FAA to Test Electronic Gadget Interference Theory

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
For the last 20 years or so, the Federal Aviation Administration has enforced a ban on electronic device usage on takeoff and landings. (Just ask Alec Baldwin) :D The world is a constantly changing place and so too are the rules. Since iPads are now allowed in the cockpit and are carried as standard equipment on some airlines, the question of myth versus reality is about to be tested. Time to call on the MythBusters.

If the FAA's eventual testing demonstrates that the theory is bunk, maybe we'll soon be able to use our gadgets on takeoff and landing.
 
Mythbusters already did this, and found no interference from consumer devices. My issue would be people's attention, take offs and landings I would prefer if people were paying attention to their surroundings in the event of an emergency rather then watching their favorite movie on a mobile device with noise cancelling ear buds.
 
Mythbusters already did this, and found no interference from consumer devices. My issue would be people's attention, take offs and landings I would prefer if people were paying attention to their surroundings in the event of an emergency rather then watching their favorite movie on a mobile device with noise cancelling ear buds.

Even if they were paying attention, the majority of people would just panic in an emergency situation. Just slap the pure o2 mask on them to generate euphoria in that situation.
 
With the angle of the plane during takeoff, the only things that could be safely used is a handheld device. I think that a crash is more likely to happen during those periods, so it's a good idea to make everyone have their shit put away.
 
Mythbusters already did this, and found no interference from consumer devices. My issue would be people's attention, take offs and landings I would prefer if people were paying attention to their surroundings in the event of an emergency rather then watching their favorite movie on a mobile device with noise cancelling ear buds.

No it is because the FAA is overly paranoid. Now I don't entirely blame them, when it comes to air travel you want to error on the side of caution. However basically it really is a case of "Electronic devices can transmit signals, and these signals can in theory interfere with plane operation, so just enforce a blanket ban."

I'm also ok with the idea of let's test first before we allow it. Who knows, maybe there is something problematic we aren't aware of.

The only thing that annoys me is that the FAA has taken so long on this shit. This should have been done 15 years ago. Test, see if there's an issue, if there's no, rescind the ban.
 
I think Mythbusters did have one recorded interference, but wasn't it with a really old analog cell phone or something similar? I only vaguely remember that episode...
 
I love having my media (books) in E format, but it pisses me off that I can't use it when I need the distraction the most, take off and landing. FAA let me read please.
 
Mythbusters already did this, and found no interference from consumer devices. My issue would be people's attention, take offs and landings I would prefer if people were paying attention to their surroundings in the event of an emergency rather then watching their favorite movie on a mobile device with noise cancelling ear buds.

Quite frankly if there was an emergency then everyone would figure it out very quickly.. For a fuck ton of people though being distracted during take off & landing would make for a much better flight for everyone else on board..
 
Mythbusters already did this, and found no interference from consumer devices. My issue would be people's attention, take offs and landings I would prefer if people were paying attention to their surroundings in the event of an emergency rather then watching their favorite movie on a mobile device with noise cancelling ear buds.

Not a fan of mythbusters anymore. After doing scientific research in a lab for a short period of time, I learned quite a bit. Tto me, their methods and experiments are pretty lousy; their results aren't great either. It doesn't help either that none of them except for one guy are actual scientists or engineers.
 
Not a fan of mythbusters anymore. After doing scientific research in a lab for a short period of time, I learned quite a bit. Tto me, their methods and experiments are pretty lousy; their results aren't great either. It doesn't help either that none of them except for one guy are actual scientists or engineers.

And on top of that, they stretch out 30 minutes of questionable, yet somewhat entertaining, results to fill hour long programming. The dialog also feels about as natural as it does in a porno.
 
"Hi mum, meet me at the arrivals, we're about to land. Sorry, WE'RE ABOUT TO CRASH LAND, STUPID LANDING GEAR INTERFERING PHONE!!!"
 
Not a fan of mythbusters anymore. After doing scientific research in a lab for a short period of time, I learned quite a bit. Tto me, their methods and experiments are pretty lousy; their results aren't great either. It doesn't help either that none of them except for one guy are actual scientists or engineers.

It makes for good TV. That's it.
 
Modern Aviation gear is and should be hardened against efi/rfi. If a consumer level device is affecting a plane, there is something wrong with that plane.
 
Now they are testing this when every damn thing has wireless built-in. But back 10 years ago they would make you put up stuff like walkmans and cameras.....I never understood how those were going to interfere with the cockpit.
 
Now they are testing this when every damn thing has wireless built-in. But back 10 years ago they would make you put up stuff like walkmans and cameras.....I never understood how those were going to interfere with the cockpit.

Because if they said, "we want your devices put away so shit doesn't start flying in the event of a CRASH!" CRASH CRASH CRASH CRASH!
Some people would start freaking out.
 
Not a fan of mythbusters anymore. After doing scientific research in a lab for a short period of time, I learned quite a bit. Tto me, their methods and experiments are pretty lousy; their results aren't great either. It doesn't help either that none of them except for one guy are actual scientists or engineers.

I started watching Mythbusteres when it first aired in Australia several years back and liked it, but within a year I stopped watching it because it was just stupid. Even then as a year 11/12 student I had enough physics knowledge to realise not only do they have a terrible method for proving/disproving something, but their knowledge of basic physics is extremely lacking and they'd often draw conclusions using completely wrong assumptions and explanations. The number of times you see "This test will simulate X environment" and you think, err, no it doesn't, or "These things won't matter so we'll simplify it to this" and you think, ummm, actually those things may very well matter, or "The reason for this result is because of blah physics explanation" and you think, umm, no it isn't.

http://www.phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1156
 
Modern Aviation gear is and should be hardened against efi/rfi. If a consumer level device is affecting a plane, there is something wrong with that plane.

There is no logical counter to your argument. You win.
 
Meanwhile US pilots get approval to use iPads in the cockpit. Only to replace those heavy flight manuals mind you ;) . :confused:
 
Not a fan of mythbusters anymore. After doing scientific research in a lab for a short period of time, I learned quite a bit. Tto me, their methods and experiments are pretty lousy; their results aren't great either. It doesn't help either that none of them except for one guy are actual scientists or engineers.

You miss the point then. It is to get young people interested in science. They have done numerous interviews stating that.
 
You miss the point then. It is to get young people interested in science. They have done numerous interviews stating that.

I appreciate that, but I don't see any excuse for not having an engineer or something to run through an episode to tell them where they're blatantly using incorrect physics :p Just because your target audience is young people doesn't mean you should teach them the wrong things, lol.
 
I wonder if the FAA is more concerned about savvy users with laptops hacking into the plane's control than wireless interference. Nothing like walking down the aisle from the bathroom, and seeing a kid on his laptop..

"Hey, Microsoft Flight Simulator looks so realistic!"

"This ain't a simulator mister. Watch this!"

*banks hard to starboard*
 
they might test it, but they wont change the rules

if it aint broke, dont fix it and bureaucracy and red tape will make sure that will reign.
 
I wonder if the FAA is more concerned about savvy users with laptops hacking into the plane's control than wireless interference. Nothing like walking down the aisle from the bathroom, and seeing a kid on his laptop..

"Hey, Microsoft Flight Simulator looks so realistic!"

"This ain't a simulator mister. Watch this!"

*banks hard to starboard*

lmao. Thanks, I needed this.

Its actually the FCC and FAA fought for not allowing electronics during taxi , takeoff and landing then taxi..neither Dept wanted to spend money on the research
 
Jesus, is this that big a deal that people have to whine about not being able to use their "gadgets on takeoff and landing. "
 
Here's how it will go.

1. FAA does study, finds no way for consumer equipment to reasonably affect the avionics regardless of what phase of the flight you are in.

2. FAA does another study after the first one is ridiculed for being too narrow. Now the study includes blenders and washing machines (which have to be specially made due to most planes running AC way over 60Hz), in addition to the previous studies mobile devices. This study costs 5... wait... 10 times more then the first. Both studies are paid for with tax revenue, ie. our money. Both come back clean.

3. FAA releases study results and gives airlines clearance to allow consumer devices where ever they see fit.

4. Airlines do studies to see how much it will cost to train employees, change notices in planes/terminals/literature. They decide this will cost too much, except Virgin, who will sell you the privilege on top of your first class ticket. The rest will slowly follow, and the inevitable trickle down ensues.

5. Eventually, something somewhere will happen to a plane, that may have been caused by some kind of interference, and the whole aviation industry will get sued for allowing people to use electronic devices during TO/L. This will set things back to where they are at present due to the epic public backlash. Of course, the incident will have been caused by pilot/mech failure, which we'll find out 6 months after the incident and all of the policies have been rolled back.


And yes, modern aircraft are exceptionally hardened against pretty much any interference you can expect to encounter at the low to mid altitudes they operate in. This is up to and including the hefty emi they encounter over the poles. Hell, they can be struck by lightning several times in a given flight without issue. However, trying to explain that to a layman is like trying to explain why a RJ45 splitter isn't just as good as a router. Or even better, why there is no 5 dollar converter from VGA do HDMI.
 
Back
Top