Do Laptops in Class Lead to Lower Grades

Well you certainly don't have to listen to the professor in logical reasoning class to see the flaw in your argument....protip - the quote "better graded than the kids who paid attention in class" invalidates your whole "curve" theory.

My point was just because you got a better grade doesn't mean you're living up to the professors standards, he very could have had to lower his standards because most of the class wasn't paying enough attention or putting in enough effort. This can happens quite frequently in public universities where you have to pander to 500 students, most private schools can weed out the slackers pretty easily, which is why standards are often much higher.
 
You know honestly, I think this article should be called "Does stupid people in college cause lower grades?"

It has nothing to do with laptops or distractions, and everything to do with idiots - both students and professors.

+100!

Yeah, it's time to change from a noone left behind mentality to noone held back! My C class was a total waste of time. Our prof told us we would be writting device drivers by the end of the semester. He spent so much time making sure everyone understood that we only got through half of the book. It's 12 years later and I still get angry over that. My money and my time were wasted. Thank God I didn't get a job as a C developer. I would have had to teach myself what my education didn't.
 
That should be should, not would. Would implies an intention or prediction of the future, while should implies a necessity on the part of the subject.
Touché, but your mistake is still worse. :D

And using should wouldn't have made the slam as powerful, but good cover. ;)
 
Touché, but your mistake is still worse. :D

And using should wouldn't have made the slam as powerful, but good cover. ;)

I realized the mistake as soon as I posted, went to hit the edit button, and then did a facepalm as I realized you can't edit this section. I debated making an add on post, but I didn't hoping it would not be noticed. Guess it didn't work :p
 
You know very little about educating, and a lot about power tripping.
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment. Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again. These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding, well that is your problem, although I believe it speaks volumes about your character. However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.
 
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Exactly my point.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

Nowhere did I say that. If I didn't learn the material, then by all means go ahead and fail me.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment.

Quite simply, no student is going to permanently learn something they don't wish to learn. Forcing them through disciplinary measures to learn things for the test may work so they can pass the course, but if you're truly concerned about "bettering them" as you state later on in your post, then you should realize that perhaps the problem isn't with the student, but with the way the compulsory education system is designed and implemented. I suggest you read John Taylor Gatto's book regarding the historical origins of the schooling system.

Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again.

Tell them no. It's their fault, after all. Yes, their parents will call and bitch at you. Tell the parents to go shove it. Yes, they will sometimes go over your head and get you in trouble with your administration. That seems to point to a flaw in the system which you knowingly work in, doesn't it? How about you try to change it instead of merely perpetuating the destructive cycle?

And regardless, if a student such as me screws around during class on the laptop (doesn't bother anyone!) yet learns the material well on my own, then since you're so concerned about bettering me and my education, you should be thrilled that I educated myself (which, by the way should be the ultimate goal of schooling - teaching people how to teach themselves, not just to regurgitate useless information).

These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

Addressed above.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding

What a load of shit. Take any bum off of the street, give him $30-50k a year, summers off, and tenure, and see who wouldn't be willing to "teach" material? I greatly and deeply respect the teachers that genuinely do want to help their students, and I've become fast friends with many of them. However, I absolutely refuse to respect a teacher who obviously doesn't care just because they are a "teacher".

However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

Remind me again how a student sitting in the back of the room with his head down typing notes is any different than a student sitting in the back of the room typing a post on hardforums (in terms of disrupting the class)?

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.

You see, this is the typical problem with our current education system. It places a disproportionately high value on some antiquated idea of what they think "learning" and "professional development is". What do you think will make you more likely to get a job nowadays - typing 130WPM or handwriting 30? I'm not saying handwriting isn't important - it is. But it's NOT important to be able to handwrite at mach1, and there is no point wasting resources trying to learn to do so when you could be educating yourself on something useful.

Typical teacher.
 
anyone who actually has read my posts on here knows i've gone through majors like metrosexuals go through shoes, and have a few various majors i finalized.

that said i have seen a lot of the education system. For some things a laptop was a necessity, when i was in IT or CS it was great to have visual studio in front of me for lectures, same with multimedia, it was great having the programs on a loaded laptop.

Note taking was also enhanced with a laptop, research was also nice because i could look stuff up to supplement the class.

on the other hand some classes are dreadfully boring or easy... and in those cases i have in more than one instance played everquest or ran WoW instances in class.
 
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment. Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again. These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding, well that is your problem, although I believe it speaks volumes about your character. However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.

I've also taught both high school and college students.

I have to argue a few of your points with a general statement.

I do agree that disruptions to a learning environment are bad adn should be dealt with, HOWEVER laptops are not one of them regardless what they are used for (well maybe not porn). I also agree with the sense of entitlement, to some degree.

Paying a teachers salary does NOT entitle a student to a passing grade, you are right on that. however the students ARE entitled to whatever help is necessary to get that passing grade if they are interested. I have run across many teachers who just don't give a shit about their students education, and are not at all passionate or even interested in what they teach. That is the biggest problem. Students or their parents pay a lot of money for teachers that don't give a shit... so they screw off in class. I would too.
 
I use my laptop to take notes, and I'll be damned if I'm going to go back to using clunky pen and paper just because some professor, who's probably never even used a computer before, can't handle it.
 
My 5th grade daughter has no books just a laptop and a smart board. I think its a waste and parents have limited options to help out there children this way.
 
I've also taught both high school and college students.

I have to argue a few of your points with a general statement.

I do agree that disruptions to a learning environment are bad adn should be dealt with, HOWEVER laptops are not one of them regardless what they are used for (well maybe not porn). I also agree with the sense of entitlement, to some degree.

Paying a teachers salary does NOT entitle a student to a passing grade, you are right on that. however the students ARE entitled to whatever help is necessary to get that passing grade if they are interested. I have run across many teachers who just don't give a shit about their students education, and are not at all passionate or even interested in what they teach. That is the biggest problem. Students or their parents pay a lot of money for teachers that don't give a shit... so they screw off in class. I would too.

What I find funny is that you scream freedom for the laptop user but then enforce your own morals or standards and stop at pr0n. Why stop there? If a laptop is not disruptive and nothing else on it would be, why wouldn't pr0n?

I'm all for being open to this freedom, but if you are going to include one thing but exclude others, thats kinda a little leaning.

And ya ya, I know you are going to come up with some rebuttal to this, just keep in mind, IMO pr0n can be just distractive as someone playing wow or someone watching the latest you tube video of midgets in bikinis running around with chainsaws and PB&J sandwiches on their heads.

IMO it's up to the professor, if he doesn't want them in his class, it's his choice. Don't like the rules of the game? Play a different game or go somewhere else. There is a reason why these ivy leauge schools are doing so well, because they live by the rule book and the professors have final say.
 
What I find funny is that you scream freedom for the laptop user but then enforce your own morals or standards and stop at pr0n. Why stop there? If a laptop is not disruptive and nothing else on it would be, why wouldn't pr0n?

I'm all for being open to this freedom, but if you are going to include one thing but exclude others, thats kinda a little leaning.

And ya ya, I know you are going to come up with some rebuttal to this, just keep in mind, IMO pr0n can be just distractive as someone playing wow or someone watching the latest you tube video of midgets in bikinis running around with chainsaws and PB&J sandwiches on their heads.

IMO it's up to the professor, if he doesn't want them in his class, it's his choice. Don't like the rules of the game? Play a different game or go somewhere else. There is a reason why these ivy leauge schools are doing so well, because they live by the rule book and the professors have final say.

Sex education, baby!
 
What I find funny is that you scream freedom for the laptop user but then enforce your own morals or standards and stop at pr0n. Why stop there? If a laptop is not disruptive and nothing else on it would be, why wouldn't pr0n?

I'm all for being open to this freedom, but if you are going to include one thing but exclude others, thats kinda a little leaning.

And ya ya, I know you are going to come up with some rebuttal to this, just keep in mind, IMO pr0n can be just distractive as someone playing wow or someone watching the latest you tube video of midgets in bikinis running around with chainsaws and PB&J sandwiches on their heads.

IMO it's up to the professor, if he doesn't want them in his class, it's his choice. Don't like the rules of the game? Play a different game or go somewhere else. There is a reason why these ivy leauge schools are doing so well, because they live by the rule book and the professors have final say.


i typed that at work really fast, the porn thing was sort of meant to be a joke stemming from the earlier post of dudes watching porn and the headphones popping out

thats all, if you can quietly watch porn and keep the bodily fluids to yourself rock on
 
i typed that at work really fast, the porn thing was sort of meant to be a joke stemming from the earlier post of dudes watching porn and the headphones popping out

thats all, if you can quietly watch porn and keep the bodily fluids to yourself rock on

You should open a college... I will bring my laptop to attend class and to *ahem* type on. :D
 
You should open a college... I will bring my laptop to attend class and to *ahem* type on. :D

funny story about that. Did you ever see the movie accepted? As someone who adheres to a libertarian philosophy i would love to start a school and get accredited and do something completely unconventional, until i get assassinated by the good ol' boys who would feel threatened.

teaching students what they want to learn by teachers that want to be there without pretenses...omg what an idea!

but yeah man i <3 me my porn (even some of the messed up stuff!), you have read plenty of my posts, i got no agenda against it or morals to force on others ;)

just trying to be funny and i failed ><

If i opened a college i'd offer you a teaching position, feel free to bring your laptop :D
 
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment. Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again. These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding, well that is your problem, although I believe it speaks volumes about your character. However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.

Gonna' agree here. I teach Freshmen-level college writing. To put it into perspective, I don't think freshmen in their first intensive writing course need to have laptops during class. I'm sure laptops help in some classes, but I don't teach those classes.

It's pretty easy to discern who in this thread actually has taught before and who are just theory-crafters for education.

And by the way, a syllabus is a legally binding contract between the student and the teacher (at the college level). If you don't like the teacher's rules, then there are many other classes to choose from or you can leave. By staying in the classroom, the student is agreeing to the rules set forth, even if it says no laptops.
 
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment. Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again. These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding, well that is your problem, although I believe it speaks volumes about your character. However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.

As a former high school and college teacher, I agree pretty much with these statements.
 
I actually teach at both the college and high school level.

Many of the posts in this thread are examples of a great problem in education. The most disconcerting being the student sense of entitlement, followed closely by the lack of respect and discipline. Many students seem to believe that because they pay tuition they are entitled to a credit or a passing grade.

To suggest an educator should simply ignore a student who is screwing around on a laptop, or not paying attention, is indicative of someone who knows very little about teaching or the classroom environment. Often students who do not pay attention will come to a teacher expecting to be taught the lesson again. These students often get disrespectful, because they don't get their way, and make asinine comments such as "well I pay your salary" or "I have already paid or this credit". They fail to take responsibility for their own actions and instead act juvenile and try to disrupt class.

If you feel you don't have to respect someone who is willing to teach your material in order to improve yourself and further your understanding, well that is your problem, although I believe it speaks volumes about your character. However, disrupting class, as has been suggested in this thread, is juvenile and selfish as it takes away from students who actually want to learn. For this reason a teacher does not let a student screw around, as it leads to other students losing focus and disrupts the learning environment.

In addition, I find it amazing how little people are concerned with professional development. Many people seem to be more concerned with doing something faster or easier, rather than improving a deficiency in the very basic skill or hand writing.

Exactly my point.



Nowhere did I say that. If I didn't learn the material, then by all means go ahead and fail me.



Quite simply, no student is going to permanently learn something they don't wish to learn. Forcing them through disciplinary measures to learn things for the test may work so they can pass the course, but if you're truly concerned about "bettering them" as you state later on in your post, then you should realize that perhaps the problem isn't with the student, but with the way the compulsory education system is designed and implemented. I suggest you read John Taylor Gatto's book regarding the historical origins of the schooling system.



Tell them no. It's their fault, after all. Yes, their parents will call and bitch at you. Tell the parents to go shove it. Yes, they will sometimes go over your head and get you in trouble with your administration. That seems to point to a flaw in the system which you knowingly work in, doesn't it? How about you try to change it instead of merely perpetuating the destructive cycle?

And regardless, if a student such as me screws around during class on the laptop (doesn't bother anyone!) yet learns the material well on my own, then since you're so concerned about bettering me and my education, you should be thrilled that I educated myself (which, by the way should be the ultimate goal of schooling - teaching people how to teach themselves, not just to regurgitate useless information).



Addressed above.



What a load of shit. Take any bum off of the street, give him $30-50k a year, summers off, and tenure, and see who wouldn't be willing to "teach" material? I greatly and deeply respect the teachers that genuinely do want to help their students, and I've become fast friends with many of them. However, I absolutely refuse to respect a teacher who obviously doesn't care just because they are a "teacher".



Remind me again how a student sitting in the back of the room with his head down typing notes is any different than a student sitting in the back of the room typing a post on hardforums (in terms of disrupting the class)?



You see, this is the typical problem with our current education system. It places a disproportionately high value on some antiquated idea of what they think "learning" and "professional development is". What do you think will make you more likely to get a job nowadays - typing 130WPM or handwriting 30? I'm not saying handwriting isn't important - it is. But it's NOT important to be able to handwrite at mach1, and there is no point wasting resources trying to learn to do so when you could be educating yourself on something useful.

Typical teacher.

I quoted Computerpro3 since he basically stated everything I would of, had I caught this earlier.

I post again only to point out the absurdity of the last point made by Draax. In my field penmanship is not professional development. It is an antiquated and irrelevant skill set to my chosen career. It is not up to some professor to dictate to me that I need to learn a skill in the interest of professional development, when I will in fact never use that skill. The most handwriting I will ever do, is sign my name or scribble down something on a sticky note. My world is electronic, that is the world that we live in today. Now if you teach a class that is focused on culture, calligraphy or journalism and the like, then you have a point. However obviously someone like me would not be taking such a course as that is not relevant to my "Professional Development".
 
I dont have any books at all, all are on the computers, we are using dualcore 3ghz (c2d) with 4850's :D
 
^^^ Penmanship might be antiquated, but most of the students I taught in high school couldn't type faster than they could write.
 
I can type notes into my laptop a heck of a lot faster than I can write them in a paper notebook. Plus I don't have to worry about handwriting quality! There are exceptions (typing notes for math/physics/etc may not go over so well), but in most classes my laptop is a valuable tool rather than a hinderance.

I type about 300% faster then I can right. And hell, if the professor draws a diagram, I just take a picture of it or make a diagram in Word that actually helps me understand the material better.
 
I remember I had a professor whose class I eventually dropped because he was such a tool. He banned all laptops in class, yet would give lectures off power points that were basically huge lists of dates/times/people etc but would cycle through them so fast there was no way a normal human could copy it down. When asked to cycle back to it he would say, there's no time, we have to cover this material! A total tool and douche bag. I remember when he said that, about 75% of us got up and left the class. Mind you, this is a class of 300, so I honestly felt a bit bad about leaving him in such a manner but hey, he asked for it by being a tool.
 
I remember I had a professor whose class I eventually dropped because he was such a tool. He banned all laptops in class, yet would give lectures off power points that were basically huge lists of dates/times/people etc but would cycle through them so fast there was no way a normal human could copy it down. When asked to cycle back to it he would say, there's no time, we have to cover this material! A total tool and douche bag. I remember when he said that, about 75% of us got up and left the class. Mind you, this is a class of 300, so I honestly felt a bit bad about leaving him in such a manner but hey, he asked for it by being a tool.

Most professors who do that also make their slides available online somewhere for you to get. Either that or he just isn't a good professor. Likely the latter is true.
 
I agree that a Laptop can help a student immensely ... but in lecture class it's both a distraction, and disruptive.

I can remember, years ago, trying to use a laptop in class. Prior to that time, I could read the books (something which is becoming a lost art!), and go to class and listen to the lecture (taking only the briefest notes), and I would remember it all. Now I was analyzing everything I was reading and hearing, to try and pick out the important points. But I was paying attention to the material.

Then I got a laptop. And I could type fast enough to take "word for word" lecture notes. But the process of taking those notes disrupted my analysis of the material, and I could no longer remember the lectures in the same way. So I had to go back to taking notes by hand (at the speed snails trot...) and the laptop stayed in the bag until I got to the library.

All of this changes if, and when, the course is "Online". Still when your course is a lecture course, you have to learn to "Listen" and analyze the subject matter, in real time (not at your own pace). So under the circumstances, in normal college courses, laptops probably should not be allowed.

I also have a sister that is a college Professor. She tells me stories of one student in twenty disturbing the class by typing (click, click, clickity, click....) during lectures and videos. She won't let her students use their laptops in class.
 
I remember I had a professor whose class I eventually dropped because he was such a tool. He banned all laptops in class, yet would give lectures off power points that were basically huge lists of dates/times/people etc but would cycle through them so fast there was no way a normal human could copy it down. When asked to cycle back to it he would say, there's no time, we have to cover this material! A total tool and douche bag. I remember when he said that, about 75% of us got up and left the class. Mind you, this is a class of 300, so I honestly felt a bit bad about leaving him in such a manner but hey, he asked for it by being a tool.
Sorry!! No sympathy here. That prof probably had it all on "E-Reserve", or it was copied from the text book, and you should have been paying attention... But I'd wager you were IM'ing your buddy, or texting your girlfriend, and you missed that part. Also those "Freshman" intro classes (the ones that always have 400 students in them...) are designed to weed out the goof offs. I'd also wager that the prof was amused when a bunch of you left, if that really happened. He isn't paid to "care", and you never even get to speak with him/her normally, you talk to the Grad Assistants, and hopefully they can help you learn to listen and analyze the lectures. That's just how it works!
 
I type about 300% faster then I can right. And hell, if the professor draws a diagram, I just take a picture of it or make a diagram in Word that actually helps me understand the material better.

Heh heh heh oh the irony.

Draez, I wouldn't waste my breath with computerpro3. A month ago there was a similar topic and he acted like he knew everything there was to know and that he dictated policy in schools and colleges - all in the name of his being a music professional of sorts.

Let it lie. Nobody could make him see it in the other thread and nobody's going to make him see it in this one too.

Reminds me of a sign my mother used to have on her bulletin board when I was a kid: "Attention teenagers! Hurry and get out of the house and get a job and buy a house while you still think you know everything!" or something to that effect.
 
Back
Top