Grrr...Bioshock widescreen cropping

Ugh. I wasn't particularly enthusiastic about Bioshock to begin with as I'm not a fan of horror games, but this is just a ridiculous copout. One of the reasons I have a widescreen monitor is so I can see MORE than a 4:3, not less. More and more studios are doing this and I really wish people would start calling them on their bullshit. Just because I can select a 16:10 ratio in the settings menu doesn't make it true widescreen.
 
Great I had this game pre-ordered. Forget it now. Looks like I'll just use the demo as a graphics benchmark and pick this game up when it's discounted. sigh.
 
Great I had this game pre-ordered. Forget it now. Looks like I'll just use the demo as a graphics benchmark and pick this game up when it's discounted. sigh.

Ten dollars you wouldn't even notice if you didn't know. :rolleyes:
 
I have a 24" 16:10 LCD monitor I think that I will notice. I haven't tried the demo yet so we'll see.
 
Great I had this game pre-ordered. Forget it now. Looks like I'll just use the demo as a graphics benchmark and pick this game up when it's discounted. sigh.

haha. i cant believe some of the people around here...really cracks me up. where the hell do you guys come from?
 
25% of the screen is missing man. Just not acceptable for a 2007 game to not have widescreen. Hopefully they will patch it but still it doesn't appear to be worth $40-50 to me.
 
So glad I stuck with my 4:3 Viewsonic VX922. 2ms response is perfect for this game.

Will the full retail game have widescreen support, I'd be a bit annoyed if I had a widescreen
 
25% of the screen is missing man. Just not acceptable for a 2007 game to not have widescreen. Hopefully they will patch it but still it doesn't appear to be worth $40-50 to me.

Is it missing if you never had it? J/k:D I'm sure there is some hot and bothered geek finding a tweek or creating a mod to fix this by the weeks end. Fo sho.
 
What would really suck about this is if V- is still rendering a full 4:3 image, and then just showing you 16:9 of it...

Example: if your screen is 1920x1080 (16:9), and it is rendering at 1920x1440 (4:3), then only displaying the 1920x1080 amount of information... Is it actually rendering that 1920x360 of 4:3 image that isn't displayed on 16:9?

Well, that could be quite a performance hit for something that isn't even making it to your screen!

I will never ever understand V-, but if that is the way V- works, it certainly sucks...
 
Just played the demo and the screen was not cropped at 1920x1200. Enabled 8XQ AA in Nvidia control panel and 8X AF and the game ran fine and no jaggies on all high settings.
 
Is it missing if you never had it?

To answer your question, no.

However this isnt the case with cropped widescreen, it happens that 25% of the normal 4:3 screen is missing, which means that the vertical part of the screen is cut out.

Considering that its such a damn easy thing to fix with a change in horizontal FOV angle and by making the HUD widescreen compatible, it's a crying shame that it's not compatible with Bioshock, this is afterall 2007.

I don't think I'd go as far as to not buy the game but developers certainly DO have to learn that this is not acceptable in games considering the fast growing number of widescreen users.

Also this may help explain possibly differences in the mouse movement, I felt it was a bit restrictive in the demo where vertical aiming seemed to be at a lower sensitivity as the horizontal, could this be to do with the cropping?
 
Funnily enough the same thing sometimes happens with film-to-dvd conversions, except in reverse, in that you're actually seeing more of the picture on dvd than you did in the cinema.
It does seem strange to crop vertically rather than increase the field of view horizontally, although I'd guess that most of the devs were using widescreen monitors and it was pretty much designed in that format, so we're not "losing" anything.
 
Maybe it was just me, but running at 1920x1080 (HDTV 1080p, 16:9), it didn't seem to be cropped or altered on the demo.

Anyone confirm?
 
And I was worried that I would miss out on a 4:3 monitor. Good for us 4:3 users, but I agree it sucks for those of you that have taken the Nestea plunge on widescreen. :(
 
When I played Bioshock i first played on a 20" CRT TV on my Xbox 360 and then over the weekend I purchased my first HDTV 37" Widescreen. Now I never owned a Widescreen display before this and I figured Xbox 360 is the perfect thing to test my new HDTV with since you know it takes advantage of HDTV. So I loaded up the Bioshock demo and I realized that the image appeared larger then I remember liked zoomed in and it threw me off. It wasn't until I read this whole thread thing about the widescreen that I realized what was going on. It is a bit nauseating I would say though its like looking through a pair of binoculars almost.
 
Guys, what happened to gameplay? Is graphics and that kind of little thing all you're focusing on nowadays? I thought gameplay was all that mattered.
 
Guys, what happened to gameplay? Is graphics and that kind of little thing all you're focusing on nowadays? I thought gameplay was all that mattered.
lets all use our integrated graphics since gameplay is all that matters :rolleyes:
 
I find that statement hard to believe by looking at your sig. ;) Certainly you're running games at a higher res than 800x600?

Mr.Stryker is a friend of mine I happen to know he owned a 1900xt, which was repalced by a 8800gtx, and now he is getting a 2900xt. He just never updated his sig.
He is right indeed, it is not all about graphics. In order to make a game good it a combination of graphics, gameplay, storyline, and the general feel of the game.
 
7800GTX - runs great at 1280x1024.
X1900XT - runs just fine at 1680x1050.
8800GTX - You guys already know.
HD2900XT - Like 2x faster than the X1900XT.

EDIT: I just noticed the sig is from 2 or 3 weeks ago. Updating now.

trek554 said:
lets all use our integrated graphics since gameplay is all that matters

It runs fine at 800x600 with some settings on low on my friend's HP Pavilion laptop that runs a Xpress 1150. You know, the UE3 engine for Bioshock is not a big hog to run. It's optimized pretty well.
 
Guess I'll wait until they get this fixed. It is confirmed to be a problem on both pc and xbox platform. Shacknews has the story and a link to the 2k forums in which it is being discussed.
 
7800GTX - runs great at 1280x1024.
X1900XT - runs just fine at 1680x1050.
8800GTX - You guys already know.
HD2900XT - Like 2x faster than the X1900XT.

EDIT: I just noticed the sig is from 2 or 3 weeks ago. Updating now.



It runs fine at 800x600 with some settings on low on my friend's HP Pavilion laptop that runs a Xpress 1150. You know, the UE3 engine for Bioshock is not a big hog to run. It's optimized pretty well.
one thing is for sure in that the game uses very little memory. there are some very low textures in odd places and think that allows the game to be run on more hardware. they really should offer an ultra mode for better overall texture appearance on upcoming graphics cards.
 
Guys, what happened to gameplay? Is graphics and that kind of little thing all you're focusing on nowadays? I thought gameplay was all that mattered.

because being able to see more of the game environment and the things in it couldnt possibly affect gameplay, could it


ignorant....
 
Hey guys with a 4:3 monitor, don't fret... just put some electrical tape and cardboard over the top and bottom 12.5" of your screen, BAM you got widescreen! :D
 
I was going to buy this today but now I changed my mind. Between this crap and the retarded mouse support it's too much.
 
Hey guys, when I alt tab out and back in it fixes the mouse wierdness. It apears to be reacting normally.
 
BTW that's with the full game, I don't know about the demo. I'm also running DX9 mode in Vista. DX10 cut too many FPS for not much visual gain.
 
UPDATE: It' wasn't the alttabbing, it was those drivers Nvidia had just released, I downgraded to the regular ones and that's what mad the mouse problem go away.
 
BTW that's with the full game, I don't know about the demo. I'm also running DX9 mode in Vista. DX10 cut too many FPS for not much visual gain.
really? I didnt notice any difference in framerate using fraps to make DX10 and DX9 benchmarks. I also didnt see any difference in the visuals.
 
There are two standard aspect ratios; Standard and Widescreen. Horizontal+ makes sense with Standard and Wide. Vert- would make sense if the two aspects were Standard and Tall, but they aren't so it doesn't :)

Widescreen_Illustration.png
 
Back
Top