First 3D TVs Listed on Amazon

Status
Not open for further replies.
i believe lcd's are more durable then plasmas. throw that in with lower power consumption/less heat and the lighter weight, and i find it very hard to want a plasma for most situations. lcd tv's might not look as good, but its like comparing today's best onboard motherboard sound with an xfi card. most people just dont see enough difference to matter either way, which is when points like i mentioned become important.
 
i believe lcd's are more durable then plasmas. throw that in with lower power consumption/less heat and the lighter weight, and i find it very hard to want a plasma for most situations. lcd tv's might not look as good, but its like comparing today's best onboard motherboard sound with an xfi card. most people just dont see enough difference to matter either way, which is when points like i mentioned become important.

The difference is that people are spending more money on an X-Fi for presumably better quality. Here we are discussing LCDs that cost more but don't look as good as a mid-range or high end plasma. The only real benefit, aside from power consumption which I understand is a concern for some people, is to manufacturers and retailers that stand to make a hell of a lot more on such high margin items. If we're talking image quality, which to me is the whole point of a home theater display, NOT portability, there is no contest, especially given cases where prices that are approximately the same.

So given an LCD with the same price, or in some cases a higher price, some people will still go with an LCD even though it doesn't look as good as a plasma. Interesting...
 
It isn't "cheap faking", it actually makes lots of sense to refresh within the same frame in order to reduce apparent flicker.

They do this in all movie theaters. The shutter in the projector blocks each frame not once, but twice. This reduces the amount of apparent flicker that the audience sees. What would be 24 frames of flicker per second, which would be like looking at a giant strobe light, is now 48 times a second, much more bearable.

Yes, they do this in theaters. That's why I hate go to movies. Even my wife notices all this and she doesn't even care about this. It all goes down once the camera starts moving.
 
i believe lcd's are more durable then plasmas. throw that in with lower power consumption/less heat and the lighter weight, and i find it very hard to want a plasma for most situations. lcd tv's might not look as good, but its like comparing today's best onboard motherboard sound with an xfi card. most people just dont see enough difference to matter either way, which is when points like i mentioned become important.

LCD's indeed used to be more durable. That was several years ago, though, and the most unreliable maker of plasmas (Vizio) has long since quit making them. This is bad from a competitive pricing standpoint. Panasonic continues to make solid and reliable units. I would most definitely purchase one myself. When it comes time to replace our 32" LCD that is the TV I want in my living room.

Back on thread topic, though, seriously ... why can't we adopt 3D viewing for plasmas somehow since they have such fast refresh rates? Theoretically, if you can send the data to the plasma at a high enough rate, couldn't you just get a 3D capable bluray player and away you go? This makes much more sense than continuing to push much more costly LCD technology that is still far behind in refresh rate compared to plasma.
 
WTF are you talking about? Plasmas are still popular and are still in demand by people that demand the best image quality. Being second place means little if you're still selling well.

There is no denial in effect, just a fully functioning pair of eyeballs. People that get suckered into buying inferior LCD displays by something as stupid as marketing simply need education, but we've already gone over that. ;)

Except they aren't selling well and just about anyone who sells high end Electronics will tell you that. You can backhandedly insult my eyesight all you want, but when I made my purchase it was not driven on cost but quality I could see.

LOL, no.

This is more like a Blu Ray vs Standard Def DVD debate in a world where Blu Ray never caught on because DVD players were cheaper. Poors will still buy their crappy DVDs but the people who bought the better tech get the better experience. Go to any serious home theater technology site and you'll be laughed off the forums for putting for the notion that LCDs are even almost as good.

Not really, especially since Blu-ray has clearly caught on and is outselling DVD in the same time frame that DVD was released.

I have long quit bothering with serious home theater sites because they are usually filled with die hard fanboys who swear up and down they have superior vision to everyone on the planet and can hear the difference between a male and female cricket 2 miles away. Money was no object when I built my home theater. I had plenty of budget to afford the best 52" I could find and I went into it with no particular brand preference. The only exception I had was DLP was out of the question because I wanted a TV I could move myself. My choice Came down to a Samsung B630 and a Panasonic Viera P50-U1. The local HT shop I have was kind enough to hook both TVs up side by side playing the same blu-ray source in an appropriately dim room. Looking at the TVs side by side I couldn't tell the difference between them. So being slightly larger and a little less the LCD won. I am sorry, but if you can't tell the difference with them sitting side by side then it isn't superior. It might be overall better on some minor points, but the average user simply isn't going to care once they have it home.

To be honest I am getting more then a little tired of you referring to everyone who disagrees with you as Poors. Just because some of us don't spend our money stupidly, does not mean we don't have it.
 
Except they aren't selling well and just about anyone who sells high end Electronics will tell you that. You can backhandedly insult my eyesight all you want, but when I made my purchase it was not driven on cost but quality I could see.



Not really, especially since Blu-ray has clearly caught on and is outselling DVD in the same time frame that DVD was released.

I have long quit bothering with serious home theater sites because they are usually filled with die hard fanboys who swear up and down they have superior vision to everyone on the planet and can hear the difference between a male and female cricket 2 miles away. Money was no object when I built my home theater. I had plenty of budget to afford the best 52" I could find and I went into it with no particular brand preference. The only exception I had was DLP was out of the question because I wanted a TV I could move myself. My choice Came down to a Samsung B630 and a Panasonic Viera P50-U1. The local HT shop I have was kind enough to hook both TVs up side by side playing the same blu-ray source in an appropriately dim room. Looking at the TVs side by side I couldn't tell the difference between them. So being slightly larger and a little less the LCD won. I am sorry, but if you can't tell the difference with them sitting side by side then it isn't superior. It might be overall better on some minor points, but the average user simply isn't going to care once they have it home.

To be honest I am getting more then a little tired of you referring to everyone who disagrees with you as Poors. Just because some of us don't spend our money stupidly, does not mean we don't have it.

I'm not saying I agree with you 100%, but it is definitely interesting that he mentioned "poors" and LCDs in the same train of thought, because often plasmas offer superior image quality at a lesser price. That may not have been the case for the two models you compared (although I would still guess that black levels should've been at least slightly better on the plasma), but often the plasma would be a better buy, and yet people won't even consider it "just because." You are not in that category because you did consider it thoroughly and made your purchased based also on other factors that were important to you, such as extra screen size and weight. I don't fault your logic at all. I do fault the people that just walk into my store and blatantly declare "oh, I don't want a plasma" without even giving them a chance.
 
My 1080p 40" Sony LCD and my dad's 42" Panasonic plasma cost exactly the same price!! And in testing, after substantial color and picture adjustment, I NEVER found a situation (other than reading still text) where my Sony LCD (and it was not a low end model!) looked as good as my dad's Panny, and text looked just fine and bearable on the plasma. The difference was minor. In fact, there were several computer resolutions that the Sony just flat wouldn't display at all that the Panasonic would actually try to display. But the plasma was noticeably better in black levels, contrast, and fast motion in all of the following situations: gaming, picture viewing, and movie watching.

Oh, wait, those are the main things you buy a TV for. I am really impressed with the black levels on some of the newest LED LCD TV's. And those TV's from Samsung are impressively thin and very efficient. But look at what they cost right now. $600 to $700 more than a comparably sized plasma. If you don't have a specific need for a ultra thin and efficient TV, you'd be CRAZY not to buy the plasma instead and use the savings on an HTPC or a PS3, Xbox ... SOMETHING.

I still think LCD's look great, and do a lot of things well, but comparably priced plasmas look noticeably better in most situations that you'd normally use a TV for.

And margins are high on the expensive, cutting edge LCDs, but on the mainstream and budget models they are just as crappy, if not crappier, than margins on plasmas right now. Why in the heck do we see stores, manufacturers, and consumers following this huge paradigm shift away from plasmas? The ones that are being made now are quite excellent for the price.

I suppose it has to do with all the hits and negative hype plasmas have had over the years, and some horrible plasma makers such as philips or Vizio (who oddly enough both happen to make good LCDs).

Pioneer dropping out was a big blow, too.
Hopefully your father's Panasonic plasma TV won't experience this noticeably:
Panasonic does not plan fix for reported black level increases
 
Has anyone considered the fact that plasmas are cheaper because no one is buying them? :p

If, or when, sales go up for plasma monitors - so will the price. Then all the sudden LCD's will be cheaper! :eek:
 
FWIW, a friend who is still rocking an old CRT is starting to do some TV shopping. He said LCD looked better than plasma to him.
 
It sucks, still the best consumer displays on the market. I really hope that the high end plasmas coming out this Fall are going to at least match them in image quality.


I think it will be a lot longer than that given the size of the gap. TVs don't even always necessarily get better from year to year. Sometimes the next year's model will come out cheaper and lower quality, even though the general trend is improvement over time. I saw that with my first pioneer plasma, a 4360. The one that came out next year lost the media receiver and several other important features while having identical picture quality. I think the people who bought the 500m, 600m, or an Elite will probably have the best TV for two years, and it will probably be another two before something comes out to truly make them jealous. There's a reason that prices on those sets have gone up well over 50% since summer.
 
Hopefully your father's Panasonic plasma TV won't experience this noticeably:
Panasonic does not plan fix for reported black level increases

This keeps getting brought up.

Yes it's shitty. They're crippling one of the major benefits of plasma tech vs LCD, but the tests I've seen of the "goofed" plasma black levels and contrast are still slightly better than good LCDs.

Plasma is the better tech. Maybe it's at some rarefied unnoticeable level, (to some users) but for ultimate home theater picture quality, buy a good plasma.
 
I just got home from Wal Mart and Best Buy...

...yup, the plasmas that have been on display for quite a while look much worse than the LCD's that have been on display. At Wal Mart, where they are selling open-box display models for cheap, the plasmas, while having apparently good contrast, look terrible in the black level department. The LCD's that are just as old look way better.

I've owned a Samsung DLP, a JVC LCoS, a few LCD's and tons of CRT's. I've always itched for a plasma, but when I wanted one the most, they were so expensive. I still want to get one - but I will refuse to until this issue is sorted out. From what I've seen - and obviously have read, plasmas degrade in quality quicker than any display type I've used. Maybe top-of-the-line Pioneer-quality displays don't get so crappy so fast, but I'm in the market for one of those mid-range, better-than-any-high-range-LCD plasma displays...but I don't want a display that's going to drop, black level wise, to much shittier levels possibly only a couple years down the line. Meaning I'm stuck. :p
 
One thing plasma finally has going for them (or at least not against them) is that they're not as susceptible to image burn-in as they once were.
 
I'm not saying I agree with you 100%, but it is definitely interesting that he mentioned "poors" and LCDs in the same train of thought, because often plasmas offer superior image quality at a lesser price. That may not have been the case for the two models you compared (although I would still guess that black levels should've been at least slightly better on the plasma), but often the plasma would be a better buy, and yet people won't even consider it "just because." You are not in that category because you did consider it thoroughly and made your purchased based also on other factors that were important to you, such as extra screen size and weight. I don't fault your logic at all. I do fault the people that just walk into my store and blatantly declare "oh, I don't want a plasma" without even giving them a chance.

I think you're confused about what makes a poor a poor. Oftentimes poors have money but waste it because of their poorish taste. Maybe "poors" is the wrong word for them and I should have said classless proles. The kind of people who show up with TAG watches and Hugo Boss suits in an attempt to show off even though anyone with taste will laugh at them. That perfectly sums up your typical LCD buyer. They get a bit of money and blow it on a trashy TV because they either have bad taste or are too lazy to educate themselves. They revel in their ignorance:

I have long quit bothering with serious home theater sites because they are usually filled with die hard fanboys who swear up and down they have superior vision to everyone on the planet and can hear the difference between a male and female cricket 2 miles away.
 
I think you're confused about what makes a poor a poor. Oftentimes poors have money but waste it because of their poorish taste. Maybe "poors" is the wrong word for them and I should have said classless proles. The kind of people who show up with TAG watches and Hugo Boss suits in an attempt to show off even though anyone with taste will laugh at them. That perfectly sums up your typical LCD buyer. They get a bit of money and blow it on a trashy TV because they either have bad taste or are too lazy to educate themselves. They revel in their ignorance:

...and this is the problem with people who you don't consider to be "poors", and thus the problem with you; we're all a bunch'a "poors" and you think you are all high and mighty with your playboy plasma style taste.

Right...LMAO! Plasma vs. LCD isn't about who has better taste - it's about priorities. Yes, I want a plasma - but not until they don't go from excellent to shit quality in 3 years, and not until they use less energy, are less fragile, and not until they weigh less. So I guess that means I have bad taste. So be it. :rolleyes:
 
...and this is the problem with people who you don't consider to be "poors", and thus the problem with you; we're all a bunch'a "poors" and you think you are all high and mighty with your playboy plasma style taste.

Right...LMAO! Plasma vs. LCD isn't about who has better taste - it's about priorities. Yes, I want a plasma - but not until they don't go from excellent to shit quality in 3 years, and not until they use less energy, are less fragile, and not until they weigh less. So I guess that means I have bad taste. So be it. :rolleyes:

Brilliant logic. Buy a TV that is already shit quality instead of one that will have a dropoff after about five years. That's why ur a poor worryin bout payin dat lectric bill while I'm chillizin here wit my dual Pioneer Plazmaz and Brioni suits. Iz all good though. If I waz rollin wit a 9800GT I'd be switchin prioritiez too.
 
Hopefully your father's Panasonic plasma TV won't experience this noticeably:
Panasonic does not plan fix for reported black level increases

I'm pretty sure it'll still look great:

"He likened it to rotating the tires on a car--an example of standard maintenance--and said that some users noticed the change "because they have trained eyes," although he also said that the change is subtle "even among trained experts...

... He reiterated that owner satisfaction was very high and that the vast majority of owners don't notice any change at all."

If I get 8 years out of it, I'll be happy. I'm not saying I have disposable income to spare, but you sure get a lot of screen for your dollar these days. We'll see how my dad's looks in five years, but all my friends with 3 yr. old Panasonic plasmas are still enjoying them, and to my knowledge not a single one of them has had to do one repair yet. (wish I could say the same for my friends with Samsung plasmas ...)
 
^ That's good.

So you mentioned you (your father) want to get 8 years out of that TV. I think that's a fair expectation. Most people w/ HDTVs probably only get 5 years out of it before they upgrade to something else and relocate that TV to another room.

My DLP is about 2.5 years old and if I get another 3.5 years out of it (bulb changes notwithstanding), then I'll be happy and then I'll probably get a 240 Hz LCD or maybe OLED if that becomes affordable by then. :cool:
 
Brilliant logic. Buy a TV that is already shit quality instead of one that will have a dropoff after about five years. That's why ur a poor worryin bout payin dat lectric bill while I'm chillizin here wit my dual Pioneer Plazmaz and Brioni suits. Iz all good though. If I waz rollin wit a 9800GT I'd be switchin prioritiez too.

You have the nerve to call LCD buyers trash, then start spouting ghetto rat drivel. Believe whatever fantasy you want, I no longer register your opinion even worth considering. Sounds to me like you are the one who got a little money for the first time, blew it on the most expensive thing you could buy without actually doing any research.

Enjoy your plasma, and I will enjoy my LCD. Because at the end of the day neither is overwhelmingly superior to the other. Each might have a few things that make it better for a given person, but to say one or the other is superior at this point is hyperbole.
 
You have the nerve to call LCD buyers trash, then start spouting ghetto rat drivel. Believe whatever fantasy you want, I no longer register your opinion even worth considering. Sounds to me like you are the one who got a little money for the first time, blew it on the most expensive thing you could buy without actually doing any research.

Enjoy your plasma, and I will enjoy my LCD. Because at the end of the day neither is overwhelmingly superior to the other. Each might have a few things that make it better for a given person, but to say one or the other is superior at this point is hyperbole.

Totally agreed.

...and for him to say the type of person who buys a plasma is superior to the type of person who buys an LCD is just moronic!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top