Best intel CPU motherboard for raid?

Joined
Mar 23, 2007
Messages
47
What's the best intel based motherboard raid solution?

Looking to build a WHS server and want a motherboard with the best raid solution (ie fast/reliable).



Greg
 
You basically have two choices the Intel chipset with its ICH9R or ICH10R or an Nvidia chipset board supporting Intel CPU with its on-board raid. Read up on Matrix Storage on Intel web site. The ability to make a mirrored raid 5 with only 4 drives is interesting for data that critical but never consider raid 5 or mirroring as a valid backup solution for truely crtical data.

If it is a true mission critical server and disk I/0 is a priority with heavy transaction loads (as opposed to serving up a couple of files every few seconds) I have to recommend the Intel boards for compatibility stability reliability and the on-board raid is rock solid and very flexible. However be aware that a ICH9R or ICH10R raid 5 array can only contain 4 physical drives unless you buy the true server/workstation chipset - I forget the number. Look at super-micro boards.

Now the on-board raid is pretty good but its not any performance leader. If you truly need high performance disk I/0 buy an Intel chipset board and stick in a raid card with true hardware based/accelerated raid functions. Buy two cards and keep one as a spare as each manuf tends to use proprietary raid formatting algorithms and if the raid card dies you cannot just slap in anyones raid card and go back to work.

In summary: really fast + really reliable = $$$$$$$$


I find the intel on-board solution fine for all my needs. I put the OS and apps and page file on a standalone drive (thinking of raid 0 for it one day) and all data on the raid. One approach would be to try the onboard but before the amount of data got out of hand - if you were not happy, then buy a true raid card.

As far as whose board an ICH9R is an ICH9R same for the 10R and so other features and concerns should drive whose board you buy. As afar as disk goes there is no difference between the 9R and 10R chip the 10R southbridge has some enhancement I cant remember but nothing to do with disk.

Me personally, for a server
 
IIRC, WHS just uses a JBOD system and you indicate individual folders for redundancy. It doesn't seem like you actually setup a RAID array to install WHS.
 
Back
Top