Apple 27" LED Cinema Display

Your budget for your hobby is your own.. people spend "too much" on cars, motorcycles, tvs, high end laptops, smartphones+contracts, gpus, jewelry, clothes, dining, booze, etc etc.

You can prob get a good 23in ips screen for much less than an acd and would be happy enough with it. Tradeoffs still apply though, as a 120hz tn would likely be more accurate for twitchy gaming. :p
 
sony fw900... New they were like $2200 when they came out

They were only $2200?

If I could get a brand new one now, I'd probably pay that. It would hurt economically. But at least it would actually be an awesome and proper display.
 
Trololollo.

Yes we are stuck on lcd tech for the profit margin. CRT has its own major tradeoffs though, and isnt the answer.

Stuck on gas cars an extra 20 to 40 yrs past necessary already too for that matter but it is what it is. High rez ips screens look awesome, especially in glossy richness imo. You dont have to buy a 27in or larger. 1 grand on 12mo no interest is well worth it to me, and that is coming fom said crt's. As i said I may eventually own two more in the long run too haha.
 
Not trolling in any way.

Especially considering that now $2200 is only 13670 SEK. That would be seriously cheap for a brand new FW900.

If the Dollar had the same value as back then when it was released, not sure what it would be... Lets just say somewhere around 20 000 SEK, that would be a lot of money sure, but it would actually still be a good price considering what you'd get for the money.

I'd rather spend more on the monitor than the computer (but that's only if the monitor is actually good and worth it, which a new FW900 would be). I don't play games so I don't even need an expensive graphics card, etc.
 
$2200 was the list price when it came out in 1998, which was a lot of money.. much more than the $1k the ACD is. A quick online calculator tells me that $2200 usd in the year 1998 is equal to $2,989.42 usd now.

To most people nowadays a FW900 is both too big and too small. It can't get the clarity and perfect geometry of an LCD, uses a lot of power, makes a lot of heat, is subject to magnetic interference and line noise, and is just hugely bulky among other things. All panel tech has tradeoffs including crt, tn, ips, whatever.. so you have to pick your poison. That's why up until recently I've used both a crt and an LCD at the same desk, and next year I may similarly have a 120hz triple TN array for gaming with the ACD beneath it (or three ACD's haven't decided yet).
..
... You major complaint was LCD is trash and seemed like you were decrying what you considered the extreme cost , when you could get a decent 23" ips for much cheaper, and a 23" 120hz tn,, which happen to be the same size as an fw900. I'm guessing they are around $280 - $350 now (compared to an "A" condition fw900 being $350 - $400 most likely).. Its when you get up to 27" + ips and 27" 120hz TN that you hit $650 - $1000 - $1200. No one is twisting your arm telling you to purchase any of the above. I'm extremely happy with my 27" 1440p ips, and my 10.2" ips tablet for that matter. The panels look great, great color and overall lushness. The word "gorgeous" also comes to mind. I think its the best monitor I've ever owned. TV LCD tech has also come a long way. Prefect? no. But neither is crt. My FW900 isn't even plugged in right now. :p
 
I smile every time I get back to using my ACD. The image quality is eye melting imo. The rez increase and pixel pitch are great too.

My thoughts exactly. :D I just bought a GTX570 and I'm now averaging ~40fps in "The Witcher 2" @ 2560x1440. It looks absolutely gorgeous on my 27" ACD. I couldn't imagine using my gaming rig with a subpar 1080p TN display. IPS displays don't suck, and if LG can get their new 3840x2160 panels to market in a timely fashion, haters will be eating crow.
 
First off...just wanted to say thank you to everyone that posted here on [Hard]Forum. I just finished building my first computer and I have to say that this place had the biggest influence on the final outcome of my project.

For those looking at the Apple 27...it really is awesome! I was on the fence between the ACD27 and the Dell U2711. Both are very highly regarded, and both have their strengths and weaknesses. No doubt, the Dell has all of the bells and whistles that you could hope for...multi-input, scaler (would be nice if it could be disabled), better color, etc. But the Apple has quite a few tricks up its sleave too...LED (less power), built-in speakers, built-in camera, better aesthetics (my opinion). That is not to say that both monitors dont have their weaknesses either. The Apple has a rediculously short set of cables (Power and DP), only a single mini-displayport input, glossy screen. The Dell on the other hand has that anti-glare screen.

I ended up getting the Apple and I do not regret it at all. I do not use it in a light controlled room and yes there are some reflections when there is a lot of sun coming in through the window (which faces the screen), but honestly the reflections are minor and do not bother me. If you have predominantly dark screens...the reflections will be worse. The speakers are fine for every-day use, and the camera works. I din not install boot camp...I only used the AppleControlPanel.exe that is posted here and am experiencing zero issues with it. I did use the trick that was posted about creating a "test" account so that I did not have to leave a bootable disk in the drive. Windows figured out the speakers, mic, and camera on its own.

The really cool part (to me) is that I have the monitor hooked up to the integrated graphics on a ASROCK Z68 Extreme4 motherboard. I don't game, but still wanted the high resolution for working with sketchup/photoshop...so a dedicated graphics card was not a requirement for me. I had zero issues with the compatibility between this mobo and this monitor.

I was nervous to spend this kind of cash on a monitor without knowing 100% that it would work...so I was really happy when I unboxed the monitor, hooked up the displayport cables (Dr. Bott = 2m extention, and some no-name mini-dp to DP adapters), and it all just worked.

Very happy with the Apple ACD27.

Thanks again!
 
I received a replacement ACD today and while this one has less back-light bleed in the bottom right corner it has another flaw that I can only describe as 'muddy'. Across the bottom when viewing full white there is some very light brownness going across the display and get's worse in the bottom right corner. This brownness is visible from all angles. I am going to keep the display for a couple days and see if the problem clears up. If not back it goes for try #4. Here is a link: http://i.imgur.com/kal5Q.jpg

Edit: It is the yellow tint issue seen here: http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=824940
 
Last edited:
that sucks. I had no probs with the one I got from bb.
 
I received a replacement ACD today and while this one has less back-light bleed in the bottom right corner it has another flaw that I can only describe as 'muddy'. Across the bottom when viewing full white there is some very light brownness going across the display and get's worse in the bottom right corner. This brownness is visible from all angles. I am going to keep the display for a couple days and see if the problem clears up. If not back it goes for try #4. Here is a link: http://i.imgur.com/kal5Q.jpg

Edit: It is the yellow tint issue seen here: http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=824940
You also have a screen with a diffuser that has some irregularity (might be bent) an inch or so above the bottom of the screen. Either that or the edge of the diffuser plate is not completely in plane with the LEDs. :( Give it some days, but I'm afraid it's a physical defect.

It's not directed at you at all, but in general it amazes me how many people receive screens with defects. If this was a Gateway monitor in a generic plastic housing, people would just move on and buy something different. I knew of a few people with the same issues, but it seems extremely wide-spread seeing that thread on MR.
 
It's not directed at you at all, but in general it amazes me how many people receive screens with defects. If this was a Gateway monitor in a generic plastic housing, people would just move on and buy something different. I knew of a few people with the same issues, but it seems extremely wide-spread seeing that thread on MR.

It is widespread, even affecting the new iMacs that just came out like a month ago. I'm no apple fan, I actually hate everything about them. Find me a 27" 1440p glossy display that's not made by Hazro and I will gladly switch.
 
It is widespread, even affecting the new iMacs that just came out like a month ago. I'm no apple fan, I actually hate everything about them. Find me a 27" 1440p glossy display that's not made by Hazro and I will gladly switch.

Man, I really want this display so hearing about your issues is frustrating. Any chance that your yellow tint issue is related to the glue that they often use in their glass-covered screens? I remember the iPad (or was it the iPhone 4?) that had a lot of people complaining about yellow haze that eventually went away as the glue dried... I guess the only way to find out is for you to keep the display and report back in a few weeks/month? :D
 
Man, I really want this display so hearing about your issues is frustrating. Any chance that your yellow tint issue is related to the glue that they often use in their glass-covered screens? I remember the iPad (or was it the iPhone 4?) that had a lot of people complaining about yellow haze that eventually went away as the glue dried... I guess the only way to find out is for you to keep the display and report back in a few weeks/month? :D

The yellow tint issue gets worse over time according to MR. It is not a theory I am willing to test. It will be going back tomorrow.
 
just ship to store at BB imo. Can easily return to store within 14 day return period no questions asked - you just have to wait on any replacements since they don't stock them in their stores. The extended warranty is much cheaper and a year longer at BB vs apple store too, if you are interested in that kind of thing (I usually get extended warranty on any fragile electronics that cost 1k or more, sometimes using squaretrade with coupons).

I had no problems with mine. I'll be following along closely though since I may buy two more for eyefinity gaming next year if I can swing it, which would increase odds of getting one with a problem. (The other option is adding three 120hz 27" TN's.)
 
The yellow tint issue gets worse over time according to MR. It is not a theory I am willing to test. It will be going back tomorrow.
Yeah I understand. Please let us know how the second one turns out.

I'm thinking of getting mine through Amazon- price seems right... even better than the Apple discount I get through my company (after tax). Anyone try to return this thing through Amazon? Any issues?
 
applecontrolpanel was working with my system (on a HDD) via the a bootdisk in the CD drive. Upgraded my system to SSD w/fresh Win7 install. I can't seem to get applecontrolpanel to work..get the usual "dont' have privilege.blah..blah" tried bootdisk; no joy. even installed bootcamp but still doesn't work with bootdisk in CD drive. anyone have any ideas?
 
applecontrolpanel was working with my system (on a HDD) via the a bootdisk in the CD drive. Upgraded my system to SSD w/fresh Win7 install. I can't seem to get applecontrolpanel to work..get the usual "dont' have privilege.blah..blah" tried bootdisk; no joy. even installed bootcamp but still doesn't work with bootdisk in CD drive. anyone have any ideas?

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1036510014&postcount=312 <-- worked for me
 
worked like a charm..thanks..now have to remove bootcamp (if I can) or start again with fresh win7
 
My GTX 580 Lightning has a displayport. Will this work 100% for the ACD if I get an DP -> MiniDP adapter?
 
What are you guys doing for warranty? Are you guys just keeping the 1-year warranty from Apple or extending through applecare or 3rd parties?
 
I got mine from BB so I could return it within 14 days to store if I had to. They only order to store however and so never have any in stock at brick and mortar. Another reason I went with them is the no interest deal, and the fact that their extended warranty was much cheaper and lasted a year longer than apple's. Another option on electronics is going with 3rd party like squaretrade (coupons for the online often if you look hard enough), but you have to start it up within so many days of your purchase.
 
Thanks elvn. I went ahead and got the squaretrade 4 year warranty since it seems to be decent.

I just received my ACD today and I noticed there is some dust inside of the panel. I also think theres 1-2 dead pixels, although this might be dust also. Does anyone have a fix to this other then replacements? Everything but this is perfect

edit: Did live chat with amazon, they shipped a replacement with 1 day shipping. Amazon is truly great when it comes to customer service.
 
Last edited:
nice! I'll keep that in mind for future purchases.
 
where would be the place to order this if i have to change for panel defects ?
 
You mean you want to setup an RMA or you're trying to play it safe by buying it from a place that does easy replacements?

looking for a place that does easy replacements without a hassle :p
 
looking for a place that does easy replacements without a hassle :p
Amazon and I heard good things about Bestbuy and Frys. I just prefer Amazon since it's no tax for me. For myself, Amazon sent a replacement with 1 day shipping. They also sent a shipping label for me to return the defective unit. Best thing about this whole ordeal was that I place my order on a Wednesday and did the $4 1 day shipping through Prime. Thursday got the defective unit and requested the replacement on Friday. Then Saturday got the replacement. 4 total days is excellent turnaround time and that's why I love amazon :p

edit: sucks that retailers have to deal with replacements for Apples own fault on crappy QC
 
Last edited:
Could I hook up the 27 ACD to my dell xps15 via mini display port? How would it look? Or should I jsut go with the u2711/u3011 maybe?
 
Anyone with experience care to compare the ACD with an HP ZR30W or anything similar? I actually like the gloss and the pixel density on the Apple, but I also like the wide gamut on the HP because of the rich colors. What does 72% of Adobe RGB space actually mean for the ACD? That it's 72% less saturated/vibrant?
 
http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/apple27inchcinemadisplay_092610174635/24902.png

As I've said before, colorspace testing is usually done in dark rooms with the testing device right up against the panel. I doubt that the highest ratings are percieved as such to the human eye at viewing distance, with the panel flooded with light. That is one reason the high end nec's come with a three sided monitor hood - to reduce image degredation caused by light pollution. Furthermore, the over-aggressive AG coatings on other mfg's IPS displays have been reported to screw up the way whites look, which is a pretty common background color when doing color specific work. They also compromise fine details like text, so may compromise fine details in authored art and photos. So as you can see, the higher rated colorspaces may not be so much to the human eye in an improper/light-polluted environment and having a thick crystal/greasy glaze on top of the screen.

The acd is very lush and vibrant, imo the glossy screen enhances it. Unless you are holding up color swatches to your screen or work in magazine publishing I doubt you'll see any difference with the ACD's 83.1 % adobeRGB 1998 in real human eye viewing.
 
Last edited:
http://images.anandtech.com/graphs/apple27inchcinemadisplay_092610174635/24902.png

As I've said before, colorspace testing is usually done in dark rooms with the testing device right up against the panel. I doubt that the highest ratings are percieved as such to the human eye at viewing distance, with the panel flooded with light. That is one reason the high end nec's come with a three sided monitor hood - to reduce image degredation caused by light pollution. Furthermore, the over-aggressive AG coatings on other mfg's IPS displays have been reported to screw up the way whites look, which is a pretty common background color when doing color specific work. They also compromise fine details like text, so may compromise fine details in authored art and photos. So as you can see, the higher rated colorspaces may not be so much to the human eye in an improper/light-polluted environment and having a thick crystal/greasy glaze on top of the screen.

The acd is very lush and vibrant, imo the glossy screen enhances it. Unless you are holding up color swatches to your screen or work in magazine publishing I doubt you'll see any difference with the ACD's 83.1 % adobeRGB 1998 in real human eye viewing.

That makes sense, thanks. In the store, the ACD seemed plenty vibrant, which is why the lower RGB numbers puzzled me. But between the factors you mentioned (glossy finish, clean whites, the questionable real-world application of those numbers), it makes more sense.
 
No problem.. thats my take on it anyway. As for text I don't find it too small. It depends on how far away you set the monitor and how good your eyesight is. Perspective wise, the closer you set a monitor the "bigger" it is ;) ... I have acute eyesight so its not a problem for me though I did move the 27" closer to 2' rather than the near-to 3' I used to keep my 1080p 27" TN. I'd have to measure it to be sure what distance it is now to be honest. Writing this from my glossy 1280x800 IPS tablet at the moment whose display also looks awesome imo. .. so not at desk to measure. Both my tablet and any apps like firefox, pdf's, office docs, on my desktop can zoom any content if it was ever a problem on a particular page but I don't find myself doing that on the ACD once I set it at a good distance.


Just to be clear though, the color space is how many subdivisions of a color there are.. like 40 "greens" vs 50 "greens" (not a real figure)... so a monitor's color pallete can still really pop without being able to display the most minute shade variances. Imagine a large grid pallete of colors... then shrink the grid around 15% - 17% knocking out some of the almost exactly similar minute color shades ... and thats vs dark room color space testing though and doesn't take into consideration light pollution and the crystal/grease coating to the human eye as I said. The difference in pallete to the eye as perceived is likely a smaller percent.
 
Last edited:
Great info, thanks! I found this website that compared both displays and they said that the 27" iMac has better color reproduction than the 27" ACD. Why do you think that is? Anyone compare both the 27" iMac and the 27" ACD side by side and notice any difference between the two?
 
They use identical panels. Any minor differences can be attributed to manufacturing variation between panels. I've seen both side by side and both were excellent.
 
I wonder if those two reviewed are using the same video card and cables. In my experience amd's 2d/desktop quality is much better than nvidia's as just one example of what would show a difference to me. As said, the panels are the same, and I believe the u2711 is the same panel as well but it uses a ccfl backlight and a lot of input processsing (lag) due to inclusion of a scaler.. and of course has the over-aggressive AG coating frost/glaze/haze. I've not seen the imac and ACD side by side and it was in store lighting, but I walked directly from one store (BB) viewing HD photos at the native rez on the imac, across a hall to an apple store to view the same type of content on the ACD on several occasions and didn't notice a difference to my eye in those conditions. Of course that was totally uncalibrated even in regard to only the brightness setting.
..
The andandtech review's chart still has higher adobe rgb 1998 color gamut for the ACD at 83.16 than the imac at 74.9 , and for the color reproduction states that you would be hard pressed to tell any difference with both calibrated.

http://www.colorwiki.com/wiki/Delta_E
"A Delta E of 1 or less between two colors that are not touching one another is barely perceptible by the average human observer; a Delta E between 3 and 6 is typically considered an acceptable match in commercial reproduction on printing presses. (Note: Human vision is more sensitive to color differences if two colors actually touch each other.):
".. Daylight human vision (a.k.a., photopic vision) is most sensitive to the green region of the color spectrum around 550nm, and least sensitive to colors near the extremes of the visible spectrum (deep blue-purples at one end and deep reds at the other). For that reason, color differences in the latter regions are harder for the average human observer to detect and quantify, making Delta E measurements for those colors possibly less accurate."
..
Of course as I've stated before, all color readings are usually done in a dark room with hardware right up against the screen, so your real-world room lighting and perception to your human eye won't be exactly the same as those numbers. I still think the ratings are useful (to me) to avoid "bad" color gamuts and stay in the "very good" or better range.
..
The blind audiophile tests of different speakers often comes to mind when people split a 10th decimal point on a piece of color testing hardware vs the human eye. lol.

.. I own the ACD and I'm very happy with it. I also have a glossy ips tablet (asus) and love the quality on it. Extremely happy with my new era of lush glossy ips' . :D
 
Last edited:
Anyone with experience care to compare the ACD with an HP ZR30W or anything similar? I actually like the gloss and the pixel density on the Apple, but I also like the wide gamut on the HP because of the rich colors. What does 72% of Adobe RGB space actually mean for the ACD? That it's 72% less saturated/vibrant?

Same here dude. These anti-glair specs on the screen are pretty distracting on a white background. But ZR30W is the one to get for games. No scaller and better input latency (but not by much compared to the Apple 27 Cinema Display http://www.anandtech.com/show/4196/nec-pa301w-review-the-baddest-30-inch-display/7 ).
 
Back
Top