Do Laptops in Class Lead to Lower Grades

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Do laptops in class lead to lower grades? If you are reading this on your laptop in class, knock it off and pay attention!

As professors attempt to figure out how to deal with all of this, some are taking the nuclear option and simply banning laptop use altogether while class is in session. That's
 
A laptop can be a very powerful learning tool. Study notes, charts, organization can all be done much quicker than by hand. So banning laptops is kind of crap.

It all comes down to self control. Take notes, or play 1v7 on an extended, super resource version of Big Game Hunters.

ZERG RUSH!!!! I mean, note taking...
 
My girlfriend apparently saw some guys watching porn in a lecture once. One of them accidentally pulled out the headphone jack and suddenly the room was filled with loud sex noises. The professor just looked at them, disgusted, and told them to leave the room.

On another note, I bought my laptop for such a purpose, but I never ended up using it. I did EE with a math minor, so with all of the drawings and equations it wasn't really worth trying to type it all up, and it was much easier to just use a pen and paper.
 
If only I had my BlackBerry in college! People often brought laptops to class. Even non-lectures. It's faster, so you get to hear more of what's presented. There are shorthand methods for taking notes, but writing is so damn slow. My handwriting sucks, but I never brought a laptop to class.


What's sad is that kids these days more and more don't how to research with real books from real libraries.
 
As i sit here typing during a lecture from my poly sci teacher on my laptop i wonder whether i am capable of understanding what he is saying while i type this and browse the internet. A good thing schools can do, is block certain ports for the wifi that only allow internet browsing and no gaming, not even facebook games.
 
No laptops when I was in school, so not for me. It was boobies that diverted my blood flow. Probably still the same? But boring propagandizing Profs always want to blame their ineptitude and BS on something. Engaging teachers usually don’t have this problem. Those hot teachers that privileged and pleasured those teens probably didn’t have these issues. :D
 
laptops are a good thing in class if teachers/professors take advantage of it.. it could cut down on lectures by just sending the lecture to the student by email.. thus leaving more time for the professor to answer questions then sounding like a mono-toned speaker all day.. makes the class more efficient and helps the students that are falling behind while the others can continue ahead of those students..
 
I can type notes into my laptop a heck of a lot faster than I can write them in a paper notebook. Plus I don't have to worry about handwriting quality! There are exceptions (typing notes for math/physics/etc may not go over so well), but in most classes my laptop is a valuable tool rather than a hinderance.
 
I can type notes into my laptop a heck of a lot faster than I can write them in a paper notebook. Plus I don't have to worry about handwriting quality! There are exceptions (typing notes for math/physics/etc may not go over so well), but in most classes my laptop is a valuable tool rather than a hinderance.

Tablet PC :D!

Seriously though... typing is much quicker and more accurate than handwriting for me, plus is completely searchable later. This is really a self-control thing, and if the students are playing games while in class, then doing poorly, that's their fault. They would do poorly with or without the laptop in that case, and most likely just find another way to goof off.
 
My laptop is a tablet. I use it for notes at meetings at work, for my side business, for a book I am writting, and soon my MBA. If I go back to school and my tablet is banned, I'll be blowing a gasket in the department chairman's office. I take much better notes with OneNote (Thank you MS!) than I ever did on paper. It can even record audio and video while I take notes. I seriously doubt my tablet will be banned from any class in an MBA program, but you never can tell.

Personally, I never liked typing notes. Not to mention having a laptop open is a distration from the presenter. I can understand the problems it could create. A tablet on the other hand is like a legal pad. It's out of the way. You can draw on it, and it does not block your view of anything.
 
I was thinking about this today at school and I'm going to have to go with a very big yes. Even more so if there is an internet connection. It's already hard enough to pay attention, let alone with a device that you can do so many different things on. It also depends on the class, as some classes require certian pieces of software.

I actually had to write a paper on whether teachers should have the ability to block wireless signals from coming into the classroom. I went with yes. For many reasons that won't get into here. Slightly off topic but related.
 
That's the theory. The reality is that everything from IM chats to online shopping excursions take place over the in-class ether, distracting everyone involved: the student, his or her neighbors, and potentially the professors, who may watch their grip on the classroom slowly slipping away


Other than watching porn and having the sound played, how is it distracting to anyone what the hell i'm doing on my laptop, whether it be checking my email, actually typing notes or just surfing the web. It's not distracting. If your paying that much for post secondary education and wasting your time on the internet that is your loss.

When I started University in 2003 is was rather rare for people to have laptops, by the end of 2008 when I finished my degree they were everywhere.
 
I'm guilty of not paying attention with my laptop. I get so bored in some classes that I find myself playing with backtrack half the time instead of actually taking notes.

Some classes I'm able to pay better attention as I can follow along with the PP or take good notes with onenote. but if I get bored, my self control is limited :D.

I do know it is my fault and that it does affect my grades, and I will not blame it on the teacher, and I do not want to hurt those that legitimately benefit from having their laptops, but I do do better in the classes that do not allow them.
 
Sid Meier's Colonization kept my classes interesting and fun. I could never get my dark templar rushes to work with a trackpad.
 
Who cares? If the idiots want to throw their education out the window because they can't exert a little discipline, then let them. I don't see why anyone should stop them so long as they aren't hindering someone else.
 
Probably true. I tried using the a tablet to take notes with for a few days. However, I was opening up Firefox too many times when I got bored. I felt I was wasting my time there so I got rid of the tablet and used old fashioned pen and paper again.
 
I wish lappys weren't banned in school because my writing sucks, and I write slow. I can hardly keep up with the notes being taken :(
 
I use a laptop in all of my classes. The ones I'm not allowed to use a laptop in, I talk to the professor, and tell them that it's my money, and my future, so I'll do it my way. They always listen if you're mature and professional about it.

Without a laptop, I'd never be able to take the caliber of notes I currently do, considering I type ~4x faster than I write.
 
Pretty soon you fucktards won't even know how to write. Illiteracy is a great thing! Now get off my lawn..
 
I'm a senior in college and I've had a laptop since I was a freshman. Having a laptop in class has never been an issue until this semester. I've been checking my RSS feeds and browsing forums a lot more during class lately. I think it has more to do with me feeling burnt out from school rather than the tool itself though.

Anyway, I've decided that for the remainder of the semester, I'm going to try and use a good'ol notebook and pencil as much as I can. (It might be tough in my programming classes though :p)
 
Pretty soon you fucktards won't even know how to write. Illiteracy is a great thing! Now get off my lawn..

Your logic is definitely faulty. Being able to write more quickly doesn't mean you won't be able to write at all :rolleyes: . A laptop is a tool to write with digitally rather than using a pen and paper to do so. Both are still writing, but just in a different manner. You may have been looking for the word "penmanship" instead of calling people who can write more quickly by pressing a button instead of drawing a figure "illiterate".
 
I can type notes into my laptop a heck of a lot faster than I can write them in a paper notebook. Plus I don't have to worry about handwriting quality! There are exceptions (typing notes for math/physics/etc may not go over so well), but in most classes my laptop is a valuable tool rather than a hinderance.

This is why i use my laptop as well i type much faster than anyone i know can write and in addition to that my laptop has auto complete which basically just makes me faster and i can always save my notes and never lose them and i can use control f to fine key words in my notes and in addition to that share my notes from the class with others and compare notes and everything. I dont see how having electronic notes is a bad thing, i love it.
 
These statements are too generalized. If I have a laptop and I'm bored I'm going to browser the web. If I have paper and a pencil and I'm bored I'm going to doodle instead. Either way I'm not going to pay attention when I'm bored. Even sitting there letting stuff go in one ear and out the other some of that information will end up stuck in between :)
 
These statements are too generalized. If I have a laptop and I'm bored I'm going to browser the web. If I have paper and a pencil and I'm bored I'm going to doodle instead. Either way I'm not going to pay attention when I'm bored. Even sitting there letting stuff go in one ear and out the other some of that information will end up stuck in between :)

Lol, for me I learn it all, but the moment I leave class my brain wanders off and I forget everything I learned....:rolleyes:
 
I take notes in class with my laptop, but only because my handwriting is absolutely terrible. This way, everyone can read my notes. ;)
 
I did not have laptops in school. I did not have laptops in college, and that was a few years ago... I did school the old fashioned way while other students used laptops. I did use a computer to type papers but never to do dumb shit that the guy next to me was doing.

My friend however, had a laptop in class and was not doing anything that had to do with class...
 
Just because you can type more notes, doesn't mean those notes are better. As an educator, I ban laptop use in the classroom.
 
Just because you can type more notes, doesn't mean those notes are better. As an educator, I ban laptop use in the classroom.

Do you have any proof that the notes are not better? I would 100% rather type on the laptop and turn things in electronically because my hand writing is bad enough that some give me a 0 for what I turn in.
 
Meh. It all come down to the student. And why do the colleges care. They got your money, and if you fail, you have to take it again. If my class was easy, a laptop was great. In my important classes, I used it when I needed it and that's it. Face it, many people in America are lazy, do the bare minimum to get by and expect much more in return then what they put in. Its really sad. I remember in high school how many Dumb @$$ people who did not give a $HIT in class and expected everything to be handed to them.
 
Just because you can type more notes, doesn't mean those notes are better. As an educator, I ban laptop use in the classroom.
You have no right to do that. I can see this for high school, but not college. If a student wants to fail, let them. Its their education and not yours. Concentrate on those who want to learn. :rolleyes:
 
The cool thing about professors is they don't need proof. Furthermore, turning things in electronically is a load of horse shit, at least print it off. Email/files are a last resort.

Can't take notes without a laptop? Why bother learning how to add when you have calculators? I find I have a much more intimate knowledge of subjects when I draw each letter (and have to think about them). Just throwing that out there.
 
You have no right to do that. I can see this for high school, but not college. If a student wants to fail, let them. Its their education and not yours. Concentrate on those who want to learn. :rolleyes:

You know very little about teaching.
 
Vengance, if he's a college professor he has every right to do that. His classroom, he can do what he wants. Maybe the fans are too loud, maybe he's old school, doesn't fucking matter, get used to it.
 
Vengance, if he's a college professor he has every right to do that. His classroom, he can do what he wants. Maybe the fans are too loud, maybe he's old school, doesn't fucking matter, get used to it.
And then the students are entitled to give him poor reviews and take other professors. Works both ways.
 
And then the students are entitled to give him poor reviews and take other professors. Works both ways.

Yeah, there will always be those students out there giving bad reviews because the professor didn't do exactly what they wanted. Guess what? Nobody gives a shit. You think he'll lose his job because students want to avoid taking him? If anything, this will make his life easier by weeding out the students that don't want to work at things and are too narrow minded to do things any way other than their own.
 
I take way better notes when I write them by hand. I can draw pictures to help me remember like a little mini-flow diagram....or punctuate something, reference other parts of my notes with a big ass arc arrow.......

I guess it depends on the class.......
 
My girlfriend apparently saw some guys watching porn in a lecture once. One of them accidentally pulled out the headphone jack and suddenly the room was filled with loud sex noises. The professor just looked at them, disgusted, and told them to leave the room.

On another note, I bought my laptop for such a purpose, but I never ended up using it. I did EE with a math minor, so with all of the drawings and equations it wasn't really worth trying to type it all up, and it was much easier to just use a pen and paper.

Lol.

But on a serious note, there is a difference between conceptual/engineering notes vs. history/content-based notes. If there's a TON of textual/background information (non-science/engr), then yeah laptop is critical. Typing vs. hand cramps? Gee is this even a question?

OTOH, engineering/math/science - you're gonna need to draw diagrams constantly, or write equations. Last time I checked, the MS Word add-on for equations was functional - but not the fastest thing. If anything, more of a "if you have chicken-scratch, use it" kind of utility. I would expect most engineers have good handwriting out of necessity though.
 
Back
Top