Auditors Question U.S. Wireless Competition

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A new report from the Government Accountability Office says that, although prices have come down over the years, consumers currently have fewer choices.

As requested, this report discusses changes in the wireless industry since 2000, stakeholders' perceptions of regulatory policies and industry practices, and the strategies FCC uses to monitor competition. To conduct this work, GAO collected and analyzed data and documents from a variety of government and private sources; conducted case studies in both rural and urban areas of four states; and interviewed stakeholders representing consumers, local and state agencies and officials, and various segments of the industry.
 
I've been saying this for years.

There may be a few competitors on the market, but in most places only AT&T and Verizon are viable options, and they pretty much behave as the same company. When one gets rid of their flat rate data plans, so does the other, etc. etc.

This is called collusion - really just another form of monopoly, as the competitors behave as one to maintain the status quo - and is illegal per the Sherman act of 1890.

The carriers have too much power in the U.S. On the wireless front Italy would be a good model for the U.S. to strive to be like. They have no 2 year contract requirements, and phones are never either locked to a network, or restricted by the carriers own firmware blocking out hardware features they want to charge you more for.
 
Zarathustra[H];1036107594 said:
I've been saying this for years.

There may be a few competitors on the market, but in most places only AT&T and Verizon are viable options, and they pretty much behave as the same company. When one gets rid of their flat rate data plans, so does the other, etc. etc.

This is called collusion - really just another form of monopoly, as the competitors behave as one to maintain the status quo - and is illegal per the Sherman act of 1890.

The carriers have too much power in the U.S. On the wireless front Italy would be a good model for the U.S. to strive to be like. They have no 2 year contract requirements, and phones are never either locked to a network, or restricted by the carriers own firmware blocking out hardware features they want to charge you more for.

Behaving exactly the same as a business creates collusion? Then why haven't they attacked petroleum companies. That's 2 ways they are borderline monopolies. If it weren't for the fact that most gas stations and card readers at pumps were owned by a third party, they would be. Then again, I never understood how you can sell a commodity for a variable price when you're the one drilling for it, shipping it to shore, processing it, and shipping it to stations.. all in one operation. That used to be called a monopoly.
 
Behaving exactly the same as a business creates collusion? Then why haven't they attacked petroleum companies. That's 2 ways they are borderline monopolies. If it weren't for the fact that most gas stations and card readers at pumps were owned by a third party, they would be. Then again, I never understood how you can sell a commodity for a variable price when you're the one drilling for it, shipping it to shore, processing it, and shipping it to stations.. all in one operation. That used to be called a monopoly.

It's the old "Acting as a business" argument.... Sigh... The problem is that Cellular service is NOT an open market. The cost barrier to entry is WAY too high. As such it needs to be regulated to ensure the consumers are not getting overly screwed. The Petroleum Companies are in a similar boat, but they are dealing with a product that's sold on commodities markets. There is no "Cellular Bandwidth" commodity market were people can speculate on. Cellular companies have relatively fixed costs. IE: Equipment doesn't just go away once it's purchased.

It collusion because Company A see's Company B raising prices so they raise there's as well because there's no Company C which people can jump too, and the two year contract prevents people from jumping ship.

My big complaint is that after the two year contract is up, how come my bill doesn't go down? The contract is required to recoup the cost of the phone, I get that, but after two years, they've recovered the cost, so how come no price break? That is a HUGE problem.
 
Behaving exactly the same as a business creates collusion? Then why haven't they attacked petroleum companies. That's 2 ways they are borderline monopolies. If it weren't for the fact that most gas stations and card readers at pumps were owned by a third party, they would be. Then again, I never understood how you can sell a commodity for a variable price when you're the one drilling for it, shipping it to shore, processing it, and shipping it to stations.. all in one operation. That used to be called a monopoly.

Um, that's probably because you don't understand the commodities market and how it works. Petroleum vs. Cellular mobile are two different things. One is subject to market forces as in the petroleum industry being at the mercy of supply/demand on the commodities exchange. The other is not subject to such forces since they aren't a producer of a commodity, but rather a reseller of frequency. They've already bought and paid for the ability to broadcast on those frequencies and those frequencies never run dry. I've oversimplified it, but that's the gist.
 
My big complaint is that after the two year contract is up, how come my bill doesn't go down? The contract is required to recoup the cost of the phone, I get that, but after two years, they've recovered the cost, so how come no price break? That is a HUGE problem.

Couldn't agree more This pisses me off bigtime. It also disincentivises you from choosing a 3rd party device, because you are going to be paying the same either way, why choose something where you have to pay upfront?

Heck, they sued Microsoft for non-competitive practices for including various pieces of software with Windows, why not sue wireless companies over this scheme?
 
Um, that's probably because you don't understand the commodities market and how it works. Petroleum vs. Cellular mobile are two different things. One is subject to market forces as in the petroleum industry being at the mercy of supply/demand on the commodities exchange. The other is not subject to such forces since they aren't a producer of a commodity, but rather a reseller of frequency. They've already bought and paid for the ability to broadcast on those frequencies and those frequencies never run dry. I've oversimplified it, but that's the gist.

Oh I understand how the commodities market works. However, cellular mobile is exactly the definition of it's own commodities market. Frequencies aren't infinite nor are the parts used to maintain them. So, in an effort to curb those costs, companies set up a marketplaces to sell a commodity: Bandwidth. Just because it isn't trade on the NYSE doesn't mean it's not a commodity.

However, oil companies don't really have supply/demand issues. Wells are constantly being found (and some are found to keep producing after thought dry) and the industry itself is changing and faces risks on all sides. The parts used to operate the industry haven't changed a whole lot since the 60's and 70's. In essence, how can you be regulated by supply/demand issues when you are the one drilling for oil? You are the one transporting it, you are the one selling it and reprocessing it. Even wages haven't altered drastically in 2 decades. Sure, if you are buying oil for upturns and seasonal sales changes then yes, you should be regulated by the market. However, it's a pretty crappy business model you have if you are planning to need to buy something you yourself are creating on such a regular basis and your price planning is based on it. On top of all that, it doesn't make sense on a global level. How come you pay the same for gas no matter where you really go in the US (depending on taxes) but drive around in Venezuela or Iraq and it's like 8 cents a gallon? If it were a real commodity, wouldn't those markets be paying more to offset the differences because surely they can't afford to ignore repurchasing of goods.. oh wait. .they don't.. they drill for what they need instead of planning for failure. Those countries also don't have to tolerate oil companies jacking up prices to fake shortages and taking in windfall profits when they should be making less.

In our case, we've outgrown oil companies in all honesty. They just have a stranglehold on manufacturing that forces us to keep dealing with this crap coupled with a stranglehold on industries that require large amounts of fuel to sustain. You ever wonder how much money the post office would save if those stupid small delivery trucks were running on solar hybrid motors? Well you'll never know due to the lengthy contracts the post office has with big oil.
 
Oh I understand how the commodities market works. However, cellular mobile is exactly the definition of it's own commodities market. Frequencies aren't infinite nor are the parts used to maintain them. So, in an effort to curb those costs, companies set up a marketplaces to sell a commodity: Bandwidth. Just because it isn't trade on the NYSE doesn't mean it's not a commodity.

I disagree - Frequencies aren't infinite yes, however just USING the frequency doesn't cause the frequency to go away, unlike petroleum products where once they are consumed, they are gone. The parts to maintain the frequency get cheaper or provide more features as time goes on. Finding new wells however continue to get more costly due to geographic and political considerations...

And where is bandwidth traded like a commodity? I'd like to buy some futures.....
 
I disagree - Frequencies aren't infinite yes, however just USING the frequency doesn't cause the frequency to go away, unlike petroleum products where once they are consumed, they are gone. The parts to maintain the frequency get cheaper or provide more features as time goes on. Finding new wells however continue to get more costly due to geographic and political considerations...

And where is bandwidth traded like a commodity? I'd like to buy some futures.....

However, much like oil, high usage can lead to problems and shortages of bandwidth. Also, oil might be gone but I haven't heard anyone say "we're running out of wells to tap". The opposite being true for bandwidth, wear competition for frequencies is rather at a fever pitch.

Oh.. and you are likely already buying bandwidth as a commodity.. just like gas.. at roughly $15-150/month for your share. Depending on usage.. again, just like oil. And if you've never run out of bandwidth, you need to get out in the country more :)
 
You know, if this continues on a little further, and the US gets governments that are successively more and more "attuned" to broadband policy, I'd expect a government takeover to be on the table. No not Chavez, but certainly Amtrak could be in the cards. Definitely Amtrak.

That is, if the states don't beat the feds out first, which is quite possible.
 
You know, if this continues on a little further, and the US gets governments that are successively more and more "attuned" to broadband policy, I'd expect a government takeover to be on the table. No not Chavez, but certainly Amtrak could be in the cards. Definitely Amtrak.

That is, if the states don't beat the feds out first, which is quite possible.

Nahh.. not Amtrak... they will be bankrupt within a couple years... the business that will take over is... VIVID VIDEO! Who wouldnt vote for their candidates with 3 hot lesbos doing each other in the campaign videos? ANd hell.. who wouldnt want to work for them with such perks to behold? Even if it was a complete overthrow... would you fight or lay down your arms, and scoop up a hot chick?

Deiniftely the United States of Vivid America....lol
 
My big complaint is that after the two year contract is up, how come my bill doesn't go down? The contract is required to recoup the cost of the phone, I get that, but after two years, they've recovered the cost, so how come no price break? That is a HUGE problem.

Completely agree.
 
Nahh.. not Amtrak... they will be bankrupt within a couple years... the business that will take over is... VIVID VIDEO! Who wouldnt vote for their candidates with 3 hot lesbos doing each other in the campaign videos? ANd hell.. who wouldnt want to work for them with such perks to behold? Even if it was a complete overthrow... would you fight or lay down your arms, and scoop up a hot chick?

Deiniftely the United States of Vivid America....lol

Amtrak isn' going bankrupt due to government mismanagement (though there is some of that). Amtrak is going bankrupt because Americans as a whole look down on shared transportation. People CRAVE their freedom, and thus HAVE to drive a car...

For some reason this does not apply to air travel...
 
Back
Top