First 3D TVs Listed on Amazon

Status
Not open for further replies.

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
If you’re interested in being part of the bleeding edge of TV technology, ZDNet reports that Amazon just listed Samsung’s first 3D TVs. As you’d expect, you’re paying a premium to be part of the first-adopters but it may not be as bad as you feared. Now you have something to spend your tax return on. ;)

Of course, you’ll need the right material to make use of these TV’s 3D capabilities. While Amazon had posted the new Samsung BD-C6900 3D Blu-ray player a couple of weeks ago, it’s now off the site and it’s not available anywhere online for pre-order. I posted earlier this week that Sony’s 3D-capable Blu-ray players will be available soon, but they’ll require a firmware upgrade this summer to show 3D movies in 3D.
 
If the normal picture on these is comparable to their standard LED line, then these are coming out amazingly cheap. The price difference between this and their standard LED of the same size is pretty minimal.

That said, I still hate 3d and will be glad when the fad ends again. :rolleyes:
 
well at least it didn't start at a ridiculous $10,000 LCD and plasma televisions cost when it first came out a decade ago. With the increase in 3D movies going on, I can imagine the price will come down pretty quick.
 
I don't even own an HDTV, my current TV is 8 years old. I'm still waiting for the 500 dollar 40 + inch LED TV's I was promised 2 years ago.
 
If the normal picture on these is comparable to their standard LED line, then these are coming out amazingly cheap. The price difference between this and their standard LED of the same size is pretty minimal.

That said, I still hate 3d and will be glad when the fad ends again. :rolleyes:

Agree. Every few years, Hollywood tries a new & improved 3D that becomes a footnote in their anals. Maybe this will force the price down on the Samsung 8500 series LCDs with local-dimming LEDs. That would be the one good thing to come of this 3D venture.
 
the only way 3d would ever work is if it doesnt require you to wear anything and it doesnt distort the picture.
 
Yeah I want a 3d tv so I can watch sports center and the discovery channel in 3d... What a waste of money.
 
The only thing I'd consider 3D for is games, namely the GoW3 patch rumor. But even that isn't worth almost 3 grands when I have a perfectly functional full HD LCD.
 
Meh, I'll wait until the 3D plasmas from Panasonic start coming out.

Such a shame that Pioneer is out of the display business. A 3D Kuro would be the best thing ever, but a high end Panny is the next best thing.
 
Agree. Every few years, Hollywood tries a new & improved 3D that becomes a footnote in their anals. Maybe this will force the price down on the Samsung 8500 series LCDs with local-dimming LEDs. That would be the one good thing to come of this 3D venture.

Colossal waste of money, get a Panasonic G or V series instead. Significantly better image quality on every level, no side-effects from local dimming or refresh rate, less input lag for gaming, all for significantly less money.

Why people insist on spending more for inferior display technology is beyond me.
 
Damn the lack of an edit button, it should say "Panasonic G or V series PLASMA"

Just to be clear :)
 
Colossal waste of money, get a Panasonic G or V series instead. Significantly better image quality on every level, no side-effects from local dimming or refresh rate, less input lag for gaming, all for significantly less money.

Why people insist on spending more for inferior display technology is beyond me.

Not necessarily true. Panasonics have issues aswell.

http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-10449939-1.html

http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?t=1167339
 
I don't even own an HDTV, my current TV is 8 years old. I'm still waiting for the 500 dollar 40 + inch LED TV's I was promised 2 years ago.

I think I'll just say it straight out. Either:

a.) You are pulling that out of your ass or

b.) Someone else pulled it out of their ass and you didn't care to do any research and just ran with the bullshit that had been placed in your hand.

...either way, you've just tripped and now it's all over your face.

Just fyi. :p
 
I'm sure I'm not the only one here.....

Does 3D TV/movies give anyone else headaches and nausea? Last time I saw a 3D movie(The Final Destination) I ended up getting a throbbing headache after about 30 minutes of the movie.... I think partly from the glasses... Then when I took them off and tried to watch the movie, it made me nauseous and I had to leave the movie. I'm going to give this technology a pass.
 
I'm sure I'm not the only one here.....

Does 3D TV/movies give anyone else headaches and nausea? Last time I saw a 3D movie(The Final Destination) I ended up getting a throbbing headache after about 30 minutes of the movie.... I think partly from the glasses... Then when I took them off and tried to watch the movie, it made me nauseous and I had to leave the movie. I'm going to give this technology a pass.

It depends on the movie. Final Destination's 3D "throws" things at you, creating nauseousness while other 3D movies create "depth".

Avatar and Up are wonderful examples of perfectly made 3D movies where it moves inward into the screen rather than outward "in your face".
 
Well I passed on seeing Avatar in 3D/Imax since the Imax in my movie theater is terrible and my previous bad experiences with 3D movies made me pass....

The only real problem I have with this technology is the quality of the games vs the visuals. Both computers and systems alike can produce very stunning image quality, but how many of those titles that you marveled at the 'graphics' did you throw away because they sucked? I can honestly see the quality of movies/games/tv dropping on an average. News reporters are going to try to get angles that produce a more involving 3D experience. Movies are going to focus more on the wow factor rather than plot. The only thing I can see being better in 3D than normal tv is Planet Earth.

I believe 3D TV will be big once that 'wow' factor has worn off. When directors and developers choose to get back to the core of entertainment, the plot.
 
I believe 3D TV will be big once that 'wow' factor has worn off. When directors and developers choose to get back to the core of entertainment, the plot.

As long as it puts us closer to full immersion within my life time I'm cool with anything.
 
Paying to see a 3D image...interesting. I thought we already experience 3D every day. We can perceive depth, we'll flinch if something flies close to our face. Our lives ARE 3D...and to pay for it while wearing homo goggles? Pass.
 
fad ends again. :rolleyes:

Yeah, until they can get this working without glasses it will never fly. They are just trying to keep the sales up for HDTVs that have been so good for the past few years. Most people have them at this point and TVs will go back to being appliances, which means sales will go way down.
 
Colossal waste of money, get a Panasonic G or V series instead. Significantly better image quality on every level, no side-effects from local dimming or refresh rate, less input lag for gaming, all for significantly less money.

Why people insist on spending more for inferior display technology is beyond me.

Damn the lack of an edit button, it should say "Panasonic G or V series PLASMA"

Just to be clear :)

I will pit my Samsung b630 52" LCD against any plasma any day of the week and come out with better picture quality, no local dimming, no refresh rate issues and no lag for gaming and no expensive plasma bulbs to replace.:rolleyes:

Plasma is Fail.
 
"Plasma bulbs"

BAHAHAHAHAHAH

Congrats on demonstrating that you know absolutely nothing.
 
Lol @ plasma bulbs!!

I like plasma displays, but from what I've seen these days, personally, nice LCD's beat nice plasmas with regards to deep black levels - and deep black levels are extremely important to me. I could argue that the color reproduction abilities of plasmas surpass the ability of LCD's to display true colors, but the difference is so minor that the black level thing is the deciding factor. Blacks on most plasmas I've seen are more close to grey.
 

In that case I would recommend Samsung's plasmas, or just wait for the 2010 Panasonics to come out. The other thing to note is that even with a black level increase over time, that wouldn't change the fact that color accuracy, image uniformity, and overall black level are still better than you would get with an LCD that costs several times as much.

It is like people comparing SSDs and their performance degradation over time without TRIM. Yeah, comparatively it is slower than a fresh SSD, but it is still a hell of a lot faster than even fast mechanical hard drives like the Velociraptor.

You'd also be skipping LCD's poorer input lag, local dimming "deciding" how to display images and fucking up things like starfields, credits over black, as well as high refresh rate panels introducing their own weird motion artifacts, etc etc. Large LCDs just look bad in general and no amount of band-aids or lipstick will change the fact that the flaws are inherent to the technology: a big light source projected through filters. It results in lighter, low power consuming displays, but it will fall short of what CRTs and plasmas (both based on glowing phosphors) will get you.
 
Lol @ plasma bulbs!!

I like plasma displays, but from what I've seen these days, personally, nice LCD's beat nice plasmas with regards to deep black levels - and deep black levels are extremely important to me. I could argue that the color reproduction abilities of plasmas surpass the ability of LCD's to display true colors, but the difference is so minor that the black level thing is the deciding factor. Blacks on most plasmas I've seen are more close to grey.

My Kuro is as black as black gets. My mom just got a G10 plasma and I'm super impressed with its image quality. Color on LCD always looks poor to me, ditto the screen door effect from viewing at off angles, the motion, input lag, everything is just bad.

That LCDs finally managed better blacks (instead of deep dark blues) from local dimming is such a hacky solution to me. The starfields in 2001 are completely fucked up and not how they are supposed to look because the LCD itself is trying to interpret how to reproduce that scene with the local dimming. Its really boneheaded and it happens with any scene that is predominantly dark with some tony light details. The image doesn't display how it was intended to be. I don't get how people keep buying into technology that can't even reproduce its source material correctly.

Well, I know, its marketing; every Best Buy ad is pushing LCDs with LED backlighting and local dimming, but it makes sense because they have nice fat profit margins compared to plasmas. I have no problem paying more for better quality, just look at my Elite Kuro, but when you're paying more for worse quality in every way )color, lag, blacks, viewing angles, etc), I have serious issues with that.
 
In that case I would recommend Samsung's plasmas, or just wait for the 2010 Panasonics to come out. The other thing to note is that even with a black level increase over time, that wouldn't change the fact that color accuracy, image uniformity, and overall black level are still better than you would get with an LCD that costs several times as much.

Like I said - I could argue that plasmas display better colors - but that's only because I enjoy warmer colors. If I appreciated cool colors more, then the opposite could be said. Either way, I can set the color temps to whatever I want on an LCD due to their more neutral levels, as to where a user would be limited to warmer temperatures on a plasma. Also - image uniformity? I totally disagree. Plasmas and LCD are both pixel-based, so image uniformity would be the same. If you want to get technical - many plasmas use resolutions like 1024x768 or 1024x1024 just with rectangular pixels, and downconvert 1280x720 or 1920x1080 signals. Either way, though - they both use fixed pixels, so image uniformity is a non-issue with them. The only display types that have uniformity issues are CRT's and older projection sets.
 
My Kuro is as black as black gets. My mom just got a G10 plasma and I'm super impressed with its image quality. Color on LCD always looks poor to me, ditto the screen door effect from viewing at off angles, the motion, input lag, everything is just bad.

That LCDs finally managed better blacks (instead of deep dark blues) from local dimming is such a hacky solution to me. The starfields in 2001 are completely fucked up and not how they are supposed to look because the LCD itself is trying to interpret how to reproduce that scene with the local dimming. Its really boneheaded and it happens with any scene that is predominantly dark with some tony light details. The image doesn't display how it was intended to be. I don't get how people keep buying into technology that can't even reproduce its source material correctly.

Well, I know, its marketing; every Best Buy ad is pushing LCDs with LED backlighting and local dimming, but it makes sense because they have nice fat profit margins compared to plasmas. I have no problem paying more for better quality, just look at my Elite Kuro, but when you're paying more for worse quality in every way )color, lag, blacks, viewing angles, etc), I have serious issues with that.

I have no doubt in my mind that plasmas are great, but the differences in image quality are absolutely nowhere near as great as you're making them out to be. I think the benefits of an LCD outweigh those of a plasma. If you pit a really nice LCD against a really nice plasma, the differences will be insanely negligible, especially with regards to image uniformity, colors and viewing angles. Viewing angles may suck on smaller, personal-sized LCD's, but on nice, home-theater grade LCD's, viewing angles are every bit as good as plasmas in the same category.

I'm really not here to argue about which is actually "better", because that's truly up to opinion - but it should be known that the performance/quality differences of these two display types are nowhere near as dramatic as they're made out to be sometimes.
 
Like I said - I could argue that plasmas display better colors - but that's only because I enjoy warmer colors. If I appreciated cool colors more, then the opposite could be said. Either way, I can set the color temps to whatever I want on an LCD due to their more neutral levels, as to where a user would be limited to warmer temperatures on a plasma.

Where did this come from? I've never heard of plasmas having a warmer color bias than LCDs. The difference is saturation, and the problem with LCDs is that they tend to be oversaturated in their colors while plasmas are more natural and tend to be more muted. This is why they are better for viewing movies as they give a more "film" like look, while at the same time they can also be oversaturated in "game" mode if you really want to boost the color, although you'll never get the cartoony colors that you would with an LCD.

Of course, I'd never want it, its a horrible look. :)

Also - image uniformity? I totally disagree. Plasmas and LCD are both pixel-based, so image uniformity would be the same. If you want to get technical - many plasmas use resolutions like 1024x768 or 1024x1024 just with rectangular pixels, and downconvert 1280x720 or 1920x1080 signals. Either way, though - they both use fixed pixels, so image uniformity is a non-issue with them. The only display types that have uniformity issues are CRT's and older projection sets.

Incorrect, image uniformity with LCDs is a product of how well implemented the backlight is. I've seen consumer sets with visible halos at the edges, which is the result of how the backlights are placed or blended with each other. More often than not I've seen inconsistent values from corner to corner and edge to edge, and that's before we get into its viewing angle issues.

This is not a problem with plasmas because as with CRTs, the pixels are glowing phosphors and are discreet from one another. You don't have a giant backlight or an array of backlights with a plasma/CRT as you do with an LCD, and the result is better blacks, no edgelight bleeding, consistent chrominance and luminance values from corner to corner and edge to edge, etc etc.
 
I have no doubt in my mind that plasmas are great, but the differences in image quality are absolutely nowhere near as great as you're making them out to be. I think the benefits of an LCD outweigh those of a plasma. If you pit a really nice LCD against a really nice plasma, the differences will be insanely negligible, especially with regards to image uniformity, colors and viewing angles. Viewing angles may suck on smaller, personal-sized LCD's, but on nice, home-theater grade LCD's, viewing angles are every bit as good as plasmas in the same category.

I'm really not here to argue about which is actually "better", because that's truly up to opinion - but it should be known that the performance/quality differences of these two display types are nowhere near as dramatic as they're made out to be sometimes.

LCDs are better than plasma in terms of heat generated, power consumption, and weight. In terms of image quality, everything inherent with large LCD displays drives me up the wall. Color accuracy, blacks, movement artifacts, input lag, everything. Put a top end LCD against a mid-range plasma and the plasma will look better, and it will be cheaper. Take a top of the line plasma like the Pioneer Elite Kuros and nothing on the consumer market will touch it.

I work in film as a cinematographer, have been an AV nerd since high school and my Laserdiscs, and I've seen more than my share of consumer and professional displays, so maybe my eye is more discerning and critical than most but there is it. I can spot the differences between both technologies from a mile away and there's just no way I can recommend someone go with a big LCD unless they want to "go green". It certainly wouldn't be for better picture quality or saving money. :)
 
Where did this come from? I've never heard of plasmas having a warmer color bias than LCDs. The difference is saturation, and the problem with LCDs is that they tend to be oversaturated in their colors while plasmas are more natural and tend to be more muted. This is why they are better for viewing movies as they give a more "film" like look, while at the same time they can also be oversaturated in "game" mode if you really want to boost the color, although you'll never get the cartoony colors that you would with an LCD.

Of course, I'd never want it, its a horrible look. :)



Incorrect, image uniformity with LCDs is a product of how well implemented the backlight is. I've seen consumer sets with visible halos at the edges, which is the result of how the backlights are placed or blended with each other. More often than not I've seen inconsistent values from corner to corner and edge to edge, and that's before we get into its viewing angle issues.

This is not a problem with plasmas because as with CRTs, the pixels are glowing phosphors and are discreet from one another. You don't have a giant backlight or an array of backlights with a plasma/CRT as you do with an LCD, and the result is better blacks, no edgelight bleeding, consistent chrominance and luminance values from corner to corner and edge to edge, etc etc.

It's a well-known fact that plasmas offer warmer colors with less ability to be tweaked. I don't know what else to say about that lol. The backlight issues you're describing, while a pain in the past, are a non-issue for most LCD's now. Sure, you'll find backlight bleeding and banding on cheap, small models, but that's a case of getting what you pay for. It's sort of as if I were to say that plasmas still suffer badly from burn-in. Is it still a factor? Yes, most definitely. But has that been improved upon greatly in the last few years? Yes, it has been, just like those backlight issues. I suppose some more cons of a plasma are the fact that they are a.) much less cost-efficient at smaller-sizes, b.) less durable than LCD's, c.) heavier than LCD's, d.) glare due to their shiny surface and e.) they use, on average, almost twice the power that LCD's do.
 
I've never thought of plasmas as having warmer colors, and any excessive warmness that degrades the image can be dialed out. My own display is color calibrated and it lines up perfectly. Plasmas certainly aren't as saturated as LCD, which IMHO is a positive as I again hate the oversaturated look LCDs have even in "movie" mode. Take them to "torch" mode like you see in big stores and forget it, horrible.

The cons you bring up are all one that I agree with. Its why you don't have plasmas in laptops, desktop displays, etc. Issues like power consumption and weight are ones that I brought up earlier. LCDs are clearly better than plasmas in those areas. Again, its all about using technology for their strengths based on their intended use. If I'm going to watch movies or play video games on a large display, plasma, easy, any day of the week. For desktop or portable use, LCD, easy. On the flip side of that, putting plasma type displays in a portable or desktop display would be impractical and stupid, and using a large LCD for watching movies simply wouldn't look as good as a plasma due to relative color reproduction, input lag, and viewing angles. I use both display types every day and have even owned large LCDs in the past. My own desktop LCDs are among the best out there, I wouldn't have dropped all that money if I didn't feel that they were worth it.

One technology isn't great for everything, it never works out like that.
 
I would love to see 3D tech gain mainstream support, but until the television industry fully supports it with more than two channels of programming, this is dead in the water.

It's a well-known fact that plasmas offer warmer colors with less ability to be tweaked. I don't know what else to say about that lol. The backlight issues you're describing, while a pain in the past, are a non-issue for most LCD's now. Sure, you'll find backlight bleeding and banding on cheap, small models, but that's a case of getting what you pay for. It's sort of as if I were to say that plasmas still suffer badly from burn-in. Is it still a factor? Yes, most definitely. But has that been improved upon greatly in the last few years? Yes, it has been, just like those backlight issues. I suppose some more cons of a plasma are the fact that they are a.) much less cost-efficient at smaller-sizes, b.) less durable than LCD's, c.) heavier than LCD's, d.) glare due to their shiny surface and e.) they use, on average, almost twice the power that LCD's do.
Sorry, but you will find backlight issues on any LCD, simply due to the nature of the design. A single light source is incapable of providing 100% equal coverage. The other problem, is that overbright/oversaturated LCD you see in the store? The bulb brightness dims far faster than plasma and will fade after just a few short years of use.

Burn-in on plasmas is a thing of the past. Pixel orbiters refresh the screen when the pixels remain static for a certain amount of time.

Black levels have always been a bigger problem with LCDs, because of the limited number of colors only allowing a limited amount of grey scale. Even on a "good" LCD, it will be difficult to make out the contrast on dark images. Look at someone with black hair in a night scene on an LCD compared to a plasma and the difference is obvious.

Bottom line, you are comparing a screen that can reproduce 1 billion+ colors at virtually infinite contrast without ghosting, to a screen that can only do a maximum of 16.7 million colors and a very finite true contrast ratio! Weight and energy concerns aside, Plasma is a superior technology in every way that LCD is incapable of ever equaling. People may try to justify to themselves that the shiny new LCD they bought at Best Buy is better, because they wanted to save a buck, but that is simply not the case.
 
"Plasma bulbs"

BAHAHAHAHAHAH

Congrats on demonstrating that you know absolutely nothing.

Lol @ plasma bulbs!!

I like plasma displays, but from what I've seen these days, personally, nice LCD's beat nice plasmas with regards to deep black levels - and deep black levels are extremely important to me. I could argue that the color reproduction abilities of plasmas surpass the ability of LCD's to display true colors, but the difference is so minor that the black level thing is the deciding factor. Blacks on most plasmas I've seen are more close to grey.

My apologies, I was thinking DLP when I wrote the post, but nice jumping to conclusions instead of assuming I might of been thinking something else when I posted. Either way, I will still pit my LCD against any plasma. I did a ton of comparisons before I finally made a purchase and the only screen I found better was the LED version. I watched a ton of plasma's side by side with LCD through a blu-ray source and if the LCD is properly tweaked it is flatly better across the board. The problem most people have with LCD is they either A) are looking at a crap one, or B) are looking at one that has not been adjusted properly.
 
I would love to see 3D tech gain mainstream support, but until the television industry fully supports it with more than two channels of programming, this is dead in the water.


Sorry, but you will find backlight issues on any LCD, simply due to the nature of the design. A single light source is incapable of providing 100% equal coverage. The other problem, is that overbright/oversaturated LCD you see in the store? The bulb brightness dims far faster than plasma and will fade after just a few short years of use.

Burn-in on plasmas is a thing of the past. Pixel orbiters refresh the screen when the pixels remain static for a certain amount of time.

Black levels have always been a bigger problem with LCDs, because of the limited number of colors only allowing a limited amount of grey scale. Even on a "good" LCD, it will be difficult to make out the contrast on dark images. Look at someone with black hair in a night scene on an LCD compared to a plasma and the difference is obvious.

Bottom line, you are comparing a screen that can reproduce 1 billion+ colors at virtually infinite contrast without ghosting, to a screen that can only do a maximum of 16.7 million colors and a very finite true contrast ratio! Weight and energy concerns aside, Plasma is a superior technology in every way that LCD is incapable of ever equaling. People may try to justify to themselves that the shiny new LCD they bought at Best Buy is better, because they wanted to save a buck, but that is simply not the case.

Except none of that is even faintly true. Someone clearly has never seen a top end LCD. There is a reason there are fewer and fewer plasma available, and it certainly is not because they are superior.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top