Does Netflix Have a Blu-ray Disc-Cracking Problem?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The Consumerist seems to think there might be a problem with Blu-ray discs cracking during the shipping process from Netflix. This problem has been discussed before but, at the time, not many of you were renting Blu-ray movies from Netflix. Since this seems to be an ongoing problem, I want to ask you guys if any of you have experienced this?

In better than 4 years we have had only ONE regular Netflix DVD arrive cracked, but with Blu Ray we've now have three arrive in just the last three weeks with this problem. I started asking around, and it seems like this is a growing problem. The Blu Ray hard coating actually seems to make the discs MORE susceptible to damage in transit.
 
I have only started to receive BR disks... probably 10 so far. None have been cracked. Though I will keep my eye out.
 
ive received over 100 blurays from netflix and not one of them has even had a scratch on them.. so where this cracking problem is i have no clue..
 
I've been receiving blu-ray since they started offering them and I've never had one cracked. I'm not sure why some people are having problems.
 
When we started two years a go we did not get any cracked disks. Then about 6 months ago we have received about 5 discs theat have been cracked. These are non Blue-rays.

I thinks its a postal sorting machine issue as, most mail is not handled by man anymore except at the beginning and the end of the process.

Have you tried to crack a cd? It bends an awful lot before it breaks.
 
Have you tried to crack a cd? It bends an awful lot before it breaks.
Can you say the same thing about Blu-ray disc? They may have a different construction. I don't feel like taking a change and bending one :D
 
I think about every 4th or 5th blu-ray disc i receive is cracked or unplayable. It's ridiculous.
 
I've been getting BRs for a little over a year and have never gotten a scratched one, let alone a broken one. Probably around 60-70 discs. BRs do bend before breaking but not as much as CDs/DVDs do.
 
I just tried to break a BD sample disk I had laying around, seemed to bend just as much as any CD/DVD.
 
We have had a couple with cracks. The biggest thing that we find is filthy disks that won't play until they are cleaned. Thats all we have seen.
 
ive received over 100 blurays from netflix and not one of them has even had a scratch on them.. so where this cracking problem is i have no clue..

2-5 discs per month for over a year, not a single one that was unplayable or damaged that I know of. That being said, Netflix's mailer is NOT liked by the Postal Service as the sorting machines don't like it. In fact, if I recall properly, didn't they receive an ultimatum to redesign their mailer or be forced to pay extra.

Yep, here it is.
 
I've been getting blu-rays for 2 years now on the 3 at a time plan and have only ever gotten 1 that wouldn't play properly (started skipping and hanging 3/4 through the movie) and it didn't have any visible damage. I've had to wipe fingerprints off of a couple but it's rare and never excessive. I've never kept track of how many we've gone through, but I'd say they're probably 75% BD and we watch 1-2 per week, so maybe 70-80 BD's in that timeframe?
 
Been getting BR discs from them since they started offering them. not one has come cracked.
 
There are a lot of factors that could cause this, perhaps a bad sorting machine, jammed sorting machines, temperatures, mailbox sizes, type of plastic used, mail handler, etc.

It's a little difficult to point this directly to bd disks without looking at all the other external factors.
 
I've personally only had two arrive cracked, haven't given it much thought, certainly nothing like the 13 out of 24 the article mentions.


HERE IS A THOUGHT:

Maybe it depends on the equipment being used at your local post office. Could explain why some people have had NO problems whatsoever while others have repeated issues.
 
Although I never got a Blu-Ray movie that was cracked, I have a somewhat similar problem: most of the damn movies I get from them now have a small label on the top inner track area around the hole, maybe 1/4 to 1/2". Might have the movie name and barcode on it. I guess it's to keep the disc from cracking from the inside out. Problem is that is causing the movies to act up. One would not play in THREE different Blu-Ray players. Anyone else have any issues like that?
 
I've personally only had two arrive cracked, haven't given it much thought, certainly nothing like the 13 out of 24 the article mentions.


HERE IS A THOUGHT:

Maybe it depends on the equipment being used at your local post office. Could explain why some people have had NO problems whatsoever while others have repeated issues.

This.

Or the people at the post office like to dump everything into a bin at once instead of bit by bit.

I could see 100lbs of mail getting dropped into a bin all at once causing problems.
 
Although I never got a Blu-Ray movie that was cracked, I have a somewhat similar problem: most of the damn movies I get from them now have a small label on the top inner track area around the hole, maybe 1/4 to 1/2". Might have the movie name and barcode on it. I guess it's to keep the disc from cracking from the inside out. Problem is that is causing the movies to act up. One would not play in THREE different Blu-Ray players. Anyone else have any issues like that?

Update your BR firmware. sounds more like you are running older versions of firmware.
 
I've personally only had two arrive cracked, haven't given it much thought, certainly nothing like the 13 out of 24 the article mentions.


HERE IS A THOUGHT:

Maybe it depends on the equipment being used at your local post office. Could explain why some people have had NO problems whatsoever while others have repeated issues.

i am going to guess local postal workers and/or equipment.

i swear i go months without getting a Maxim in the mail, then all of a sudden i get one. i don't care since it is a free subscription, and the magazine is completely stupid and only good for something to read while taking a massive shit.
 
HERE IS A THOUGHT:

Maybe it depends on the equipment being used at your local post office. Could explain why some people have had NO problems whatsoever while others have repeated issues.

That is exactly what I was thinking. I'd say the local sorting machine is the problem if some people report several while others report none. I imagine Netflix has a process to check and dispose of damaged discs when they return. I doubt the same damaged disc would go to multiple customers.
 
I haven't had any unusual post office issues. I have more issues with DVD's being too scratched so they don't play compared to being cracked.
 
It's because Netflix went back to machine sorting. It has nothing to do with the type of media. This used to happen quite a lot back in the early says with the DVDs too. I still get the occasional cracked disc, either Blu-Ray Disc or DVD.
 
I think it has a lot to do with the mail carrier and your post office. I was previously living in an apartment building in NYC and there would be stretches of time where the discs would be repeatedly cracked. Then, stretches of time with no problems whatsoever. After I moved to a different neighborhood, I have not had a single cracked disc, DVD or Blu-ray.
 
Update your BR firmware. sounds more like you are running older versions of firmware.

Latest firmware downloaded from the player from the net on all three different branded players. Not a firmware issue as the movies were confirmed to be playable on those brands by other people.
 
Never had a cracked bd from nf ever... In a year and a half...
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
I had 1 out of 8 Netflix Blu-rays arrive at my house without a crack. That's 7 out of 8 that were unplayable, and a complete waste of my time. Netflix's response? Bitch to the Postmaster.

Obviously, my postal station's equipment likes to crack Blu-rays, but what am I supposed to do about it? I can't switch my mail to another station. I had to drop the Blu-ray portion of my subscription, but I'd love to add it back.
 
Dont BD have a special feature to resist scratching? Maybe its this feature that is causeing the highnumber of cracked disks.
Those of you testing out the disks by bending them try bending them both ways as it will make a differance.

I have not yet started getting BD from netflix so I cant comment on that.
 
forget about the BR discs, why do my playboys come out of the plastic with stuck pages from the postoffice?
 
Dont BD have a special feature to resist scratching? Maybe its this feature that is causeing the highnumber of cracked disks.
Those of you testing out the disks by bending them try bending them both ways as it will make a differance.

I have not yet started getting BD from netflix so I cant comment on that.
that is for scratch resistance.
 
I blame Kyle for this ; )... Hardocp pushed Blu-Ray when it should have been championing the better technology HD-DVD. HD discs are much more resilient than the Blu-Ray's and they cost less to make as well.

:D
 
I've been doing blu-ray via the blockbuster equivalent to netflix for about a year.

Discussing this same subject on other boards, it seems that some disks just crack. They are manufactured in a sub standard manner or something and are brittle. You get small hairline cracks at the edge that are about 3/8" long.

I've also gotten blu-ray disks with no discernible damage that just won't play. It's not player updates as I'm using a PS3 that is on-line and patched regularly. I suspect it is the multi-layer substrate delaminating or something.

With DVDs, anything that might appeal to the 15-25 age group has about a 50-50 chance of looking like they tried to play the thing with a fork. Occasionally, they were cracked from the edge to the hole or had pieces broken off. My rate of bum disks is actually lower with blu-ray, but given how little damage it takes to put them out of commission, I'm not looking forward to them being the norm.
 
I have had 3 problems with Netflix in over two years of using them.

Last week the mail to me flap got torn off and UPS sent that to me in a plastic bag saying sorry and sent the dvd back to Netflix.

And I have had 1 cracked DVD and one DVD to badly scratched up to play (that was a kids movie and I could see how a bad parent could let their kid just get it scratched like that).
 
ive gotten BD disks that are unplayable but the surface seems perfect (maybe about 5 out of 100) but no cracked disks... when i request they send me another disk of the same movie that one has always been ok...

im more interested in knowing why the perfectly fine looking disks were unplayable
 
I've personally only had two arrive cracked, haven't given it much thought, certainly nothing like the 13 out of 24 the article mentions.


HERE IS A THOUGHT:

Maybe it depends on the equipment being used at your local post office. Could explain why some people have had NO problems whatsoever while others have repeated issues.

Same for me no cracked yet..I think the above might have more to do with it.
 
Back
Top