Apple Fired Manager Responsible For Maps

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Holy cow, that sure did take long enough, didn't it? For some reason, I thought this had already happened.

Apple Inc. has fired the manager responsible for its troubled mapping software, seeking to win back the trust of users disappointed after the program debuted in September, according to people familiar with the move. Richard Williamson, who oversaw the mapping team, was pushed out by Senior Vice President Eddy Cue, said the people, who asked not to be named because the information wasn’t yet public.
 
This is the thread for those that care.

On a side note. Google is going to release Google Maps as a separate app I heard.
 
I know I'm gonna get raged at here, but seriously, the Apple Map App was a significant upgrade from the existing google app allowed on the iPhone at the time.

- Voice guidance while driving
this is a huge thing for me, reading a map while driving is incredibly dangerous​
-Simplification of zoomed out map, detailed zoom-in map
sure it wasn't perfect, but I'm okay with this.​
-Constant follow while driving in a third-person view rather than bird's eye

Since I've only owned an iPhone and haven't used the Android OS yet, I don't know enough about what google has to offer. I'm fairly certain that Apple restricted google's next-level map app that probably makes the Apple app look like shit. Ok. You can rage at me now. :eek:
 
Since I've only owned an iPhone and haven't used the Android OS yet, I don't know enough about what google has to offer. I'm fairly certain that Apple restricted google's next-level map app that probably makes the Apple app look like shit. Ok. You can rage at me now. :eek:

Well that pretty much sums it up. I use both an iPhone and RAZR and the Google Maps app on Android has been way better than the iPhone option for years. I think the problem here is instead of firing the poor smuck that led the team creating Apple Maps, they should shoot the person that was more interested in sticking it to Google than providing their users a good program.

Oh wait.... I'm pretty sure he's already dead!
 
I know I'm gonna get raged at here, but seriously, the Apple Map App was a significant upgrade from the existing google app allowed on the iPhone at the time.

- Voice guidance while driving
this is a huge thing for me, reading a map while driving is incredibly dangerous​
-Simplification of zoomed out map, detailed zoom-in map
sure it wasn't perfect, but I'm okay with this.​
-Constant follow while driving in a third-person view rather than bird's eye

Since I've only owned an iPhone and haven't used the Android OS yet, I don't know enough about what google has to offer. I'm fairly certain that Apple restricted google's next-level map app that probably makes the Apple app look like shit. Ok. You can rage at me now. :eek:

I've had all three for a long time on my android. It seem they were maybe limiting the Apple version?

P.S. I only "rage" to stupid fanboy (which you obviously aren't) and the company itself, you're safe :p
 
There are some places where Apple maps sucks hard. But, in flat Eastern Oregon and Washington, it works great for me.

I still prefer Google Maps, but Apple maps aren't that bad for a lot of places.
 
Google Demanded things like Latitude be integrated into the app aswell in exchange for things like Voice Guidance.

Its not like Apple just said "NO!" to Google, they didnt want Google branding in their phone, which isnt a terrible business decision.
 
Well that pretty much sums it up. I use both an iPhone and RAZR and the Google Maps app on Android has been way better than the iPhone option for years. I think the problem here is instead of firing the poor smuck that led the team creating Apple Maps, they should shoot the person that was more interested in sticking it to Google than providing their users a good program.

Google wanted to brand the app (change it from Maps to Google Maps) and plaster their name all over the interface, as well as require Latitude integration (privacy-invading nonsense)

Ditching Google wasn't about "sticking it" to anybody, it was about protecting the brand and not letting their largest competitor in the space plaster their name all over their product. It could have been done far more gracefully (they had nearly a year left on the contract with Google, enough time to wait until iOS 7 for the new Maps) but leaving Google at some point was kind of their only choice.
 
I wonder if they tried to fire the guy in person?

Apple CEO's: Alright it says here to turn left then right, and then defy physics. You know what, fuck it just give him a call and tell him he's fired. Someone pull out an Android phone and get Google maps out.

Apple-Maps-Remedy.jpg
 
Steve Jobs would have fired him earlier. With more anger too.
 
I wonder if they tried to fire the guy in person?

Apple CEO's: Alright it says here to turn left then right, and then defy physics. You know what, fuck it just give him a call and tell him he's fired. Someone pull out an Android phone and get Google maps out.

Apple-Maps-Remedy.jpg

that looks fun to drive on
 
Considering what the guy had to work with, I'd say he did a damn good job of getting a usable product out there. Sure its not perfect, Google does it much better, but considering they removed Google from the picture and did it their own way there had to be bumps in the road (pun intended I guess :D).
 
As I recall, they bought two mapping companies and integrated their data into their new pipeline. So it's not quite as much work as you might expect, but still quite a lot of work.

I've had one issue with the new Maps app, but apart from that, it's done what I've wanted. Quite a lot of fuss over not so much an issue. I do, however, miss Street View.
 
If this guy was wholly responsible for the decision to use TomTom as their mapping service provider then he should indeed get that shaft for such a horrible decision. If he was pushed into it in the ill-advised rush to part with all things Google then I have a bit of sympathy for him. But the fact of the matter - regardless - is that Apple released one of the most unfinished apps I have ever seen from a major player, and no amount of kool-aid is going to wash that horrible taste out of anyone's mouth anytime soon.
 
Google Demanded things like Latitude be integrated into the app aswell in exchange for things like Voice Guidance.

Its not like Apple just said "NO!" to Google, they didnt want Google branding in their phone, which isnt a terrible business decision.

kind of was considering where they are now with their maps......
 
If you want to make an omelet, you have to break some eggs. Apple just broke too many eggs.
 
Apple is cleaning house? More like the developers sat there and said it's not ready and the execs said push it through any way.... and the manager gets shit canned?
 
..................no amount of kool-aid is going to wash that horrible taste out of anyone's mouth anytime soon.

The new iPhone 6 kool-aid flavor will wash it out just fine. It'll have a new button!
 
It was probably higher financial managers not putting enough funding into it and underestimating it.
Google maps is a massive project. To pull that out of your ass and say that you are going to improve on it is a hard statement for apple to follow through with. (if that was their intention/ Not quoting or anything)
 
You know, it's really not as bad as people make it. A lot of the issues will be fixed as the millions of Apple iOS users walk around with their Personal Tracking Devices (also known as a cellphone these days.) It could be because I'm in NYC, but maps has significantly improved in this area since the initial release. Sure, it didn't have quality Apple has been known for, it was a substandard release. However, the outrage was overblown IMO. Google kicks Apple in the pants on Maps, but they've also been going at for a lot longer. In due time and with sufficient user data, it'll get up to par with Google's release.

All that said, I'll be using Google's standalone Maps app on my iPad once they release it on iOS.
 
Will it be a shinny button? If it's shinny, they oooh and awwww over it.:D

The Apple wil say that they have a patent for X number of buttons on their phone and if you have the sam enumber you are infringing
 
I know I'm gonna get raged at here, but seriously, the Apple Map App was a significant upgrade from the existing google app allowed on the iPhone at the time.

- Voice guidance while driving
this is a huge thing for me, reading a map while driving is incredibly dangerous​
-Simplification of zoomed out map, detailed zoom-in map
sure it wasn't perfect, but I'm okay with this.​
-Constant follow while driving in a third-person view rather than bird's eye

Since I've only owned an iPhone and haven't used the Android OS yet, I don't know enough about what google has to offer. I'm fairly certain that Apple restricted google's next-level map app that probably makes the Apple app look like shit. Ok. You can rage at me now. :eek:

You could have downloaded Waze for free and had a superior (to the current Apple Maps) turn-by-turn navigation solution for awhile now. In fact, you still can and I suggest you do -- the only thing Apple Maps has going for it is integration (which is more of an irritant that it can't be changed as the default).
 
Back
Top