Are Intel, AMD Six-Core Chips Worth It?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
C|Net’s Brooke Crothers asks the question, are six-core processors really worth it? I think we all know the answer to this question, don’t we?

All of this means more choice at the high end for consumers, but are those extra cores really necessary? Do the newest six-core systems, such as the HP Pavilion Elite HPE-460z series and Dell Studio XPS 9100, offer an appreciable spike in performance?
 
Today? Probably not.
Tomorrow? Yes.

Multi-threaded apps are the wave of the future.
 
Nothing is multi threaded enough to make use of it. However if you are a user in a production environment with heavy software for video, CAD, development tools, then maybe. From what I understand the really professional made softwares are tweaked enought to evolve with technology, because they realize how competitive it is, and companies like Autodesk want to make sure people continue to use their software (despite not letting me OWN it :) )
 
Gotta have the hardware first for the software to me made. x264 use my 6 cores very well.
 
call me old school but Im with bigger caches and higher clockspeeds... and just 2 cores. Gamer CPU anyone?
 
Depends on what you do, in reality for most people today then no they aren't worth it.
 
I really hate these tech "What-If?" questions.

They are pointless.

Is getting USB 3.0 on a new motherboard really worth it?

Is Windows 7 a good upgrade?

Do I need to change my diaper or will the shit start to stink?

These retarded journalist wake up in the morning and their editor needs a editorial piece for the day so between sipping their coffee and texting their wife or girlfriend they come up with these bone head what-if tech questions that serve no point other than to waste everyone's time.

I see dozens of these a week.
 
Granted, indeed few uses for most (but think of lots of background tasks that sap CPU such as AV, etc).

For me, give me more than 6 CPUs. I run VMs for work / learning. I am running a 6-core AMD 1090T with 16 GB RAM as I write this. There are often times when I will have 5 server VMs running. So, I will see all 6 cores chugging along merrily, 15 GB in use... works like a charm. Upgraded to this config from a Q-6600 with 8 GB RAM. That was decent, this is closer to heaven...
 
2 Questions...

Those that really do need that much concurrent processing power will generally have the budget to spring for the pricier (and faster) Intel chips. Six-core at (the lower AMD) price point is really for two things: selling off the shelf to consumers who don't know better (why buy four cores when you can have six!) and keeping Intel on its toes.

Are others interpreting this as saying Intel chips are fast and desirable, and AMD chips are for silly consumers who don't know what they're doing?

AMD's answer to (the thermal challenge) has been to sell (six-core processors) with slower clock speeds to ensure they don't get into thermal trouble

Is this a true statement, or her well educated guess on this? I've seen plenty of people running the stock HSF, and overclocking into the 3.4 - 3.6 GHz range, without experiencing thermal issues. To me this would imply default speeds could be set higher, without thermal issues, if AMD chose to. (not to mention they developed a 95w version of the 1055T)

This "report" seems kind of junk to me.
 
I really hate these tech "What-If?" questions.

They are pointless.

Is getting USB 3.0 on a new motherboard really worth it?

Is Windows 7 a good upgrade?

Do I need to change my diaper or will the shit start to stink?

These retarded journalist wake up in the morning and their editor needs a editorial piece for the day so between sipping their coffee and texting their wife or girlfriend they come up with these bone head what-if tech questions that serve no point other than to waste everyone's time.

I see dozens of these a week.

Let's send the journalists machines with an Intel 8086, 64kb RAM and dual 5.25" floppy and a green 14" monochrome monitor to remind them that if it wasn't for advancements, we'd still be using that.
 
The difference Dell / Gateway / HP, etc will charge you between 2 core / 6 core is nearly nothing. Some people will go out of their way to save $15 dollars, I've seen it before many times. Oh will I heard that I don't need those extra cores so just drop in 2 cores. You're going to use this computer for a few years right? Yes, why? Oh never mind. OK, sure, 2 core system. Then you watch them go across the street and spend $15 dollars for lunch. I always just answer these types of questions with common sense and logic as I think most people should.
 
Let's send the journalists machines with an Intel 8086, 64kb RAM and dual 5.25" floppy and a green 14" monochrome monitor to remind them that if it wasn't for advancements, we'd still be using that.

Great idea.
 
It will be worth it for me, especially in a production server environment using vmware - as vmware licenses per socket with up to 6 cpus... what companies that use virtulisation spend out now on the cpu you should save in licensing and other stuff bits.
 
I do a lot of image building with VMware Workstation and a 6 core chip will be great!!! My quad core does it fairly well when I have 2 or 3 VM's running, but a six core would be great!
 
Nothing is multi threaded enough to make use of it. However if you are a user in a production environment with heavy software for video, CAD, development tools, then maybe. From what I understand the really professional made softwares are tweaked enought to evolve with technology, because they realize how competitive it is, and companies like Autodesk want to make sure people continue to use their software (despite not letting me OWN it :) )

Freely available consumer reencoding software is fully capable of using 6 cores as well...
 
for me and what I do my quad core is overkill.

I Tell myself I am future-proofing, I also told myself I was future proofing when I got a 1gb x800 card, and that didn't work out like I thought it would.

so who knows for me
 
I think a lot of people miss the most important value of multi-core systems. I rarely use one application that would take use of more then one core. In fact I would want to. I don't want to encode a video and have it kill all 4 of my cores just to have it done quicker (though I do like the flexibility of being able to do so if I wanted it to). But I think as multimedia options go, with having a user play games, as a DVD is being ripped, and someone streaming video over to the Xbox in the living room. Having more cores is more important and has been for 3 years then increases in clock speed.

Anything that is bottle-necked by single core speeds seems to be exactly the programs that get the biggest boost from multi-core setups. Those programs also get larger benefits from a second core then they would from even a 50% increase in clock speed.
 
The Thubans are definitely worth it in certain situations that can utilize all those cores, while the Intel ones are kinda expensive for what they do.
 
Not for a a $900 dollar price tag. And I could care less about AMD 6 core CPUs as Intel's higher end 4 core CPUs outperform it. (now Bulldozer looks interesting though).
 
I went from a 920 to the 980x and overall things have felt a bit more responsive. This rig has been worth every of the many pennies I put in it.:D
 
Nothing is multi threaded enough to make use of it. However if you are a user in a production environment with heavy software for video, CAD, development tools, then maybe. From what I understand the really professional made softwares are tweaked enought to evolve with technology, because they realize how competitive it is, and companies like Autodesk want to make sure people continue to use their software (despite not letting me OWN it :) )

I would disagree with the nothing bit.

As an example, Civilization V was just released. New AI and other features has made this a rather CPU intensive game. To mitigate this, they programmed it in a way that every single little in game task and AI routine is given its own process and sent to the CPU to be - well - processed.

The end result is that it scales very nicely with multiple cores.

During end of turn calculations all 8 of my "logical cores" on my Core i7-920 see pretty heavy load. I would expect that to be true for a hexacore CPU as well.

As to what would the benefit be? Well, it may reduce end of turn calculations from 10 seconds down to 7 seconds, so is that significant? If you are impatient maybe :p
 
Is 12 cores, 24 threads "worth it"?
I dunno but that didn't stop me from buying them for Team 33. :D
 
I can some up the answer to this in one word: Virtualization. Of course having more cores is worth it for those that are using software designed to make use of them. With many of the virtualization tools I use, I may need to dedicate certain VMs to a particular core and having more cores allows me to run more processes in virtualization. Why else would companies spend huge amounts of money to get huge parallel processing servers with inordinate amount of cpus? Even on a small workstation scale this is important, especially for R&D and special support environments.
 
Yes, but I'd also like faster processors too. Let me have my cake and eat it too!
 
Absolutely they're worth it. Virtualizing is fantastic with two 6-core CPUs + hyperthreading.
 
for me and what I do my quad core is overkill.

I Tell myself I am future-proofing, I also told myself I was future proofing when I got a 1gb x800 card, and that didn't work out like I thought it would.

so who knows for me

I future proofed when I got my 6800GT.... that card lasted me comfortably till the latter part of 2007 :) the x800's were just the wrong choice :)
 
If the performance of the chips was there then I'd say yes. But I've seen the performance of the AMD 6 core chips and it really isn't all that impressive.
 
I future proofed when I got my 6800GT.... that card lasted me comfortably till the latter part of 2007 :) the x800's were just the wrong choice :)

Oh that 6800gt.

It was in my primary box from late 2004/early 2005 some time (can't remeber) until summer of 2009 when I finally decided to build a new rig...
 
I for one am glad that the CPU makers seem to be taking up the clock speed race again (I'm thinking about the various "turbo" modes that are being implemented), as well as each core do more per clock.

Multiple cores is great if you want to do many unrelated things at once.. but that's not always how real applications work. You will always have a certain number of operations that depend on data from other operations. Splitting up an applications into two more or less independent threads is usually fairly easy, four is more tricky. With 8, 16 etc. threads, it's a case of diminishing returns for many typical desktop applications and games.

Where we need innovation is on the software front, because even Quad-core CPUs are horribly underutilized by many applications and games.
 
Just think of how fast you could compile your Gentoo installation with 6 cores, I drool at the thought.
 
Back
Top