSU may have screwed your hard drives a bit.
 
I have a Corsair Hx520 now. Vista been running a couple of hours now, what apps can I use to check the HD is okay? Should I buy another Raptor just be on the safe side?
 
no kidding! Maxtor has killed me. I've lost more data than i've got saved now with those damned cretins!

I think the speakers could certainly be the culprit. I'd format both and see how they do.

dR
 
Back
Top