FCC Cracking Down on Cell Phone Jammers

Lady answers the door saying their cordless phones haven't worked since they installed a cell phone jammer to block the young offenders' cell phones.. :rolleyes:

I understand theaters, restaurants and religious services.

However, with kids who are either grounded or in some sort of social services location just confiscate their damned phones. Problem solved.

My 12 year old step son is currently grounded. He lost is cellphone, his computer access, TV access AND his iPod.

The point of grounding is a complete cutoff from the outside world.

We allow him to read books until he is no longer grounded.
 
My problem with signal jammers is not only do your risk killing someone or disrupting something important but more importantly what have you taught someone? The whole point of courtesy is that people learn to do it volentarity because they see how bad things get if everyone is rude and they see how people view them when someone walks up and asks them publicly to cut out what they are doing this actually teaches them through social interaction to not do it again. It is kind of like trying to stop a teen aged kid from doing something by cutting him off of something like the internet but not telling him you did it, well fine but as soon as he gets away he will do what ever. Jammers are cop outs. If you have a major problem with someones behavior strap on a pair and ask them to be polite, don't sit there with your tail in bettween your legs from far away activating your jammer. There are hundreds of places where I see people doing something rude, talking on the phone or to others in a place that should be quiet, cutting in lines, and if it is important enough for you to care then it should be important enough for you to say something. I see signs up all over stating that cell phones are not allowed and I see the people in these places too sissy to enforce that rule. Now I hear they are jamming signals. Anything at all at any risk to avoid being an adult now days I guess.
 
Not sure if anyone mentioned this or not yet but why oh why won't they mandate that the jammers be installed in the penitentiary system? Obvious that the FCC works for the industry and not for the constituency of this nation.

/Rant :mad:
 
My problem with signal jammers is not only do your risk killing someone or disrupting something important but more importantly what have you taught someone? The whole point of courtesy is that people learn to do it volentarity because they see how bad things get if everyone is rude and they see how people view them when someone walks up and asks them publicly to cut out what they are doing this actually teaches them through social interaction to not do it again. It is kind of like trying to stop a teen aged kid from doing something by cutting him off of something like the internet but not telling him you did it, well fine but as soon as he gets away he will do what ever. Jammers are cop outs. If you have a major problem with someones behavior strap on a pair and ask them to be polite, don't sit there with your tail in bettween your legs from far away activating your jammer. There are hundreds of places where I see people doing something rude, talking on the phone or to others in a place that should be quiet, cutting in lines, and if it is important enough for you to care then it should be important enough for you to say something. I see signs up all over stating that cell phones are not allowed and I see the people in these places too sissy to enforce that rule. Now I hear they are jamming signals. Anything at all at any risk to avoid being an adult now days I guess.

Stop with the extreme statements please. You are not putting anyones life in danger by operating a jammer. That situation would be sub 1% if it could even be measured at all.

That said, we have tried to teach people to be polite for years now. Places have signs up, people have been called out and in my place people literally get charged $25 if they answer their phone during a meeting. Yet people continue to simply not learn. Honestly I think you are heavily overestimating the intelligence of most people and giving them more credit for courtesy then they deserve. All of the above have failed miserably for years basically everywhere. It is time to try something different and Jammers seem to be the only guaranteed results solution being offered right now. Sorry but when you are in certain places, access to your cell phone is not an inherit right.
 
Stop with the extreme statements please. You are not putting anyones life in danger by operating a jammer. That situation would be sub 1% if it could even be measured at all.

That said, we have tried to teach people to be polite for years now. Places have signs up, people have been called out and in my place people literally get charged $25 if they answer their phone during a meeting. Yet people continue to simply not learn. Honestly I think you are heavily overestimating the intelligence of most people and giving them more credit for courtesy then they deserve. All of the above have failed miserably for years basically everywhere. It is time to try something different and Jammers seem to be the only guaranteed results solution being offered right now. Sorry but when you are in certain places, access to your cell phone is not an inherit right.

It’s not a life/limb issue. Commercial entities pay the FCC huge sums of money for unfettered access. The FCC has the legal obligation to protect that access.

With unlicensed devices, as defined and utilized by Annex K of the NTIA manual, "mutual" interference by like items (ISM, Part 15, 92) is acceptable but no one has the right over another to operate over another. So I can’t maliciously interfere or try to locally regulate unlicensed operations (ie I can charge you to use my wi-fi spot but if I am airport I can’t prohibit you from operating a wi-fi spot.)

To be frank would I like to see some usage? For school teachers and prisons it makes some sense.
 
It’s not a life/limb issue. Commercial entities pay the FCC huge sums of money for unfettered access. The FCC has the legal obligation to protect that access.

With unlicensed devices, as defined and utilized by Annex K of the NTIA manual, "mutual" interference by like items (ISM, Part 15, 92) is acceptable but no one has the right over another to operate over another. So I can’t maliciously interfere or try to locally regulate unlicensed operations (ie I can charge you to use my wi-fi spot but if I am airport I can’t prohibit you from operating a wi-fi spot.)

To be frank would I like to see some usage? For school teachers and prisons it makes some sense.

Actually as a private entity you could prohibit access to anything you don't want. That access only applies to public spaces, not private.

That said, schools yes. I disagree with prisons though as Cops use secure cell phones as well as radios that jammers can interfere with. Jamming in a prison is more detrimental to the staff then anything.

Now here is my thoughts though. IF you are going to operate a jamming device in any kind of environment, there must be a Land line alternative available in case of emergency. For example in our environment yes cell phones are jammed, but there are 2 land line phones in the room not to mention a receptionist that handles all incoming calls and directs them appropriately. Like I said though for us everything was tried and everything failed. The people we deal with just flat out don't care. Now bear in mind this place is full of A type personalities, so while these means might stop a normal person. This group is just going to do how they please everyone else be damned. If you can think of another solution, believe me I am all ears.
 
I have seen alot of cases in person and TBH every time it does not work I can blame it squarely on enforcement. Obvoisly I cannot go check out your case Dekoth. A local high school near me takes phones away if you are not paying attention or disturbing class. On the second offense a parent must pick the phone up the student cannot on the third offense the parent is asked not to allow the student to bring the phone to school anymore. I do not know anyone who has made it to the third offense yet. You are a teacher kick the idiot out of class if it so bad. Also have you considered the laughable hypocracy of a teacher trying for force people to be polite by breaking the law?

The air waves are not bound by anything whatever you do has a gradient effect on the quality of signal around you. The reason the FCC exist is to make sure that one company or person does not try to cause trouble by jamming another companies signal or boosting their signal to much higher levels to out run competition, or even that a company does not accidentally create interference. They do this for the good of us all to provide us with a good signal and fair use of wireless devices. When you use a jammer you are interfering with this signal and degrading the over all quality for everyone. Start multiplying that up as more and more people take your mentality and you can see where it is headed. Many things many more than just cell phones that teen agers use operate on these frequencies, I have a wireless credit card processor that does this. Outside your room it is possible that people with 1 or 2 bars can no longer get a signal, also most cell phones tune the power of their radio so if they cannot connect to a tower they increase the power if a jammer blocks this then you could get much more interference as all the cell phones in the room and ones near by boost their signal to compensate.

It is one of those things that has a compounding negative effect, while I realize you will probably never change your mind it is just not worth it.
 
Zarathustra[H];1036845965 said:
My AT&T service has been pretty spotless. I think it gets a worse rap than it deserves.

In certain markets though (notably NYC) service is reportedly rather poor.

It's crap in my area, so much so that they gave me a MicroCell for free. I can at least make and receive calls from in my house now.
 
No, I simply bought the correct sized one. They do come in varying ranges and you can with little effort purchase one that covers the exact area you need too and nothing more.

We have land lines in the building for emergency purposes.

I am sure all the people with lives, families, children, etc have had time to notify everyone those land line numbers for emergencies rather then just give them their cell number, right? It's not just outbound calls to 911 people are talking about, inbound calls too.
 
I am sure all the people with lives, families, children, etc have had time to notify everyone those land line numbers for emergencies rather then just give them their cell number, right? It's not just outbound calls to 911 people are talking about, inbound calls too.

For these purposes we managed just fine before every 2 year old had a smartphone pocket in their diapers.

I'm sure we'll be fine without it today as well.
 
Does the US military use this technology with IEDs use in Afganistan/Iraq? I'm sure they can make a larger range jammer.

Most IED are very simple hard wired devises triggered by a close local operator or trigger such as a pressure plate, some are triggered by cell/pager most are not.


I would love a cell phone jammer for my motorcycle and car, hay buddy, stfu and get off the phone and watch the road.
 
I have seen alot of cases in person and TBH every time it does not work I can blame it squarely on enforcement. Obvoisly I cannot go check out your case Dekoth. A local high school near me takes phones away if you are not paying attention or disturbing class. On the second offense a parent must pick the phone up the student cannot on the third offense the parent is asked not to allow the student to bring the phone to school anymore. I do not know anyone who has made it to the third offense yet. You are a teacher kick the idiot out of class if it so bad. Also have you considered the laughable hypocracy of a teacher trying for force people to be polite by breaking the law?

The air waves are not bound by anything whatever you do has a gradient effect on the quality of signal around you. The reason the FCC exist is to make sure that one company or person does not try to cause trouble by jamming another companies signal or boosting their signal to much higher levels to out run competition, or even that a company does not accidentally create interference. They do this for the good of us all to provide us with a good signal and fair use of wireless devices. When you use a jammer you are interfering with this signal and degrading the over all quality for everyone. Start multiplying that up as more and more people take your mentality and you can see where it is headed. Many things many more than just cell phones that teen agers use operate on these frequencies, I have a wireless credit card processor that does this. Outside your room it is possible that people with 1 or 2 bars can no longer get a signal, also most cell phones tune the power of their radio so if they cannot connect to a tower they increase the power if a jammer blocks this then you could get much more interference as all the cell phones in the room and ones near by boost their signal to compensate.

It is one of those things that has a compounding negative effect, while I realize you will probably never change your mind it is just not worth it.

The situation I personally deal with is as follows;
I am not a teacher, I am an IT manager. I voluntarily teach technology classes to our clients. These clients are real estate agents so while they work here, they do not work for us. They pay us to use our space. As such taking their phones away from them is simply a non option. However they are all willing to accept that the training room simply is a "Dead space". Long story short, it stopped all the conflict we had over phones being used interrupting everyone else without a word of complaint. Every other thing we tried resulted in complaining and fighting. One would think that grown adults, especially adults who earn 6 and 7 figure incomes would be able to act accordingly, one would be wrong for thinking that sadly.

Is it hypocritical? Likely it is, but it is the only reasonable solution I was able to find to a touchy situation. Like I said, if anyone has a better solution by all means let me know.

I am sure all the people with lives, families, children, etc have had time to notify everyone those land line numbers for emergencies rather then just give them their cell number, right? It's not just outbound calls to 911 people are talking about, inbound calls too.

The below quote beat me too it. Because so many people died before everyone and their brothers sisters aunts cousin had a cell phone available at all times. :rolleyes:

Yes that was sarcasm. The sense of entitlement people seem to get with their phones is just astounding.

Zarathustra[H];1036846324 said:
For these purposes we managed just fine before every 2 year old had a smartphone pocket in their diapers.

I'm sure we'll be fine without it today as well.
 
At first, I'm all for cell phone jammers pre-installed on vehicles. But then, after giving it serious consideration, I realized it would cause more problems than it's worth. Imagine if you will dumbass #1 driving along and hitting your dead-spot while he's having a conversation with his mistress. Oops... call dropped, gotta call her back (takes eyes off road and hands of wheel to dial...). I'm sure you can see where this is going.
 
They're probably not allowed to due to the FCC.. :eek:

In all fairness, we can't allow the prevention of religious expression. Jihadists have just as many rights to the airwaves as a 16-yo girl in the movie theatre or a celebrity on an airplane.:rolleyes:
 
It wouldn't be so great when somebody in that theater goes into cardiac arrest and nobody can call 911...

For most of human existence there have been no cell phones. If all cell phones disappeared from the Earth, life would be more relaxed for most of us.
 
Actually as a private entity you could prohibit access to anything you don't want. That access only applies to public spaces, not private.

Interesting point! Thinking this through, it depends on what is defined as private. I can see this going several different ways.
 
The below quote beat me too it. Because so many people died before everyone and their brothers sisters aunts cousin had a cell phone available at all times. :rolleyes:

Yes that was sarcasm. The sense of entitlement people seem to get with their phones is just astounding.

Oh please you might as well go back to the prehistoric days of no phones or mass communication, when letters had to be carried by ship to the Americas and claim people didnt need cell phones then and dont now. After all you should expect that letter stating a family emergency to take 6+ months to get there.

The world has evolved. It has changed. Wake up smell the coffee. When I was a kid I knew the phone numbers to both parents jobs. We dont give that info out to our families anymore because of the effectiveness of cell phones.

Further just because you disagree with what I am saying and why I am saying it does not make it OK for you to put me into the camp of so called entitled people who are so often rude and inconsiderate with their personal technology. I agree on that point. People are loud mouthed jerks. They are rude everywhere. Eating, movies, air travel, etc. Take a look at Google, this next generation is flagged already as being ego-centric and having expectations of immediate gratification.

My point is that you (thats the generic second person you) dont have the ethical right to make a decision for another person about when and where their personal technology and communication is available and working.

Just because you think that people should know and give out the phone numbers of each and every place they work, take a class, watch a movie and eat food, to each and every one of their friends and relatives in case of emergency does not make it right for you to take away their phone access.

The world has marched on. Get with it or start practicing yelling "get off my lawn."
 
I know a guy who has one of the military jammers. He goes to all kinds of military auctions and buys some serious hardware. I highly doubt he can legally have some of the stuff he has. I don't know the specifics of the device but from what he says his jammer apparently makes him a rolling dead zone in his truck. No cell phone, no radar guns, no speed cameras, no gps, etc. Considering I've seen a few of the things that he possesses, I'll take his word for it.
 
For most of human existence there have been no cell phones. If all cell phones disappeared from the Earth, life would be more relaxed for most of us.

For most of human existence there were no computers. Throw yours out the window right now.
 
Oh please you might as well go back to the prehistoric days of no phones or mass communication, when letters had to be carried by ship to the Americas and claim people didnt need cell phones then and dont now. After all you should expect that letter stating a family emergency to take 6+ months to get there.

The world has evolved. It has changed. Wake up smell the coffee. When I was a kid I knew the phone numbers to both parents jobs. We dont give that info out to our families anymore because of the effectiveness of cell phones.

Further just because you disagree with what I am saying and why I am saying it does not make it OK for you to put me into the camp of so called entitled people who are so often rude and inconsiderate with their personal technology. I agree on that point. People are loud mouthed jerks. They are rude everywhere. Eating, movies, air travel, etc. Take a look at Google, this next generation is flagged already as being ego-centric and having expectations of immediate gratification.

My point is that you (thats the generic second person you) dont have the ethical right to make a decision for another person about when and where their personal technology and communication is available and working.

Just because you think that people should know and give out the phone numbers of each and every place they work, take a class, watch a movie and eat food, to each and every one of their friends and relatives in case of emergency does not make it right for you to take away their phone access.

The world has marched on. Get with it or start practicing yelling "get off my lawn."

Your assumptions that I have an objection to technology are amusing. I live off my smart phone, there is just a time and place where it is inappropriate to use. Read some of my previous posts if you want more detail.

In my domain when I am taking my personal time to offer information, it is Absolutely my right to deny those in my environment phone access. If they don't like it they are more then welcome to go to a community college and pay $1500 for a class that will teach them out of date worthless information instead of getting mine for free. My only charge of admission? Your total undivided attention for a scant 1 hour per week.

If university professors can ban laptops from their classrooms, then it is well within my rights to ban cellphones. Since I can't physically ban them, I use the option to prevent their operation.

/Old man voice

Get off Mah Lawn!
 
Docs, EMT, volunteer fire-fighters all go to the movies.

(I'm not any of the above)

My wife and I got dirty looks one Valentine's when we got a phone call in the movies, until we both got up and left and didn't come back. Child had become violently ill, and one of the care-takers was immune-system compromised.

Real life happens.
 
Great both ways.
That's what she said.

Other than that, businesses need to have more balls kicking abusive customers out. Just like technology isn't a substitute for parenting technology shouldn't be a substitute for growing a set.
 
there are more cons than benefits.

sure, it's a nuisance in a theater. But it's easier to tell a person sternly to "shut that shit off !"

i'm sure every rapist would love to have one of these in the toolbox.

I've had one in my rape kit for years!!!!!
 
If I ever see a cell phone jammer, I'm going to smash it into flinders, and perhaps burn the person who owns it alive.
 
That's what she said.

Other than that, businesses need to have more balls kicking abusive customers out. Just like technology isn't a substitute for parenting technology shouldn't be a substitute for growing a set.

++++++1!

aaaaand BRB, UPS w/new cell phone jammer FTW!
 
Noooooooooooo!!!

I was telling someone literally in Decemeber that I was going to order a huge box JUST BECAUSE OF THIS. DAMNIT, DAMNIT. I was going to get me a whole box of preban and resell them but I don't think it will be legal, now with this happening, no? Amazon hasn't had them for a while, or at least the ones I saw for the lowwwww price.

Gotta check my outlet, I can get them for under $50 a piece shipped :D ,,,,,,China man please be in business still! :D

(Yessss... I still have them in stock for me, ordering ASAP :D ))
 
Most IED are very simple hard wired devises triggered by a close local operator or trigger such as a pressure plate, some are triggered by cell/pager most are not.


I would love a cell phone jammer for my motorcycle and car, hay buddy, stfu and get off the phone and watch the road.
Does the US military use this technology with IEDs use in Afganistan/Iraq? I'm sure they can make a larger range jammer.

Actually, they do use short range radio devices as well for IEDs in Iraq/Afghanistan/Pakistan/etc.

One very, very popular one is garage door openers as they are typically made in China for less than $10 and are used worldwide so they are easy to find. Those and cell phones are the most commonly used.

And to counter-act this, most new coalition vehicles traveling dirty roads have this special radio device that sends out EVERY RADIO signal it possibly can to set off the IEDs before the terrorists can trigger them. Pressure plates seem to be becoming more popular as well, but sometimes fail more often from stuff ive seen on liveleak the past 4 years.

----

And to the people above claiming these are bad... there are literally tracking devices being sold in stores now, including walmart and radio shack. $100 and $20 a month and anyone can track your every movement.

THESE TRACKERS ARE BEING USED DAILY BY POLICE, so therefor, these jammers should be legal just as much as guns should be legal. It's my privilage and right to be able to defend myself from unknown tracking devices...... and it DOES NOT block but 30 feet in radius around my person so I would not be interfering with anyone but maybe the cars or people directly next to a device. You guys are acting like the device is going to block police and EMS for a mile, no they are NOT that strong at all.... 50 feet max radius depending on the jamming device!
 
Really? Students in k-12 need cellphone access??? What ever did people do before 2002?

K-12 is NOT a place for cellphones and they should be handled just like any other disruptive toy in the class room.

If it makes you feel better I took away 2 cell phones today and have taken away 7 the last 1.5 weeks. The problem is with the teachers who choose to turn a blind eye and not enforce the rules. I have only taken away about 11 all year, this week has just been crazy to have 7 in 1.5 week.

I have walked into classrooms as a sub where teachers are talking and almost all the students are playing on their phone/game system or whatever.

Not in my classroom :p
 
I know few people that have the portable versions of these that take them with them when they go out and eat or just in the car. They turn them on when they come in the building to eat and turn it off when they leave.

Is it asinine Yes! Do they have to listen to other people scream into their phone...No!

Also I have a friend that keeps his in his truck and only uses it when some stupid teenybopper or idiot on the road is talking\texting on their phone and not paying attention to the road. He'll flip it on and drop their signal. He seems to get quite a smile out of getting people off the phone to pay attention to the road. Once again not very ethical but there's nothing I can do about it.

It would be nice to have one for reasons like above though lol. He said he got it off ebay for 10-20 bux and it was shipped out of China.
 
Your assumptions that I have an objection to technology are amusing. I live off my smart phone, there is just a time and place where it is inappropriate to use. Read some of my previous posts if you want more detail.

In my domain when I am taking my personal time to offer information, it is Absolutely my right to deny those in my environment phone access. If they don't like it they are more then welcome to go to a community college and pay $1500 for a class that will teach them out of date worthless information instead of getting mine for free. My only charge of admission? Your total undivided attention for a scant 1 hour per week.

If university professors can ban laptops from their classrooms, then it is well within my rights to ban cellphones. Since I can't physically ban them, I use the option to prevent their operation.

/Old man voice

Get off Mah Lawn!

Your taking time to teach anyone anything does not grant you any special rights or privileges. It is pure arrogance and ego-centric entitlement, just the same entitlement you claim is wrong in others when using their personal property in a way you disagree with.

I would like to see your source that university teachers can ban laptops from class. I went back and got a degree a few years ago and took my laptop, and in some cases, a printer, to class and not one teacher cared. I further would be willing to state that in no collage a teacher can 100% ban personal computers. Yes they can bad disruptive behavior, not blanket ban computers.

You do understand, if it is ok and ethically right for you to ban people, at your whim, because they dont pay you attention in class or for whatever reason, then it must be ok for anyone at any time to ban any cellphone use or for that matter any behavior they feel is inappropriate, drinking, porn, 'R' movies, many books, masturbation (look at the history books it has been tried), and well anything anyone finds objectionably anywhere.
 
Back
Top