Apple Maps Gaining Ground on Google?

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The king of the Internet mapping world has always arguably been Google, but surprisingly Apple Maps made significant improvements to their mapping platform and is poised to give Goggle a run for its money.

As today's iPad and MacBook-wielding students become more and more accustomed to Apple Maps, they will come to believe that it is how all maps should look – and will question anything else they encounter.
 
Aren't there more Android phones in user's hands than iDevices?
 
......No.....Integration wise if you prefer simplicity Apple Maps is a good fit (most apps are running Apple maps to view their GPS usage). But If you want the entire package nothing beats Google Maps in directions from Walking, to driving, to even transit.

Long way to go there apple, but in time they`ll come up with something
 
sure if you like something so simple a monkey could use it, go with apple.

It will look pretty, do ONE thing, and cost 2X the competition that does 100 things.

Is there a place for crap like this? Sure there is, damn sure not on my phone or my computer though.
 
Significant improvements?
Apple maps was so bad any improvements would be considered significant improvements!
 
Just an FYI, Apple maps takes a massive dump on your device if you use ur GPS when traveling thru different continents. (On a tri-intercontinental journey on a plane). Recently did that, and now my Maps knows my location, but doesnt generate any 2d scenery. Only can show the satellite images when in satellite mode or overlay. But no 2d roads, street names anything 2d.
 
Google spends more time trying to, "get better", than they do being "good". /Always in state of flux, to the point of excess.
 
uhhh No ... my GF has an new iPhone and she uses their map / gps feature and my 2 year old Nexus Prime still does a hell of a lot better job finding anyplace we need to go. iPhone still has a 25% chance to take us somewhere weird
 
what-are-the-funniest-apple-maps-memes-1697595821-sep-26-2012-1-600x449.jpg
 
^LMAO

Google Maps: Navigate easier
Apple Maps: Navigate like they did back in the 1600s*

*Required Accessories can be bought for only $99.99 each
-iCompass
-iTelescope
-iLost :(
 
Aren't there more Android phones in user's hands than iDevices?

^ this.

Android 81% market share in 2013.
iOS 12.9%

Doesn't matter how good it is if its only in 13% of user's hands. It won't drive more purchasing.

For 13% of the market Apple maps becomes the default. For the rest of the world, nobody will notice.

BB
 
^ this.

Android 81% market share in 2013.
iOS 12.9%

Doesn't matter how good it is if its only in 13% of user's hands. It won't drive more purchasing.

For 13% of the market Apple maps becomes the default. For the rest of the world, nobody will notice.

BB

there's also more tricycles than carbon fiber racing bikes available
 
sure if you like something so simple a monkey could use it, go with apple.

It will look pretty, do ONE thing, and cost 2X the competition that does 100 things.

Is there a place for crap like this? Sure there is, damn sure not on my phone or my computer though.

What are you talking about now?

Maps is free and included on every iOS device. Or maybe you went off the rails and are talking about the phone itself, in that case show us a premier phone that costs HALF of the $650 that an iPhone costs. I'm talking about the full price, off contract.

I don't need a map program to do 100 things. I need it to show me where an address is from where I am.
 
What are you talking about now?

Maps is free and included on every iOS device. Or maybe you went off the rails and are talking about the phone itself, in that case show us a premier phone that costs HALF of the $650 that an iPhone costs. I'm talking about the full price, off contract.

I don't need a map program to do 100 things. I need it to show me where an address is from where I am.

Moto X was $350 yesterday. I think the deal will be resurrected on Monday.

Nexus 5 is dirt cheap.

That's just off the top of my head right now. There are a few other brands that are cheap too.
 
there's also more tricycles than carbon fiber racing bikes available

Exactly but your comment reinforces his argument.

The existence of the carbon fiber racing bicycle does not mean Toddlers are going to start selling their Tricycles for Carbon Fiber Racing Bicycles as the quoted segment of the article suggests.

The assumption that once a toddler has tried a carbon fiber racing bicycle, he won't ever go back to a tricycle is absurd as like the iphone (arguable points here) its less useful for the toddler(he needs the third wheel or additional 'features' on the tricycle) and the tricycle costs far less.

Besides, at a 13% market share, the toddler is not that likely to ever see or ride on a carbon fiber racing bicycle in real life. Try asking a random guy on the street or a random guy in a coffee shop with an iPhone if you can borrow his $3,000.00 carbon fiber bike or $500.00 iPhone 5 to take it around the block a few times to compare it to his own bike or use his gps to find the way to the closest ___ restaurant. Chances are, neither guy will not let you ride off with his $3,000.00 or $500.00 item even if you promise to return it -- soon. Maybe, a real close friend might but still ... who wants to be without their phone/bike?

The idea that users are going to try Apple maps by finding one of the 13.6% of the population that uses an iDevice and then that person lend out their device, they try it and are suddenly a convert for life swearing on google maps forever seems within the realm of possibility but of poor odds. Like flipping a fair coin and getting heads 10x in a row(~0.1% chance). It CAN happen but you'd have to spend all day flipping coins to see it happen once.
 
What are you talking about now?

Maps is free and included on every iOS device.

I think he may be referring to that nothing is free.

Anything 'bundled for freeeeeee!' is really marketing speak for 'We increased by base cost by x and now the cost is included with the retail price so customers no longer have an option as to whether they want to buy a given feature but as every customer buys that feature its slightly less expensive being amortized out over millions of phones'.

When a star bucks or some restaurant, for example, starts offering free-wifi, the cost of the average coffee probably goes up by 1 cent to pay for the wireless internet connection, router and infrastructure.
 
The king of the Internet mapping world has always arguably been Google, but surprisingly Apple Maps made significant improvements to their mapping platform and is poised to give Goggle a run for its money.

Considering this is an iPhone only application, it really doesn't matter if it becomes the defacto on that platform over google maps other then reducing google profits. Google maps will still be the #1 platform used.
 
it's always interesting to see just how far many on this board will go to ignore factual data to support whatever they're gnashing their teeth over...

specifically:

Apple has a smaller overall market share yet drives the majority of purchasers behavior

Apple devices do not cost 2x the amount of comparable non-apple devices

Apple devices have not gone up in price after Apple bundled additional software with them

I can't understand WBurchnall's post regarding tricycles
 
So, Apple Maps is close on achieving Google's functionality and it's available on devices that comprise only a small percentage of the smartphone market? Congrats, Apple! There's nothing like throwing money into a feature that Google would have offered iDevice users for free. Maybe next they'll follow Microsoft's lead and start their own search engine because Google.
 
it's always interesting to see just how far many on this board will go to ignore factual data to support whatever they're gnashing their teeth over...

specifically:

Apple has a smaller overall market share yet drives the majority of purchasers behavior
explain.....
and please include a corollary about why non-apple users who will not switch to apple products care about how apple's pretty picture mapping software is finally at parity? Unless apple makes it cross platform, which I don't think it ever will, since it is now "part of the operating system" per the article, nobody who doesn't already use or want apple for a myriad of other reasons care. The likelihood of "Apple Maps dominat[ing] the world" is vanishingly small.

Apple devices do not cost 2x the amount of comparable non-apple devices

Apple devices have not gone up in price after Apple bundled additional software with them
agreed

I can't understand WBurchnall's post regarding tricycles

rflcptr's analogy was poor and false, but brchnall ran with it anyway. It was a valiant attempt, but given how poor the original false analogy was, its not a surprise that the expansion was also a failure.

BB
 
was supposed to be the majority of purchasing behavior. numerous articles have been posted on this site and elsewhere demonstrating that Apple users spend more money online than other users.

You wrote that Apple devices are only in 13% of the population's hands and that Apple won't drive more purchasing. The data are clear that Apple devices do drive purchasing and they do it at higher volume *and* higher amounts than the rest of the public.
 
(I don't think your 13% market share claim is accurate anyway)
 
(I don't think your 13% market share claim is accurate anyway)
 
rflcptr's analogy was poor and false, but brchnall ran with it anyway. It was a valiant attempt, but given how poor the original false analogy was, its not a surprise that the expansion was also a failure.

BB

lol, a claim without evidence? what is THIS?
 
Honestly I have felt that bing maps is better than google maps much of the time, but it doesn't matter because its all about the vertical integration. Apple will surely move many of their customers over to apple maps and google will continue to hold on to their android devices. Wont matter if its better or worse because maps are basically becoming a commodity just like internet browsers something that most people could care less about so long as it actually works whatever is default will be good enough.
 
I use Apple Maps for iPhone and Google Maps as a backup. Oddly enough, when Apple can't find a location, Google has the exact same error. It's like the kid in class who cheats by copying answers from a B-student.

All this aside, Apple's 3D mode is waaaaay better than anything Google offers.
 
that issue of whatever is default so long as it's good enough will be used by most is one of the main points of the article. there are probably a lot of people on this board using custom roms. that experience might lead people to believe that google maps is default on android devices, but that's not actually true. every android device I used had its own maps version. in fact, google maps didn't have turn by turn directions for years and that was one of the main gripes against it by those of us using android in the earlier stages.

aside from that, google isn't default on anything else with the exception of chrome books. the tablet scene is still currently ruled by Apple and google isn't default there. the desktop is ruled by Microsoft and google isn't default there. cellphones aren't ruled by any monolithic entity atm even though android devices are ubiquitous. the only place where google is pseudo-default would be on custom roms and even there one has to download google apps and install maps. so even where it would be expected to be the default it's not.

so while google might be the de facto standard it's not the default. people have to go and get it and set it up. unless you've set your parents/grandparents/family members up with chrome they're most likely using Bing. OR they're using a built-in web browser to go to google.com

and therein lies the rub the article discusses. OS calls to the mapping service. instead of relying on a user to navigate to an external app and then use the browser to access maps, iOS and OSX developers can now be 100% sure that the calls they write will work as they intend them. and as Apple beefs up its mapping service its users will become less and less inclined to go elsewhere. this isn't some scheme to get android users to try apple maps but rather ensuring its users stay within the ecosystem and its developers can expect and deliver consistency.

in the future, there isn't any reason apple couldn't launch an iMaps.com for everyone. frankly their current practices suggest they don't have any inclination to increase market share like that but they certainly could once they became established.
 
aside from that, google isn't default on anything else with the exception of chrome books. the tablet scene is still currently ruled by Apple and google isn't default there. the desktop is ruled by Microsoft and google isn't default there. cellphones aren't ruled by any monolithic entity atm even though android devices are ubiquitous. the only place where google is pseudo-default would be on custom roms and even there one has to download google apps and install maps. so even where it would be expected to be the default it's not.

While I've seen evidence of it not being the default, all my phones have used it as default, LG, Moto and Samsung products.

There may have been an app on the Moto where it tried to trick me into signing up for ATT's old 'Wer U At?" service but that was the worst I've seen. Everyone other time if I've searched or plugged an address in its always gone straight to Google Nav.
 
I noticed this recently. Google Maps on the iPhone is going backwards. Fucking thing turns itself off randomly during navigation, and you don't know unless you look at the phone.

What's the point of having a navigation app when I'm in a state I've never been in before, if I get halfway through a 50 mile trip around a bay and the app turns off when I need to get on a different highway?

I started using Apple navigation, for when I actually need navigation help. It can't be a lot worse than something that randomly shuts off.
 
The GF and I have had some major issues with google maps recently. I would easily and quickly jump ship.

But we both run android, so really, we don't have the apple maps option :p
 
You know, just how much fanboy-hatred that Apple gets here only really became obvious to me AFTER I tried switching to some Apple devices.

I use an iPhone, coming from Andriod (SG3), and a Macbook. And you know what? Apple products are fine. They do what you want them to, and they do it pretty damn well.

I don't get you lot sometimes, honestly.
 
You know, just how much fanboy-hatred that Apple gets here only really became obvious to me AFTER I tried switching to some Apple devices.

I use an iPhone, coming from Andriod (SG3), and a Macbook. And you know what? Apple products are fine. They do what you want them to, and they do it pretty damn well.

I don't get you lot sometimes, honestly.

I prefer Android devices, but I get an iPhone 4S and free plan from work. When faced with free Apple stuff vs $1000/year of a bit better Android stuff, I go with Apple. Works well enough to save me $1k.
 
Eh, not really sure why people are hating on Apple so much. Google maps is my go-to mapping application on my phone, but competition is good and it's good to see improvement even if it's improvement from being crap to slightly less crap.

Competition is best regardless of what product we're talking about.
 
I think the problem here most people including myself is that Apple, a company that talks and takes pride in taking their time and releasing mostly finished products can release such a bad unfinished product as Apple Maps.

The same "haters" of Apple Devices also knocked the iPhone 5, 5s when it failed to provide a significant feature update. Apple is known to release some groundbreaking products into the mainstream market. When their product release maps don`t coincide with their historical activity-people get mad and become "haters".

just my 2 [H] cents :)
 
So I read all the complaints about Apple Maps when it was introduced. But I figured by now they would have ironed out the problems. Nope. I was driving to a friend's house the other week at around 11:30pm and Apple Maps directed my girlfriend and I through a sketchy neighborhood, to the gates of a cemetery, and then told us to get out and walk ~1 mile to the house. Yes, seriously.
 
So I read all the complaints about Apple Maps when it was introduced. But I figured by now they would have ironed out the problems. Nope. I was driving to a friend's house the other week at around 11:30pm and Apple Maps directed my girlfriend and I through a sketchy neighborhood, to the gates of a cemetery, and then told us to get out and walk ~1 mile to the house. Yes, seriously.

It's a feature! But seriously, it does have a good interface but it has a long hill to climb before it matches Google on address fidelity.
 
The GF and I have had some major issues with google maps recently. I would easily and quickly jump ship.

But we both run android, so really, we don't have the apple maps option :p

Same here. It worked fine before. Last summer we went no a 4hour roadtrip and apple maps put us all over the place, trying to make us turn off bridges and shit. I laughed at it and we made it just fine with my android smartphone.

Then this week-end I try to go to a friend's house in my hometown, then to my sister's near Montreal, both places that should have been pretty easy for google, and it was really weird. Couldn't put my position on the road, didn't rotate the screen when I turned on a new screen (like it kept north up ot something) and just had general trouble navigating. Then I used it again to get back home and all was normal. o_O
 
Back
Top