Documents Prove Samsung Did Not Copy Apple?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Groklaw has a rather lengthy article posted today that seems to prove that Samsung never instructed its employees to copy Apple. The article also covers the "biased" jury foreman and other aspects of the case. Make sure you refill your coffee before clicking the link.

"Be people with creativity", he told them. It's *others* who told him to make something like the iPhone, but he tells the designers instead to be creative. Muster up more strength, he says, and make something so easy to use it's like flowing water. He definitely didn't tell them to copy the iPhone, just to strive for quality.
 
I think this is kind of obvious.

Phone design has been my whole problem with these sort of cases because really, how many ways can you design a phone? I mean, are people like Samsung, HTC, Nokia, etc suppose to design round phones or triangular phones as to not copy Apples "rounded corners" or icon based OS layout?

This is like GE patenting the square design for microwave ovens...its like, you are going to reach that point where it has to be FEATURES that make products stand out more so than DESIGN. If companies were to take Apples approach then ALL auto manufactures, airplane manufacturers, shoe makers, appliance makers, etc, etc, etc would ALL be waging war with one another because MOST products look alike BECAUSE in essence they HAVE to! Goes back to my original point that there's only so many ways to design a certain product.
 
iFridge.png
 
"Be people with creativity", he told them. It's *others* who told him to make something like the iPhone, but he tells the designers instead to be creative. Muster up more strength, he says, and make something so easy to use it's like flowing water. He definitely didn't tell them to copy the iPhone, just to strive for quality.

Reminds me of this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LTnSEFsInp0
 
I think this is kind of obvious.

Phone design has been my whole problem with these sort of cases because really, how many ways can you design a phone? I mean, are people like Samsung, HTC, Nokia, etc suppose to design round phones or triangular phones as to not copy Apples "rounded corners" or icon based OS layout?

This is like GE patenting the square design for microwave ovens...its like, you are going to reach that point where it has to be FEATURES that make products stand out more so than DESIGN. If companies were to take Apples approach then ALL auto manufactures, airplane manufacturers, shoe makers, appliance makers, etc, etc, etc would ALL be waging war with one another because MOST products look alike BECAUSE in essence they HAVE to! Goes back to my original point that there's only so many ways to design a certain product.

I think Samsung should put out a phone in the shape of a 2D Apple with a bite taken out of it. :D
 
considering apple has been suing anyone with an apple in its logo don't know how that would work... :p
 
Should have included more info there. That's the Braun 1958 T3 Pocket Radio. Apple has no business whatsoever suing anyone over design. They have no grounds at all considering.
 
And? That still doesn't get past the fact that Apple did it first. Pot calling the kettle black.
 
I still think Samsung deserved the majority of the judgement for their shameless touchwiz iOS ripoff. Wasnt the hardware a relatively small part of the overall judgement?
 
I won't argue the validity of the software. But being able to patent that rounded corner design is just plain asinine.
 
I still think Samsung deserved the majority of the judgement for their shameless touchwiz iOS ripoff. Wasnt the hardware a relatively small part of the overall judgement?

I'm pretty sure a majority of the decision was on the patent for rectangle design with rounded corners....I could be wrong though.
 
The most fascinating part for me was the information about the head juror. He seemed to have an axe to grind.
 
How can Samsung prove that they did NOT copy Apple?

They can prove that their design supervisor directed them to come up with a new design, but there's no way to prove a negative...

Pedantic, I know, but this whole saga has gotten so ridiculous that it just needs to be over.
 
I still think Samsung deserved the majority of the judgement for their shameless touchwiz iOS ripoff. Wasnt the hardware a relatively small part of the overall judgement?

software patent is garbage! They even said apple owns the phone icon and gear icon and the way its lined up in rows. You look at everything apple "invented", it's been done before and on other platforms.

But i guess your like jury foremen and believe that if its on another processor patents aren't interchangeable unless its an apple patent. :rolleyes:
 
There were some aspects of the OS of Samsung phones that were very close to the iOS design. Don't mind the judgement on those. Others were just so out there, and so common among most, if not all, smart phones, that it doesn't make sense that a patent would be issued in the first place.
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.

Apple will be history before long as it is only a matter of time before their bubble collapses. Android devices are more affordable and offer a superior, vastly more customizable and flexible operating system that respects the users freedom and does not force you to use a walled garden. Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

Apple realizes this and this is why they use dirty tricks such as colluding with the state politburo to engage in acts of violence against anyone that would dare to compete with them. They obviously see Samsung as a threat or they would not have spent so much effort trying to shut them down.
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.

Apple will be history before long as it is only a matter of time before their bubble collapses. Android devices are more affordable and offer a superior, vastly more customizable and flexible operating system that respects the users freedom and does not force you to use a walled garden. Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

Apple realizes this and this is why they use dirty tricks such as colluding with the state politburo to engage in acts of violence against anyone that would dare to compete with them. They obviously see Samsung as a threat or they would not have spent so much effort trying to shut them down.

It's a conspiracy!
 
Apple isn't going to be "history" for a good while.

Especially since people are so invested in them, and Apple has no plans on making it easy for them to leave. But at least the music from iTunes is available DRM free, that was a nice gesture.

"Apple may never be a market leader again" may be a more accurate statement. Without a frontman like Steve Jobs at the helm, it's unlikely they'll have another shot at market dominance again. It's a shame that they got cocky and limited sales to AT&T only for the first, critical years in iOS history... they could have maintained dominance for a few more years at least if they didn't get greedy and sold through all carriers.
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.
Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

That's like saying Honda, Kia, Hyundai, Mazda has surpassed the sales of Corollas. Meanwhile, Apple is still getting 73% of the profits from the ENTIRE mobile market.
 
That's like saying Honda, Kia, Hyundai, Mazda has surpassed the sales of Corollas. Meanwhile, Apple is still getting 73% of the profits from the ENTIRE mobile market.

I'd guess Bugatti is making pretty decent profit off designer Veyron models as well. That doesn't mean I care or think someone is intelligent when they buy one.

I'd imagine the aftermarket for a Veyron is pretty small, albeit profitable as well. Big deal.

As more users are introduced to the Android marketplace, more apps, accessories etc will be sold, and you'll see the profitshare swing just like usershare.
 
I think Samsung should put out a phone in the shape of a 2D Apple with a bite taken out of it. :D
Or in the shape of the piece that was bitten off of the apple. I doubt that Apple has a copyright on that, and it could infer so many hidden meanings.
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.

Apple will be history before long as it is only a matter of time before their bubble collapses. Android devices are more affordable and offer a superior, vastly more customizable and flexible operating system that respects the users freedom and does not force you to use a walled garden. Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

Apple realizes this and this is why they use dirty tricks such as colluding with the state politburo to engage in acts of violence against anyone that would dare to compete with them. They obviously see Samsung as a threat or they would not have spent so much effort trying to shut them down.

Pretty much, yeah: Their heavy reliance on copyright/patent abuse in the judicial system reminds me a lot of Oracle and their business strategy of purchasing "IP" to sue over instead of actually developing better products.
 
I'd guess Bugatti is making pretty decent profit off designer Veyron models as well. That doesn't mean I care or think someone is intelligent when they buy one.

I'd imagine the aftermarket for a Veyron is pretty small, albeit profitable as well. Big deal.

As more users are introduced to the Android marketplace, more apps, accessories etc will be sold, and you'll see the profitshare swing just like usershare.

I own a GSIII, and the google play store leaves much to be desired. I am actually confident to say the apple app store trounces google play.
 
software patent is garbage! They even said apple owns the phone icon and gear icon and the way its lined up in rows. You look at everything apple "invented", it's been done before and on other platforms.

But i guess your like jury foremen and believe that if its on another processor patents aren't interchangeable unless its an apple patent. :rolleyes:

Apple doesn't have a patent on the icon... See Apple Corp. v. Xerox. UIs are not patentable, and that wasn't even at the center of this case.

Most of the "Judgment" came from ridiculous and incorrect assessments of which patents Samsung violated. For instance, the Galaxy Tab 10.1 was to be found non-infringing on all the design patents. That included the "rounded corners" patent. The Jury blatantly either misunderstood or disregarded the instructions from the judge, forgot how to do addition when they issued the verdict, and of course may be liable for misconduct (the appeal doesn't look good for Apple on that front).

Cheers,

Cheers,
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.

Apple will be history before long as it is only a matter of time before their bubble collapses. Android devices are more affordable and offer a superior, vastly more customizable and flexible operating system that respects the users freedom and does not force you to use a walled garden. Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

Apple realizes this and this is why they use dirty tricks such as colluding with the state politburo to engage in acts of violence against anyone that would dare to compete with them. They obviously see Samsung as a threat or they would not have spent so much effort trying to shut them down.

How is Android more affordable?
 
And in come the trolls.....this thread is going to be another heated argument of another thread of being another Apple vs Android debate which we have seen countless of times. ./thread.
 
TouchWiz is irrelevant.

Apple will be history before long as it is only a matter of time before their bubble collapses. Android devices are more affordable and offer a superior, vastly more customizable and flexible operating system that respects the users freedom and does not force you to use a walled garden. Android phones have already overtaken the iPhone and it won't be long until the combined assault of Android and Windows tablets do the same for the iPad.

Apple realizes this and this is why they use dirty tricks such as colluding with the state politburo to engage in acts of violence against anyone that would dare to compete with them. They obviously see Samsung as a threat or they would not have spent so much effort trying to shut them down.

Being outsold by competitors means little to market differentiators. For instance, Macs have been outsold by PCs by at least 15:1 (and all the way up to 50:1) for decades and they're still pulling in millions and seeing growth in desktop sales. I've never owned an Apple product, maybe never will, but they're certainly not going away any time soon.
 
How is Android more affordable?
More supply(number of phones) on the market to the point where all of them except for the flagship model have to be sold for $0-$100 with contract. Also, you pay for that "freedom" when it comes to support. A good part of the Apple premium is that they provide much superior support for their products because if a customer has an issue with an iPad/iPhone/Mac, all they have to do is go to any Apple store and everything is handled with a high level of professionalism and courtesy(and I can speak from personal experience). Good luck trying to get that level of service with an Android phone at a cell carrier's store.

I'd guess Bugatti is making pretty decent profit off designer Veyron models as well. That doesn't mean I care or think someone is intelligent when they buy one.
It costs about $8 million to make every $1.6 million Veyron. Since Bugatti is owned by Volkswagen, that deficit is easily offset by the profit made from mass-produced VW cars.
 
I don't mind the existance of apple products. I just wish they'd go play with themselves in the corner and leave everyone alone who doesn't like them. For saying they're unique, they sure have an unpleasant way of seeking attention and getting in the way...like a bratty child.
 
That's like saying Honda, Kia, Hyundai, Mazda has surpassed the sales of Corollas. Meanwhile, Apple is still getting 73% of the profits from the ENTIRE mobile market.

If you think that is sustainable, you are deluded. Especially in this economy. Intelligent people will not continue to buy overpriced items when cheaper ones are available. If Tim Cook continues Steve Jobs megalomania (which he, as of now, seems to be doing), they will not reduce their prices.

Being outsold by competitors means little to market differentiators. For instance, Macs have been outsold by PCs by at least 15:1 (and all the way up to 50:1) for decades and they're still pulling in millions and seeing growth in desktop sales. I've never owned an Apple product, maybe never will, but they're certainly not going away any time soon.

Macs were irrelevant until they switched to x86 and gained the ability to run Windows and Windows programs without emulation. As it is now, they are just overpriced PCs with a proprietary EFI that is just different enough from industry standards to cause headaches.

How is Android more affordable?

The operating system itself is free. There are multiple Android phone and tablet manufacturers.
 
Back
Top