Google Using Site Speed In Search Ranking

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Google now says that it will be factoring in site speed when ranking sites in its search results. What does speed have to do with relevance? What do you think of the change?

Speeding up websites is important — not just to site owners, but to all Internet users. Faster sites create happy users and we've seen in our internal studies that when a site responds slowly, visitors spend less time there. But faster sites don't just improve user experience; recent data shows that improving site speed also reduces operating costs. Like us, our users place a lot of value in speed — that's why we've decided to take site speed into account in our search rankings.
 
Site speed has a lot to do with how you browse (No Script, etc.), but it will definitely make businesses think twice about spamming their site with indiscriminate graphics and banner ads.
 
I welcome this change big time. Hopefully this will get many developers to adopt better practices and reduce the weight on their website. Like not using tables and a million crappy image files for spacing.

Count me in the group that doesn't wait for slow pages to load.

As to how it relates to relevance of the search. Well it doesn't... yet. Technically speaking, how quickly data arrives doesn't make a page more or less relevant, when we are specifically talking about comparing keywords to documents. FTA, we see that Google says this and has put significantly less weight on the speed compared to the search parameters (so far it affects less than 1 percent of all searches). Here are two ways search time could mean more relevance:

1) It could lead people to put more precise content on their page. Nobody likes a page that scrolls for 20 miles and 5 minute load time because a phrase matched. (I'm looking at you, Mr. I-use-pdf-files-for-content guy). Theoretically, a smaller page that matches a specific phrase is more likely to be what you were looking for than one that matches a tiny piece of a huge document. A nice side effect may be that it clobbers all them nasty pages that are just run-on gibberish to get those matches in the first place.

2) Developers who semantically write their HTML naturally and style properly with CSS will naturally have smaller, quicker pages. At that point, HTML tags and attributes could be used to further enhance search results. Obviously the main content of a page is the article, the navigation, header, footer and aside have less weight. If the search engine could identify these parts properly, it could bring better results to the end user.
 
I think this will be awesome it will hopefully make people clean up their websites. Among other things don't want ot get ranked down then up your bandwidth with your ISP.
 
As a web designer, I personally think this is a step in the wrong direction. Google will be penalizing sites solely based upon loading times irrelevant of content. If Google's algorithm's can somehow factor in site content AND optimization vs. loading times, as opposed to strictly basing it upon loading times alone (i.e, site size) then it will be valuable.

Otherwise, it's just going to be pushing the market towards lean websites... when the reality is, robust and rich content experiences are what people need, not websites that load faster than a dry fart.The connection speeds should be growing to accommodate rich online experiences, not the other way around!

I have plenty of tricks up my sleeve to save bandwidth (that many developers don't even bother to do), such as further optimizing PNG's with pngout etc. which often saves 30-40% on top of photoshop's "save for web", but sometimes you just can't optimize it any further. If Google realizes that the site is 99.99% optimized considering the content it has, I don't think it should be penalized at all... many rich websites these days are packing 500kb+, which is under 3-5 seconds for most broadband connections, I think that's more than in the realm of acceptability.

We are not challenged for space nor speed these days... why not fully embrace the capabilities in terms of storage and download speeds that we have available? Even a basic DSL service is 1mbit per second, which means that 500kbyte website will download in 4 seconds... are we that impatient?
 
One thing I forgot to mention: I'd much rather wait 10 seconds for a website is appropriate & looks nice, rather than 0.1 seconds for an irrelevant page that's difficult to navigate as it hasn't got many visual cues.

We have the bandwidth now and the color palette's are standard among every PC that we don't need to revert back to optimizing gif's for 256 colors...
 
One last thing, a website with 100 50x50px images composed of 1 sprite will load lightyears ahead of a web page with 50 seperate 50x50px images. Will google factor in optimizations such as this in terms of loading speed?

I just think this is such a bad move, I think penalizing sites not embracing CSS that are loaded with tables etc. is fine, but what if the coding practices are perfect but the client simply wants a very rich experience? Should they be ranked lower even though their content (and overall user experience) is probably better?
 
I think this is good, slow sites piss me off and I won't use them
 
I think this can hurt archive sites that can't really keep their servers on the forefront.
 
One last thing, a website with 100 50x50px images composed of 1 sprite will load lightyears ahead of a web page with 50 seperate 50x50px images. Will google factor in optimizations such as this in terms of loading speed?

I just think this is such a bad move, I think penalizing sites not embracing CSS that are loaded with tables etc. is fine, but what if the coding practices are perfect but the client simply wants a very rich experience? Should they be ranked lower even though their content (and overall user experience) is probably better?

I think you're focusing a little bit too much on content loading times. I expect most of the difference will come from downloading from a .com vs. a.co.uk site, for example. Assuming the search algorithm is smart enough to factor in where you are connecting from, you could get more local, and therefore speedier searches.

Heck, even DNS servers do that nowadays (link state vs. distance-vector routing).
 
That's what we keep asking for uber handwidth for... oh... excuse me, is it slowing down your pron?

That said. I've worked for a few Korean companies so i regularly saw some of their websites. I cringed every time i looked at them coz they go against everything i've been taught about bandwidth conservation. The odds of running into those pages outside of korea is pretty slim tho.
 
That isn't right at all. BloodyIron brings up a good point.

Way to stuff it to the little guys, Google.
 
I like how everyone in this thread figures suddenly that this is going to be the ONLY factor instead of one of many factors.
 
More exposure to all the established sites with good funding behind them. This is a troublesome development, but hardly surprising.
 
I like how everyone in this thread figures suddenly that this is going to be the ONLY factor instead of one of many factors.

No kidding. You'd think the sky was falling or something.

I know a "web designer" who makes sites with so much flash that they take minutes to load and then they eat up 100% of a CPU... It's going to affect him in a negative way, and rightfully so.
 
More exposure to all the established sites with good funding behind them. This is a troublesome development, but hardly surprising.
It's definitely worth reading the blog. Google provides links to many free tools--even Yahoo's--to help webmasters optimize their sites.

And there's this to support NKDietrich's point:
While site speed is a new signal, it doesn't carry as much weight as the relevance of a page. Currently, fewer than 1% of search queries are affected by the site speed signal in our implementation and the signal for site speed only applies for visitors searching in English on Google.com at this point. We launched this change a few weeks back after rigorous testing. If you haven't seen much change to your site rankings, then this site speed change possibly did not impact your site
 
As a web designer, I personally think this is a step in the wrong direction. Google will be penalizing sites solely based upon loading times irrelevant of content. If Google's algorithm's can somehow factor in site content AND optimization vs. loading times, as opposed to strictly basing it upon loading times alone (i.e, site size) then it will be valuable.

Otherwise, it's just going to be pushing the market towards lean websites... when the reality is, robust and rich content experiences are what people need, not websites that load faster than a dry fart.The connection speeds should be growing to accommodate rich online experiences, not the other way around!

I have plenty of tricks up my sleeve to save bandwidth (that many developers don't even bother to do), such as further optimizing PNG's with pngout etc. which often saves 30-40% on top of photoshop's "save for web", but sometimes you just can't optimize it any further. If Google realizes that the site is 99.99% optimized considering the content it has, I don't think it should be penalized at all... many rich websites these days are packing 500kb+, which is under 3-5 seconds for most broadband connections, I think that's more than in the realm of acceptability.

We are not challenged for space nor speed these days... why not fully embrace the capabilities in terms of storage and download speeds that we have available? Even a basic DSL service is 1mbit per second, which means that 500kbyte website will download in 4 seconds... are we that impatient?

Omg, isn't this more clear than water?
Google doesn't charge you because they don't need to. Leaving finances aside, they have positioned themselves in a place where they can dictate who lives and who dies on the Internet.
This might be overly dramatic stated but in reality it is fact to some extent.
Talk about State Socialism.
 
I'd actually prefer them to not factor anything in like they used to where a search result provided relevent results and not the "most popular website that happens to have these two words" on there someplace.
 
Sounds like a good idea. I like the free market taking care of things itself. Please do not let the goverment get involved.
 
<1% of sites are being affected. So basically they are just penalizing the super slow sites.

Also does anyone know if this is based on latency or site elements? ie slow ass javascript and excessive use of certain things like tables.
 
Omg, isn't this more clear than water?
Google doesn't charge you because they don't need to. Leaving finances aside, they have positioned themselves in a place where they can dictate who lives and who dies on the Internet.
This might be overly dramatic stated but in reality it is fact to some extent.
Talk about State Socialism.
It always amuses me when people tout something they don't like as evidence of a political agenda they don't like. Surely, Google controlling everything would be a capitalistic "dictatorship of the bourgeoisie" as opposed to the socialist "dictatorship of the proletariate?" Yes, this is just verbal diarrhea from wikipedia, what's your point?

I personally see this as Google trying to make their search offering superior to a real competitor (Bing) for a change. Talk about capitalism.
 
Back
Top