Goodbye ASUS

WangChung

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 19, 2013
Messages
181
I'm moving on from ASUS. I've liked the feature rich boards they sell - when they work. Otherwise, it's a complete shit show.
It seems like they have laser focus on "point of sale" only, meaning getting you to the door and out the door with their box is all they drive. Once the transaction is complete, kick rocks.
Zero tech support, horrific RMA experience, zero driver updates, zero BIOS updates (even when needed to fix a glaring issue).

ASRock has been great, though I've noticed their BIOS updates are slow to none as well. At least they use pretty standard components on their boards so you can go scavenger hunt for up-to-date drivers if need be.

I've been looking for another go-to main board manufacturer, and besides ASRock it looks like Gigabyte or MSI are it. Any thoughts?
 
only when they have totally destroyed the brand will they reinvent it as a bargain/value brand and the cycle starts again

modern gotcha mercantilism
 
I'm still sticking with Asus for all the builds I do for myself or friends. I have yet to receive a DOA or faulty board from them (knock on wood). So I can't attest to their shitty customer service because I haven't needed it yet and that's why I keep coming back.

If I did leave them, MSI would likely be the brand I'd choose. They've been making some really nice boards lately and getting really good reviews. But so far, Asus has been bulletproof for me from my $200 indestructible Sabertooth to the $70 AM3+ 970 I bought for my son's PC a month ago.
 
You do realize that ASrock is a child company of Asus right? :rolleyes: For my end, i've been using Asus boards for 12 years on 6 different builds and only one went bad and was fixed under 3 year warranty.
 
I switched over to mostly Gigabyte motherboards with Lynnfield's release in 2009. I still really like Asus notebooks, though.
 
The Gigabyte BK series is worthy. "GIGABYTE Black Edition motherboards undergo an extra 168 hours (7 days) of stress testing before shipment to ensure premium quality for our customers"
 
I'm using a Gigabyte P67a board since early 2011 and its been great with my 2500K.
But I've been watching reports of the newer UEFI BIOS boards, that the BIOS are difficult/annoying to operate and dont seem to get any better. ie they are not fixing the issues on the newer board releases.

I may be buying a Skylake system if my Dad needs a new PC for an upcoming project (He will have my PC :))
I'm heavily opposed to buying anything Asus after being given the cold shoulder by them so am also looking at other motherboards.
 
cold shoulder

exactly

paying $400+ for a premium product and then when you have a problem it's "ha ha ha, we already have your money sucker...get lost" leaves a rather bitter taste.

I was a huge fan, built my sig rigs from their parts, can not recommend at this time.
 
I have three computers currently running Asus boards.
Z87,X79 and brand new Z97.
They have worked great right out of the box. Super overclockers and slick BIOS.

My only fear is what would happen if they needed RMA.

I think you just have to trust they wont.
 
You do realize that ASrock is a child company of Asus right? :rolleyes: For my end, i've been using Asus boards for 12 years on 6 different builds and only one went bad and was fixed under 3 year warranty.

Used to be, they are no longer.
 
A lot of friends get on my case for never buying ASUS products. I was all on the Asus Hype train years ago (2006ish). Bought a "wonderful*" P5N32-E SLI board due to the rave reviews about how amazing this board was.

This beast killed 2 sets of Crucial Ballistix RAM and an EVGA 8800GTS. Both EVGA and Crucial came back noting that the motherboard was at fault. I was inclined to agree. ASUS, however, kept me in RMA limbo for just long enough for me to get out of my exchange / refund window.

They noted that there were some BIOS and firmware issues on the board which may be causing voltage issues (documented online). They offered to flash the BIOS for a fee or give me instructions to do so myself. I declined and noted that I wanted a new replacement board as this one had already killed multiple pieces of hardware. Under no circumstances was I going to send more parts to ASUS Hell.

ASUS at this point refused to honor their warranty...on a brand new board...After I had my issue resolved by Newegg. I kept tabs on the board, in case I could ever get it fixed.

ASUS, true to form, instead of issuing fixes for the people who bought the board, they instead released a new SKU, the P5N32-E SLI Plus, which supposedly fixed the BIOS and voltage issues. Effectively screwing anyone who got a bum board with the original model.

I contacted Newegg and pointed out my dilemma. Newegg apparently had some issues with returns on this board as well, as the policy was changed from their Full Refund/Exchange to Exchange Only.
Since I was a longstanding customer, and for good service in general, Newegg refunded me the FULL price of the board, and told me to not bother sending the board back, just purchase the new board at my convenience. Ended up buying a DFI LanParty board which is still running after 8+ (friend bought the machine off me).

So ASUS taught me a valuable lesson.

So did EVGA and Crucial and NewEgg.

Customer service matters, and I'm still a loyal NewEgg, EVGA and Crucial customer.

Asus can bite me.
 
I find myself looking at Asus products most of the time. I had to RMA one board out of maybe 15 and I got it back in a "reasonable" amount of time and it was actually fixed.

That being said, I've had good experiences with ASRock and Gigabyte lately. I wouldn't hesitate going with either of those two if the price was right.
 
After dealing with a HIS RMA Asus is golden in my eyes lol... I only had to RMA 1 asus product out of the COUNTLESS things ive bought. it was a sabertooth mobo and was refurbed super fast.
 
For motherboard I will continue using ASUS. Haven't had any problems thus far.
 
Oddly enough, the ASUS rma horror stories are what kept me from buying any high end items from them. I purchased 2 $25 routers from them back in '08 that are still trucking along today, but other than that I stick to MSI, Corsair, XFX, and Gigabyte - Not that there is anything wrong with other brands, but I've had good luck with those 4 so far.
 
Love all the people posting that they'll stick with ASUS because "they haven't had an issue with them so far and their products have been rock solid" when the fact remains that they do make good products, but the problem is when those products fail and their lack of good customer service. This is a similar issue that OCZ was having a couple years before Toshiba bought them.

Also AsRock is no longer affiliated with ASUS and hasn't been for about half a decade now.
 
I've only had good experiences with ASUS so far. I've owned a lot of their motherboards over the years and the only failure I've had was in a machine running 24/7 for 10 years. Of course in Europe we don't deal with the companies directly for RMA, it's the reseller's job to replace faulty equipment.

I can't say the same about Gigabyte or MSI of course I don'T have the most recent experiences with them, I've sold my last gigabyte MB 2 years ago, and about 3 years since my last MSI board went away. But I've had stability issues with both of them. I would get random freezes and bluescreens that I couldn't get to the bottom of. So instead I just got rid of both. And both were very high end boards at the time of their purchase.

So if my budget allows I'll stick with ASUS, or if not then I choose Asrock as for my current system.
 
I rode the ASrock train for 1 build, wasn't a bad board, but suffered pretty bad Vdroop, my Gigabyte board has been the best I have owned, ASUS is the new DFI it feels like.
 
I've had a number of ASUS boards and a couple of them were defective (Rampage V and Sabertooth z97) both were RMA'd.

Well..... After the Rampage V went defetive (One of the usb ports wasn't working) I submitted a request for an RMA and I heard back from them within hours. After they approved my request, I shipped it off the next day. They received it and then sent me another one within 48 hours of them receiving it. I got it back and the total time was I think 2 weeks. Ground shipping both ways was the reason for the 2 weeks... Board worked after installing/


Sabertooth Z97 died and I submitted a request for an RMA. Read the above and thats what happened with this one as well.

I kept the original invoice for both and RMA process was smooth.

ASUS sells millions of products and the horror stories you read on the forums and whatnot probably only account for 1 % of the warranty claims that they process. On top of that people leave out important bits of information. You rarely hear of the entire story.
 
ASUS sells millions of products and the horror stories you read on the forums and whatnot probably only account for 1 % of the warranty claims that they process. On top of that people leave out important bits of information. You rarely hear of the entire story.

So does MSI, Gigabyte, EVGA, Intel, AMD, XFX, etc... and yet. You hardly ever hear of horror stories from them. ;)
 
I rode the ASrock train for 1 build, wasn't a bad board, but suffered pretty bad Vdroop, my Gigabyte board has been the best I have owned, ASUS is the new DFI it feels like.

What Asrock board was that? So far, my 990FX Extreme 4 and 990FX Extreme 9 are trucking along with the first one being 4 years old and the second one being 2 years old. I am able to set things up so that I get almost no VDroop which works well enough for me. Not saying you are wrong, just wondering what you had.
 
I've considered Gigabyte as an alternative. I used to be all Intel all the time but those jerks quit making boards :p. I went with an X99 Deluxe from Asus this time around and seem to have good luck in that it doesn't have problems. But man, when they do have problems support is non-existent.

Anyone have any experience with Gigabyte support?
 
I sent a Gigabyte GPU back for repair back in the GTX 400 series days. Card was artificating real bad about a week before the warranty ended. They fixed the issue no problem. Turn around from the time I shipped it off till I got it back was a little over a week.
 
For motherboard I will continue using ASUS. Haven't had any problems thus far.

Same here. Apart from side issues for buying second hand X58 Rampage boards back in the day that is not an issue with Asus boards in general.

Sounds like OP had bad luck with said board. That doesn't apply for everything Asus makes being a faulty piece of crap, far from it.

The only brand that I've had with more than a dozen (yes a dozen) RMA's and replacements is the old XFX and ASRock motherboards from socket 775 Core 2 Duo days. Never had any with Asus, had 2 with the UD3 and UD5P X58 boards from Gigabyte and over a dozen with XFX and ASRock.

Graphics cards on the other hand, a whole different story.
 
I have had very few problems with ASUS motherboards over the year and I feel confident in saying that overall it is the brand I've had the least trouble with despite having worked with more of their motherboards than any other.

I used ASUS motherboards for about a decade before reviewing motherboards. I've had tons of them in my own machines in the last 20 years and I've worked with nearly ASUS' complete motherboard line for the last several generations. Out of all of those I've seen three or four with hardware problems in the last 20 years. My one customer service experience with ASUS was actually quite positive. They sent out a new BIOS chip for a bricked motherboard. I didn't have to pull the board from the case or RMA it. ASUS and ASRock are the only two manufacturers who use removable BIOS ROMs to this day.

GIGABYTE and MSI have had more hit and miss models over the years than ASUS but they have both been pretty solid as well. GIGABYTE, prior to doing reviews was one of my last choices given how many I saw fail. Over the last 10 years they've done nothing but improve. They still make decisions which leave me scratching my head sometimes but they make some good stuff. MSI on the other hand has been generally solid with few motherboards that weren't all that great over the years.

EVGA, was one that never was all that great aside from select models. The X58 Classified was the last good motherboard I saw from them. Everything else had questionable build quality, buggy firmware and a seemingly high failure rate.

ASRock, as we know has been a manufacturer I've disliked severely over the years. It's motherboards have had atrocious build quality and firmware. On the high end ASRock has improved greatly with some excellent models but on the low end I still can't ID most of the manufacturers of the components and the PCB's still have that undercooked bacon straightness to them.
 
My onboard sound went out on my x79 sabertooth a couple years back. Sent it in, they fixed it, and received the board back. 3 week turn around if i remember correctly.
 
Yep, gave up on ASUS 3 years ago, been with Gigabyte ever since and so far so good..
 
I've been using Asus motherboards in personal machines for the past 20 years and haven't had one fail on me yet.

here's a pic from a number of years ago when I was cleaning out my closet and getting rid of old boxes,
boxes.jpg
 
Asrock for me. They are quirky, but I have built literally hundreds of machines with Asrock boards, and they have an awesome reliability/failure rate, and their RMA service isn't Asus-like, which means they are much better.
 
I love your framed thirdgen pic.

thanks. I was doing some work for a friend who owns a sign shop and has this giant inkjet printer, a Roland Soljet, and he printed this pic for me on it.
acu4-oct05.jpg
 
I will be looking at what MSI has to offer before all else on my next motherboard purchase. The mpower was easily the best motherboard experience I've had.

I had some of Asus boards (A7N8X-E deluxe, P7P55D-LE, Maximus II Formula) in the past and never really had a standout experience with them. I have had more Asus boards during the Socket A era, i just don't remember them.

My EVGA x58 SLI LE had some minor issues, but probably will not get an EVGA board again, it had some cold boot fail to start problem which was kind of annoying, other than that it was a decent board.

I've never had a Gigabyte board, but I will probably look at them along with MSI for my next build.
 
I had one mobo from ASUS go bad.. Was a bad Bios update flash. ASUS RMA'ed it very fast and fast shipping. Not sure the hate on the customer service. Will be sticking with them.
 
Back
Top