FCC Cracking Down on Cell Phone Jammers

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The FCC is putting retailers on notice about selling the popular cell phone jammer through their outlets. The FCC wanted to make it clear to the retailers that such devices are strictly illegal. Major sales outlets such as Amazon and Target have received notification, as well as manufacturers of the devices.

Cell-phone jammers have become popular devices in theaters and restaurants in some cities in an effort to create a quiet and non-disruptive environment for customers.
 
Apparently, the nobody from the FCC has been to any of those theaters or restaurants.
 
Good. While disruptive people are annoying, a future of random dead spots everywhere is not the solution.
 
Apparently, the nobody from the FCC has been to any of those theaters or restaurants.

Theaters? Understandable. Restaurants? I have never been disturbed in a restaurant by a cell phone. Not sure what your issue is there.
 
About a year ago I had a client whose WiFi was knocked out for a good two days. Not until they started complaining their cell phones and cordless phones were out as well did we figure things out..

Walked next door to the social services office and asked them if they were having any problems. Lady answers the door saying their cordless phones haven't worked since they installed a cell phone jammer to block the young offenders' cell phones.. :rolleyes:

Lol.. So I tell her their cell jammer is disrupting our WiFi, cell phones, and cordless phones.. A look of shock came across her face and she said (and I'm not kidding) "You mean, it goes through the walsl too?"..

Yeah..

Riley
 
Theaters? Understandable. Restaurants? I have never been disturbed in a restaurant by a cell phone. Not sure what your issue is there.

Well, someone on the phone should be no more disruptive than someone talking to the person at their table. It's the numbskulls we all know who yell into phones unnecessarily that irritate people in restaurants I think.
 
there are more cons than benefits.

sure, it's a nuisance in a theater. But it's easier to tell a person sternly to "shut that shit off !"

i'm sure every rapist would love to have one of these in the toolbox.
 
I got to play with one for a few days and never turned it on for extended periods of time. I found it more useful for cutting off calls when people got to noisy, and even then I only felt it was appropriate once in a theater when a girl was squealing about something right behind me during the movie.
 
ahahaha.

it looks like everyone else wasn't in on the joke.
they're just sitting there helpless........ and that is the problem- people are too passive.

Yeah, thats why I like it. Supposedly, he just goes to random places, so you're seeing the reactions of people that have no idea whats going on. There was only one, I think it was the park one, where someone told him to "shut the fuck up", but that was as far as it went.

Its gotten so bad that when I hear someone shout "hey" I don't even turn around anymore, because 9 out of 10 times, its some idiot yelling on a cellphone.
 
Jammers that use radio may be illegal, but audio white noise generators are not.. You can still hear your phone, still send and receive texts, but the people on the other end of the call will just have a hell of a time understanding you should you attempt a conversation.

In truth I am for putting up signs saying that cell phone usage in a certain place is unacceptable, and that people that don't get it will be asked to leave. And then of course actually enforcing it. Places like theaters, recitals, and the like are places for such signs and enforcement.
 
It wouldn't be so great when somebody in that theater goes into cardiac arrest and nobody can call 911...
 
Theaters? Understandable. Restaurants? I have never been disturbed in a restaurant by a cell phone. Not sure what your issue is there.

I have, and it's a fucking peace destroying nightmare. There is something about talking on a phone that jacks up the talker's volume, and steers the conversation to either stupid or disgusting areas. Like the fat fuck retard (and I'm a fat fuck so you skinnies don't get you panties twisted) who proceeded to tell his phone how his bowel medication wasn't helping and was causing symptoms that I DIDN'T WANT TO HEAR ABOUT WHILE EATING.:mad:

there are more cons than benefits.

sure, it's a nuisance in a theater. But it's easier to tell a person sternly to "shut that shit off !"

i'm sure every rapist would love to have one of these in the toolbox.

Are you fucking serious?:confused: Setting aside the rapist comment- haven't you been to a theater where it isn't just one person sitting right next to you, it's 4 to 6 scattered throughout the theater, and that's talking. Never mind the 12 others who think they are being polite because they're txting and not talking.:rolleyes: Yeah, in a dark theater your fucking flashlight of a phone and the loud assed "clickity clickity clickity" doesn't disturb me in the least.:rolleyes:

people who talk or txt in a theater are going to the "Special Hell", so sayth the Shepard.:mad:
 
About a year ago I had a client whose WiFi was knocked out for a good two days. Not until they started complaining their cell phones and cordless phones were out as well did we figure things out..

Walked next door to the social services office and asked them if they were having any problems. Lady answers the door saying their cordless phones haven't worked since they installed a cell phone jammer to block the young offenders' cell phones.. :rolleyes:

Lol.. So I tell her their cell jammer is disrupting our WiFi, cell phones, and cordless phones.. A look of shock came across her face and she said (and I'm not kidding) "You mean, it goes through the walsl too?"..

Yeah..

Riley
After they took down the jammer I would have been on the phone to the FCC.
 
Jammers that use radio may be illegal, but audio white noise generators are not.. You can still hear your phone, still send and receive texts, but the people on the other end of the call will just have a hell of a time understanding you should you attempt a conversation.

Not entirely correct. Although a white noise generator used for personal use in blocking out sound (ie headphones) is legal; a white noise generator used for the purpose that you mentioned would be illegal.

"It is unlawful for any person to willfully or maliciously interfere..."

The means does not matter.

The specific laws that cover this are United States (See Section 302(b) of the Communications Act, 47 USC § 302a(b) and Section 2.803(a) of the FCC's rules, 47 CFR § 2.803(a)) and section 333 of the Communications Act, 47 USC § 333). Further, Section 301 of the Act, 47 USC § 301.
 
Not entirely correct. Although a white noise generator used for personal use in blocking out sound (ie headphones) is legal; a white noise generator used for the purpose that you mentioned would be illegal.

"It is unlawful for any person to willfully or maliciously interfere..."

The means does not matter.

The specific laws that cover this are United States (See Section 302(b) of the Communications Act, 47 USC § 302a(b) and Section 2.803(a) of the FCC's rules, 47 CFR § 2.803(a)) and section 333 of the Communications Act, 47 USC § 333). Further, Section 301 of the Act, 47 USC § 301.

simple: implement noise pollution laws.
 
It wouldn't be so great when somebody in that theater goes into cardiac arrest and nobody can call 911...

So theaters are too stupid to have a land line?:rolleyes:
I would love to have one for "date" nights...:)
Where do you buy one?
 
Theaters? Understandable. Restaurants? I have never been disturbed in a restaurant by a cell phone. Not sure what your issue is there.

Agree most restaurants are noisy other then the candle lit ones.
 
People are inconsiderate pricks..period. While I can understand enforcement of public areas I disagree that the FCC can regulate private areas. These jammers don't have an unlimited range after all and the 911 comments can be largely ignored since you usually only need walk 10-20 feet away from the source.

I teach technology classes in private offices and the people in these offices simply don't understand the concept of turning off their damned phones. You can damn well bet that I have a signal jammer that kills anything in that room. Anything outside said room is just fine.
 
Jammers that use radio may be illegal, but audio white noise generators are not.. You can still hear your phone, still send and receive texts, but the people on the other end of the call will just have a hell of a time understanding you should you attempt a conversation.

So instead of them having their conversation and getting it over with it goes something like this:

"WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU CAN'T HEAR ME?"

"WHAT?!"

"HOLD ON LET ME CALL YOU RIGHT BACK."

Severe annoyance.
 
I would love to have one.

I think anyone under the age of about 27 where i live has no concept of not using a cell phone at the movie's

pisses me off to no end.

I once about ejected a kid out of his seat, dude in front of me felt the need to text opening night for transformers 2

10 mins into the movie he starts texting
does so for about 10 mins

I wanted to rip is phone out of his hand, rather i kicked the back of his chair as hard as i could, he almost flew into the row in front of him. not once did i see his cell phone again the rest of the movie.

dude was prolly 17-20 I at the time was 31

I try to be super selective on when I go to the movies now.

anyways I want a jammer now seems like a great idea
 
Heck yeah, i'm all for jamming theatres and public schools. Stupid people aren't getting any less stupid, might as well make use of technology to work around them. Other than those two areas I don't see any good use of them.
 
i have a battery powered 30ft jammer.... and i teach in a public high school. I use it for the first couple days and all the students are pissed that they dont get service in my room.. after that i dont even really need to use it because they all just keep their phones in their bags or pockets.

I wish they were legal. We have real phones that actually call the real, local, 911 that knows where you are rather than a regional, busy, 911 location.

it would be great for their to be jammers in each classroom that are on when class is in and then turn off when the bell rings...

would be easy enough to setup. then have a master switch for an "emergency"

but really, in an emergency the school phones are a better choice than a cell phone to use for 911
 
The problem with jammers is they prevent any incoming emergency calls. Until they can leave the txt lines open for incoming txts, the tech is a fail IMHO. There are things far more important in life than a cheezy, POS, hollywood flick. BUT, I'm all for instant removal (without refund) of people who create noise in a theatre, of any sort, be it talking on the phone, talking to someone next to them, calling shit out to the sceen, etc. An incoming text to a phone on vibrate would bother no-one.
 
People are inconsiderate pricks..period. While I can understand enforcement of public areas I disagree that the FCC can regulate private areas. These jammers don't have an unlimited range after all and the 911 comments can be largely ignored since you usually only need walk 10-20 feet away from the source.

I teach technology classes in private offices and the people in these offices simply don't understand the concept of turning off their damned phones. You can damn well bet that I have a signal jammer that kills anything in that room. Anything outside said room is just fine.


Perhaps your jammer is a bit anemic, read up. Other people are reporting ones that go though walls. If they do that they can also cover streets.

I do find people are inconsiderate using their phones and understand wanting to be able to jam them.

I know if I am not getting a signal I'll walk, provided I'm not the one having the heart attack,
or have a broken leg, or any of other reasons that jamming could cause serious injury or death.

Yes, the odds of it happening to me or you is low, with a world population of close to 7 billion and a US population around 310 million, those one in a million chances have a habit of happening.

A business may well have a land line, many residents no longer have one. I dont want to have to deal with one of my neighbors jamming my phone, because the kids on the other side of him are obnoxious, etc.

There are places, like correctional facilities that, with clear notification, can and should jam however.

I have a question though, is it because you are teaching that you believe you have the right to take away someone else's access to using their phone? I hope none f those people have sick children at home, or have a kid that gets into an accident at school, or grandma just went into the hospital and probably wont make it, or any number of other of life's unplanned moments. You could end up sued or in jail.
 
Be an interesting experiment to put one in your pocket and visit a local college or mall. I bet you develop an invisible forcefield around you as people walk around trying to find a signal.
 
Hrm. This is an interesting issue that I need to give more thought. I think I take the following position:
  • Prohibiting sale of jammers is a heavy-handed position, and the FCC should screw off (and disband ;)).
  • If you use a jammer off your own property (or it affects someone else off your property), you're basically attacking someone else (or multiple people) through your communications sabotage. This should be at least a civil offense.
  • If you're a theater/restaurant/homeowner annoyed with his chatty and grounded teenage girl, actually using a jammer on your personal property should be legal (assuming the jamming doesn't extend beyond your property)...but in many cases, it's probably a bad idea. As others have said, there are things far more important than a quiet dining experience or the latest popcorn flick.
 
Perhaps your jammer is a bit anemic, read up. Other people are reporting ones that go though walls. If they do that they can also cover streets.

I do find people are inconsiderate using their phones and understand wanting to be able to jam them.

I know if I am not getting a signal I'll walk, provided I'm not the one having the heart attack,
or have a broken leg, or any of other reasons that jamming could cause serious injury or death.

Yes, the odds of it happening to me or you is low, with a world population of close to 7 billion and a US population around 310 million, those one in a million chances have a habit of happening.

A business may well have a land line, many residents no longer have one. I dont want to have to deal with one of my neighbors jamming my phone, because the kids on the other side of him are obnoxious, etc.

There are places, like correctional facilities that, with clear notification, can and should jam however.

I have a question though, is it because you are teaching that you believe you have the right to take away someone else's access to using their phone? I hope none f those people have sick children at home, or have a kid that gets into an accident at school, or grandma just went into the hospital and probably wont make it, or any number of other of life's unplanned moments. You could end up sued or in jail.

No, I simply bought the correct sized one. They do come in varying ranges and you can with little effort purchase one that covers the exact area you need too and nothing more.

We have land lines in the building for emergency purposes.
 
I really want to install one of these in a few Apple stores. Must... fight... urge...
 
Theaters? Understandable. Restaurants? I have never been disturbed in a restaurant by a cell phone. Not sure what your issue is there.

I carry my cell to Church and have the decency to set it to vibrate so it won't be a disturbance. Of course there is always some idiot during the service who gets a call; his ring tone is AC/DC Back in Black set to LOUD then he will answer the phone and talk during the message. Putting up signs and messages on the LCD screens all over the place pleading for people to leave the cells off during the service has not worked. People are too self centered. :rolleyes:
 
Why not just take everyones phone off them and give them a coverless iphone? When they complain that they can't make calls just tell them they're holding it wrong.
 
Why the hell would you need them in the classroom? What is it somehow different now then it was 15 years ago? If the teacher didnt want you messing with something (anything) in class they took that shit and there was sometimes almost nothing you could do to get it back until the end of the school year or have your parent come get it. I know more have phones now but why the lack of authority on the teachers part?
 
Really? Students in k-12 need cellphone access??? What ever did people do before 2002?

K-12 is NOT a place for cellphones and they should be handled just like any other disruptive toy in the class room.
 
there are more cons than benefits.

sure, it's a nuisance in a theater. But it's easier to tell a person sternly to "shut that shit off !"

i'm sure every rapist would love to have one of these in the toolbox.

your first thought about these was how a rapist would use one.......wow.

anyhow, I love the ones you can carry around in your pocket, not that I would ever use one of those ;)
 
Does the US military use this technology with IEDs use in Afganistan/Iraq? I'm sure they can make a larger range jammer.
 
i have a battery powered 30ft jammer.... and i teach in a public high school. I use it for the first couple days and all the students are pissed that they dont get service in my room.. after that i dont even really need to use it because they all just keep their phones in their bags or pockets.

I wish they were legal. We have real phones that actually call the real, local, 911 that knows where you are rather than a regional, busy, 911 location.

it would be great for their to be jammers in each classroom that are on when class is in and then turn off when the bell rings...

would be easy enough to setup. then have a master switch for an "emergency"

but really, in an emergency the school phones are a better choice than a cell phone to use for 911

We had the opposite at my school. We rented out a tower on the roof to a GSM provider. For some reason we had really bad signal strength on CDMA phones. Don't know if it was related or not.
 
Good. While disruptive people are annoying, a future of random dead spots everywhere is not the solution.

I feel it should be legal, as long as you can guarantee the jammers/blockers only impact your own private property.
 
Back
Top