BFG es800 2 gone bad anyone else?

dondude

Weaksauce
Joined
Dec 6, 2005
Messages
84
I'm currently rma'ing my 2nd es800 power supply. 2 different systems both had the dreaded on flicker then shutdown. BFG having problems with these or what? Both worked for about 3 -4 weeks.
 
Dunno, mine's been flawless from the start, and only shutdown to reboot. I've had it going since August.
 
I got one for a new build this week. The fan bearing on the first one was bad from the start - it made an awful rattling/ticking noise as it spun. Got a replacement yesterday that's trucking along just fine so far, but it's only been 2 days. Hopefully I won't run into the bad luck you've had :)

-Fin
 
I was thinking it might be my house electrical but I've never had any problems before. 3 dvr's and 3 computers running all the time maybe it is just bad luck. Hopefully next one will last.
 
I was thinking about purchasing an ES800, but 2 bad, and one with a defective fan isn't setting my mind at ease. This completely nulls the fact that H gave it a gold award. What good is an awesome PSU if it only works for the review sites, and craps out for regular users that don't have the prestige to have it tested before hand?

I would go with the Enermax Revolution, but $340 for a PSU? Why not just ask for my first born while you're at it?
 
I was thinking about purchasing an ES800, but 2 bad, and one with a defective fan isn't setting my mind at ease. This completely nulls the fact that H gave it a gold award. What good is an awesome PSU if it only works for the review sites, and craps out for regular users that don't have the prestige to have it tested before hand?

How does two stories of 3 bad PSUs completely null the [H] Gold Award? That's only two user reviews. I'm more than willing to bet that there are lot more people out there who have had good experiences with the BFG ES-800. Also note that most of the time, only those who have problems tend to complain/post/reviews
 
How does two stories of 3 bad PSUs completely null the [H] Gold Award? That's only two user reviews. I'm more than willing to bet that there are lot more people out there who have had good experiences with the BFG ES-800. Also note that most of the time, only those who have problems tend to complain/post/reviews

Valid point. BUT
I was going to get the ES800, but when I went to buy it on Newegg, the large amounts of DOA, or deaths after a few weeks was somewhat larger than I was comfortable with. It may be a PSU worthy of the [H] gold, but that has nothing to do with quality control...
 
Valid point. BUT
I was going to get the ES800, but when I went to buy it on Newegg, the large amounts of DOA, or deaths after a few weeks was somewhat larger than I was comfortable with. It may be a PSU worthy of the [H] gold, but that has nothing to do with quality control...

But like I said, "Also note that most of the time, only those who have problems tend to complain/post/reviews "

I usually take Newegg reviews with a grain of salt.
 
Did you happen to notice that some of the bad reviews came before the PSU was even released?!
 
Valid point. BUT
I was going to get the ES800, but when I went to buy it on Newegg, the large amounts of DOA, or deaths after a few weeks was somewhat larger than I was comfortable with. It may be a PSU worthy of the [H] gold, but that has nothing to do with quality control...

FACT: Of the 3000 units BFG has sold, I have only received 63 units back. That's a 2% RMA rate, which is actually a little higher than I'd like to see (I'd like 1% or less, of course) but nothing alarming.

I suppose there's a lot of negative reviews on Newegg because we haven't provided any incentive to convince people to post good reviews. For the most part, if someone has a bad experience, they post a bad review. If they have a good experience, they don't post anything at all. I must admit, I do the same thing.
 
I got one from the egg...it's working great - but I didn't post. I will check and see if I still can.
 
BFG doesn't actually make these. I don't recall who the OEM supplier is, but it would be interesting to see if other manufacturers using the same OEM are having similar problems.
 
FACT: Of the 3000 units BFG has sold, I have only received 63 units back. That's a 2% RMA rate, which is actually a little higher than I'd like to see (I'd like 1% or less, of course) but nothing alarming.

I suppose there's a lot of negative reviews on Newegg because we haven't provided any incentive to convince people to post good reviews. For the most part, if someone has a bad experience, they post a bad review. If they have a good experience, they don't post anything at all. I must admit, I do the same thing.

For what it's worth, I am extremely pleased with my ES-800. The overall build quality is outstanding. I wasn't too sure of how I felt about the mirrored finish, but it's definitely grown on me. The unit's efficiency is top notch, drawing a good ~60W less to power the same computer. It's also a great deal quieter than my previous supply; now the loudest components in my case are my hard drives.
 
FACT: Of the 3000 units BFG has sold, I have only received 63 units back. That's a 2% RMA rate, which is actually a little higher than I'd like to see (I'd like 1% or less, of course) but nothing alarming.

I suppose there's a lot of negative reviews on Newegg because we haven't provided any incentive to convince people to post good reviews. For the most part, if someone has a bad experience, they post a bad review. If they have a good experience, they don't post anything at all. I must admit, I do the same thing.
I do the same thing. If an item does everything I want it to, I am satisfied... and that's usually it.
But, don't get me wrong, I am a big BFG fan. My current PSU (GS650) and video card (GTX260 Maxcore) are both BFG, as was my previous card (8800GT). Thanks for the input though...
 
BFG doesn't actually make these. I don't recall who the OEM supplier is, but it would be interesting to see if other manufacturers using the same OEM are having similar problems.

It's Andyson, and now one else in the US is using the MT8 platform.

63 out of 3000 isn't really what I would call a problem ;)
 
I am on my third ES-800 as well. I know any manufacturer can have problems and you do only hear about the bad, but it's also hard to not become jaded when you get hit by a string of bad luck. I still think BFG make excellent products on the whole, but I think until this thing has been running with no issue for a year, I will still be thinking about it. Just yesterday my whole system just powered off in the middle of a TF2 match; I still haven't been able to pinpoint exactly what happened, but in the back of my head I still suspect the PSU.

The first ES-800 I purchased from Newegg literally sparked and smoked when I powered on. The second one had a high pitched capacitor whine that I deemed unacceptable and RMA'd direct to BFG. So far I have been pretty happy with the 3rd try. The fan seems a little louder than what is mentioned in most reviews, but I recognize I am a bit over sensitive to computer noise and just don't want to deal with it anymore :). 3rd PSU is probably going on about 3 months now.
 
I was also a little skeptical after reading the NewEgg reviews, but they're right, users only post bad reviews usually.

No issues here, granted I'm not really pushing the PSU to the limit, but I'm very satisfied with everything so far. The ONLY negative I can find is the non-modular part. If my PSU ever goes bad, then it will be a bitch to undo my wiring job :( for an RMA (Lifetime warranty FTW).

I also had a great experience with their 24/7 tech support, took awhile to get on the line (not too long for customer service), but it was a very pleasant experience. I just might have to start getting BFG video cards instead of EVGA now.
 
I am on my third ES-800 as well. I know any manufacturer can have problems and you do only hear about the bad, but it's also hard to not become jaded when you get hit by a string of bad luck. I still think BFG make excellent products on the whole, but I think until this thing has been running with no issue for a year, I will still be thinking about it. Just yesterday my whole system just powered off in the middle of a TF2 match; I still haven't been able to pinpoint exactly what happened, but in the back of my head I still suspect the PSU.

The first ES-800 I purchased from Newegg literally sparked and smoked when I powered on. The second one had a high pitched capacitor whine that I deemed unacceptable and RMA'd direct to BFG. So far I have been pretty happy with the 3rd try. The fan seems a little louder than what is mentioned in most reviews, but I recognize I am a bit over sensitive to computer noise and just don't want to deal with it anymore :). 3rd PSU is probably going on about 3 months now.

So really you had one bad unit. Other than annoying and audible to some people the whine from electronics is actually fairly normal.
 
So really you had one bad unit. Other than annoying and audible to some people the whine from electronics is actually fairly normal.

Well I considered it bad, the noise it was generating was far beyond normal electronics noise such that it was the predominant noise coming from the PC, over the fans and hard drives, though true, maybe its just me.


That said, I do want to also add to KevanB's comment too. Given the complaint, BFG tech support was still absolutely awesome. I had no hassles with getting a replacement shipped out quickly and the folks on the phone were very polite and helpful. I don't think I even had a wait time on a Sunday afternoon. The support behind the products alone was enough to convince me. :)
 
That's true. I am a bit of a cynic when it comes to technology in that I assume it will die or break eventually. A good example is AT&T Uverse. I was a first-adopter in my area and had some issues at the beginning. The reason I still have it almost a year and a half later is because when I called for help, I got amazing service.
To be honest, if it goes back under $100 again on the 'egg ;) I might bite...
 
It's Andyson, and now one else in the US is using the MT8 platform.

63 out of 3000 isn't really what I would call a problem ;)

Unless your one of the 63. :D

Which was my point, but I guess those are pretty good odds. I just really try to stay away from hardware where single users have more than one of the same item go bad on them, though I do understand that it may not be the products fault, but still. Nobody has time to be RMAing back PSUs, let alone multiple times.

I may still get it, but if I am one of the 63, you will be sure to feel my complaint. It will feel like 100 bad reviews all posted at the same time. :)
 
Well... what's odd here is we have one gent that's gone through two and another that's gone through three. Not to displace blame, but if I got through more than one of anything (never mind two), I have to start looking at other causes of the problem. ;-)
 
I'm currently rma'ing my 2nd es800 power supply. 2 different systems both had the dreaded on flicker then shutdown. BFG having problems with these or what? Both worked for about 3 -4 weeks.

The problem you are describing is not a bad PSU, and if we were close enough I'd bet big I could have the problem solved in about 15 min or so.

Google your symptoms, you will find that the problem (as described) spans the entire PSU as well as Motherboard market.

Diagnostics requires a logical pattern of thought and if you have one, a multimeter. Any modern PSU needs to "see" a specific set of parameters to turn on and stay on, miss one and you get the on off syndrome or no turn on all together. Most motherboards are protected as well.

Find the bad parameter match, problem solved. Honest.;):)
 
Well were talking about 2 completely different systems. Both times I was able to put my colorjit or colorsit 480w power supply and both worked flawless. The first system worked fine for over 2 years with the 480w power supply. I received my 3rd es800 today and is in my system right now. Hope it lasts. Maybe I was unlucky?
 
Well were talking about 2 completely different systems. Both times I was able to put my colorjit or colorsit 480w power supply and both worked flawless. The first system worked fine for over 2 years with the 480w power supply. I received my 3rd es800 today and is in my system right now. Hope it lasts. Maybe I was unlucky?

Could be, but the odds are against it;)
 
So if my systems have a problem why would they both work with other power supplies installed with nothing else changed? Both systems work fine with old power supplies. Why would new BFG supply not boot when elcheapo power supply works fine? I'm using replacement es800 right now if my system had a problem wouldn't it not boot like old supply?
 
So if my systems have a problem why would they both work with other power supplies installed with nothing else changed? Both systems work fine with old power supplies. Why would new BFG supply not boot when elcheapo power supply works fine? I'm using replacement es800 right now if my system had a problem wouldn't it not boot like old supply?

I understand you line of reasoning I really do.

The problem is too many variables between the machines. Something as dumb as a bad Molex to three pin adaptor for instance, I now have a collection of three.

Sometimes it's as simple as a BIOS reset or simply allowing the motherboard to sit a day or two for all the caps to discharge. Many motherboards have onboard logic and the complete removal of a PSU and replacement can trigger the on off thing.

I've seen the issue of lack of current on the standard PCI bus and a two year old Creative Sound Blaster cause the problem, replacing the sound card with the newer PCI-e solved the problem. Of course so would simply pulling the sound card.

Hey, I'm just an old guy with time on my hands and a few limited skills so I tend to be a digger, I don't like unsolved mysteries. ;)
 
Well I've made it past 2 days so far on this power supply. Lets hope my problems are over and I'll be a happy camper for along time with this psu.
 
3rd power supply still going strong just upgraded to phenom 2 940 system is working great. Thanks bfg.
 
I got one from the egg...it's working great - but I didn't post. I will check and see if I still can.

That was over 8 months ago now...still running great and to me it doesn't even make any discernable noise.
 
Back
Top