Grrr...Bioshock widescreen cropping

It's just ridiculous that widescreen users think they are entitled to have more screen space. It's as intelligent as saying vanilla is better than chocolate.
Hilarious. Your food-related analogy is completely nonsensical and highly amusing. I detect a subtle hint of widescreen envy!

Are you, by chance, Ray Nagin, mayor of New Orleans and king of nonsensical vanilla/chocolate-oriented analogies?
 
can't find a thread, but wasn't it proven somewherethat we as humans see things more in a horizontal plane than a vertical?
 
I would think that it goes without saying, since our eyes are set side by side. Including peripheral vision, your horizontal spec is also much less obstructed (cheeks, brows).
 
can't find a thread, but wasn't it proven somewherethat we as humans see things more in a horizontal plane than a vertical?

its easy to prove
hold a pen at arm length and move it around your head and note at what point you can not see it any more

then do the same thing vertically

your FOV is about 180 horizontal and about 100 or so in the vertical
 
Hilarious. Your food-related analogy is completely nonsensical and highly amusing. I detect a subtle hint of widescreen envy!

My flat CRT is superior to widescreen LCDs in every way, so why would I be envious?
 
Widescreen is just easier on the eyes, especially for a first person perspective. 4:3 CRTs produce color and picture better. If only widescreen CRTs caught on. But then again, my widescreen lcd isn't a 40 pound, giant box.
 
also wide screen is the same has HDTV if you saw LESS on your HDTV then a SD TV wouldnt you be pissed?
http://www.widescreen.org/examples/tomorrow/index.shtml
also almost EVERY move has more on the sides
the point of gaming with a wide screen is to get more cinematic experience

Trying to make a comparison with TV is pointless. TV is recorded with a fixed resolution, so you're not going to record at SD and then upscale to HD when you can record at HD and crop (the alternative being to downscale to SD and letterbox).
Games will render at whatever resolution you choose, so it's impossible to compare picture quality between different aspect ratios in games like you can between SD and HDTV.
Complaining that Bioshock does widescreen "wrong" is just bandwagon-jumping idiocy.
 
Trying to make a comparison with TV is pointless. TV is recorded with a fixed resolution, so you're not going to record at SD and then upscale to HD when you can record at HD and crop (the alternative being to downscale to SD and letterbox).
Games will render at whatever resolution you choose, so it's impossible to compare picture quality between different aspect ratios in games like you can between SD and HDTV.
Complaining that Bioshock does widescreen "wrong" is just bandwagon-jumping idiocy.

lets look at the new MOH game for one i got some get screen shots that show how bad cropping is

4:3
mohademo243cr7.jpg


16:9
mohademo2169xw5.jpg


now if you look here you will notice the field of view is the same for both and the top and bottem are cropped this also makes the game look more zoomed in it also may be stretching it abit to

now lets look at HL2

4:3
hl2430lg.jpg


16:10
hl216108uv.jpg


as you can see here this is how it should be done H+ all the hight is the same and with a wider FOV in 16:10 and no zooming

its called WIDE screen not NARROW screen the image should be wider and there for wider FOV not same FOV and narrow vertical FOV
 
Complaining that Bioshock does widescreen "wrong" is just bandwagon-jumping idiocy.
No, it isn't at all.

What exactly do you believe the purpose of a widescreen aspect ratio is? Can you answer that question?
 
Well after reading about this i think i will try the demo first. Not getting the full wide screen seems odd. I don't think it would be THAT big of a deal to do it. I know for Red Orchestera(build on UT04) you could change the ini file to set it to widescreen and change the FOV to 105. I wonder if you can this for bioshock?

I missed Elios earlier post but the screen shots speak for themselves. I dont want a crop and zoomed in view. valve got it right and i really enjoy playing source games in true 16:9.
 
Well after reading about this i think i will try the demo first. Not getting the full wide screen seems odd. I don't think it would be THAT big of a deal to do it. I know for Red Orchestera(build on UT04) you could change the ini file to set it to widescreen and change the FOV to 105. I wonder if you can this for bioshock?

I missed Elios earlier post but the screen shots speak for themselves. I dont want a crop and zoomed in view. valve got it right and i really enjoy playing source games in true 16:9.

thank you
and theres 1 hack out for bioshock since the FOV is hardcoded and im helping with another
if you like come by http://www.widescreengamingforum.com
and you can get the FOV hacks for Bioshock they work well Racer_S made them almost over night with the help of some of us on the wsgf irc channel and theres another guy working on a multi ap widescreen trainer as well that will work in DX9 and 10 modes
Racer_S' only works in DX9 mode

both will let you change the FOV on the fly in game
 
Notice that 4:3 users don't bitch and moan when games like HL2 give widescreen users more screen space than 4:3 users, essentially 'screwing' 4:3 users. Anyone care to elaborate on why this is? Step right up.
 
Notice that 4:3 users don't bitch and moan when games like HL2 give widescreen users more screen space than 4:3 users, essentially 'screwing' 4:3 users. Anyone care to elaborate on why this is? Step right up.

becouse a wider then 90 FOV in 4:3 looks "fish-eyed"
try it your self in the bioshock demo go get Racer_S' FOV hack set the FOV to say 100 with a 4:3 setup and see how it looks gime a few and ill take some screens of that :)
 
Notice that 4:3 users don't bitch and moan when games like HL2 give widescreen users more screen space than 4:3 users, essentially 'screwing' 4:3 users. Anyone care to elaborate on why this is? Step right up.

They do bitch and complain. IMO its the reason why the Battlefield games letterbox, so that the people without widescreen don't think they are at a disadvantage. Its all idiotic complaining and ignorance anyways... Bioshock supported widescreen, but gave a ridiculous FOV, and many people including me noticed straight off. I've been using widescreen in games for a couple years now, and I prefer to game in widescreen now. The fov in Bioshock made it look like some kind of full screen zoom was stuck on. I'm glad Racer_S made this so that I can correct the FOV when gaming @ 16:10.

I'm not foaming at the mouth mad about what 2K did, and I still bought the game and played almost half the game without using this widescreen hack. However now with the improved FOV, the gameplay is improved and so is my enjoyment of the game. All you fucking assholes that don't have widescreen come here and flame us is really sad... All I want is proper 16:10 widescreen with a standard fov, and now I have it. Either way, I still would have bought Bioshock, because the game is amazing. It just looks so much better in a proper 16:10 fov.
 
All you want is the advantage over 4:3 users, I know. Well you can take off your emo helmet, you got what you wanted.
 
All you want is the advantage over 4:3 users, I know. Well you can take off your emo helmet, you got what you wanted.

the ask your mommy to get you a shiny new widescreen monitor hell there cheap now
i bet if you got an after school job you could save for one in a month or 2
:rolleyes:

oh yea CS and CS:S do H+ widescreen one of the most competitive FPS' ever soo your bit about an advantage is moot since Valve didnt think it was much of one
 
All you want is the advantage over 4:3 users, I know. Well you can take off your emo helmet, you got what you wanted.

Lame to the extreme.

I guess game devs should cap all games at 20-30fps since those with better hardware would have an "advantage" over those whose systems aren't capable of 60+fps. :rolleyes::rolleyes:

Come on man, we just want proper support for the hardware we have...


Ply
 
All you want is the advantage over 4:3 users, I know. Well you can take off your emo helmet, you got what you wanted.
yeah, because Bioshock is online and we can 'pwn' you in the online multiplayer portion of Bioshock because we would be able to 'see more'...


I would expect something like this from EA, but meh. hopefully we'll have a hack to fix this. And in all seriousness this is no kind of war between the two aspect ratios, seriously if you actually think about it fighting over aspect ratios is quite hillarious.
 
It's funny how you assume that a widescreen LCD monitor is a luxury that 4:3 users are pining for. I bought a flat CRT monitor a little while ago for around $400, a very nice one, when I could have gotten a widescreen LCD, but I chose to have a superior display.

These monitor manufacturers love you though. You consider anything new the greatest thing ever and gladly throw away your money into it.
 
becouse thats the POINT of wide screen if it wasnt why bother
You shouldn't have bought a monitor with the top and bottom chopped off if you didn't want the same to happen in your games.
 
It's funny how you assume that a widescreen LCD monitor is a luxury that 4:3 users are pining for. I bought a flat CRT monitor a little while ago for around $400, a very nice one, when I could have gotten a widescreen LCD, but I chose to have a superior display.

These monitor manufacturers love you though. You consider anything new the greatest thing ever and gladly throw away your money into it.


I've used CRT monitors my whole life, none of them can compare with the LCD monitor I have now... I would never go back to 4:3 after experiencing true widescreen gaming.

oh and $400 for a CRT? Im guessing you're into some digital image editing, otherwise you're pretty much a hypocrite telling folks they they have 'thrown their money away'.
 
oh and $400 for a CRT? Im guessing you're into some digital image editing, otherwise you're pretty much a hypocrite telling folks they they have 'thrown their money away'.

First I am not against widescreens(I used to own a GDM-FW900), but more LCD technology. I just find it absurd when people think their aspect ratio is somehow the 'right' aspect ratio.

I'm not into digital image editing, but I appreciate:

-true blacks(especially in dark games or space games)
-great color
-the ability to use many different resolutions that all look great(which provides for more flexible tweaking in gaming performance)
-0 ms response time and 0 ms input lag(well not technically but you know what I mean)

The funny thing is that these features, which were available on displays many years ago are going to be features boasted in years to come on new displays that people will pay top dollar for.
 
And as for widescreen, we also want to say we completely understand a user's desire to augment their FOV. BioShock is a harrowing experience, but we don't want anyone to feel limited (or motion sick!). So we are in the process of working on an official PC patch to give widescreen PC users a choice to expand their horizontal FOV, and are investigating creating a similar update for the 360.

And finally, I want to personally congratulate Racer_S from the Widescreen Gaming Forums, and his awesome user patch to expand the widescreen FOV in BioShock. I'm currently tracking him down via email, but hopefully, he'll accept my gratitude, and maybe an Nvidia 8800 to boot.


http://www.2kgames.com/cultofrapture/home.html
 
And as for widescreen, we also want to say we completely understand a user's desire to augment their FOV. BioShock is a harrowing experience, but we don't want anyone to feel limited (or motion sick!). So we are in the process of working on an official PC patch to give widescreen PC users a choice to expand their horizontal FOV, and are investigating creating a similar update for the 360.

And finally, I want to personally congratulate Racer_S from the Widescreen Gaming Forums, and his awesome user patch to expand the widescreen FOV in BioShock. I'm currently tracking him down via email, but hopefully, he'll accept my gratitude, and maybe an Nvidia 8800 to boot.


http://www.2kgames.com/cultofrapture/home.html

In your Mutha Fucking face! Pshhhh! :cool:
 
I just find it absurd when people think their aspect ratio is somehow the 'right' aspect ratio.
I don't think that's the case. There's a "right" way to handle 4:3 and a "right" way to handle 16:10/16:9. We've made investments in displays that can specifically accommodate a wide field of view. If it were just about resolution, a 4:3 display may have made more sense. I know that, at times, I don't have as much vertical real estate as I'd like. It's a trade-off. As widescreen owners, we do want games to leverage our displays properly, though we'll settle with no widescreen support at all if that's the case. We can run a lower resolution and use our cards/displays to frame it the way we want it, or we could stretch it to fill.

What's problematic is that Irrational made running in widescreen resolutions on widescreen monitors detrimental. We see more in the frame by running a 4:3 resolution and stretching it. Why? That's a completely backwards, bizarre way to handle the projection matrix. With so many people owning LCDs, it's almost essential to run games at the panel's native resolution, and doing so in BioShock, on widescreen monitors, comes with a penalty. That's entirely illogical.
 
You shouldn't have bought a monitor with the top and bottom chopped off if you didn't want the same to happen in your games.

did you even look at the HL2 shots ?
the vertical on my LCD is actuly MORE then a 19" 5:4 with a lot more on the sides
1280x1024 vs 1680x1050
same or more in this case
then we move up to 1920x1200 which is the same vertical as 1600x1200
 
First I am not against widescreens(I used to own a GDM-FW900), but more LCD technology. I just find it absurd when people think their aspect ratio is somehow the 'right' aspect ratio.

I'm not into digital image editing, but I appreciate:

-true blacks(especially in dark games or space games)
-great color
-the ability to use many different resolutions that all look great(which provides for more flexible tweaking in gaming performance)
-0 ms response time and 0 ms input lag(well not technically but you know what I mean)

The funny thing is that these features, which were available on displays many years ago are going to be features boasted in years to come on new displays that people will pay top dollar for.

the thing is 4:3 is going the way of the dodo look at laptops not many left with a 4:3 screen
then lets look at dell there almost giving away 17" widescreens with new low end PCs
http://www.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/inspndt_53xs?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs
look here see any thing thats right the defult monitor with cheapest Dells are 17" and 19" widescreens

4:3 is the past
http://configure.us.dell.com/dellstore/config.aspx?c=us&cs=19&l=en&oc=DDCWGA2&s=dhs
the cheapest dell i can find doesnt even offer a 4:3 monitor as an option
 
did you even look at the HL2 shots ?
the vertical on my LCD is actuly MORE then a 19" 5:4 with a lot more on the sides
1280x1024 vs 1680x1050
same or more in this case
then we move up to 1920x1200 which is the same vertical as 1600x1200
The point is, some CRTs are just as wide as your widescreen, but also taller; now using your logic, you can just as easily argue that they should have the same horizontal fov and an increased vertical fov. After all, in the example I'm using, the widescreen would more aptly be called a shortscreen.

There isn't a correct way to do this; it's just a design decision.
 
What's problematic is that Irrational made running in widescreen resolutions on widescreen monitors detrimental. We see more in the frame by running a 4:3 resolution and stretching it. Why? That's a completely backwards, bizarre way to handle the projection matrix. With so many people owning LCDs, it's almost essential to run games at the panel's native resolution, and doing so in BioShock, on widescreen monitors, comes with a penalty. That's entirely illogical.

Here is your quote. Now after the official patch, here's a similar quote from a 4:3 user

What's problematic is that Irrational made running in 4:3 resolutions on 4:3 monitors detrimental. We see more in the frame by running a 16:10 resolution. Why? That's a completely backwards, bizarre way to handle the projection matrix. That's entirely illogical.

Don't you get it. You emo kids have made enough noise for irrational to favor widescreen users by increasing the FOV on widescreen resolutions. Now 4:3 users can turn around and say, hey I'm getting less screen space than widescreen users.

Yes it makes sense for irrational to do this, since all of the vocal emo kids own widescreen lcds. Does this bother me, a 4:3 user? No, I could give a crap. I don't whine and bitch about such trite things I just like making fun of the people who think they and their equipment is the center of the universe. :rolleyes:
 
damonposey what the hell are you talking about? By your logic SLI, duel core and High res hardware shouldn't be supported. It great that you like your 4:3 but i want my 16:9. There is no reason for the support not to be there. As stated before this is a single player game where it doesn't even matter and for a game like cs:s to support it and give an "advantage" to wide screen players, so what anyone that whats to be "completive" will have a wide screen anyway. its been fixed by a hack and looks like it will have an official fix soon anyway.
 
damonposey what the hell are you talking about? By your logic SLI, duel core and High res hardware shouldn't be supported. It great that you like your 4:3 but i want my 16:9. There is no reason for the support not to be there. As stated before this is a single player game where it doesn't even matter and for a game like cs:s to support it and give an "advantage" to wide screen players, so what anyone that whats to be "completive" will have a wide screen anyway. its been fixed by a hack and looks like it will have an official fix soon anyway.
Why should users with monitors that are the same width but taller have to put up with a reduced horizontal FOV. It seems to me that given two monitors of the same width, the horizontal FOV should be the same.
 
Why should users with monitors that are the same width but taller have to put up with a reduced horizontal FOV. It seems to me that given two monitors of the same width, the horizontal FOV should be the same.

first of all show my any one that games in portrait mode
2nd games that do proper widescreen CAN do tallscreen too if you realy want to

but last i checked my eye were on the left and right not top and bottom

you see more to the sides then you can up and down thats the point
the way bioshock does widescreen its like walking around with blinders on
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blinders
 
it's funny how this simple issue activitates the 'ha ha' and reveals some severe inferiority complexes.

4:3 users don't lose anything when widescreen is implemented properly. they're just happy that it was done wrong in this case and now they're super-awesome-better because us widescreen users have had a problem displaying the game correctly. :rolleyes:


well too bad for all those 4:3 users who have enjoyed our plight. now the game looks as it should and once again we are the reigning champions of all y'all 4:3 suckas!. :rolleyes::rolleyes:

honestly, i've got both crt and lcd and i can't for the life of me figure out why 4:3 users feel so offended that we want our widescreens to display this game properly.
 
honestly, i've got both crt and lcd and i can't for the life of me figure out why 4:3 users feel so offended that we want our widescreens to display this game properly.

thats what i don't get either. Lets all get out our 486 computers and play some bioshock :p Its fixed thats all i care about, to bad my power went out just before i was going to try the demo and then most likely buy now that i get my wide screen goodness.
 
first of all show my any one that games in portrait mode
2nd games that do proper widescreen CAN do tallscreen too if you realy want to

but last i checked my eye were on the left and right not top and bottom

you see more to the sides then you can up and down thats the point
the way bioshock does widescreen its like walking around with blinders on
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blinders
The horizontal FOV in Bioshock is the same for both 4:3 and 16:10 displays. You are no more blinded on 16:10 then you are with 4:3.

16:10 monitors are not innately wider than 4:3 displays. It's reasonable to say that the wider monitor should have a wider FOV, but the aspect ratio has no bearing on width.
 
The horizontal FOV in Bioshock is the same for both 4:3 and 16:10 displays. You are no more blinded on 16:10 then you are with 4:3.

16:10 monitors are not innately wider than 4:3 displays. It's reasonable to say that the wider monitor should have a wider FOV, but the aspect ratio has no bearing on width.

then why does HDTV show more on the sides then SDTV?
 
Back
Top