First 3D TVs Listed on Amazon

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would love to see 3D tech gain mainstream support, but until the television industry fully supports it with more than two channels of programming, this is dead in the water.


Sorry, but you will find backlight issues on any LCD, simply due to the nature of the design. A single light source is incapable of providing 100% equal coverage. The other problem, is that overbright/oversaturated LCD you see in the store? The bulb brightness dims far faster than plasma and will fade after just a few short years of use.

Burn-in on plasmas is a thing of the past. Pixel orbiters refresh the screen when the pixels remain static for a certain amount of time.

Black levels have always been a bigger problem with LCDs, because of the limited number of colors only allowing a limited amount of grey scale. Even on a "good" LCD, it will be difficult to make out the contrast on dark images. Look at someone with black hair in a night scene on an LCD compared to a plasma and the difference is obvious.

Bottom line, you are comparing a screen that can reproduce 1 billion+ colors at virtually infinite contrast without ghosting, to a screen that can only do a maximum of 16.7 million colors and a very finite true contrast ratio! Weight and energy concerns aside, Plasma is a superior technology in every way that LCD is incapable of ever equaling. People may try to justify to themselves that the shiny new LCD they bought at Best Buy is better, because they wanted to save a buck, but that is simply not the case.

No, you will not find backlight issues on any and every LCD. Perhaps the monitors YOU have had the displeasure of owning have given you that impression? Also, where did you get that LCD's burn out faster than plasmas? Both LCD's and plasmas have nearly the EXACT brightness half-life. In fact, it's only been recently that manufacturers have been able to rate their plasma life expectancy as high as LCD's. One nice thing about LCD's, as well, is the fact that the bulbs are replaceable, so once your image is half as bright as it used to be, you can make it like new again. Plasma? Nope. It's officially a piece of trash once the picture starts to dim. The colors get dull, the contrast goes to shit, and your blacks become grey. Also - burn-in is barely an issue, as you've said, and as I've said in my other post - but it's still a factor.

You're talking about "superior" technology. Since when has "superior" technology meant ANYTHING at all? That 1 billion colors that a plasma may theoretically be able to reproduce means jack shit when your video source is only 16 million colors. Other issues - color saturation. Way-too-bright Etc. The wonderful thing is that those can all be turned down. Those are non-issues. Now if the manufacturer set them all at ultra-high-eyes-bleeding mode settings, and made it to where the TV would kill my whole family if I tried to change settings - then we'd have a problem. Thank the heavens that's NOT the case.

If we based which display type was "best" on color reproduction alone, then we wouldn't have plasmas or LCD's, we'd still be using CRT's. But that's not all there is to it. A modern LCD is fully capable of displaying exactly what it's fed. It can reproduce every bit of the content it's given, faithfully. Sure, a plasma can theoretically reproduce even more...but by the time we have content that matches the abilities of a plasma, your plasma will be on it's last breath, ready to be thrown away, and LCD's will have far surpassed plasmas in every way. ;)
 
My apologies, I was thinking DLP when I wrote the post, but nice jumping to conclusions instead of assuming I might of been thinking something else when I posted. Either way, I will still pit my LCD against any plasma. I did a ton of comparisons before I finally made a purchase and the only screen I found better was the LED version. I watched a ton of plasma's side by side with LCD through a blu-ray source and if the LCD is properly tweaked it is flatly better across the board. The problem most people have with LCD is they either A) are looking at a crap one, or B) are looking at one that has not been adjusted properly.

Yeah, I've demo'd your TV. We agree to disagree, LCDs, even top of the line, fall behind plasma and CRT in terms of image quality. There is simply no comparison, viewing angles, motion, color reproduction, its all off to me. Glad you enjoy your set though.

You're talking about "superior" technology. Since when has "superior" technology meant ANYTHING at all? That 1 billion colors that a plasma may theoretically be able to reproduce means jack shit when your video source is only 16 million colors. Other issues - color saturation. Way-too-bright Etc. The wonderful thing is that those can all be turned down. Those are non-issues. Now if the manufacturer set them all at ultra-high-eyes-bleeding mode settings, and made it to where the TV would kill my whole family if I tried to change settings - then we'd have a problem. Thank the heavens that's NOT the case.

If we based which display type was "best" on color reproduction alone, then we wouldn't have plasmas or LCD's, we'd still be using CRT's. But that's not all there is to it. A modern LCD is fully capable of displaying exactly what it's fed. It can reproduce every bit of the content it's given, faithfully. Sure, a plasma can theoretically reproduce even more...but by the time we have content that matches the abilities of a plasma, your plasma will be on it's last breath, ready to be thrown away, and LCD's will have far surpassed plasmas in every way. ;)

Absolutely ridiculous. :rolleyes:

I mean that in the nicest way possible. :)

I went from a 40" HD CRT to my 60" Kuro. It took years before I was confident enough to make the jump, but I can safely say that color reproduction is finally at a point where I feel like I'm looking at a film print when I'm watching something like No Country For Old Men. Motion artifacts, color, and viewing angles are something that still fall short even in the best LCDs. As with Dekoth, we agree to disagree. I'm not taking any commission on what I recommend as a professional. If you want to go with something else, be my guest. :)
 
Don't get me wrong - I really appreciate the quality that plasmas can give, but the things I said in my last post are true. Everything from half-life to bulb replacement. That's not speculation in any way. Of course, I was just being a smart ass when I talked about LCD's surpassing plasma technology - but it very well may be the case due to the worldwide adoption rate of and acceptance of LCD's being the dominant display type on the market. As long as LCD's sell, they will get better and better.

...but agree to disagree.
 
Don't get me wrong - I really appreciate the quality that plasmas can give, but the things I said in my last post are true. Everything from half-life to bulb replacement. That's not speculation in any way. Of course, I was just being a smart ass when I talked about LCD's surpassing plasma technology - but it very well may be the case due to the worldwide adoption rate of and acceptance of LCD's being the dominant display type on the market. As long as LCD's sell, they will get better and better.

...but agree to disagree.

Outside of lower power consumption, LCDs sell well for two big reasons: cheaper prices in the low end, and marketing.

Look at any Best Buy store display or TV ad, the main thing they are pushing in the mid and high end are LED backlit LCDs, etc. The reason is that they have better profit margins than plasmas. Slim margins and lower sales in the premium high end are why Pioneer decided to exit the display market (RIP).

As for LCDs getting better, we'll see how much better they get before both LCD and plasma are supplanted by an even better display technology. All of the new features in LCDs, 120hz/240hz refresh, local dimming, LCD backlighting, are band-aids to fix inherent issues with the display technology ("lipstick on a pig" if we want to throw one more analogy in the mix :)). Again, I don't see the point of paying more for added features that are attempts to bring the image quality closer to what you get with with plasmas and CRTs when those other displays (well, plasmas) exist now and deliver superior quality at a lower price. And if you want to splurge on a plasma, I'd argue that nothing else in the consumer arena comes close, not until you get into the mid-five figure DLP projectors, and those have their own set of restrictions (requires a room with complete lighting control, etc).

Anyway, we'll see if LCDs get better. I'll fully support them the moment I see one, but they just aren't there yet and therefore I can't recommend them. I have no allegiance to any technology, nor do I make commissions or anything, nor does my bank account restrict me (ie - if I see a superior display of any sort I will buy it). I just care which one looks better right now, that's all. Cheers.
 
do you need to wear glasses for the effect?

Yes sir. There are two types, passive polarized like you'd wear in almost all 3D movie theaters and active LCD which "open" each eye in sync with the TV (ie - left eye is open when the left image is on screen, right eye is open when the right image is one screen). The refresh rate is very fast so the flicker doesn't register.

I've seen similar systems with Nvidia's active 3D system on WoW. The objects didn't pop out of the screen at you, it was more like the display was a diorama box that you could reach into. I thought it was pretty cool.
 
My 61" Samsung DLP, 2008 model for well under $2000, with LED light engine (rated to ~7-8 years of actual on time) is 3D capable. LED light engine not only lasts forever, has no spinning color wheel, switching colors at a higher rate than the old color wheel types, and no bulb to burn out.

Oh sure, it's not 1080p per eye when 3D, sort of 960x1080p but it works pretty trick. Actually, thanks to the awesomeness of the human brain interpolating data, I found viewing stereoscopic images on the TV with my ghetto glasses setup to have the appearance of greater resolution that the display was capable of. I hacked up a driver board from spare parts I had laying about to the VESA 3D glasses output jack of my TV to run my old ASUS shutter glasses from my GF2 and GF4 boards, they ghost like a mofo though, not sure if it's my ghetto driver board or the glasses. They're ancient and my driver board is about as simple as you can make it. Probably needs some dwell time between eyes to cut down on ghosting, but not worth the time investment.

Once there's some real content other than 3rd party driver hijinx to output DLP 3D format from DX games, I'll get me some DLP Link shutter glasses. No separate emitter, the timing info is blasted from the DLP itself in the periods when both lenses are opaque. Not cheap yet, but should be more so once there's content and its not nearly as niche.

DLP 3D transmits a pattern of left eye pixel, right eye pixel in 1080P, and then the next row is right eye pixel, left eye pixel, repeat (checkerboard pattern). Multiple 3D BR makers have promised this as an output mode and also Mitsubishi is making an adapter box that takes in the full 1080P HDMI 1.4 modes and converts to DLP 3D (which works the same for Mitsu and Samsung), so I'll be taken care of. RealD apparently is going to be rolling out a similar device but their stuff while high quality is $$$$. I figure Mitsu's solution would be cheaper...

After seeing Avatar in 3D I'm sold on *sensible 3D* in movies. Avatar didn't hit golf balls at you except when they lampshaded the trope literally, unlike a lot of older 3D material where it was WHOOOAAAA THREEEE DEEEEEeeeE!!! I've been sold on 3D gaming since the GF2/4 days with bulky glasses and low resolution video modes to get enough vertical refresh for the CRTs I had (and I had Pro series ViewSonics, so they could scan pretty high). Just waiting for the implementation to be workable...

Glad I haven't bought a blu-ray player yet, holding out for a 3D capable one. No point missing out on a feature just to have it now.
 
This is the gist of the article:
Online retailers are already posting details about the new models, which comprise the C7000 line of 240Hz LED-based LCDs. The 46-inch UN46C7000 is available for pre-order at Amazon.com for $2,599.99 with a release date of February 26. Also available on the same day is the 55-inch UN55C7000 for $3,299.99. There’s also a 40-inch set in the series, but neither Amazon nor other retailers have it available yet. The prices are nowhere near the magic $1,000 price point necessary for mainstream success, but there doesn’t seem to be a huge price premium given the prices for Samsung’s non-3D 240Hz LED sets.
I wonder what Black Fri. prices for them will be. :cool:
 
This is the gist of the article:

I wonder what Black Fri. prices for them will be. :cool:

I never worry about prices on Black Friday, but how badly they cripple a model you thought you were buying.
 
Yes sir. There are two types, passive polarized like you'd wear in almost all 3D movie theaters and active LCD which "open" each eye in sync with the TV (ie - left eye is open when the left image is on screen, right eye is open when the right image is one screen). The refresh rate is very fast so the flicker doesn't register.

I've seen similar systems with Nvidia's active 3D system on WoW. The objects didn't pop out of the screen at you, it was more like the display was a diorama box that you could reach into. I thought it was pretty cool.

hmm I'm not sure if I'd like wearing glasses but I guess if it was that cool it'd be worth it.
 
You're talking about "superior" technology. Since when has "superior" technology meant ANYTHING at all? That 1 billion colors that a plasma may theoretically be able to reproduce means jack shit when your video source is only 16 million colors. Other issues - color saturation. Way-too-bright Etc. The wonderful thing is that those can all be turned down. Those are non-issues. Now if the manufacturer set them all at ultra-high-eyes-bleeding mode settings, and made it to where the TV would kill my whole family if I tried to change settings - then we'd have a problem. Thank the heavens that's NOT the case.

"Superior" technology means something when it allows one product to be far superior to another. As in Plasmas having much better picture quality than LCDs. LCDs are for poors. Enthusiasts almost uniformly have plasmas.
 
"Superior" technology means something when it allows one product to be far superior to another. As in Plasmas having much better picture quality than LCDs. LCDs are for poors. Enthusiasts almost uniformly have plasmas.

LCD's are for "poors"? ...but I thought plasmas were cheaper? LOL!!! To me, the superior product is the one that will be widely supported in the long-run. That longevity almost guarantees that LCD's will eventually surpass plasma's quality, as most manufacturers don't give half of a shit about plasma.

...with that said, you keep missing my point. It's not that plasma's aren't great and that they are not better than LCD's (at least, picture quality wise), it's that LCD's don't pale in comparison to plasma's near as much as some people like to make it sound like. Not even close.
 
LCD's are for "poors"? ...but I thought plasmas were cheaper? LOL!!! To me, the superior product is the one that will be widely supported in the long-run. That longevity almost guarantees that LCD's will eventually surpass plasma's quality, as most manufacturers don't give half of a shit about plasma.

...with that said, you keep missing my point. It's not that plasma's aren't great and that they are not better than LCD's (at least, picture quality wise), it's that LCD's don't pale in comparison to plasma's near as much as some people like to make it sound like. Not even close.

Now this is a self-contradictory post if I've ever seen one. You claim that plasmas are cheaper than LCDs, but also that manufacturers don't care about plasma. Now, if you had finished that second claim it would read "manufacturer's don't give half a shit about plasma because they are more expensive to make and the profit margins are lower."

You also have a very interesting definition of superior. To me, superior means better. And right now plasmas are flat out better than LCDs, which I don't think you can even dispute. Why would someone buying a TV now care about what is "widely supported in the long run"? This isn't like choosing between Blu Ray and HDDVD. You buy the best TV available at the time regardless of what's going to happen in the future. At any rate, don't plan on LCD catching up to plasma before something new comes out that makes both techs obsolete.
 
LCD's are for "poors"? ...but I thought plasmas were cheaper? LOL!!!

Yeah, that's a bit of a WTF. The thing with LCDs is that they occupy a wider range of prices than plasmas. You have cheap cheap LCDs, something that I have no issue with even though they don't look that great. If you're on a tight budget, it is certainly a way to go. My problem is with the $2000+ LCDs with LED backlighting and 240hz and local dimming, all these features thrown on to bring LCDs up to plasma levels of quality and yet they still fall short.

I don't have a problem with someone paying less for inferior technology, I do think its silly to pay more for something that isn't as good as something that costs less (ie - a mid-range plasma)

...with that said, you keep missing my point. It's not that plasma's aren't great and that they are not better than LCD's (at least, picture quality wise), it's that LCD's don't pale in comparison to plasma's near as much as some people like to make it sound like. Not even close.

No, they do pale in comparison, still, a lot. Sorry. ;) But if you need a "greener", more energy efficient, lighter, and brighter display, LCD all the way.
 
I never worry about prices on Black Friday, but how badly they cripple a model you thought you were buying.

Just remember buyer beware and make sure the model you think you're buying is indeed the one you are getting. Of course, do your research beforehand to know everything about said model. :)
 
They need another new type of movie player (3D bluray disc??) to play movies?? Can't dual layer BD's hold enough information? This is getting ridiculous, and even before the bluray market even remotely fully matures.
 
Now this is a self-contradictory post if I've ever seen one. You claim that plasmas are cheaper than LCDs, but also that manufacturers don't care about plasma. Now, if you had finished that second claim it would read "manufacturer's don't give half a shit about plasma because they are more expensive to make and the profit margins are lower."

You also have a very interesting definition of superior. To me, superior means better. And right now plasmas are flat out better than LCDs, which I don't think you can even dispute. Why would someone buying a TV now care about what is "widely supported in the long run"? This isn't like choosing between Blu Ray and HDDVD. You buy the best TV available at the time regardless of what's going to happen in the future. At any rate, don't plan on LCD catching up to plasma before something new comes out that makes both techs obsolete.

I am pissed off that I keep hearing that plasmas are dying. If they really are superior to LCDs when it comes to picture quality, and they are cheaper, what could they possibly do other than drive lower prices on LCDs and motivate manufacturers to improve them more and more???

I really hope they stay alive and well, but with so many manufacturers that have dropped out of making them, and the majority of what retail stores being LCDs now, it's not looking good!
 
Now this is a self-contradictory post if I've ever seen one. You claim that plasmas are cheaper than LCDs, but also that manufacturers don't care about plasma. Now, if you had finished that second claim it would read "manufacturer's don't give half a shit about plasma because they are more expensive to make and the profit margins are lower."

You also have a very interesting definition of superior. To me, superior means better. And right now plasmas are flat out better than LCDs, which I don't think you can even dispute. Why would someone buying a TV now care about what is "widely supported in the long run"? This isn't like choosing between Blu Ray and HDDVD. You buy the best TV available at the time regardless of what's going to happen in the future. At any rate, don't plan on LCD catching up to plasma before something new comes out that makes both techs obsolete.

I'm not the only one who's claimed they're cheaper, read everyone elses posts ;) ...and manufacturers don't care about plasma, hence the fact that most have completely dropped support for and production of plasma technology.

...and I'm not disputing which has better quality, picture-wise. Are you even reading my posts? Lol...
 
No, they do pale in comparison, still, a lot. Sorry. ;) But if you need a "greener", more energy efficient, lighter, and brighter display, LCD all the way.

I suppose I'm looking at things from more of a perspective view. Most people won't notice a huge (if any) difference between a plasma and an LCD. They'll see a super-bright, super-saturated in-store model and think it's better because it's brighter. What most people happen to actually need at this point in the game is a "greener", more energy-efficient, lighter and brighter display, plain and simple, making LCD the "better" choice.

But this is really going nowhere lol. I respect your views totally and completely and I really feel there's nothing left to argue. You and I have said it many times already..."No they don't pale in comparison...", "Yes they do pale in comparison...", etc etc. But I will end my argument with the simple fact that I'm sure we both respect each others opinions. :)
 
Yes sir. There are two types, passive polarized like you'd wear in almost all 3D movie theaters and active LCD which "open" each eye in sync with the TV (ie - left eye is open when the left image is on screen, right eye is open when the right image is one screen). The refresh rate is very fast so the flicker doesn't register.

I've seen similar systems with Nvidia's active 3D system on WoW. The objects didn't pop out of the screen at you, it was more like the display was a diorama box that you could reach into. I thought it was pretty cool.

I have my good share of experience with nVidia's 3D Vision. The flicker does register. A lot. I wouldn't go as far as call it terrible but it's certainly bad and certainly not good enough for anything, especially fast paced FPS games.

Prior to my initial testing, quite a few people have told me the flicker would just go away withing the next 10-30 minutes. It did not go away at all. Of course it wouldn't go away. 60Hz is not enough. Hell, I can tell if a CRT is refreshing the image at 85Hz, let alone 60.

Tech has a future but numbers should be at least doubled.
 
I have my good share of experience with nVidia's 3D Vision. The flicker does register. A lot. I wouldn't go as far as call it terrible but it's certainly bad and certainly not good enough for anything, especially fast paced FPS games.

Prior to my initial testing, quite a few people have told me the flicker would just go away withing the next 10-30 minutes. It did not go away at all. Of course it wouldn't go away. 60Hz is not enough. Hell, I can tell if a CRT is refreshing the image at 85Hz, let alone 60.

Tech has a future but numbers should be at least doubled.

I think one I looked at was 120hz per eye, and I'm pretty sure that the 3D sets require a high refresh rate. 60hz would be unbearable, flicker city.
 
Once OLED hits mass production, it'll end the LCD vs. plasma vs. DLP debate. :cool:
 
At this rate, by the time OLED is commercially viable there will be something else that is way better than all four. ;)


You know what's funny? Right after I posted that commented, I scanned the 1st page of [H] news and saw Sony is pulling out of OLED in Japan, LOL. Oh well, someone will continue to develop that tech. It's got too many pros to be disregarded so quickly due to cost.
 
You know what's funny? Right after I posted that commented, I scanned the 1st page of [H] news and saw Sony is pulling out of OLED in Japan, LOL. Oh well, someone will continue to develop that tech. It's got too many pros to be disregarded so quickly due to cost.

I hope you're right. I have owned three car decks that have had OLED displays. The one I have now has full color. It was like a $500 deck, and I figured it would wear out or something, so I bought the 4 year service plan on it at Best Buy. The tech also told me that since it wasn't Alpine, it probably wouldn't last that long so I should buy the plan. Here I am four years later, and the thing still works perfectly, and the screen still works great. I really think OLED has some serious potential, and I sure would like to see it further developed.

Sony just can't afford any endeavors like that right now. They don't have real market dominance in several areas where they used to, and the influx of shareholder money apparently isn't sufficient for such risky ventures and high expenditures right now. Sony's in a bit of a tough spot. I hope the 3D TVs do well for them. I'm no Sony zealot by any means, but I don't want to see another big electronics competitor drop out of areas where it competes. That's NEVER good for us consumers.
 
I hope you're right. I have owned three car decks that have had OLED displays. The one I have now has full color. It was like a $500 deck, and I figured it would wear out or something, so I bought the 4 year service plan on it at Best Buy. The tech also told me that since it wasn't Alpine, it probably wouldn't last that long so I should buy the plan. Here I am four years later, and the thing still works perfectly, and the screen still works great. I really think OLED has some serious potential, and I sure would like to see it further developed.

Sony just can't afford any endeavors like that right now. They don't have real market dominance in several areas where they used to, and the influx of shareholder money apparently isn't sufficient for such risky ventures and high expenditures right now. Sony's in a bit of a tough spot. I hope the 3D TVs do well for them. I'm no Sony zealot by any means, but I don't want to see another big electronics competitor drop out of areas where it competes. That's NEVER good for us consumers.
Yeah, I remember OLEDs being out for a while. That's great your radio is still displaying so well after 4 years like it did on Day 1. I remember a really small MP3 player that was in the shape of a cube that had an OLED display.

More and more phones are coming out with AMOLED displays. So for small screens, they're relatively cheap to manufacture, apparently. But for HDTV sizes, I guess cost is too much of an object for manufacturers like Sony. I agree on there being more players in the market to keep competition lively among them.
 
The Zune HD uses an OLED screen, and it looks fantastic in person. The black on the screen is as black as the unit itself.
 
I think one I looked at was 120hz per eye, and I'm pretty sure that the 3D sets require a high refresh rate. 60hz would be unbearable, flicker city.

There are no such shutter glasses on the market. Not only that, there are no TV sets or monitors capable of providing real refresh rates at 240Hz. Well, there are some plasma TVs with funny 500+ Hz rates haha. You can not input so much data in the TV, thus it's cheap faking.
 
There are no such shutter glasses on the market. Not only that, there are no TV sets or monitors capable of providing real refresh rates at 240Hz. Well, there are some plasma TVs with funny 500+ Hz rates haha. You can not input so much data in the TV, thus it's cheap faking.

I would think because of such high refresh rates plasmas would be the ideal candidate for cost effective 3D adoption. Regardless of whether it's "cheating" or not, I've NEVER seen an LCD that "felt" as smooth as a good solid plasma during very fast motion video. LCDs are getting closer, but plasmas just handle fast motion stuff amazingly well and with no ghosting.

But the market is so anti-plasma right now. I hate it. I mean, I like nice LCD's too, but my dad's plasma is so amazing. It's a 1080p panasonic, and it kicks butt for gaming on. It has a much more pleasing image than the just as expensive 1080p Sony LCD I purchased at the same time (and broke 2 days later.:eek::()
 
What I really don't about plasma is their "solution" to overburn - pixels blink all the time, and yes, I see that right away.
 
There are no such shutter glasses on the market. Not only that, there are no TV sets or monitors capable of providing real refresh rates at 240Hz. Well, there are some plasma TVs with funny 500+ Hz rates haha. You can not input so much data in the TV, thus it's cheap faking.

It isn't "cheap faking", it actually makes lots of sense to refresh within the same frame in order to reduce apparent flicker.

They do this in all movie theaters. The shutter in the projector blocks each frame not once, but twice. This reduces the amount of apparent flicker that the audience sees. What would be 24 frames of flicker per second, which would be like looking at a giant strobe light, is now 48 times a second, much more bearable.
 
I would think because of such high refresh rates plasmas would be the ideal candidate for cost effective 3D adoption. Regardless of whether it's "cheating" or not, I've NEVER seen an LCD that "felt" as smooth as a good solid plasma during very fast motion video. LCDs are getting closer, but plasmas just handle fast motion stuff amazingly well and with no ghosting.

But the market is so anti-plasma right now. I hate it. I mean, I like nice LCD's too, but my dad's plasma is so amazing. It's a 1080p panasonic, and it kicks butt for gaming on. It has a much more pleasing image than the just as expensive 1080p Sony LCD I purchased at the same time (and broke 2 days later.:eek::()

Motion, input lag, color, black, I see absolutely nothing even the best LCD can do better than plasma outside of lower power consumption and portability, which is why we have LCDs in cell phones and laptops.
 
This debate now reminds me of the long running Blu-ray vs HD-DVD debates. Where the supporters of the technology that has clearly lost the momentum it needs to stay in the market are in complete denial. :p

Sorry guys, Plasma might have been the clearly superior technology at one point. I myself even remember looking at plasma's at one point and seeing a massive difference. Unfortunately that difference has all but disappeared. That said, before it really matters one way or the other, I tend to agree that Plasma and LCD will both end up replaced with something better.
 
WTF are you talking about? Plasmas are still popular and are still in demand by people that demand the best image quality. Being second place means little if you're still selling well.

There is no denial in effect, just a fully functioning pair of eyeballs. People that get suckered into buying inferior LCD displays by something as stupid as marketing simply need education, but we've already gone over that. ;)
 
This debate now reminds me of the long running Blu-ray vs HD-DVD debates. Where the supporters of the technology that has clearly lost the momentum it needs to stay in the market are in complete denial. :p

Sorry guys, Plasma might have been the clearly superior technology at one point. I myself even remember looking at plasma's at one point and seeing a massive difference. Unfortunately that difference has all but disappeared. That said, before it really matters one way or the other, I tend to agree that Plasma and LCD will both end up replaced with something better.


LOL, no.

This is more like a Blu Ray vs Standard Def DVD debate in a world where Blu Ray never caught on because DVD players were cheaper. Poors will still buy their crappy DVDs but the people who bought the better tech get the better experience. Go to any serious home theater technology site and you'll be laughed off the forums for putting for the notion that LCDs are even almost as good.
 
LOL, no.

This is more like a Blu Ray vs Standard Def DVD debate in a world where Blu Ray never caught on because DVD players were cheaper. Poors will still buy their crappy DVDs but the people who bought the better tech get the better experience. Go to any serious home theater technology site and you'll be laughed off the forums for putting for the notion that LCDs are even almost as good.

My 1080p 40" Sony LCD and my dad's 42" Panasonic plasma cost exactly the same price!! And in testing, after substantial color and picture adjustment, I NEVER found a situation (other than reading still text) where my Sony LCD (and it was not a low end model!) looked as good as my dad's Panny, and text looked just fine and bearable on the plasma. The difference was minor. In fact, there were several computer resolutions that the Sony just flat wouldn't display at all that the Panasonic would actually try to display. But the plasma was noticeably better in black levels, contrast, and fast motion in all of the following situations: gaming, picture viewing, and movie watching.

Oh, wait, those are the main things you buy a TV for. I am really impressed with the black levels on some of the newest LED LCD TV's. And those TV's from Samsung are impressively thin and very efficient. But look at what they cost right now. $600 to $700 more than a comparably sized plasma. If you don't have a specific need for a ultra thin and efficient TV, you'd be CRAZY not to buy the plasma instead and use the savings on an HTPC or a PS3, Xbox ... SOMETHING.

I still think LCD's look great, and do a lot of things well, but comparably priced plasmas look noticeably better in most situations that you'd normally use a TV for.

And margins are high on the expensive, cutting edge LCDs, but on the mainstream and budget models they are just as crappy, if not crappier, than margins on plasmas right now. Why in the heck do we see stores, manufacturers, and consumers following this huge paradigm shift away from plasmas? The ones that are being made now are quite excellent for the price.

I suppose it has to do with all the hits and negative hype plasmas have had over the years, and some horrible plasma makers such as philips or Vizio (who oddly enough both happen to make good LCDs).

Pioneer dropping out was a big blow, too.
 
This is more like a Blu Ray vs Standard Def DVD debate in a world where Blu Ray never caught on because DVD players were cheaper.

Hah, nailed it

My 1080p 40" Sony LCD and my dad's 42" Panasonic plasma cost exactly the same price!! And in testing, after substantial color and picture adjustment, I NEVER found a situation (other than reading still text) where my Sony LCD (and it was not a low end model!) looked as good as my dad's Panny, and text looked just fine and bearable on the plasma. The difference was minor. In fact, there were several computer resolutions that the Sony just flat wouldn't display at all that the Panasonic would actually try to display. But the plasma was noticeably better in black levels, contrast, and fast motion in all of the following situations: gaming, picture viewing, and movie watching.

Oh, wait, those are the main things you buy a TV for. I am really impressed with the black levels on some of the newest LED LCD TV's. And those TV's from Samsung are impressively thin and very efficient. But look at what they cost right now. $600 to $700 more than a comparably sized plasma. If you don't have a specific need for a ultra thin and efficient TV, you'd be CRAZY not to buy the plasma instead and use the savings on an HTPC or a PS3, Xbox ... SOMETHING.

I still think LCD's look great, and do a lot of things well, but comparably priced plasmas look noticeably better in most situations that you'd normally use a TV for.

And margins are high on the expensive, cutting edge LCDs, but on the mainstream and budget models they are just as crappy, if not crappier, than margins on plasmas right now. Why in the heck do we see stores, manufacturers, and consumers following this huge paradigm shift away from plasmas? The ones that are being made now are quite excellent for the price.

I suppose it has to do with all the hits and negative hype plasmas have had over the years, and some horrible plasma makers such as philips or Vizio (who oddly enough both happen to make good LCDs).

Also nailed it, this is EXACTLY why all marketing dollars are going towards LED backlit LCDs with local dimming, not because they are superior to plasmas (they aren't, not by a longshot), but because they make manufacturers and retailers the most money.

Anyone buying into it over a cheaper, superior plasma is buying into their schemes hook line and sinker.

Pioneer dropping out was a big blow, too.

It sucks, still the best consumer displays on the market. I really hope that the high end plasmas coming out this Fall are going to at least match them in image quality.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top