Google Sheltering $10B In Bermuda

Oh really? Why don't you analyze the effects of a poor person having to pay 18% of their income vs a rich person. It might not seem like a "fair tax" then...

Have you actually read the fair tax? The rate is 25% and there is a prebate for ALL taxes paid up to the poverty line. You start out really paying 0% taxes at the bottom up to 25% at the top. It's actually fairly progressive when it comes to taxing those who can barely afford to live vs the people at the top.
 
Have you actually read the fair tax? The rate is 25% and there is a prebate for ALL taxes paid up to the poverty line. You start out really paying 0% taxes at the bottom up to 25% at the top. It's actually fairly progressive when it comes to taxing those who can barely afford to live vs the people at the top.

I don't think he's referring to the proposed "fair tax"... just using the word "fair" in response to a flat tax proposal.
 
I do my own taxes, and my state doesn't have income tax. I paid Federal Income tax (plus SS and Medicare stuff). At the time I was making ~$24k a year.

I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset but as a single person with no dependents 24K is not poor. Been there done that and did quite well at time. It is all about living within your means.
 
Ok. I have to agree a flat tax isn't all that great of an Idea. There are a lot of worthless sponges out there, but that certainly doesn't mean everyone who barely makes enough to live is. Many have physical or mental disabilities and making them dig into their limited food budget to pay taxes feels wrong to me.
 
I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset ...

Then don't try to justify any level of compensation. They will always want more, because they feel they deserve it.

These are the people largely responsible for our dire economic situation. We pass the buck to politicians but we choose them. We just chose a full second round of Captain Dipshit, for chrissakes. People may want reform, but they want it less than they want to keep their "free" shit.
 
I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset but as a single person with no dependents 24K is not poor. Been there done that and did quite well at time. It is all about living within your means.

It largely depends on where you live too. 24k in some places is a nice chunk of change... while in others it's barely enough to make ends meet.
 
I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset but as a single person with no dependents 24K is not poor. Been there done that and did quite well at time. It is all about living within your means.

That really depends on where you live. Money goes a lot further in some places than others. Many places you could buy and pay for a very small house or descent apartment with that income. Others, like say New York or LA, you'd almost have to live out of a cardboard box on that.
 
I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset but as a single person with no dependents 24K is not poor. Been there done that and did quite well at time. It is all about living within your means.

24k is poor in places with a relatively high population. You'd never survive in New York City or Northern Virginia, I'd bet, with 24k.
 
Then don't try to justify any level of compensation. They will always want more, because they feel they deserve it.

These are the people largely responsible for our dire economic situation. We pass the buck to politicians but we choose them. We just chose a full second round of Captain Dipshit, for chrissakes. People may want reform, but they want it less than they want to keep their "free" shit.

To be fair the alternative wasn't all that great either. I still think if the republicans had nominated a good candidate Obama wouldn't have had a chance.
 
24k is poor in places with a relatively high population. You'd never survive in New York City or Northern Virginia, I'd bet, with 24k.

If you want to live in the best areas, of course not. So? We're talking about people with a low income, not somebody who has their pick of where they want to live.

Right there, you demonstrated this entitlement mindset: that everyone gets to live in a nice neighborhood with all the room and view that they could ask for. No, they don't. In big cities, there is a higher demand for living space than in rural areas, and so therefore it comes at a higher premium. If you don't have the ability to make more than a certain amount of money, perhaps you should choose to live in a less expensive area. If you choose not to do so, don't be surprised that you can't afford the lifestyles you see of everyone around you.

That's a harsh reality that no amount of class warfare rhetoric, tax increases, or social programs can solve.
 
I realize we live with a society that has an entitled mindset but as a single person with no dependents 24K is not poor. Been there done that and did quite well at time. It is all about living within your means.

Uh, what? I'm thinking you missed the whole point. The point is that I paid taxes and people who would tell you otherwise aren't giving you the truth.

Also, where I live, $24k is rather poor. I make quite a bit more than that now, but at the time we were talking about living paycheck to paycheck. I'm not complaining about it, I made what I was worth to the market at the time. To say that income bracket pays no taxes is what I take issue with.
 
You mean deductions?

I'm all for that!!! Get rid of deductions across the board and simplify the tax code. Everyone owes X%. No more write offs or special privileges... that way, nobody has a right to bitch about anything.

Irish Sandwich and Double Dutch are not deductions. They are loopholes. Even if deductions for the domestic tax code were completely eliminated, it would only affect small to medium sized business owners and private citizens. Corporations, especially multi-nationals, would still be able to shelter money and avoid a large part of their tax bills.
 
No, he wasn't all that great. I didn't even vote for the dip. But you know what? At least he wouldn't have been putting his supporters to work as propaganda drones.

Agreed. I didn't vote for either of those douchbags. I don't care so much about the social side of it. It's not my business what someone else does with their life. I do care about fiscal responsibility or the lack thereof. The direction were going fiscally is very bad for everyone and it mostly comes down to excessive gov't spending.
 
Class warfare is an effective tool to manipulate the masses, though. Always has been, unfortunately. Worked quite well about 100 years ago in Russia, as well as Germany.
Winner winner chicken dinner, he found a way to not only include nazi's but communists as well. 100 Internet points to you, sir.
 
I find it absolutly insane that people are trying to destroy the 1% (AKA very hard working people) and not demonizing google for this action.

Makes me sick
 
Would be funny as hell if Bermuda suddenly had a financial crisis and the money got "lost" or devalued.
 
If you want to live in the best areas, of course not. So? We're talking about people with a low income, not somebody who has their pick of where they want to live.

Right there, you demonstrated this entitlement mindset: that everyone gets to live in a nice neighborhood with all the room and view that they could ask for. No, they don't. In big cities, there is a higher demand for living space than in rural areas, and so therefore it comes at a higher premium. If you don't have the ability to make more than a certain amount of money, perhaps you should choose to live in a less expensive area. If you choose not to do so, don't be surprised that you can't afford the lifestyles you see of everyone around you.

That's a harsh reality that no amount of class warfare rhetoric, tax increases, or social programs can solve.
Yes, but there is also a problem of that moving costs money. It costs money just to physically move, and it also costs money through the opportunity costs of moving instead of working, especially if you do not have a job lined up where you are moving to. So the very poor can end up stuck in an area with no jobs or extremely poor job options but without the means to move themselves to an area where they can afford to live or get a job. It's not an easy problem to solve.
 
Then don't try to justify any level of compensation. They will always want more, because they feel they deserve it.

These are the people largely responsible for our dire economic situation. We pass the buck to politicians but we choose them. We just chose a full second round of Captain Dipshit, for chrissakes. People may want reform, but they want it less than they want to keep their "free" shit.

Yeah, I mean people feel entitled to food! Where they hell do they get off trying to live when they can't even get a job!!

This may be a shock to you, but the people at the bottom aren't always there because they are "lazy". The economy thrives on having a certain percentage of people being desperately poor. These are the people that actually keep the economy going. They have a small, tiny percentage of the wealth in the country, but what they get they spend. They spend the money on necessities and a few luxury items, and a couple of other things. This is what stimulates the economy. This group of people are the ones on welfare, the people who have minimum wage jobs, some of the elderly retired and some other types of people.

And there isn't some magic bullet. You increase education, and that increases the requirements to get basic jobs too. You need a high school diploma to get a job in fast food. That rewards people for going to school, but hurts others. Society shifts to keep a percentage at the bottom in small ways. It's a supply/demand economy everywhere.

However, these people at the bottom pump money into the economy. You give $1 million to a rich person and they'll put it into a bank or an investment and that's it. It doesn't go into the economy. The same goes if you give the same amount to a company. You give $1000 to 1000 poor people, and the money will be thrown into the economy.
 
Yeah, I mean people feel entitled to food! Where they hell do they get off trying to live when they can't even get a job!!

This may be a shock to you, but the people at the bottom aren't always there because they are "lazy". The economy thrives on having a certain percentage of people being desperately poor. These are the people that actually keep the economy going. They have a small, tiny percentage of the wealth in the country, but what they get they spend. They spend the money on necessities and a few luxury items, and a couple of other things. This is what stimulates the economy. This group of people are the ones on welfare, the people who have minimum wage jobs, some of the elderly retired and some other types of people.

And there isn't some magic bullet. You increase education, and that increases the requirements to get basic jobs too. You need a high school diploma to get a job in fast food. That rewards people for going to school, but hurts others. Society shifts to keep a percentage at the bottom in small ways. It's a supply/demand economy everywhere.

Show me a person in the United States who is hungry and I'll show you somebody who isn't using the abundance of assistance available to them.

However, these people at the bottom pump money into the economy. You give $1 million to a rich person and they'll put it into a bank or an investment and that's it. It doesn't go into the economy. The same goes if you give the same amount to a company. You give $1000 to 1000 poor people, and the money will be thrown into the economy.

Where do you think money in "a bank or an investment" goes?

It doesn't go into the economy

You clearly have no idea how money and economies work. None.
 
Irish Sandwich and Double Dutch are not deductions. They are loopholes. Even if deductions for the domestic tax code were completely eliminated, it would only affect small to medium sized business owners and private citizens. Corporations, especially multi-nationals, would still be able to shelter money and avoid a large part of their tax bills.

right... but I was referring to the poster that said to close all the loopholes. I was being facetious as most people don't see that stuff as a 'loophole'... only when the wealthy or companies do it. I do mean it though... Get rid of deductions and simplify the tax code. It would make things a whole lot easier and would save the govt (us?) money.

As for what Google is doing, there isn't much that we (the U.S.) can do about it
 
You clearly have no idea how money and economies work. None.
He's not entirely wrong. Right now companies are sitting on an abundance of capital, and yet they are still not hiring. There has to be demand for products as well, and while investments are obviously necessary for business and economic growth, having consumers to purchase the products that these companies make is equally important.
 
He's not entirely wrong. Right now companies are sitting on an abundance of capital, and yet they are still not hiring. There has to be demand for products as well, and while investments are obviously necessary for business and economic growth, having consumers to purchase the products that these companies make is equally important.

I'll ask you the same question:

When you put money in a bank, where do you think it goes?
 
Yeah, I mean people feel entitled to food! Where they hell do they get off trying to live when they can't even get a job!!

This may be a shock to you, but the people at the bottom aren't always there because they are "lazy". The economy thrives on having a certain percentage of people being desperately poor. These are the people that actually keep the economy going. They have a small, tiny percentage of the wealth in the country, but what they get they spend. They spend the money on necessities and a few luxury items, and a couple of other things. This is what stimulates the economy. This group of people are the ones on welfare, the people who have minimum wage jobs, some of the elderly retired and some other types of people.

And there isn't some magic bullet. You increase education, and that increases the requirements to get basic jobs too. You need a high school diploma to get a job in fast food. That rewards people for going to school, but hurts others. Society shifts to keep a percentage at the bottom in small ways. It's a supply/demand economy everywhere.

However, these people at the bottom pump money into the economy. You give $1 million to a rich person and they'll put it into a bank or an investment and that's it. It doesn't go into the economy. The same goes if you give the same amount to a company. You give $1000 to 1000 poor people, and the money will be thrown into the economy.

Life isn't "fair", and I'm not sure it needs to be.
 
I'll ask you the same question:

When you put money in a bank, where do you think it goes?
I know where it goes. The bank loans out the money to others or otherwise invests it. That still doesn't mean that investment is the same as consumption. People at the bottom of the income bracket spend their money rather than save it. It's important to have consumers for products, not solely capital investment. This is why having a middle class is a big deal.
 
I know where it goes. The bank loans out the money to others or otherwise invests it. That still doesn't mean that investment is the same as consumption. People at the bottom of the income bracket spend their money rather than save it. It's important to have consumers for products, not solely capital investment. This is why having a middle class is a big deal.

Money saved in a bank today is money spent today.
Money saved in a mattress today is money spent tomorrow.

You seem to be implying that when I put money in a bank it disappears from "the economy"... and that's completely incorrect.


Consumer spending is high. Nobody is talking about consumers.
What's happening here is somebody trying to demonize saving and investment with a fallacious economic viewpoint.
 
if governments were financially responsible i could see your point, the truly sad part is that is not the case. all governments not just ours are getting out of control with spending and taxing which is borderline criminal.[/url]

My problem with this, is at least here in canada it's not the governments fault entirely.
They tell us were massively in debt, they tell us they need to do cuts, people scream bloody murder for them to get spending under control...

Teacher pay freeze? screw you were gunna strike...
Police pay freeze? screw you were gunna strike...
Hospital spending cuts? screw you were gunna strike...
Services cut? OMG it's the end of the world you can't cut any spending from us

The country has no money, but no one is willing to give up even a dime in the crap that money goes to and demand more all the time, so what's the government suppose to do?
 
He's not entirely wrong. Right now companies are sitting on an abundance of capital, and yet they are still not hiring. There has to be demand for products as well, and while investments are obviously necessary for business and economic growth, having consumers to purchase the products that these companies make is equally important.

The problem with stagnant sales is that those pesky consumers need a job that pays enough that they have some disposable income that they can use to do so. Those same pesky consumers insist on good wages but many of the companies that want them to buy their stuff insist on doing the minimum, or less, for them on wages. Their bottom line is to line the bottom of their pockets, not the employees.

If you want companies to hire more people then the companies have to have increased demand for their goods. It's as simple as that. You can throw all of the cash and tax breaks at these companies that you want to and all you will end up with is companies sitting on piles of cash, just like we have now. Demand is the name of the game. Nothing is going to change until you do something to increase demand.

Paying people less isn't the solution, it's part of the problem.
 
Money saved in a bank today is money spent today.
Money saved in a mattress today is money spent tomorrow.

You seem to be implying that when I put money in a bank it disappears from "the economy"... and that's completely incorrect.


Consumer spending is high. Nobody is talking about consumers.
What's happening here is somebody trying to demonize saving and investment with a fallacious economic viewpoint.
That's not what I was implying. I'm saying you need both investment and spending. Right now the problem seems to be lack of demand not lack of investment.
 
Keep drinking whatever KoolAid you're drinking. US companies were given an amnesty to bring profits that were stacked away with accounting moves like Double Dutch and Irish Sandwich, and we were told at that time, there would be a an increase on corporate spending yadi yadi yadi...nice try. Didn't happen, then won't now. Fix the loopholes and this wouldn't be happening.

Loopholes or deductions? A lot of people confuse the two.
 
The mental gymnastics you go through to come up with the conclusion that the government is greedy for asking for taxes and that corporations are not greedy for hiding their money in foreign countries to avoid taxes is really quite impressive.

No mental gymnastics when the truth is on your side. The tax code is massive, unbearable, unmanageable, convoluted, and is a complete drain on the economy as a whole. Instead of caterwauling on how corporations are within their legal rights to shelter the money they do not want to be taxed on, maybe you should look at how to reduce government spending so that government doesn't require massive infusions of the generated wealth of the citizens and the companies that employ them to use on moving those vast sums of wealth from the producers to themselves and the non-producers.
 
Why is it sad?

It's sad, because if the businesses that took advantage of these loopholes weren't allowed to do so and taxed appropriately, then governments world wide would responsibly disseminate the receipts. :D

The :D implies sarcasm.
 
That's not what I was implying. I'm saying you need both investment and spending. Right now the problem seems to be lack of demand not lack of investment.

The problem is inability to service debt accumulated by a government induced bubble.
 
You mean deductions?

I'm all for that!!! Get rid of deductions across the board and simplify the tax code. Everyone owes X%. No more write offs or special privileges... that way, nobody has a right to bitch about anything.

Then you kill incentive on a lot of activities. The this is the reason why people confuse deductions with loopholes. They aren't the same. Let's say for example you eliminate business deductions on capital investments or capital equipment. How would a company manage appreciations or depreciation? On the consumer side, what is the incentive to buy a house instead of renting if you don't get an interest deduction? How about deductions for charitable giving?
 
That's not what I was implying. I'm saying you need both investment and spending. Right now the problem seems to be lack of demand not lack of investment.

It's a force multiplies. You see lack of demand, therefore you will see lack of investment. Since the argument is that money is cheap at it's current rate, it's better to divest it in other areas that carry a considerably larger return on where those investments will go. For example, dividends or stock repurchase. Or move the money where there is a better return on it. Right now, when you have government and namely this administration looking to spend 1 to 1.5 trillion in annual deficits until his term is over plus with a treasury and treasury secretary buying up poisoned paper to the tune of 40 billion per month ad infinitum, then you are setting up your currency for a massive inflationary bubble that will be unsustainable and when that hits, it will hit everyone. Not just in the US, but on a global scale. There is no way to shelter yourself from what is coming other than hedging it to tangible assets. That is the only leverage you will have.
 
Have you actually read the fair tax? The rate is 25% and there is a prebate for ALL taxes paid up to the poverty line. You start out really paying 0% taxes at the bottom up to 25% at the top. It's actually fairly progressive when it comes to taxing those who can barely afford to live vs the people at the top.

Thought it was 23%. However, there is no provision in the fair tax on how to curtail congress from raising or lowering that rate. Also, there is already rumbling that a federal consumption tax or vat tax is coming, but in conjunction with the current tax code we have now. There will be no refuge for the average citizens at that point. Government has no desire to freeze or cut spending and sees the citizens as it's infinite piggy bank into indentured servitude to the state. This last election was basically a referendum on the The Declaration of Independence to the acceptance of The Declaration of Dependence. The whole point of starting this country was to get away from the very thing we have now. Remarkable how in less than 250 years we have borked this experiment to what we have now.

60 of those years spent in total and utter leftist indoctrination and inculcation from the K-PhD system. The 5th column takeover is complete. The low hanging fruit voters have won. Bread and circus.
 
Back
Top