ASUS Support has failed me.

Silverghost

2[H]4U
Joined
Dec 22, 2002
Messages
2,627
My Crosshair IV stopped booting on me. The GPU fan would sit at 100% and only some of the fans plugged into the motherboard would turn on. Some will turn on after a few seconds. No Post, no beep, nothing. Sounds like the motherboard to me.

So I RMA'd it and ASUS sent it back it. Passed their boot test. Now what do I do?
 
test the board if not make sure it doesnt boot when u send it to them but.... Thats not cool... Idk
 
Try booting the machine with only 1 DIMM, in the slot closest to the CPU. If that works report back.
 
I tried playing with the ram. No change. Doesn't change the fact that 3 fan headers are still dead. I waited a week and a half for them to send the damn board back. So frustrated.
 
I tried playing with the ram. No change. Doesn't change the fact that 3 fan headers are still dead. I waited a week and a half for them to send the damn board back. So frustrated.

Damn only a week and a half? That is a freaking amazing turn around time for Asus.

I've gotten a dead board back from Asus after 2 months :(
 
Man, I thought I had it bad. I guess that's why you have a MSI board now?

I had bad experiences with two Asus board RMAs, and then Asus managed to spell "Athlon" wrong on a POST screen and I never used an Asus board again :D I still use them when I help other people build PCs if they request Asus.
 
In my experience, MSI boards have extremely fast turnaround times. I've sent it out Monday and gotten it back by Saturday of the same week. And getting an RMA number is simply waiting overnight for me. Of course, it helps that I'm literally ~3 hours from their RMA center...

However, with the recent debacle with their boards blowing up with Thuban, I'm sticking with Asus or Gigabyte for any Phenom II x6 builds. Never had to deal with Asus's RMA though, all I know is that I like my Crosshair IV right now. That really isn't right though, what they did to you.
 
Hi Silverghost,

Sorry that you had to deal with that experience. I've sent you a PM. Please reply with the details and I'll make sure we get this taken care of for you.
 

The power of the Forum!!

luis_carias_he-man_power.jpg
 
My Asus mobo has something called "Quite" mode for the fans. I'm not "Quite" sure what that does so I haven't used it yet.
 
Could be a bad cpu also. It's unlikely but possible which might explain why the board passed asus' tests.
 
Could be a bad cpu also. It's unlikely but possible which might explain why the board passed asus' tests.

I know your not claiming that it's 100% definitely the CPU but a bad cpu will not cause fan headers to be defective and not spin up fans.
 
I know your not claiming that it's 100% definitely the CPU but a bad cpu will not cause fan headers to be defective and not spin up fans.

Yeah which is why I said unlikely but I have seen boards do some funky stuff with bad cpu's that you wouldn't think would happen. It's worth a test if he has another cpu laying around, or trying another board with the same cpu. Won't lose anything by trying if he has the stuff.
 
I don't have any spare parts. That's the one thing I don't like about diagnosing. Gotta have spare stuff all the time :p
 
I would not suggest anyone doing this but for me, when I have a board that I know for a fact has issues I make sure the board is D-E-A-D when I send it in to prevent exactly what happened to this guy from happening to me. I had a MSI board I sent in a few years ago and it got returned to me with a tech report basically saying they could not find anything wrong. Yet, I had the same problems with multiple components. And that was a $200 dollar board. $200 dollars I was out.

If you have a suspect board with intermittent problems, you might want to consider killing the board before sending it in.

Some of you might know about the 9volt trick.
 
Same thing happened to me about 3-5 years ago when I turned in my p4c800 deluxe socket 478?

It ran fine for years, I NEVER touched it, and one day it would not boot or post. I shipped it to Asus (when they were not as popular as they are today, only for their motherboards and made nothing else) I think it actually went to China.

They sent it back, same thing..... I got really old DOT MATRIX style paper, just one paper, saying "Passed Boot". The funny part is, it still gave me problems.

I ebayed it (when ebay wasn't so shitty and didn't help scammers rip people off like they do today), ..... I actually got MORE THAN WHAT I PAID FOR IT YEARS BEFORE (p4c800 ended up being popular as hell then they quit making it, jacking UP the price :D )

But yeah... Asus RMA has been half-ass to me as well. They are great online, and communication... but once you ship it out you are then "lost at sea without a motor", honestly.

Good luck is all I can say I guess.....
 
I would not suggest anyone doing this but for me, when I have a board that I know for a fact has issues I make sure the board is D-E-A-D when I send it in to prevent exactly what happened to this guy from happening to me. I had a MSI board I sent in a few years ago and it got returned to me with a tech report basically saying they could not find anything wrong. Yet, I had the same problems with multiple components. And that was a $200 dollar board. $200 dollars I was out.

If you have a suspect board with intermittent problems, you might want to consider killing the board before sending it in.

Some of you might know about the 9volt trick.

Dude just no... You shouldn't do this yourself and you shouldn't encourage other people to purposefully destroy things before sending them in for RMA.
 
Last edited:
I would not suggest anyone doing this but for me, when I have a board that I know for a fact has issues I make sure the board is D-E-A-D when I send it in to prevent exactly what happened to this guy from happening to me. I had a MSI board I sent in a few years ago and it got returned to me with a tech report basically saying they could not find anything wrong. Yet, I had the same problems with multiple components. And that was a $200 dollar board. $200 dollars I was out.

If you have a suspect board with intermittent problems, you might want to consider killing the board before sending it in.

Some of you might know about the 9volt trick.

Yes, kill it dead, then send it in...........therefore, no controversies.
 
@ocellaris Relax

You read my disclaimer where I clearly stated from the start "I would not suggest anyone doing this" And if I were to truly encourage people I would have showed them how to kill a board, which I didn't. I've already got one PM asking me about the trick to where there will not be a reply. I don't feel comfortable here on Hardocp providing that kind of info but I will share my own personal stories from time to time.

These boards are extremely expensive. The prices are expected to rise 10% to 20%. That will make a $300 board cost on average $350 or a $400 dollar board costing well over $500 dollars.

There are too many stories out there about bad experiences with warranty work. And for anyone that didn't now, the raw material cost along with labor on average for these boards that they sell for $400 dollars is only about $75 dollars per unit. Also built into the retail cost of all boards is a board replacement tax the manufacture tack on. Of all the components in a PC, the number one part subject to failure due to user error is, DING! You guessed it, the motherboard. They are making a very healthy profit.

Personally, you will never catch me putting myself in a position to get effed over. In Russia, you work the system, not the system work you.
 
Last edited:
@ocellaris Relax

You read my disclaimer where I clearly stated from the start "I would not suggest anyone doing this" And if I were to truly encourage people I would have showed them how to kill a board, which I didn't. I've already got one PM asking me about the trick to where there will not be a reply. I don't feel comfortable here on Hardocp providing that kind of info but I will share my own personal stories from time to time.

These boards are extremely expensive. The prices are expected to rise 10% to 20%. That will make a $300 board cost on average $350 or a $400 dollar board costing well over $500 dollars.

There are too many stories out there about bad experiences with warranty work. And for anyone that didn't now, the raw material cost along with labor on average for these boards that they sell for $400 dollars is only about $75 dollars per unit. There are making a very healthy profit.

Personally, you will never catch me putting myself in a position to get effed over.


I completely agree.
I would not condone wacking a board just because it did not meet your expectations.....
that said, if you have a REAL problem and have tried to work it through to your best, sending it in to some knucklehead who's having a bad day is just wrong.

Make sure it's obvious broken.
 
They sent it back, same thing..... I got really old DOT MATRIX style paper, just one paper, saying "Passed Boot". The funny part is, it still gave me problems.

I ebayed it (when ebay wasn't so shitty and didn't help scammers rip people off like they do today),
So you sold the board for parts?

Or did the board work for the buyer?
 
Well I feel like a jackass. Got my new motherboard only to have the issue again. It was my damn power supply the whole time. I apologize to ASUS for ranting and RMA'ing a perfectly good board.. My diagnostic skills are lousy. I dug up an old power supply and I am posting on my main rig now.

Who knew a power supply could only partially work. I thought when they went bad, they completely stopped working. Now to RMA my power supply.
 
Well I feel like a jackass. Got my new motherboard only to have the issue again. It was my damn power supply the whole time. I apologize to ASUS for ranting and RMA'ing a perfectly good board.. My diagnostic skills are lousy. I dug up an old power supply and I am posting on my main rig now.

Who knew a power supply could only partially work. I thought when they went bad, they completely stopped working. Now to RMA my power supply.

Power supply failures can often be a bitch to diagnose. Glad you found the real problem now.
 
Yup, the psu has become one of the pieces that I just don't skimp on in any fashion. Problems with it are just so hard to figure out and can affect anything and everything in the weirdest ways, not to mention it has the highest probability of taking other components with it if it fails.

Glad to see Asus still active around here and that the rma diagnosis was in fact correct. I had seen a few posts recently with similar rma problems as you originally stated and they were justified. My feeling is that the base rma process with Asus seems to be one of the more difficult, although it can usually get resolved with some work. It's a shame though, as I consider Asus boards to be some of the better performers on the market, and if it weren't for rma problems popping up I'd have 0 problem giving them the same type of glowing recommendation that corsair has garnered.
 
Well I feel like a jackass. Got my new motherboard only to have the issue again. It was my damn power supply the whole time. I apologize to ASUS for ranting and RMA'ing a perfectly good board.. My diagnostic skills are lousy. I dug up an old power supply and I am posting on my main rig now.

Who knew a power supply could only partially work. I thought when they went bad, they completely stopped working. Now to RMA my power supply.

Thanks for being honest about it. Glad you managed to work out the fault.
 
I had a problem a few months ago that I thought for sure was the motherboard. Turned out it was the power supply. Try changing out various parts for different ones (power supply first and processor last, as that is the most to least likely parts to go out) until you get a successful boot.
 
Back
Top