Disc-Based Games Will Be Around Forever

Back when I was using a Commodore Amiga 1000 and was chronically broke, I would rent games for 3 days at a time from a local software business, then copy the floppies and photocopy the manuals so that I could continue playing them after the game was returned. Since then I have frequently purchased those same games when they became available on more modern platforms and operating systems.

After a bedroom move in 1992 when I was 12 I lost the manual for Sid Meier's Civilization, which I had received as a gift the year before.

For several months until I finally found it it became a matter of saving frequently and guessing the answers to the questions they pulled out of the Civilopedia. I got pretty good at it after a while :p
 
Zarathustra[H];1041886677 said:
After a bedroom move in 1992 when I was 12 I lost the manual for Sid Meier's Civilization, which I had received as a gift the year before.

For several months until I finally found it it became a matter of saving frequently and guessing the answers to the questions they pulled out of the Civilopedia. I got pretty good at it after a while :p

Nice! I didn't finally play the first Civilization until around the year 2007,when I bought, on physical media, a Civilization collection that included Civilizations 1-4, all of the dlc for the second and third installments, and a substantial little softcover book describing each game and the audience's reception to it. If I recall correctly, that first Civilization game by that point had the Civilopedia entirely in-game, so I didn't have to refer to a printed manual at all; I don't even think it had any copy protection.
 
Found a link on Amazon to that exact Civilization bundle that I was describing. It is called Civilization Chronicles, and was released in October 2006. It also came with a nice making-of DVD that I've watched only once, though if I can dig it up I'll watch it again sometime.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Nice! I didn't finally play the first Civilization until around the year 2007,when I bought, on physical media, a Civilization collection that included Civilizations 1-4, all of the dlc for the second and third installments, and a substantial little softcover book describing each game and the audience's reception to it. If I recall correctly, that first Civilization game by that point had the Civilopedia entirely in-game, so I didn't have to refer to a printed manual at all; I don't even think it had any copy protection.

I'm not 100% certain, as it's been a while since I fired up the first game, but as I recall Civ1 did have the Civilopedia entirely in game, but when the piracy check screen would come up, it would be locked on that screen until you entered the correct answer, so you couldn't check it. So you had to look at the paper version in the manual.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041886484 said:
Where do they even sell PC games in retail these days?

That is what I am trying to figure out for some of these people. Where do they actually live that PC games are still on disc everywhere.

I miss browsing the aisle in best buy, looking at the fancy boxes with screenshots and descriptions, deciding what game looks fun to buy. Ill never have that again :(

Now the best they do is a small box with a redeem code inside.

I'm slowly creeping into the "git off mah lawn" crowd....

Yup, that is what I see in most places, you get a card with a code. However that isn't buying a physical copy, that is buying a code for a digital copy. Which somehow people are confusing that and physical copies of games. And yup, we are all slowly getting into that crowd. Why are we getting old :(
 
Zarathustra[H];1041886766 said:
I'm not 100% certain, as it's been a while since I fired up the first game, but as I recall Civ1 did have the Civilopedia entirely in game, but when the piracy check screen would come up, it would be locked on that screen until you entered the correct answer, so you couldn't check it. So you had to look at the paper version in the manual.

This screen shot seems to confirm this:

blogcivilizationscreen.jpg


It's funny how looking at this, even now almost 25 years later, just seeing a square city icon without a bold black outline makes me anxious :p
 
That is what I am trying to figure out for some of these people. Where do they actually live that PC games are still on disc everywhere.
Gamestop will order PC games on demand, but otherwise they won't stock anything unless it's guaranteed to sell copies. Mostly Blizzard stuff, but their boxes only have a code inside these days. The Target and Wal-mart stores around me actually have a decent selection of PC games on display.
 
Gamestop will order PC games on demand, but otherwise they won't stock anything unless it's guaranteed to sell copies. Mostly Blizzard stuff, but their boxes only have a code inside these days. The Target and Wal-mart stores around me actually have a decent selection of PC games on display.

digital codes do not equal physical copies of games though. Target and Walmart by me have maybe 10 pc games on a shelf if that. everything else is console games or digital code cards.
 
I buy DVDs and Blu-Rays for movies and television seasons, I buy games via digital download from GOG (my all time favorite digital download game platform), Steam, and Origin, and I prefer to buy music that I can instantly download vs. CDs, though I do make an exception for albums remastered by Rock Candy Records, as they often contain bonus tracks, expanded CD booklet artwork, and a new ~3,000 word essay by legendary metal journalists. Also, out of print CDs that aren't available on Amazon's Digital Music store I will track down and buy if they're from artists that I like.

Buy from Amazon and get both :D
 
1. Not just talking about PC games.

2. Like somecallmeTim said, consider the source.
 
Well, seeing as Securom/Safedisk are now a no-go on Windows what are they going to use for DRM on disk based games now? All those games with Securom/Safedisk sitting on the shelves of retail stores need to be thrown in the dumpster out back. But of course they won't and will keep selling them anyway.
Criminal.
 
their boxes only have a code inside these days.

It's interesting. Something similar was the case with Civ5 when it launched 5 years ago.

The retail version actually came with a disk, but required Steam in order to run. There were so many early patches though, that many who got the retail version complained that they pretty much downloaded the whole thing from Steam anyway, when they installed it. Very little was actually read from the disk.
 
The only games I get on DVD are collector's editions. Even those just use a code for the actual game.
 
As was mentioned, replace disc with physical media and this is more accurate. Now I wouldn't say "forever", but foreseeable future for sure.

I would say that roughly 1/3 of my game purchases are pure digital. Discount the game enough and Sure I'll get it digitally, Try and charge me the same price as the disc and frankly you can take a flying leap, I want a disc if I'm not getting a discount. The disc guarantees me at least "some" return on investment if I so choose to exercise that option. That for me is really the crux of it, I want the "Option" to be able to get some return value on my purchases. Digital doesn't offer that and as a result I value it far less than physical. That and sometimes for very specific games I enjoy some of the fun things you can get with CE's. Most suck sure, but I have a small collection of art and figures I appreciate having.
 
Steam?

I don;'t buy anything physical. I have over 400 games though the years.
 
It's funny how this somehow transformed into only PC games and nothing else.

Console games, in physical form, can be resold. Depends on how popular the game is, you can resell it for more than you bought it for. How my old Xenogears was for PS2.

There's not even a point in talking about PC games, when you're stuck registering it to some kind of online service, rendering that install disc pretty pointless. That only leaves Limited/Collector's editions with some other kind of physical incentive. Pretty much I just went through 2 pages of pointless drivel.
 
When was the last time anyone here purchased a PC game on physical media?

i prefer to buy my games/movies/music on physical media. i bought all my WoW expansions on CD/DVD, the Warcraft III Battle Chest with both expansions, Oblivion, Skyrim, the Morrowind GOTY edition with both expansions, Guild Wars 1 & 2, several of the Lego games, etc.

i just like having a physical copy of whatever it is i'm buying, especially in the case of movies & music....with those physical copies, i can rip/encode those things any way i see fit, and know with 100% certainty that the resulting end-product will not have any sort of DRM or other limiting bullshit in it.

i'll make a .BIN or .ISO copy of my music, and an .MKV copy of my blurays, then store those on my media server for general use, and store away the physical media in a safe place. if anything ever happens to my digital copy, no problem, i just re-rip it and i have it again, rather than wasting my monthly allotment of data on my ISP plan to re-download it.
 
This is ONLY because 50GB downloads for the 72% of Americans not on a fixed broadband is untenable. That said, the only game I've considered buying in disc format over the last 5 years is Fallout 4, and that's just because I wanted a Pip Boy. That ship sailed though, without me on it :(
 
This is ONLY because 50GB downloads for the 72% of Americans not on a fixed broadband is untenable. That said, the only game I've considered buying in disc format over the last 5 years is Fallout 4, and that's just because I wanted a Pip Boy. That ship sailed though, without me on it :(

Yea but when the games come out with bugs and hd textures and such, who doesn't have to download all that even with physical media?
 
Yea but when the games come out with bugs and hd textures and such, who doesn't have to download all that even with physical media?

PC physical media requires you to activate online anyways and half the time, it just starts auto-updating with 20+ gig updates.
 
Yea but when the games come out with bugs and hd textures and such, who doesn't have to download all that even with physical media?

Which is largely why I've largely stopped playing modern games. I have a 300gb cap, or roughly 10gb a day to use, so it comes down to downloading 60gb of game and patches and paying a extra $20-30 for the overage, or saving it for netflix or recreational surfing.
 
Which is largely why I've largely stopped playing modern games. I have a 300gb cap, or roughly 10gb a day to use, so it comes down to downloading 60gb of game and patches and paying a extra $20-30 for the overage, or saving it for netflix or recreational surfing.

I have been thus far dodging the data cap bullet (lucky to live where that isn't happening), but a close friend of mine does so usually he is a month behind to play a game we both bought at the same time. It really is crappy how much that holds someone down from gaming. Sometimes I wont turn steam on for a month or so and opening that would destroy any cap and cost a fortune just with updates, same thing for console games.
 
I rather see a USB device media to replace CD's would be a better idea, the thing I hate about CD's is if it gets scratched, you won't be able to use it.
 
I rather see a USB device media to replace CD's would be a better idea, the thing I hate about CD's is if it gets scratched, you won't be able to use it.

I'm not worried about durability. I can probably count the number of CDs (not CDRs) that quit working due to scratches on one hand, and I've got CDs that are 30 years old. Same with DVDs and Blu Ray (though the sample size is much smaller and the time frame is no more than 17 years).

OTOH, Optical is much slower than USB3 (never mind 3.1). I assume that flash drives cost more than a DVD or a BD. I think the best thing about stand alone games on optical media is that you own the game. Granted, you may not have all the patches on it, but if Steam disappeared tomorrow, your games could disappear too. I'll always have my optical media as a fall back.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041886484 said:
Where do they even sell PC games in retail these days?

Most of Europe. EU Steam prices are terrible so we keep our PC shelves alive.
 
Yeah, but many of the newer titles still aren't playable without Steam, even if you have a disk.

The disk is just there to aid in making the install faster (which it only does when the title is new, because as soon as there are patches, large portions must be downloaded again.)

Not a big deal for me personally though, as I have pulled as much as 17 MB/s off of steam.
 
Most of Europe. EU Steam prices are terrible so we keep our PC shelves alive.

Interesting.

I wonder why that is. They are very competitive here.

You'd think Steam would make even more sense in Europe, where internet connections are typically of better quality than in the US.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041891523 said:
Games on the shelves must be cheaper in Europe than here.

I just found a Steam price comparison tool, and while prices were indeed higher in Europe, it wasn't significantly so.

Retaining the dollar = euro policy is enough for me to consider it bad enough and buy new games from a retailer. EA is doing much better work in that regard, even though they don't sell games that I want. In the end I download the game from Steam for a few minutes anyway. Sounds ridiculous but it is what it is.

nilepez, that sounds like a great way to get my library taken away from me. Not worth it over a game or ten :)
 
Which is largely why I've largely stopped playing modern games. I have a 300gb cap, or roughly 10gb a day to use, so it comes down to downloading 60gb of game and patches and paying a extra $20-30 for the overage, or saving it for netflix or recreational surfing.

These CAPs absolutely have to go if game/media companies want us to buy and download their products. We need to organize and demand the government force the ISPs to stop this bs. I pay $63.00 per moth before taxes and that has a 250GB CAP - unacceptable! :mad:
 
These CAPs absolutely have to go if game/media companies want us to buy and download their products. We need to organize and demand the government force the ISPs to stop this bs. I pay $63.00 per moth before taxes and that has a 250GB CAP - unacceptable! :mad:

Truth is, this should be able to be challenged in the courts, as the only reason they do this is to limit peoples availability to cut out their TV packages and replace them with streaming services.

As such it is using their control of the last mile internet service, to lock out a competitor in the different market, and last time I checked this was illegal.

If Microsoft can be sued for using Windows as a vehicle to promote their own browser, then the ISP's can CERTAINLY be sued for this.
 
Retaining the dollar = euro policy is enough for me to consider it bad enough and buy new games from a retailer. EA is doing much better work in that regard, even though they don't sell games that I want. In the end I download the game from Steam for a few minutes anyway. Sounds ridiculous but it is what it is.

nilepez, that sounds like a great way to get my library taken away from me. Not worth it over a game or ten :)

I bet they don't care. Assuming VAT is included in the price, if you buy it in the U.S., you have no VAT.

You could also create a fake account and gift yourself games :D
 
I bet they don't care. Assuming VAT is included in the price, if you buy it in the U.S., you have no VAT.

You could also create a fake account and gift yourself games :D

If they wanted to follow the audit trail it wouldn't be too difficult.

The question is, do they care enough to do so?
 
These CAPs absolutely have to go if game/media companies want us to buy and download their products. We need to organize and demand the government force the ISPs to stop this bs. I pay $63.00 per moth before taxes and that has a 250GB CAP - unacceptable! :mad:

I just hope TWC doesn't change their policy now that they're being bought out. I went from 30 down 5 up to 200 down and 10 or 20 up at no extra charge and all with no caps. I'm actually thinking of lowering my plan, because I rarely manage to use 100 Mbps, much less 200. I may even drop to the lowest plan (50 mbps).
 
Zarathustra[H];1041891829 said:
If they wanted to follow the audit trail it wouldn't be too difficult.

The question is, do they care enough to do so?

I don't think they do. They get paid either way. You're avoiding VAT and and about 12 cents/dollar due to the exchange rate.
If you mostly buy stuff during sales, then they're arguably Gifts for Xmas.
I know the only time I buy them is during the big sales (and not always then).

Maybe you can save money by buying via Humble Bundle and make it harder for Valve to check
 
I just hope TWC doesn't change their policy now that they're being bought out. I went from 30 down 5 up to 200 down and 10 or 20 up at no extra charge and all with no caps. I'm actually thinking of lowering my plan, because I rarely manage to use 100 Mbps, much less 200. I may even drop to the lowest plan (50 mbps).

On the FiOS 150/150 plan I almost always get at least 8MB/s, very often I'm at 12MB/s to 14MB/s and frequently all the way up to ~17.5MB/s when downloading from Steam.

My overall cable package costs a little bit more than I'd like though, especially since I'd drop the cable package if it weren't for my fiance.

I'd take one of those Gigabit Googe Fiber/Community Internet packages any day though.
 
Back
Top