FCC Updating Broadband Subsidy Program

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The FCC will vote Tuesday on restructuring the Universal Service program funding. Initially the program was set up to provide basic telephone service to insure nationwide coverage. The FCC wants to redistribute the allocation, initiating wider broadband coverage, especially in rural areas.

"Broadband serves the same role in the 21st Century that telephone service served in the 20th Century," Genachowski said. "So we need to modernize this program."
 
Hold onto your wallets since I suspect that if this is approved the FCC will suddenly decide they need billions of dollars more to do it, and will likely either increase current fees or create new ones, to make all of us pay for it.
 
The article says that Republicans oppose the program, yet the states that benefited the most from it (Mississippi, Texas and Kansas) all voted Republican . Why not just let the Republican politicians kill the program? It's the representation those states voted that they want, right? It sure would be cheaper on everybody in the other less rural states to not have to pay into the USF anymore.
 
"Broadband serves the same role in the 21st Century that telephone service served in the 20th Century," Genachowski said. "So we need to modernize this program."

He's right, y'know.
 
AT&T, Verizon and others argue that the current intercarrier compensation system is outdated and irrational since phone company payments vary widely based on the type of carrier involved, the type of network traffic being exchanged and the distance that the traffic travels. That leads carriers to game the system — by sending traffic along inefficient routes or pumping up traffic volumes, for instance — in order to manipulate access payments.

What the fuck? And the Telcos aren't punished for this because......?

How about this: any telco or ISP that gamed the system has to give 10% of their yearly profit back into the USF.
 
What the fuck? And the Telcos aren't punished for this because......?

How about this: any telco or ISP that gamed the system has to give over 9000% of their yearly profit back into the USF.

Fixed. Yeah, yeah, old meme, but still...if you game the system, you should get played. :mad:
 
Hold onto your wallets since I suspect that if this is approved the FCC will suddenly decide they need billions of dollars more to do it, and will likely either increase current fees or create new ones, to make all of us pay for it.
Right on the money. That sound you hear is the telco's entering new USF charges into their billing systems.
The article says that Republicans oppose the program, yet the states that benefited the most from it (Mississippi, Texas and Kansas) all voted Republican . Why not just let the Republican politicians kill the program? It's the representation those states voted that they want, right? It sure would be cheaper on everybody in the other less rural states to not have to pay into the USF anymore.
Heck I'll take it a step further. Sure, let the Republicans kill the bill. This sort of thing should be handled on the state level anyway.
 
"Broadband serves the same role in the 21st Century that telephone service served in the 20th Century,"

Sounds like an argument for needing net neutrality to me.
 
Please cut it! Or at least pay for it from the general budget instead of some hokey line item on my phone bill. While they're at it, can they get rid of the Federal Subscriber Line Charge (which is basically the FCC says the telco can charge whatever they want and call it that, instead of just upping the rate)
 
yay now we get to spend billions on a retarded project that will be obsoleted by something like 5g or 6g as soon as its done. hurray for government "fixing" stuff
 
Good government is good. Bad government is bad. Regarding this bill, the idea is sound and it's a worthy goal.

Reason? Not because I'm a socialist and believe in wealth redistribution.
The reason is that it's the only real strong case (public investment in ISP subsidies) that will hold any chance at stopping metered internet use for cable connections.

No public investment? Good luck telling them NO to metered service.
 
The article says that Republicans oppose the program, yet the states that benefited the most from it (Mississippi, Texas and Kansas) all voted Republican . Why not just let the Republican politicians kill the program? It's the representation those states voted that they want, right? It sure would be cheaper on everybody in the other less rural states to not have to pay into the USF anymore.

The people in these states who are often poor and uneducated often vote against their best interests. Religion, being in the Bible Belt I'm sure plays a big part of that.
 
Good start to the program. Maybe if this passes I can get something better than this ADSL crap Centurylink is feeding us here in NC.
 
"So we need to modernize this program."

What that should read at the end is "because we as the government refuse to ever cut anything that is no longer valid for the economy, we just rename it, and stuff it back up your asses"
 
Why is everyone so opposed to public investment into infrastructure? Do you think the telco's are going to pay for this? Why would they do that?

Public investment into broadband infrastructure in areas that private corporations will not invest into because it's not profitable sounds like a great usage of funds to me.
 
The people in these states who are often poor and uneducated often vote against their best interests. Religion, being in the Bible Belt I'm sure plays a big part of that.

Or they are strong on values like work hard for what you want, and don't expect the government to take care of you. You know the American way, unlike half of you with your socalist ideals.
 
Why is everyone so opposed to public investment into infrastructure? Do you think the telco's are going to pay for this? Why would they do that?

Public investment into broadband infrastructure in areas that private corporations will not invest into because it's not profitable sounds like a great usage of funds to me.

Not against investments in infrastructure, but I don't see the sense in running fiber to some town in the sticks with 100 people living there. Or even worse, running it to 10 houses 35 miles outside of town. Satellite sucks for gamers, and torrenters, and really heavy bandwidth users, but is generally fine for everything else, and is ideally suited to the role of serving people that choose to live in those places.

If you need internet service it is available via satellite. If you have heavy bandwidth wants, you should choose to live somewhere that has the ability service your wants.
This is not a choice between internet and no internet. It is a choice in levels of bandwidth.

Yes, yes, they said the same thing about telephone service back in the day. Would they have run lines to the sticks back then if cell phones were as cheap and available as today? Prolly not. Same goes for cable/internet since we have satellite imho.
 
Not against investments in infrastructure, but I don't see the sense in running fiber to some town in the sticks with 100 people living there. Or even worse, running it to 10 houses 35 miles outside of town. Satellite sucks for gamers, and torrenters, and really heavy bandwidth users, but is generally fine for everything else, and is ideally suited to the role of serving people that choose to live in those places.

If you need Internet service it is available via satellite. If you have heavy bandwidth wants, you should choose to live somewhere that has the ability service your wants.
This is not a choice between Internet and no Internet. It is a choice in levels of bandwidth.

Yes, yes, they said the same thing about telephone service back in the day. Would they have run lines to the sticks back then if cell phones were as cheap and available as today? Prolly not. Same goes for cable/internet since we have satellite imho.


I agree 100%. I don't understand how some people move out to BFE and expect super fast wired broadband. Why should the cable company or Telco be force to serve some people so choose to live so far away from civilization. I remember years ago house hunting and one of my stipulations was that where ever I moved so HAD to have broadband access. Living rural would have been cheaper but basically I would be forced to use Satellite (YUCK) or dial up.
 
I agree 100%. I don't understand how some people move out to BFE and expect super fast wired broadband.

I have to explain loop length to people day in and day out. Most just don't know.
 
I am not really for the subsidy either. The way it has been handled previously is basically corporate welfare...

I think also, when looking at this, you just can't say.. OH REPUBLICANS ARE DUMB! THEY WANT TO STEAL YOUR INTERNET, BECAUSE THEY ARE BIBLE THUMPERS.

First, You have to look at the cost per person effected... If it turns out to be say in the billions, which past offers to expand broadband have.. Is it worth 5,000 per person? Is it worth 25,000 per person? If they spend billions, and the low populated areas don't stand to gain a lot.. Is it really worth something like 25,000.. or even 50,000 per person to gain this coverage? What are your priorities? Is it just to spend anything you see something that sounds good.. or is it to be frugile, and understand that in this economy.. borrowing 50,000 per person, and paying interest on it may not be feasible.

Another consideration, IMO, is the fact that they technically already have access to 1mbps-3mbps through satellite for somewhat reasonable prices, considering the situation.. Is it worth it for them to gain 5mbps for the cost?

How many of the people effected would even use this bandwith? Afterall, most backwoods types of people may not stream torrents. 1mbps+ is plenty for browsing.

Investing in infrastructure in and of itself doesn't make it a good investment.. Furthermore, I can think of plenty of infrastructure investments in the past that have not been worth the investment.
 
Not against investments in infrastructure, but I don't see the sense in running fiber to some town in the sticks with 100 people living there. Or even worse, running it to 10 houses 35 miles outside of town. Satellite sucks for gamers, and torrenters, and really heavy bandwidth users, but is generally fine for everything else, and is ideally suited to the role of serving people that choose to live in those places.

If you need internet service it is available via satellite. If you have heavy bandwidth wants, you should choose to live somewhere that has the ability service your wants.
This is not a choice between internet and no internet. It is a choice in levels of bandwidth.

Yes, yes, they said the same thing about telephone service back in the day. Would they have run lines to the sticks back then if cell phones were as cheap and available as today? Prolly not. Same goes for cable/internet since we have satellite imho.

You have to look at the larger picture. You're not running fiber to 100 people in the middle of nowhere, you're running fiber to the 40% of the population that doesn't live in a city.
 
You have to look at the larger picture. You're not running fiber to 100 people in the middle of nowhere, you're running fiber to the 40% of the population that doesn't live in a city.
Ok, so you're running fiber out to 100 people in the middle of nowhere, and repeating it a million times.
 
Not against investments in infrastructure, but I don't see the sense in running fiber to some town in the sticks with 100 people living there. Or even worse, running it to 10 houses 35 miles outside of town. Satellite sucks for gamers, and torrenters, and really heavy bandwidth users, but is generally fine for everything else, and is ideally suited to the role of serving people that choose to live in those places.

If you need internet service it is available via satellite. If you have heavy bandwidth wants, you should choose to live somewhere that has the ability service your wants.
This is not a choice between internet and no internet. It is a choice in levels of bandwidth.

Yes, yes, they said the same thing about telephone service back in the day. Would they have run lines to the sticks back then if cell phones were as cheap and available as today? Prolly not. Same goes for cable/internet since we have satellite imho.


Because some people want to go to college and need certain amounts of bandwidth for courses. I remember when my professor used to send us 180mb downloads every night and I was on dialup.

He didn't send the assignment until ~8pm, class was a 4 hour daily drive round trip, and there wasn't a chance in hell I could stay to use the wireless on campus to wait for the assignment as I had to be back at 8am for class. The way I see education in the future is that broadband access is as important as pens and paper when I was growing up.

I think a lot of you'll take the areas you live in for granted. The "If you want an education, then you need to get off your lazy tails and move to a city." mentality is very shortsighted guys.

If a farmer's son wants to study chemical engineering so that maybe he wants to work for Monsanto one day, doesn't mean his father has to sell the farm that produces the food city dwellers consume to move closer to the city for broadband. The son might have to commute to school as he works with his family on the farm during certain seasons. But he needs broadband to do his homework and access data to study. His family pays their taxes without fail, which finance the roads the city dwellers ride on (and of course other things). Why shouldn't his son be allowed to study chemical engineering like the city kids?


Or do you think education in America should be based on social status and not opportunity?
 
You have to look at the larger picture. You're not running fiber to 100 people in the middle of nowhere, you're running fiber to the 40% of the population that doesn't live in a city.

Exactly. If the people who don't live in the city don't deserve the same level of broadband access as the city dwellers, then they shouldn't be taxed for it. No taxation without representation!

They said the same thing about phone lines back in the day. Some wanted to segregate the population in certain areas because of their distance from the main phone lines. And the government had to step in so that everyone could have equal access to a phone as they saw phones as a necessity in the future. Just like the government had to step in and make states install a roadway to all areas. Otherwise we'd still be walking to work and school.
 
I vote that we stop shipping fresh produce into the city. After all, if they want food, they should move to the country, where the food is.
 
Not against investments in infrastructure, but I don't see the sense in running fiber to some town in the sticks with 100 people living there. Or even worse, running it to 10 houses 35 miles outside of town. Satellite sucks for gamers, and torrenters, and really heavy bandwidth users, but is generally fine for everything else, and is ideally suited to the role of serving people that choose to live in those places.

If you need internet service it is available via satellite. If you have heavy bandwidth wants, you should choose to live somewhere that has the ability service your wants.
This is not a choice between internet and no internet. It is a choice in levels of bandwidth.

Yes, yes, they said the same thing about telephone service back in the day. Would they have run lines to the sticks back then if cell phones were as cheap and available as today? Prolly not. Same goes for cable/internet since we have satellite imho.

This is exactly how i've felt on this issue. Broadband internet is not a right and others shouldn't be forced into paying for it to bring it to a location that just doesn't make sense. Satelite isn't the best form of broadband, but it is more than enough. It just does not make sense to spend millions of dollars just so a town with 35 people can download Japanese fetish porn at 10+Mbps when Satelite will still give them their Japanese fetish porn, although slower. If you then spend millions of dollars, then you have to spend millions more over time just trying to maintain and fix the lines.
 
Waste of money, meanwhile I live in a county with nearly a million people who all live mostly on top of one another and still don't have DOCSIS 3.0.
 
I vote that we stop shipping fresh produce into the city. After all, if they want food, they should move to the country, where the food is.
Bad analogy. The farmers get paid for that produce. Urban dwellers don't get jack for subsidizing internet to rural areas.
 
Bad analogy. The farmers get paid for that produce. Urban dwellers don't get jack for subsidizing internet to rural areas.

The U.S government subsidizes corn and other produce. I grown my own, so why should I have to pay for your food?
 
Because some people want to go to college and need certain amounts of bandwidth for courses. I remember when my professor used to send us 180mb downloads every night and I was on dialup.
you know what though, they need to fucking pay for it then. They have a cheaper cost of living, want something like this, then they need to be the ones who pay for pull wire out there.

They want to bury phone/power lines around here due to possible "EM radiation" (or fuck if I know so it doesn't look like a 3rd world country), every fucker on that block pays for it. They put in those smart meters so they can charge us more or someshit "better for us" that price was factored into our electricity bill. In both of those cases, we didn''t have a choice in the matter it just happened, and we paid for it, or in most cases pay for a long time.

That's how this has to happen, find some cost effective technology to be certain, maybe a satellite relay that can handle the bandwidth, and from there wire all the 100 rural homes, because I doubt they all would need that much bandwidth at once. Then tack it on their property taxes, or phone bill, or anything else. No need to make them pay for it all at once, just a recurring price that reflects the cost of said service. Then instead of the 100% of the people paying that $1-2 per month for "universal whatever the fuck" service, you let the 40% who don't live in cities (statistic taken from another poster), pays $2-4 per month since they're the people who are benefiting from this.
 
The U.S government subsidizes corn and other produce. I grown my own, so why should I have to pay for your food?
Agreed, you shouldn't be. Corn subsidies are another nice example of government doing more harm than good.
 
Because some people want to go to college and need certain amounts of bandwidth for courses. I remember when my professor used to send us 180mb downloads every night and I was on dialup.

He didn't send the assignment until ~8pm, class was a 4 hour daily drive round trip, and there wasn't a chance in hell I could stay to use the wireless on campus to wait for the assignment as I had to be back at 8am for class. The way I see education in the future is that broadband access is as important as pens and paper when I was growing up.

I think a lot of you'll take the areas you live in for granted. The "If you want an education, then you need to get off your lazy tails and move to a city." mentality is very shortsighted guys.

If a farmer's son wants to study chemical engineering so that maybe he wants to work for Monsanto one day, doesn't mean his father has to sell the farm that produces the food city dwellers consume to move closer to the city for broadband. The son might have to commute to school as he works with his family on the farm during certain seasons. But he needs broadband to do his homework and access data to study. His family pays their taxes without fail, which finance the roads the city dwellers ride on (and of course other things). Why shouldn't his son be allowed to study chemical engineering like the city kids?


Or do you think education in America should be based on social status and not opportunity?

Satelite has the badwidth needed for that.
 
Satelite has the badwidth needed for that.

It would be impossible to serve that many people via satellite. We would have to use every square inch of empty space above us to do it. Because of this, you run into major over subscription, and usage caps at 200mb per day. Who wouldn't want a 1000kbit/200kbit connection with a 200mb cap for the low low price of $60 a month.
 
It would be impossible to serve that many people via satellite. We would have to use every square inch of empty space above us to do it. Because of this, you run into major over subscription, and usage caps at 200mb per day. Who wouldn't want a 1000kbit/200kbit connection with a 200mb cap for the low low price of $60 a month.

I never said it was great compared to cable or DSL. Merely that it was an option, one markedly better than dial up or wasting $$$ to run FIOS to a farmhouse a hundred miles from nowhere. It is one of the costs associated with living in the country, same as crappy traffic, and high food and housing costs are a problem for city dwellers.
 
I never said it was great compared to cable or DSL. Merely that it was an option, one markedly better than dial up or wasting $$$ to run FIOS to a farmhouse a hundred miles from nowhere. It is one of the costs associated with living in the country, same as crappy traffic, and high food and housing costs are a problem for city dwellers.

You seem to be under the impression that there are a lot of people living alone in the middle of nowhere. Thats not how it works, people tend to group together. The places that need help are small towns of less than 5000 people that are separated by 50 miles, these could be wired easily and cheaply with fiber (and this is something the state of Maine is doing right now). The people that live 100 miles away from the main road will still be SOL for internet. Look at how the telcoms handle it now. If your driveway is longer than 100feet, you have to pay them $150 per telephone pole that they have to put in to get a phone line to your house. This is how it should be. No one is saying that we need to run fiber right up to the person's door, just set up a backbone, and run it along the roadways, like we did with copper.
 
You seem to be under the impression that there are a lot of people living alone in the middle of nowhere. Thats not how it works, people tend to group together. The places that need help are small towns of less than 5000 people that are separated by 50 miles, these could be wired easily and cheaply with fiber (and this is something the state of Maine is doing right now). The people that live 100 miles away from the main road will still be SOL for internet. Look at how the telcoms handle it now. If your driveway is longer than 100feet, you have to pay them $150 per telephone pole that they have to put in to get a phone line to your house. This is how it should be. No one is saying that we need to run fiber right up to the person's door, just set up a backbone, and run it along the roadways, like we did with copper.

As long as that town of 5000 is footing the bill, I am fine with it. This is not like telphone where, at the time, there was is no other way to get service.
 
As long as that town of 5000 is footing the bill, I am fine with it. This is not like telphone where, at the time, there was is no other way to get service.

Just like you paid to have internet access brought to your area, right? I'm not seeing whats different here. There is no other way to get service. A few thousand more people can probably get satellite internet before the cost of the hardware overcomes the amount they can realistically charge. Time Warner had no problem bringing 10mbit/s cable internet to my town of 3,400, but it would somehow require a monumental amount of tax revenue to do it somewhere else?
 
How about just using Motorola Canopy.... create local broadband ISPs like in my town :)

I just heard of it, it's supposed to be something new and enables small companies to make ISPs. Startup is like $500 but its about the same price monthly for the same basic broadband speeds of nowadays.
 
How about just using Motorola Canopy.... create local broadband ISPs like in my town :)

I just heard of it, it's supposed to be something new and enables small companies to make ISPs. Startup is like $500 but its about the same price monthly for the same basic broadband speeds of nowadays.

We have a company using Ubiquity networking products around here, $150 for 50km range. The only problem is you need fiber run to every tower. You can set up a mesh network, or have wireless backhauls, but latency will add up quickly
 
Just like you paid to have internet access brought to your area, right? I'm not seeing whats different here. There is no other way to get service. A few thousand more people can probably get satellite internet before the cost of the hardware overcomes the amount they can realistically charge. Time Warner had no problem bringing 10mbit/s cable internet to my town of 3,400, but it would somehow require a monumental amount of tax revenue to do it somewhere else?

Again, it is part of the cost of choosing to live in a certain place. It is a choice between how fast the internet is, not whether they have it or not.
I get to pay, usually higher property taxes, more for food, deal with more traffic, smog, pay higher insurance premiums, deal with more crime, and a ton of other shit they don't have to. I don't get to bitch, because I chose to live here.

And I was not suggesting federal or even state tax dollars be used. I was suggesting if a community wants broadband via cable or fiber, that that community brings it in their selves or that they convince some company that there is money in doing so for them. I am against the FCC's lame attempt at keeping control of money they were about to lose control of under this pretense. Especially since we would not get broadband to the stix out of it. We would get broadband to a few places in the stix till the FCC ran out of money for the ISPs to stuff there pockets with while doing the bare minimum, and then the program would be expanded or quietly canned. It makes little sense to do this unless you just want your cake, and to eat it as well, all at taxpayer expense.
 
Back
Top