Do Laptops in Class Lead to Lower Grades

Yeah, there will always be those students out there giving bad reviews because the professor didn't do exactly what they wanted. Guess what? Nobody gives a shit. You think he'll lose his job because students want to avoid taking him? If anything, this will make his life easier by weeding out the students that don't want to work at things and are too narrow minded to do things any way other than their own.
It's the job of the professor to assist the students in learning the subject and information presented. If the professor fails at that, then he/she's failing at his/her job, it's that simple. If a student learns best by using a laptop to take notes and organize the information, why restrict the tool from him? Laptops are a very useful tool in college now, not recognizing that is ignorance. It's ironic that you think the students are narrow-minded for not learning the way the professor tells them to; it's the professor that is narrow-minded for not assisting the students, since they are the ones doing the learning.
 
I see both having pros and cons.

If I do it by hand, there's more flexibility. If I type it, it's extremely linear. What if the professor draws/illustrates something you need in the notes -- what do you then? Take out your cell phone and take a photo for each update on the illustration? What a terrible and distracting way to learn.

Sure laptops have their pros -- I'm not saying that they're completely bad. I can type between 100wpm to 130wpm accurately when I feel like it, so I would be able to keep up with notes easily and type up papers at efficient speed (man, if I WROTE papers -- I would probably be doomed).

Then again, college is a business. They don't care; they have your money. You fail, your problem. However, I would personally obey the professor -- no sense in rebelling.
 
Was linking back to this thread intentional? If so, then I agree... wait the prof is saying something... Okay I am back.

What was I talking about?
 
Just because you can type more notes, doesn't mean those notes are better. As an educator, I ban laptop use in the classroom.

I use my tablet PC for all of my notes in class.

Last semester, I took very detailed notes with my laptop in OneNote for all classes, especially Business Law.

Get to the end of the semester, the teacher says that it's open-note, open-book, and you're allowed to type it IF you bring a a laptop to class. Of course, he let me use my typed notes. He also mentioned that NOBODY should run out of subjects to write on before the two hour exam period ended.

I ended up with eight typed pages in those two hours, and an A in the class. Nobody else even came close to having as much as I did.... did it hurt them? I would hope not. Did it help me substantially? Hell fucking yes!

Plus.... I can work from class when necessay :D
 
Bah, I forgot to mention.... my university, despite being $28k a year, is still using Office 2003. They need to get real if they think I am going to go through a MS class using Office 2003. I use my laptop THE MOST in my MS class (and it's in a lab....)
 
Just because you can type more notes, doesn't mean those notes are better. As an educator, I ban laptop use in the classroom.

I would say to you as mentioned in this thread; I am helping pay your salary, I will take notes how I deem fit. It is my grade and my education, not yours.

You know very little about teaching.

Does not matter, you are trying to dictate to someone how they get to record the material. This is not your place to do so. If someone wants to screw off and screw themselves over that is their right and choice. I however being 30 years old and in the IT field never write hand written notes. As such my penmanship is illegible and honestly I have no need to improve it for any reason, much less some nazistic professor who thinks he can ban the device I rely on for everything just because he is stuck in a 40 year timewarp.
 
It can go both ways. It's in the way that you use it. You can use it to your benefit or you can use it foolishly.
 
Yeah, there will always be those students out there giving bad reviews because the professor didn't do exactly what they wanted. Guess what? Nobody gives a shit. You think he'll lose his job because students want to avoid taking him? If anything, this will make his life easier by weeding out the students that don't want to work at things and are too narrow minded to do things any way other than their own.

Powerage wins the thread....
 
I've seen one laptop in class that hasn't had Facebook plastered on its screen.

I think it dooms you to bring it... unless you're fucking elite.

I know I could never bring a lappy, lol
 
I would say to you as mentioned in this thread; I am helping pay your salary, I will take notes how I deem fit. It is my grade and my education, not yours.



Does not matter, you are trying to dictate to someone how they get to record the material. This is not your place to do so. If someone wants to screw off and screw themselves over that is their right and choice. I however being 30 years old and in the IT field never write hand written notes. As such my penmanship is illegible and honestly I have no need to improve it for any reason, much less some nazistic professor who thinks he can ban the device I rely on for everything just because he is stuck in a 40 year timewarp.
Exactly my point. I don't see why profs care. As long as the students do disrupt or distract other students from learning, seriously who care what they do. Plain and simple.
 
I've seen one laptop in class that hasn't had Facebook plastered on its screen.

I think it dooms you to bring it... unless you're fucking elite.

I know I could never bring a lappy, lol
Then you have no self control or do not care about your education. Ok that sounds a bit harsh but in reality that's what it boils down to.
 
I got my degree in computer science. I would have DIED without my laptop! I'd still be in college if I didn't have one. :)
 
My college (Loras College) gives each student a laptop to use for the school year. Everything is wireless and the professors are pressed pretty hard to make everything available on our network/portal as far as homework, guides, projects, information, etc goes.

I'm in my junior year here and would have to say that the allowance/disallowance of laptops being used is split nearly 50/50 between all the professors. Some professors hate them because the class doesn't get involved with discussion enough if we have them open, some love them because it's easier to take notes and the professor can move faster, some will allow them to be open but you will find out on your own that you weren't following the lecture enough and end up doing badly.

The latter happened in my Adv. Accounting class. I've always had my laptop open and multitask. I thought I could BS my way through this ACC class and somehow end up with an A or B+ like every other class. This wasn't the case; my mid-term grade was a C...and I knew why. I didn't pay attention at all to the professor during class time. Stopped opening the laptop during class and my grade has shot up.
 
I would say to you as mentioned in this thread; I am helping pay your salary, I will take notes how I deem fit. It is my grade and my education, not yours.



Does not matter, you are trying to dictate to someone how they get to record the material. This is not your place to do so. If someone wants to screw off and screw themselves over that is their right and choice. I however being 30 years old and in the IT field never write hand written notes. As such my penmanship is illegible and honestly I have no need to improve it for any reason, much less some nazistic professor who thinks he can ban the device I rely on for everything just because he is stuck in a 40 year timewarp.

I wholeheartedly agree with this.

In one of my Anatomy & Physiology classes my professor would speed through each slide so it was difficult to write out... I often found myself making shorthand notes and comments but when I read them over I had shortened so much that I wasn't really sure what I had written in the first place. I can type incredibly faster than I can write so I brought my laptop and typed out everything he presented. That really helped me.

So what's the big deal? As long as I'm not distracting by playing music or something then I don't see why I'm not allowed to use a tool that helps me learn. It's 2009, laptops are pretty common now, especially for college kids because it can be a superior learning tool to hand notes. Just because that's how YOU did it back in 1973 doesn't mean it's best for me.
 
Plato's Phaedrus --
"... writing destroys memory. Those who use writing will become forgetful, relying on external resource for what they lack in internal resources. Writing weakens the mind."

Replace "writing" with "computers" and jump forward ~2500 years.
 
What's sad is that kids these days more and more don't how to research with real books from real libraries.

I hear you on that one - but honestly, if I can find millions of times the information from doing a Google search, as opposed to spending forever looking for books at the library, I'd much rather do it the quick and efficient way.
 
Yeah, I gotta say, pulling up research on a topic is a hell of a lot faster through jstor than it is through inter-library loan.
 
Everyone at my college had laptops, and it really depends how you use them IMO. They are great for note taking. Typing is much faster, so you miss less stuff (not only notes, but also missing points from a lecture). Also, you have much greater flexibility in how you lay out your notes. Another nice thing is you can quickly look things up (if you have internet access) which can help clarify things that are being discussed.

On the other hand, a lot of people at my college mainly used their laptops to play games (during class), which obviously isn't going to be good for your grades/knowledge. Teachers would often pass out prepared "notes" so a lot of them thought that was enough I guess (even though the notes were more of a general outline for the lecture). I guess it's their loss though, paying thousands of dollars to sit in a classroom and play games.

For high/middle school I would frankly be a bit weary of laptops. In my experience, a lot of kids just don't seem to care about school at that age, and don't show a great deal of maturity. I'm sure some kids would make good use of them, but I suspect more would be using them "improperly".

Then again high school was such a joke, and moved at such a stupidly slow pace, that perhaps playing games during class is the only challenge you'll get ;) I always found it funny when I'd go on vacation missing a full week of school, and then finish the entire week's work in 2-3hrs.
 
Students will listen if the teacher is good. However if the teacher is bad or we know they will drone on, then they should be happy students even bothered to show up.

I have had teachers who talk so much that I had no time to do other stuff other than take notes.
But with every horrible CS class I have taken, most of them read from power points. Whats worse is when the lecture is recorded, they just talk fast and assume we will go back to watch it again afterwords.

So my point is the teachers who have this problem simply suck and just have something really easy to point at. Ban laptops? Then they simply won't show up to class and the grades will drop for that reason.
 
Plato's Phaedrus --
"... writing destroys memory. Those who use writing will become forgetful, relying on external resource for what they lack in internal resources. Writing weakens the mind."

Replace "writing" with "computers" and jump forward ~2500 years.

writing is still writing typed or hand written.
Learn to memorize from just hearing it :p
my Highschool teachers hated me for it
never had a notebook to turn in but i could quote word for word lectures from the beginning of the year.
 
Alright, I guess ill give my 2 cents here.

I started as a freshman in '03 and was one of the few that had a laptop in class. I learned after my first midterm that I cannot read my own handwriting worth a darn so I started to type all of my notes. This ultimately has been extremely helpful to me to be able to search and actually read what I write.

I think if they are worried about people not paying attention then DON'T PUT WIFI IN THE CLASSROOM, that is probably the single most stupidest thing they could have done. I admit, during some of the super boring classes ill get on pidgin or forums and what not. The best though is when I would get to class and email my professor the assignment! haha.

But seriously stop putting wifi in the classroom so it goes back to how it was when I first started and everyone would fight over the 2 or 3 ethernet jacks in the classroom (along with power plugs too!).
 
The ever growing problems with discipline and respect in the classroom are aptly demonstrated in this thread.
 
If only I had my BlackBerry in college! People often brought laptops to class. Even non-lectures. It's faster, so you get to hear more of what's presented. There are shorthand methods for taking notes, but writing is so damn slow. My handwriting sucks, but I never brought a laptop to class.


What's sad is that kids these days more and more don't how to research with real books from real libraries.

Sadly libraries aren't what they used to be. I went to the Chicago Public Library on State and Van Buren the other day just for kicks and you wouldn't believe how dated their books were.

But then again, I tend to browse the technology aisles and that field moves pretty damn quick.
 
Respect is earned, not demanded.

Exactly. And telling me that I can't use a laptop to take notes in class when I'm the one paying for school isn't a great way to get my respect. It almost makes you seem like a washed up professor who desperately wants to be an authority figure, who therefore lays down the iron fist on the smallest and most irrelevant details in order to make themselves feel more empowered.

God, I'm glad there is nobody like that in academia! ;)
 
And BTW - for those of you that have professors that don't let you use laptops in class, buy a TV-B-Gone or other universally programmed TV remote and don't let your professor use the projector or TV in class. I figure if they want me to take notes by hand, they should have no problem teaching by hand too.
 
And when the student fails they be the first to say "Professor Smith failed me", instead of saying "I failed myself, because I spent too much time on Facebook".
 
The problem is that so many students are still immature children. That is where the problem arises. Those of us who are mature and can utilize a tablet or laptop in business meetings should not be punished because our classmates haven't grown up yet.

I take my tablet on business trips, corporate training, meetings with subordinates and superiors. Why not in the classroom? If I can meet with my Sr. VP and pay attention to what he says while taking notes on my tablet, why should a university classroom by any different?

I see a simple solution for profs. If a student is not paying attention or disruptive for ANY REASON, show them the door. I'm sick of people wanting to punish everyone to stop the offenders. That is an immature and unprofessional response. I'm not going to fire my whole department because two guys are screw-offs. I'll just fire the screw-offs. Thtat's the real world. Of course, university classrooms aren't thre real world are they?
 
And when the student fails they be the first to say "Professor Smith failed me", instead of saying "I failed myself, because I spent too much time on Facebook".

Or they get better graded than the kids who paid attention in class because it's more efficient to go home and teach yourself from the book than to listen to the professor's drivel.
 
Exactly my point. I don't see why profs care. As long as the students do disrupt or distract other students from learning, seriously who care what they do. Plain and simple.

I think the point is that it *is* disruptive and distracting to other students when people are listening to music/watching movies/playing games on a laptop in class. I certainly know it was for me when I was in college. Also, in a typical entry-level course at the university I attended, there could be 200-500 students. Even if some of them were using their laptops for notes, there were probably 4 out of 5 that weren't, not really anyway.

It sucks that more people have to "suffer" (I use quotations because it's not as if writing will kill you, how do you think people did it before laptops? :rolleyes:) because of the actions of some, but it's impossible to do it on a per-case basis with that many students.
 
Or they get better graded than the kids who paid attention in class because it's more efficient to go home and teach yourself from the book than to listen to the professor's drivel.

Or they got better grades because the professor is forced to grade on a curve, afterall he can't fail everyone, because then the school administration would be all over his ass.

Having been in college recently and having had the opportunity to teach both high school and college students, the vast majority of students do not do well with the "teach yourself" method.
 
I agree it would be nice if you could trust your students and they would hold themselves accountable, but the truth of the matter is that more often then not the students will place blame on the professor ofr bad grade, and not take responsibility for their own actions.
 
I see a lot of people complaining that they can't write fast enough to take notes because the professor talks/lectures too fast. I cannot recall even ONE professor in my four years of college that did not say something to the extent of, "If I'm going too fast, let me know and I can slow it down." Not ONCE. You have to engage yourself if you want to learn, and oftentimes that means interacting with the professor. In this case, asking them to slow down so that you can take good notes.

If your professors didn't say this, you probably had shitty professors and should have chosen other classes. I found that the best way to win in college was to make sure the professors you choose to take classes from are going to work for you, and also with you.
 
Or they got better grades because the professor is forced to grade on a curve, afterall he can't fail everyone, because then the school administration would be all over his ass.

Having been in college recently and having had the opportunity to teach both high school and college students, the vast majority of students do not do well with the "teach yourself" method.

It shouldn't matter what most students do well at. It matters what I, the person paying for MY education, does well at. Mandatory class attendance is bullshit enough when you have a 4.0, if I want to teach myself the material and can get an A in the class, I should have that right. Stop linking everyone to the "average" or "most students" and we'll solve a lot of problems in the education system. I don't give a shit about the kid next to me who's got drool coming out of his mouth and a frat t-shirt on, he shouldn't even be in college to begin with. I care about me, and me only in my education. Call it selfish, but if I'm paying for it, you bet your ass I'm going to be selfish.
 
OneNote is just too powerful to loose for me. My first two degrees were before the days of laptops in the class. My notes were never arranged right, some got lost. Having a notebook for each class was inefficient.

With OneNote, I write on the tablet just like paper. I have digital notebooks with tabs an pages, even subpages. The "page" can be as long as I want. In a 4 hour meeting I might write 10 printed pages worth of notes on a single OneNote page. That rocks! One "page" per meeting/class. One tab per course. One notebook has all the notes for all my courses right there.

This is very useful in meetings. It is very impressive to others when I am in a meeting and my boss asks a question about something in the past, and I go to that exact page and say "7 months ago we did this" OneNote can even search my notebook if I don't know what meeting something was in and READ MY HADWRITTING! I draw, make short hand, whatever I want. Such a powerful tool is too good to loose.
 
Apparently there was a teacher at a very posh high school in england who was ajudicating an A-level exam. There were monitors arranged around the exam hall which were hooked up to a laptop next to the teacher. They were intended to display exam rules and such like to the pupils. However the teacher did not realise monitors were mirroring his screen and he was subsequently disciplined when his porn browsing was beamed across the exam hall. The pitfalls of technology.
 
Or they get better graded than the kids who paid attention in class

Or they got better grades because the professor is forced to grade on a curve, afterall he can't fail everyone, because then the school administration would be all over his ass..

Well you certainly don't have to listen to the professor in logical reasoning class to see the flaw in your argument....protip - the quote "better graded than the kids who paid attention in class" invalidates your whole "curve" theory.
 
You know honestly, I think this article should be called "Does stupid people in college cause lower grades?"

It has nothing to do with laptops or distractions, and everything to do with idiots - both students and professors.
 
Back
Top