Grrr...Bioshock widescreen cropping

Hi guys I just tried Racer_S's FOV Hack - it only works with the Demo atm.

I'm not 100% sure if I used the correct setting for 90 Degrees, but I think I did :p Correct me if I'm wrong (0.8333333)

Credit to Racer_S, he doesnt have the full version yet to make one compatible with it. It works beautifully with the demo so far, supporting any widescreen res you could possibly want.

99650296pq2.jpg


60064647ia4.jpg


96752034dd0.jpg
 
Ok one more time, though this time I changed BOTH the Horizontal and Vertical FOV. (recommended to set both to the same value)

11294667bw4.jpg


59180709iy6.jpg


98461790ix0.jpg


Anyhow the FOV scaling looks like an easily fixable issue :)
 
that's squishing things and thus a useless hack
No - you actually see more geometry (wider fov angle) on screen as with proper FOV implemented. It does work.

Credit and thanks to WSGFmedia.

bio1xj1.jpg


We just need to wait for the author to get the final version, OR for 2Kgames to release a fix.
 
oh I didnt think I noticed all screens were at the same size.

it would be stretched back out on a widescreen, right.
 
oh I didnt think I noticed all screens were at the same size.

it would be stretched back out on a widescreen, right.
Yeah I don't have a widescreen to take screenshots on, but its great news for people who get headaches and nausea playing in low FOVs (thats what caused the issue with HL2, its FOV was only 75).

Its not only for widescreen people, but people who get sick at low FOV on any screen :)

Edit: version 1.1 is now released, and supports the final retail version.
 
i can confirm this works was helping getting it working with the demo
Racer_S is a god :cool::eek:

ok what you need to is find the 4:3 closest to your wide screens native for 1680x1050 that would be 1400x1050 then use this hack to make the FOV wider then use scaling to stretch it back out
hope that helps
 
Sure, I was a little upset when I initially heard this news too, since all of my displays are widescreen. But you know what, 10 minutes into the game I couldn't f'ing care less... the game was just too fun.

I realize this is the internet and we're gamers and all.... so the bitching is inevitable. But this is hardly game breaking or affecting your experience in any way. My advice would be to play the game. It's good.
 
I realize this is the internet and we're gamers and all.... so the bitching is inevitable. But this is hardly game breaking or affecting your experience in any way. My advice would be to play the game. It's good.
As I mentioned before, its not only about "correct" settings and widescreen monitors - there are many gamers who experience headaches and nausea at low FOV settings like 75, which is what the game defaults to.
 
As I mentioned before, its not only about "correct" settings and widescreen monitors - there are many gamers who experience headaches and nausea at low FOV settings like 75, which is what the game defaults to.

Yeah, that would actually suck... and I feel for those people. But my comment was more aimed at the majority who are lashing out at the pure technicality of it all. Especially those boycotting the game entirely without even playing it. It's laughable really....

And yes, Racer_S is awesome for always doing this for our games.
 
Jesus the default FOV was 75? Wow that is ridiculous, Source engine defaults to 90 for 4:3 and 110 for 16:10.

This works great in the demo, those Widescreen Gaming guys are awesome. What are the correct settings to get the proper 110 degree FOV for 16:10?

BTW, I am boycotting the game not because of a technicality but because an Irrational employee back in may posted:
"The game will render in full 16:9 aspect ratio, with no letterboxing unless your resolution is not true 16:9. You will see more in widescreen. We use a different projection matrix; there is no squashing or stretching of the image involved."

Bullshit. Forcing 75 FOV on 4:3 is bad enough but on 16:9 and 16:10, it's borderline vicious. No wonder I was getting claustrophobic when playing the demo on a friends 16:9 TV. Sure Ken kinda responded to the issue but he only mentioned the PC, its even worse on the 360 due to the wider ratio.

And I'm also boycotting because they are forcing the 360 acceleration curve on PC mouse users.
 
um I can't find this hack on the site. can someone please point out the where an d how? and thanks to Racer for doing this so quickly.
 
Googlestater just calculated and posted a bunch of values to use with the FOV Hack.

These are based off 90 FOV base and literal horizontal scale.
16:9 = 0.625 sliders. Effective FOV 120 degrees
16:10 = 0.694 sliders. Effective FOV 108 degrees
5:4 = 0.888 sliders. Effective FOV 84.375 degrees
4:3 = 0.833 sliders. Effective FOV 90 degrees

You can see the rest of the values in his post here, for example if you prefer 75 FOV as a base for other resolutions (which is what the game shipped with)

Other key offsets have been found, so in the short future expect easier-to-use versions of the FOV hack to be released.
 
Thanks for the values. I have some bad new though, check this bullshit out:

"We understand there has been some concern about the implementation of widescreen mode in BioShock. Hopefully, we can clarify how we’ve chosen to do this.

The first thing we want to make clear is the mode we developed the game on and the optimal mode for playing the game is the widescreen mode. 90% of our development stations were widescreen displays: artists, programmers and designers.

- BioShock was primarily developed and tuned for widescreen mode. Artists and designers worked with widescreen displays and chose a field of view (FOV) that best reflected their intentions with respect to the way the world is perceived, the perceived speed of movement of the player relative to the world and the amount of the world they wanted to be viewed for the best game-play experience. We went through dozens of iterations and finally settled upon a widescreen aspect ratio that best suited the gameplay experience.

- When playing in widescreen modes the game makes use of the full screen resolution, and does not crop or stretch a lower resolution image into a wide screen one. For example, at 720p the game renders natively to the full 1280x720 resolution.

- Once this FOV was established, we chose to keep exactly the same horizontal FOV for standard def displays, so as not to in any way alter the gameplay experience.

- Instead of cropping the FOV for 4:3 displays and making all 4:3 owners mad in doing so, we slightly extended the vertical FOV for standard def mode: we never wanted to have black bars on people’s displays. (This way, everybody is happy…) This does mean that people playing on a standard def display see slightly more vertical space, but, this does not significantly affect the game-play experience and, we felt that it best served our goal of keeping the game experience as close as possible to the original design and art vision on both types of displays. Reports of the widescreen FOV being a crop of the 4:3 FOV are completely false.

One thing we can assure you that all these decisions were made with the best interests of the game in mind. We didn’t save any money or development time by choosing this set of parameters. We did what we thought was the best thing for the game: developing and optimizing it for widescreen displays, and making the decision not to do the usual crop for 4:3 displays. As a consumer, you certainly have the right to disagree.

We understand that not all users might not be happy with these choices and we will be looking into options for allowing users to adjust FOV settings manually. But as we mentioned earlier, changes to video game code do not happen in minutes or hours. We appreciate your understanding."

- Elizabeth

Lies, and spin. Do they really think we are all retarded, I mean they must really feel that way, I can't imagine how they could say all that shit when it's total bullshit. We know it's bullshit, and some of us won't buy the game. This spin will backfire, the issue won't go away. Gamers can be pretty forgiving and understanding laid back people buy we don't like being treated like this. Elizabeth is gonna have to earn every penny of her salary in the coming days.
 
Lies, and spin. Do they really think we are all retarded, I mean they must really feel that way, I can't imagine how they could say all that shit when it's total bullshit. We know it's bullshit, and some of us won't buy the game. This spin will backfire, the issue won't go away. Games can be pretty forgiving and understanding laid back people buy we don't like being treated like this. Elizabeth is gonna have to earn every penny of her salary in the coming days.

I think that's just her way of saying, "there is a small population of PC gamers that will whine like little bitches no matter what we do or say.... but please continue to voice your opinion while our game sells like gangbusters."

I'd say she did a job well done.
 
I can't imagine how they could say all that shit when it's total bullshit.
Most problematic is this:
Elizbeth said:
Reports of the widescreen FOV being a crop of the 4:3 FOV are completely false.
This statement is completely false. I said so at TTLG:
The effective field of view is, in fact, a crop of the original 4:3 frame. Saying otherwise is completely incorrect. This has been validated by WSGF users, among others, and said users are not incorrect when they say that the widescreen field of view is a crop of the 4:3 frame -- it absolutely is!

I'd say she did a job well done.
I don't believe she's qualified to do the job she's doing, actually. If you feel Irrational did it "right", you don't understand the issue.
 
but please continue to voice your opinion while our game sells like gangbusters."
and gets torrented in record numbers by angry gamers who would ordinarily purchase a great game to support the developer, pissed off about they way they have been and still are being lied to.
 
I was playing it last night on my rig (sig) and I couldn't tell a thing. I thought it looked better than the demo I played on the 360. I was also happy to say that I could pretty much max everything and have it run great. *shrug*

When I get home I will hook it up to my old 19 to see if I can tell a difference.
 
Instead of cropping the FOV for 4:3 displays and making all 4:3 owners mad in doing so, we slightly extended the vertical FOV for standard def mode: we never wanted to have black bars on people’s displays. (This way, everybody is happy…) This does mean that people playing on a standard def display see slightly more vertical space, but, this does not significantly affect the game-play experience and, we felt that it best served our goal of keeping the game experience as close as possible to the original design and art vision on both types of displays. Reports of the widescreen FOV being a crop of the 4:3 FOV are completely false.
Is it just me or do those statments completely contradict each other?

By taking a 16:10 ratio and adding vertical FOV to make a 4:3 ratio, you're creating a vert- 16:10 screen. Period. Adding to a 16:10 ratio to make it 4:3 is no different than rendering the 4:3 first and then cutting out the extra. It's the same thing just done in reverse.

The simple fact that you get more viewable area on a 4:3 than you do on a 16:10 monitor is proof positive that the game was not created with widescreen as the primary focus.
 
I think the default FOV is fine, the hack makes the game look awful IMO.
 
I think the default FOV is fine, the hack makes the game look awful IMO.
LOL ? The default FOV is 75, which is horribly low, ESPECIALLY for widescreen users. I'm guessing you didnt set both sliders to the same value, or you set them too low or too high.
Typically, in most fps games, 4:3 users have a FOV of about 90, and Widescreen users have a FOV of about 108-120 (depending on the res).

Forcing a FOV of 75 unto Widescreen users is batshit insane.

(and on top of it all, there are many many people who experience nausea/headaches/ sea-sickness etc at low FOV values, like under 80)
 
I downloaded this hack and adjusted the sliders to have approx. 108 - 100 FOV @ 1680x1050. I can finally see around me! The blinders have been kicked off my head, and it makes the game much more enjoyable. I bow to thee author of this hack! ;)
 
LOL ? The default FOV is 75, which is horribly low, ESPECIALLY for widescreen users. I'm guessing you didnt set both sliders to the same value, or you set them too low or too high.
Typically, in most fps games, 4:3 users have a FOV of about 90, and Widescreen users have a FOV of about 108-120 (depending on the res).

Forcing a FOV of 75 unto Widescreen users is batshit insane.

(and on top of it all, there are many many people who experience nausea/headaches/ sea-sickness etc at low FOV values, like under 80)
It moves the camera 2 feet in front of where it should be, causing you to misjudge perscpetive and discance, all of which no doubt contribute to the motion sickness.
 
they're recommending 0.84 / 0.82 for 16:10 over on the 2K forums, might want to try those values...
 
I can't seem to get the hack to work. Vista 32, maybe I'm doing something wrong?

I downloaded the hack to my desktop, ran the program, after moving the sliders and closing the program it created a config file. Am I suppose to place that in the Bioshock directory somewhere? I just left it in that folder. I have the resolution in the game set to 1680X1050 (Dell 2005FPW). Start the game wait till after the plane crashes, hit the * key and nothing changes? This is on the demo. I even tried it without the DX 10 enhancements and still nothing.

Buying the full game tonight but I don't really want to play it unless I can get this fixed.
 
:rolleyes:

if they kept the blackbars on for 4:3 users widescreen people wouldn't be bitching right about now for no reason. They programmed the game for widescreen and HD in mind but your not happy. Where was the outcry when Condemned on 4:3 monitors was letterboxed or RE4?
 
Indeed - all these widescreen owners act like they have right to a bigger picture, implying that the 4:3 picture should always be a cropped portion of the 16:9/10 screen. Why should that be the case? The inverse is applied here and is just as valid a situation.
 
Indeed - all these widescreen owners act like they have right to a bigger picture, implying that the 4:3 picture should always be a cropped portion of the 16:9/10 screen. Why should that be the case? The inverse is applied here and is just as valid a situation.

For a multiplayer fps it kind of makes sense b/c you have a bit of an advantage over other players. For a NON multi fps it's dumb b/c wtf cares if the AI is at a disadvantage? Make it so thanks.
 
I can't seem to get the hack to work. Vista 32, maybe I'm doing something wrong?

I downloaded the hack to my desktop, ran the program, after moving the sliders and closing the program it created a config file. Am I suppose to place that in the Bioshock directory somewhere? I just left it in that folder. I have the resolution in the game set to 1680X1050 (Dell 2005FPW). Start the game wait till after the plane crashes, hit the * key and nothing changes? This is on the demo. I even tried it without the DX 10 enhancements and still nothing.

Buying the full game tonight but I don't really want to play it unless I can get this fixed.

Same here, I wonder what is the special thing to do to make it work :confused:
 
For a multiplayer fps it kind of makes sense b/c you have a bit of an advantage over other players. For a NON multi fps it's dumb b/c wtf cares if the AI is at a disadvantage? Make it so thanks.

I don't follow - why should the 4:3 view NOT be the widescreen view with extra areas added at the top and bottom? This is exactly the inverse arguement to the popular one that widescreen should bt the 4:3 view with extra areas added to the sides, and is just as valid. Widescreen users have no right to or monopoly on the bigger view area.
 
I don't follow - why should the 4:3 view NOT be the widescreen view with extra areas added at the top and bottom? This is exactly the inverse arguement to the popular one that widescreen should bt the 4:3 view with extra areas added to the sides, and is just as valid. Widescreen users have no right to or monopoly on the bigger view area.

becouse thats the POINT of wide screen if it wasnt why bother

http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11712

and that pretty much proves its fucked up WHO THE HELL WRITES A GAME FOR TALLSCREEN?
 
becouse thats the POINT of wide screen if it wasnt why bother

http://www.widescreengamingforum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11712

and that pretty much proves its fucked up WHO THE HELL WRITES A GAME FOR TALLSCREEN?

The same people that infect your pc with ROOTKIT thorough the fucking demo!

try to delete folder: C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\Application Data\SecuRom

make sure you enable "show hidden files and folders" first.
 
The same people that infect your pc with ROOTKIT thorough the fucking demo!

try to delete folder: C:\Documents and Settings\Administrator\Application Data\SecuRom

make sure you enable "show hidden files and folders" first.

already know aboutit
fucks need to stop with the shitty copy protection
Oblivion had what a disk check and that was it and its one of the best selling PC games EVER :rolleyes:
http://www.hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1215945
 
stop whining already.

widescreen and 4:3 displays are chocolate and vanilla. they are preferences. Some game devs choose one over the other to have the most screen space.

you say widescreen has more horizontal space, another says they have less vertical space. It's just ridiculous that widescreen users think they are entitled to have more screen space. It's as intelligent as saying vanilla is better than chocolate.
 
i was one of the people who were originally disappointed by this news...

but i played the game for the first time last night, and once you get into it, none of this matters. it's a fantastic game. sit on your couch or at your desk and just enjoy it. jesus.
 
stop whining already.

widescreen and 4:3 displays are chocolate and vanilla. they are preferences. Some game devs choose one over the other to have the most screen space.

you say widescreen has more horizontal space, another says they have less vertical space. It's just ridiculous that widescreen users think they are entitled to have more screen space. It's as intelligent as saying vanilla is better than chocolate.

one of the devs was asked LONG be for the game came out if it would porper wide screen he said "you will see more with wide screen" any way you look at it you see less
i dont like being lied to

also wide screen is the same has HDTV if you saw LESS on your HDTV then a SD TV wouldnt you be pissed?
http://www.widescreen.org/examples/tomorrow/index.shtml
also almost EVERY move has more on the sides
the point of gaming with a wide screen is to get more cinematic experience
 
one of the devs was asked LONG be for the game came out if it would porper wide screen he said "you will see more with wide screen" any way you look at it you see less
i dont like being lied to

also wide screen is the same has HDTV if you saw LESS on your HDTV then a SD TV wouldnt you be pissed?

Here's the thing. With the HDTV standard it was decided that it gets more screen space than SDTVs because most everything is filmed in widescreen.

BUT, we are talking about the PC here. there are no such standards put in place. We've had high resolutions on CRT monitors since the 80s. Widescreen hasn't brought anything innovative to the PC, it's just a different aspect ratio. So then its up to the developers on what screen they design the game to have more screen space for.
 
Here's the thing. With the HDTV standard it was decided that it gets more screen space than SDTVs because most everything is filmed in widescreen.

BUT, we are talking about the PC here. there are no such standards put in place. We've had high resolutions on CRT monitors since the 80s. Widescreen hasn't brought anything innovative to the PC, it's just a different aspect ratio. So then its up to the developers on what screen they design the game to have more screen space for.


the point is to follow the same set as HDTV if it can have a wider view so can PC gaming AND console gaming on HDTVs
 
Back
Top