ASUS, why would you do this to yourself?!

Zoson

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Aug 4, 2001
Messages
6,113
Some of you might recall the issues I had with ASUS recently RMAing my P5N-T and having them send me a board that didn't work and had a very obviously blown up capacitor.

Well, I had decided to flash my S2NSE to the latest S2NSE bios since it was newer than the S2E BIOS I had been using. Long story short is the board wrote, verified the bios ok, and then just didn't come back to life(yes I tried the battery trick, which worked on the last bios flash before this one, but did not work this time). So the board was dead and I started a new RMA.

Today I received the replacement board from ASUS, and once again, like the P5N-T, the replacement S2NSE is VERY obviously damaged and/or missed QA completely.

The Images are HUGE. I took them at high res for ASUS's management. Look if you dare!

Damaged Back Panel:
Broken CMOS reset switch
Mangled Esata and slightly damaged firewire.
Note the LCD Poster connection is COMPLETELY snapped off.
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/damagedbackpanel.jpg

Damaged Traces Near the PCI slots:
Very visible damaged traces. I noticed this within 1 second of removing the board from its anti static bag.
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/damagedtracesbypcie.jpg

Visible signs of a water leak:
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/waterspots.jpg
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/waterspots2.jpg

Very poorly mounted stack cool II
You can literally see light coming through there... Isn't the cooler supposed to be touching those components? =P
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/improperlymountedcooler.jpg
http://i144.photobucket.com/albums/r193/zoson/improperlymountedcooler2.jpg

Once, yeah I can understand shit happens... But this is twice IN A ROW.
 
and when you try and return it, theyll try and claim ZOMG Physical dmg not our problem kk byebye, "prease bye more auss stuff in fruture pwease."

even better when they send you refurbished shit, pisses me off, even more when they dont disclose it


i hate their support, only reason i got my board it was the only x48 in stock at the time
 
I havent owned an asus board since they sent me 4 (yes 4) non working replacements for my P5N32.....
 
I havent owned an asus board since they sent me 4 (yes 4) non working replacements for my P5N32.....

I used to love ASUS, and their products. That view is very quickly turning sour.
 
I was having problems with my Maximus Formula SE being picky about my RAM after a year of using them together. I'm still not sure if the RAM died, would be odd for both sticks to have died at once after completely turning the power off but I guess could still happen.

After hearing and seeing a lot of recent ASUS horror stories about their RMA and support, I am very glad I didn't have to go down that way. I simply had to buy new RAM.

I hope it turns out well for you and I'm going to guess that this will be your last ASUS?
 
I have let ASUS management know of this thread.
 
I haven't purchased ASUS since they ran me around over an A7N8X Deluxe. I eventually threw that board in a trashcan because ASUS had left me to rot on the tech support treadmill trying to avoid giving me an RMA. Went to MSI and Gigabyte and have been happy ever since. Hmmmmmm.....lets see......thats about 6 years without buying anything from Asus. I know I don't make a spit in Asus' bucket but if they knew how many boards and graphics cards I'd purchased since then plus how many times I've taken the opportunity to join threads bashing ASUS they would have politely RMA'd my M****R F*****G A7N8X Deluxe instead of dicking me around over and over and over and over. I'm still mad about it to this day. Probably more at myself for giving up and letting them get away with it but still.




I must reveal that I jumped on the $34 ASUS 9600GSO but it went into my In-Law's computer and they ultimately paid for it so.......
 
I'd send it back based on the damaged traces alone. Who knows what damage a potential short will cause to your other components.

As for the 'water spots', I'm quite sure that is no-clean flux residue. Reason being most PCA's are not built with aqueous flux any longer due to the 'lead-free' movement all companies are required to abide by, therefore negating the reason to wash the PCA's at all. (Flux residue is left on the boards). If this board was washed through an electro-cleaner, I would bet it was done 'against-the-rules' since you aren't 'sposed to wash boards that contain no-clean solder (hence the name 'no-clean').

Either way, I'd send it back and demand a brand new, unopened board or have hell to pay with the BBB.

Good luck!
 
so who's Mobo RMA process is best?

Only time I ever had to RMA a mobo was through Abit and it was smooth. Advanced RMA with deposit and it was fast. To bad they went out of business.
 
I'd send it back based on the damaged traces alone. Who knows what damage a potential short will cause to your other components.

As for the 'water spots', I'm quite sure that is no-clean flux residue. Reason being most PCA's are not built with aqueous flux any longer due to the 'lead-free' movement all companies are required to abide by, therefore negating the reason to wash the PCA's at all. (Flux residue is left on the boards). If this board was washed through an electro-cleaner, I would bet it was done 'against-the-rules' since you aren't 'sposed to wash boards that contain no-clean solder (hence the name 'no-clean').

Either way, I'd send it back and demand a brand new, unopened board or have hell to pay with the BBB.

Good luck!

If the residue were flux residue, it would only appear on the PCB itself, not on the tops of the actual components attached to the board itself.

ASUS has issued me an advanced RMA for a third board now that they have the pictures in hand.
 
I'd send it back based on the damaged traces alone. Who knows what damage a potential short will cause to your other components.

As for the 'water spots', I'm quite sure that is no-clean flux residue. Reason being most PCA's are not built with aqueous flux any longer due to the 'lead-free' movement all companies are required to abide by, therefore negating the reason to wash the PCA's at all. (Flux residue is left on the boards). If this board was washed through an electro-cleaner, I would bet it was done 'against-the-rules' since you aren't 'sposed to wash boards that contain no-clean solder (hence the name 'no-clean').

Either way, I'd send it back and demand a brand new, unopened board or have hell to pay with the BBB.

Good luck!


i have a feeling the board was an RMA from some idiot that didnt know how to do water cooling.. if you notice the water stains.. then on top of that the PWM/mosfet heatsink is loose. that would lean toward the board having a mosfet water block on it and the idiot that had it before didnt put the heatsink back on all the way.. but thats my best guess..

good luck on the RMA.. after 5 different attempts with my m2n-sli deluxe board and never getting an actual fully working board back i gave up on asus and unless its a killer deal on one of their boards ill probably never buy one again.. made the switch to biostar about a year ago and have yet to find something to complain about them..
 
Water spots can be from them cleaning the board, not a water coolign set up, i had that on one board, it was all over the board back and front.

but even still ALL of the other issues, this is ridiculous, are companies getting this lazy / careless, they just spit out used boards.


i am sorry , if i buy a new product and it does not work, it gets replaced with a NEW product!
 
My buddy and I have both RMA'd ASUS boards of late.

He sent back his P5E, which had some strange errors occuring, that we traced to the motherboard. They sent the board back after "testing"... still the same problem. Sent it back again, and they sent him a completely non-working board. Once more, and he now actually has a working (for now) board... still a refurb though.

I've sent 2 boards back, and both times have gotten working, although visibly imperfect boards (the copper heatsink fins are bent and mangled on both boards, other various neglect problems, bent pins on the front panel connection area, etc).

Sucks that you pay so much for a brand new board, keep it nice, something happens to it, and you get someone else's beat up junk that may or may not work.
 
Only time I ever had to RMA a mobo was through Abit and it was smooth. Advanced RMA with deposit and it was fast. To bad they went out of business.

I really miss abit. I owned two BP6's, three NF7-S's(one 1.2 and two 2.0's), and an IC7. The BP6's were run until I upgraded and decommisioned them, all three of the NF7-S's are still running and in use, and the IC7 is also still in use.

I never had to RMA anything to abit, ever. Seriously, what the hell happened to quality like that?
 
Saving a few dollars per board or sending used boards as RMA is going to cost ASUS a hell of a lot more money in the long run. They must of got some new cheapskate CEO in the US division. Probably some guy that got fired from GM or AIG or something.
 
Wow. Forget everything else. Those ripped up trace circuits are pathetic on their own. I think you are owed a brand new board.
 
i like asus but this is one of many horrible rma support ive heard over the years about asus. i hope i never have to rma one. that is very unprofessional of them to even send that board to you .....in that condition.
 
I had a horrible experience with an Asus RMA last fall. I sent back a P5B because the BIOS completely effed up and left the board inop. I sent back the board using my companies UPS account and had my information inside the package. It was in the bag with the motherboard and yet they delayed my RMA almost two months because the label on the box was wrong :mad: I was told two weeks; three weeks max to receive my board back. After this, I do not think I'll buy another Asus board because of what "might" happen. I was buying Asus boards since the socket 7 days until last year...
 
I have been using DFI since socket A. DFI Street was great back in the day. I had a bad bios flash on my Ultra D and DFI sent me a fed ex pick up, reflashed it and sent it back, all in about 2 weeks. I have been using their boards since.
 
That's why you should buy an EVGA ;)

Ive seen alot of EVGA and BFG posts as of late where people also need to bitch and moan on a popular public forum to get service, thankfully they do have reps who respond and read the forums which i guess makes up for it, granted i dont think people should have to go to that extreme for good service
 
Wow, pretty surprised about this thread. Although I have never had to RMA an Asus board, I was always told they are great.

I thought when you use the Advanced RMA that they send you a new board?
 
sorry to hear that you've got the short end here, although I would say, at least they're ahead of ECS....

few years ago I had an ECS mainboard for my backup/#2 rig (was a P4 S478 with a GF FX, generally good hardware, and the mobo wasn't a slouch when it was new), took it apart for cleaning one day (clean the dust out of the graphics card, cable management, etc), got it all shiny and clean, everything was together 100% correctly, flipped it on and walked over to the kitchen to get a drink, came back, and (I bullshit you not) the thing was on fire :eek:

thankfully no hardware was damaged except for the mobo (which burned up) and the case (which had burns on the interior metal), the graphics card, CPU, PSU, RAM, etc all pulled out and went into another board with no issues, so I took a few pictures, sent 'em off to ECS Customer Support and Newegg, still haven't heard back from ECS, Newegg refunded me before the thing was even issued an RMA # (thankfully)

so, moral of the story:
it could be much worse, and hopefully thanks to bringing light to the issue, they'll work to fix the problem for you
 
Whoa, that's insane. 2 years ago I RMA'd a P5B-Plus for a friend and got a brand new board in return. I can't believe it's turned around so badly so quickly...:(
 
I have always bought and loved ASUS boards until my x58 experience with them. I had to wait THREE MONTHS for a working BIOS to support SLi on my P6T WS Pro. Sold and advertised for stellar SLi support, the board shipped with NO SLi support. Pissed me the F off for 3 freakin' months. I had a P5B-D blow up on me and I never bothered to RMA it because of threads like this one.

ASUS boards kick serious ass when they work, just hope n pray they keep working.
 
A bit OT, but I've been following some of the Asus press releases (taking on nintendo, building a better computer) and I can't help but wonder if all the MBA weenies that have been fired of late have found a new home in Taiwan. I mean, it seems like they are going to shoot themselves in the foot with the enthusiast by pushing total systems and foregoing the their current lines.

I don't think it's an industry trend, I returned a 12GB kit of OCZ memory awhile back that pooped, and OCZ upped me to 1600mhz from 1333 because it took them a day extra to test my return. Come on ASUS, you need to keep up here! Loyalty in a recession is everything, I'd wager. Came with a nice apology letter and everything.
 
Yikes, this isn't what I like to hear. Luckily I haven't had to RMA anything recently--and when I did it was back to Newegg, which offered a flawless experience.
 
Wow, pretty surprised about this thread. Although I have never had to RMA an Asus board, I was always told they are great.

I thought when you use the Advanced RMA that they send you a new board?
THIS. I have to check the text, but now that you mention it, I'm pretty sure the box DOES SAY that you get a *new* board. I specifically purchased this board because it was a part of the Advanced RMA. I didn't want to chance the same thing happening again as with my P5N-T. Clearly I spent the extra $100 on this motherboard for no reason though, since it happened again anyway.
 
I am about to pull the trigger on about $7k worth of components for a batch of computers for one of my clients. I'm now going through and removing all Asus components from my cart. I wouldn't want to touch any of this BS with a 10-foot pole.
 
I never had to RMA anything to abit, ever. Seriously, what the hell happened to quality like that?

Quality is expensive, and nobody wants to pay for it! :(

I'm disappointed in Asus, because they used to be my #1 pick for premium components but now it seems like they just care about the mainstream and the EEE line.
 
Dear Mr. Zoson:

We are owning your motherboardz.................resistance is futile.:eek:

Sorry to hear that you got hosed.

I've had several ASUS boards, but never had to RMA one, thank goodness.

As for the other posters, no one is perfect, but EVGA is pretty damn good about handling RMAs.
My very first evga MB purchase was a just released X58-SLI (758 A1 variety).
It arrived DOA.....called evga CS and got a replacement sent out same day.
I posted on the evga forums and here that I was bummed......I had evga CS all over me to make sure I was taken care of.
 
Hope I never have to RMA my 4850.... Glad I don't have any other ASUS components at the moment.

I hate dealing with trashy RMA. Been too many times I have received items back that were the same exact ones I have sent in with absolutely nothing done to them.

On the other hand... Logitech and Saitek have the BEST RMA ever. a while ago, I bought a used G7 mouse off of Ebay. It started messing up after a couple months. Posted on the Logitech forums looking for help and they told me to get an RMA... I even made sure they knew it was used when I bought it. They sent me out a nice, shiny, brand new G9. Didn't even have to send the broken G7 back.

A few years ago, I was given a used Saitek X35 Flight Stick / Throttle setup. It had the older style DB-15 joystick connector and wouldn't work due to some timing issue with faster computers. While trying to figure it out, I e-mailed their tech support asking about it, and they gave me an RMA and told me to send it in and they would replace it with the newer USB style one.

I only buy Logitech and Saitek input devices now.... Support like that is what wins customers.
 
People please by Asrock stuff. they are shinning in the market. their nex X58 extreme board is as good as Asus rampage II extreme and less than half price. I never need a rma or anything, i cant say anything about asrock customer service. But if they are good at customer service in 2 years they will be the one of the best manufacturer.
 
That's why you should buy an EVGA ;)

eVGA may have good RMA support but they are terrible at bios updates. The 650i took almost 8months to even get a bios update to support 45nm dual cores. Thats pretty fucking terrible. My 3yr old Asus 650i had one out within 2 weeks.

I am about to pull the trigger on about $7k worth of components for a batch of computers for one of my clients. I'm now going through and removing all Asus components from my cart. I wouldn't want to touch any of this BS with a 10-foot pole.

Really? One person has an issue with Asus and you are completely abandoning them? Overreact much?

As we all well know, people seldom post positive things about a company. Most will bitch and moan though when shit doesn't go their way.

All of my Asus RMA's have gone flawlessly and the support has been top notch. I bought an Asus GPU because of my stellar experience with their mobo's. EVGA lost me with thier shoddy bios support.

Don't forgot with Asus you don't have to register to get a warranty. Automatic 3 years w/ serial number. Means you can sell it with the warranty intact and make a few extra bones.

I kinda feel like I'm pimping them but Asus is honestly one of the best companies I've dealt with. I own a few of their mobo's, a gpu and an EEE pc and I've been nothing but satisfied.

Please people don't read this thread and assume all Asus products are shoddy and that their support is terrible. It's not.
 
Last edited:
I feel for you, OP. I know people here mention that they've had zero issues with Asus, but they should consider themselves fortunate. Every time I buy Asus I get burned. BURNED. Sorry Asus, but it's the truth.

On a side note, I remember watching a review of a new Asus mobo on TechTV. They mentioned that they originally planned to review it earlier, but had to RMA the boards they purchased. LOL. Then they gave the board HUGE praise. ROFL.
 
Back
Top