AMD Breaking up

More customers and more competition will win. If apple didn't protect it's market they would have done better. Markets with no competition will die

I don't think anyone won with the demise of the PPC.

I guess you're not old enough to have witnessed how things went from the start of the microcomputer era.
Here's a few highlights:
- All CPU manufacturers developed their own architecture.
- All computer manufacturers wrote their own software (OS, although you really couldn't call it that in the early days... and applications). There were some 'standards', such as a basic interpreter or a CP/M interface, but they were generally not fully compatible with others.
- Most computer manufacturers developed their own custom chipset and peripherals.

As such, you had completely different CPUs and computer systems competing against eachother... Atari, Commodore, Tandy, Amstrad, Apple, Schneider, BBC, IBM etc... they all had their own system... Most of them were incompatible with other systems at the hardware and/or software level.
Note also that Apple invented the concept of the PC.

Now IBM came into the PC game a bit late... They had to rush their system, and used mostly off-the-shelf components. This resulted in three things:
1) The PC had rather poor hardware capabilities and performance compared to other computer systems.
2) It was easy for other companies to create clones by using the same off-the-shelf components. The main issue was the BIOS code. Compaq was the first to create a clone, and went to court over the rights on the BIOS code. The result was that PC clones were allowed, as long as the BIOS was clean-room reverse engineered.
Bill Gates had apparently foreseen this, because they negotiated a non-exclusive license for MS-DOS with IBM. Normally software was sold, not licensed.
This meant that Microsoft could license the same OS to the other PC clones, creating perfectly compatible systems from multiple vendors.
3) IBM was afraid of possible supply problems, and demanded that Intel get a second-source manufacturer to ensure IBM that they would always have a decent supply of CPUs for their PC line. This got AMD involved in manufacturing x86 processors, the rest is history.

So the IBM PC was the odd one out in those days. By reasons beyond and above explanation, the IBM PC somehow became a huge success despite its high price, poor performance, lacking hardware capabilities and archaic operating system.

Apple is the only independent system manufacturer remaining, from that early era. And therefore the only one that was still using a different CPU (first 68k, later PPC), and their own OS. That doesn't make the cloning and licensing system of the IBM PC the way things are supposed to happen though. It was just a fluke.

It's nice that Intel has licensed its x86 architecture to AMD and some others, but that doesn't mean that it's supposed to happen that way. Most CPU architectures were never licensed to other parties.

Likewise with the hardware... IBM didn't want those PC clones, they actually tried to create their own proprietary platform with the PS/2 range, but in the end the PC clones won.

What Apple does is normal, PCs are weird.
Apple is actually doing better than most PC manufacturers. There's only a handful of big PC manufacturers left. Even big names like Compaq and IBM are gone now, let alone all the smaller ones we had in the 80s and 90s.
If I'm not mistaken, Apple is about as big as Dell... Which would actually make them one of the biggest computer manufacturers in the world. Not bad eh?
I'm quite sure they wouldn't have been that successful if they had allowed clones (just like IBM dropped out of their own PC market) or if they had moved to making generic Wintel boxes.
 
AMD is building a chip manufacturing plant about 20miles from where I live....

Malta, NY
 
How do you know? Can you prove it?

Common sense doesn't require proof.
Historically, prices for products and services offered by monopolies are higher then when there's competition. This is a fact of life and a reality in business. Even a small child understands this.

The fact you are willing to argue against this shows that either

A) you're a moron
B) you are swinging on Intel's nuts so fast you have brain damage and refuse to use common sense
C) you're a troll and just like to argue
D) all of the above
 
If Intel has to drop x64, they'll lose the 40-bits of memory addresses that x64 provides.

If this was the case, we wouldn't be seeing any Intel desktop systems with more than 4GB ram.

Plus, I thought windows 7 was supposed to be x64 only. OSX is now x64 only now too. If Intel lost the x64 license, they'd be boned in the future. All they'd have is 32-bit linux.

I think AMD put Intel in a really really bad place, and I don't think Intel will be doing anything with AMD's license. AMD won, hands down.

And about this "switching architectures" stuff. Gas just got way expensive in America, and you don't see us all lining up and buying electric cars, do you? Do you see everyone driving around in Teslas?

No. If AMD dies, and all that's left is Intel and x86, that's where we're going to stay. There's way to much stuff to port.

Look at the whole Y2K thing. All of those problems were from not using enough memory to store the year. Could you imagine how much recompiling and porting would have to happen to migrate to another architecture than x86?

Scali2, you come across as bright, but I think you're kinda dumb.
 
Common sense doesn't require proof.

Even if we assume this to be true, you still have to prove that the above statement is a result of common sense.

You try to compare it against other types of monopolies (which you fail to specify), but you do not describe the mechanics that would result in the claimed phenomena.
So I am still missing a lot of valuable information to deduce one from the other.
 
If this was the case, we wouldn't be seeing any Intel desktop systems with more than 4GB ram.

Which wouldn't affect 99% of all users.

Plus, I thought windows 7 was supposed to be x64 only. OSX is now x64 only now too. If Intel lost the x64 license, they'd be boned in the future.

Why? The existing x86 OSes will just disappear into nothingness? And there is no way to make OS X or Windows 7 x86-compatible again?

Look at the whole Y2K thing. All of those problems were from not using enough memory to store the year. Could you imagine how much recompiling and porting would have to happen to migrate to another architecture than x86?

An emulator would take care of legacy applications that can't/won't be ported. It worked for Apple, didn't it?
 
I guess hypocrisy is hard to explain. :D It never looks as good when you have to admit it out loud or in writing.

The difference is I'm transparent in my intentions. No matter how many times I've explained that, yes, I will make allowances so that a competitor to Intel will remain viable, you pretend I've never mentioned them. If that competitor were VIA, Montalvo, or even Intel if it were AMD which was the dominant company, then I'd support an alternative so long as the performance drop-off wasn't significant enough to notice.

You've stated yourself that AMD is hurting for cash. They actually handled the B2 problem fairly well by going public with it at a time when it killed their Q4 07 sales. Most people (myself included) opted to wait for B3 hardware.

You haven't taken a stand on anything, other than attack me for my honesty. At least Scali, while I disagree with him, is honest and states his intentions and takes a stand. I actually understand where he's coming from. He doesn't like x86, and having done x86 assembly before with the myriad of rules and minuscule number of semi-general purpose (but not really general purpose) registers, I agree with that part of his arguement.

You on the other hand, are just a troll, whom I will stop feeding as of now.
 
I don't think anyone won with the demise of the PPC.

I guess you're not old enough to have witnessed how things went from the start of the microcomputer era.
Here's a few highlights:
- All CPU manufacturers developed their own architecture.
- All computer manufacturers wrote their own software (OS, although you really couldn't call it that in the early days... and applications). There were some 'standards', such as a basic interpreter or a CP/M interface, but they were generally not fully compatible with others.
- Most computer manufacturers developed their own custom chipset and peripherals.

As such, you had completely different CPUs and computer systems competing against eachother... Atari, Commodore, Tandy, Amstrad, Apple, Schneider, BBC, IBM etc... they all had their own system... Most of them were incompatible with other systems at the hardware and/or software level.
Note also that Apple invented the concept of the PC.

Now IBM came into the PC game a bit late... They had to rush their system, and used mostly off-the-shelf components. This resulted in three things:
1) The PC had rather poor hardware capabilities and performance compared to other computer systems.
2) It was easy for other companies to create clones by using the same off-the-shelf components. The main issue was the BIOS code. Compaq was the first to create a clone, and went to court over the rights on the BIOS code. The result was that PC clones were allowed, as long as the BIOS was clean-room reverse engineered.
Bill Gates had apparently foreseen this, because they negotiated a non-exclusive license for MS-DOS with IBM. Normally software was sold, not licensed.
This meant that Microsoft could license the same OS to the other PC clones, creating perfectly compatible systems from multiple vendors.
3) IBM was afraid of possible supply problems, and demanded that Intel get a second-source manufacturer to ensure IBM that they would always have a decent supply of CPUs for their PC line. This got AMD involved in manufacturing x86 processors, the rest is history.

So the IBM PC was the odd one out in those days. By reasons beyond and above explanation, the IBM PC somehow became a huge success despite its high price, poor performance, lacking hardware capabilities and archaic operating system.

Apple is the only independent system manufacturer remaining, from that early era. And therefore the only one that was still using a different CPU (first 68k, later PPC), and their own OS. That doesn't make the cloning and licensing system of the IBM PC the way things are supposed to happen though. It was just a fluke.

It's nice that Intel has licensed its x86 architecture to AMD and some others, but that doesn't mean that it's supposed to happen that way. Most CPU architectures were never licensed to other parties.

Likewise with the hardware... IBM didn't want those PC clones, they actually tried to create their own proprietary platform with the PS/2 range, but in the end the PC clones won.

What Apple does is normal, PCs are weird.
Apple is actually doing better than most PC manufacturers. There's only a handful of big PC manufacturers left. Even big names like Compaq and IBM are gone now, let alone all the smaller ones we had in the 80s and 90s.
If I'm not mistaken, Apple is about as big as Dell... Which would actually make them one of the biggest computer manufacturers in the world. Not bad eh?
I'm quite sure they wouldn't have been that successful if they had allowed clones (just like IBM dropped out of their own PC market) or if they had moved to making generic Wintel boxes.

This is the best history lesson that shows competition is a good thing. Without those clones, we would end up today using a PC from IBM or a MAC from Apple. We know what would happen without competition, just look at Apple who don't allow clones, you get an inferior hardware for a higher price.
 
I don't think anyone won with the demise of the PPC.

I guess you're not old enough to have witnessed how things went from the start of the microcomputer era.
<snip>
Very accurate and well written, btw...
 
This is the best history lesson that shows competition is a good thing. Without those clones, we would end up today using a PC from IBM or a MAC from Apple. We know what would happen without competition, just look at Apple who don't allow clones, you get an inferior hardware for a higher price.

Actually it doesn't.
Apple might not be a good example, but the Commodore Amiga and Atari ST were excellent examples of computer systems that were MUCH cheaper than PCs, yet also were MUCH more capable.
I could buy 4 Amiga 500 systems for the price I paid for my (Commodore) XT, which I think was around 1987/1988.
On top of that, the CPU and chipset of the Amiga were far more powerful than the XT was, and the OS was far more advanced. On the Amiga I had a GUI, multitasking, realtime video animation and stereo digital audio, where my XT had none of that.
The first soundcard that I bought (Creative SoundBlaster Pro) was actually MORE expensive than my Amiga (while delivering worse audio quality).

PCs were clearly the inferior hardware for the higher price, until eventually everything but Apple died out.
 
Actually it doesn't.
Apple might not be a good example, but the Commodore Amiga and Atari ST were excellent examples of computer systems that were MUCH cheaper than PCs, yet also were MUCH more capable.
I could buy 4 Amiga 500 systems for the price I paid for my (Commodore) XT, which I think was around 1987/1988.
On top of that, the CPU and chipset of the Amiga were far more powerful than the XT was, and the OS was far more advanced. On the Amiga I had a GUI, multitasking, realtime video animation and stereo digital audio, where my XT had none of that.
The first soundcard that I bought (Creative SoundBlaster Pro) was actually MORE expensive than my Amiga (while delivering worse audio quality).

PCs were clearly the inferior hardware for the higher price, until eventually everything but Apple died out.
That is the keyword, were. Without competition, it will still be the inferior hardware with higher price today.
 
That is the keyword, were. Without competition, it will still be the inferior hardware with higher price today.

No, you get it wrong.
PC hardware is still as poor and expensive as it always was, there's just nothing cheaper and better anymore, because it was all drowned out by the competition.
So the superior and cheaper hardware was annihilated by the competition, which is NOT a good thing.
 
If Intel has to drop x64, they'll lose the 40-bits of memory addresses that x64 provides.
The x86-64 "license" is a Sharikou-like (in top mental form today) fantasy. AMD can not yank that from Intel. It was an open spec and Intel made its own implementation of it, a feat not so amazing since it is just an extension (widening 32-bit registers to 64-bit) of the same old x86 instruction set that Intel created. :p

Anyways, I suggest you read the Intel-AMD license agreement linked a couple of pages back. The wording states that if AMD breaks the agreement, AMD does not get to continue using Intel IP (effectively ending AMD's CPU sales), but Intel gets to keep using anything AMD gave Intel.

6.2. Termination for Cause.
---------------------

(a) A party may terminate the other party's rights and licenses
hereunder upon notice if the other party hereto commits a
material breach of this Agreement and does not correct such
breach within sixty (60) days after receiving written notice
complaining thereof. In the event of such termination, the
rights and licenses granted to the defaulting party shall
terminate, but the rights and licenses granted to the party
not in default shall survive such termination of this
Agreement subject to its continued compliance with the terms
and conditions of this Agreement.
We're not even at the point of a notification of a breach, which if it is even going to happen won't be until early next year. The are several remedies to it, including a change in the structure of FAB ownership, if it runs afoul of the agreement. An AMD design house without an x86 license makes it worthless with current designs. The reorganization scheme depends on AMD continuing to sell processors.
 
Anyways, I suggest you read the Intel-AMD license agreement linked a couple of pages back. The wording states that if AMD breaks the agreement, AMD does not get to continue using Intel IP (effectively ending AMD's CPU sales), but Intel gets to keep using anything AMD gave Intel.

I already thought the limit on outsourcing production was a stroke of genius in the x86-license, but they seem to have thought of EVERYTHING!
If this is true, Intel can push AMD as hard as they can, because they have nothing to lose.
 
The deal will almost certainly go though, with AMD keeping the x86 license. I posted a link above on several ways that AMD becomes even more vulnerable due to new risk factors.

Price wars in particular *were* painful to AMD in the past. It can become very lethal in the future due to the new cost structures.
 
Regarding pricing during the P4 and X2 era: What many seem to forget is that it was Intel dictating the prices, not AMD. Sure, AMD had sku's priced in the $1000 range, but the never really had a choice. For the sole reason that Intel also had sku's in that range, and higher, AND SELLING HUGE QUANTITIES OF THEM. It can't be forgot that Intel had major OEM's in their pocket, and regardless of AMD's pricing would have still sold millions. Meanwhile AMD would have had to sit back and vacuum up crumbs, making significantly lower margins than their competitor. This is the #1 reason for AMD's legal charges against Intel.

In short, it is Intel that dictates the entire pricing schemes of today, and their past illegal actions dictated pricing regardless of performance. Their is(was) nothing AMD could do but compete in the environment Intel created. However, that is going to change...
 
Didn't think I was going to post in this thread anymore, but what technologies (if any) does AMD lisense from Intel in their fab plants? The x86 liscense itself may be similar, but maybe AMD is going to make the case that Foundry Co does not liscense any Intel manufacturing processes. They keep the Intel architectural IP inside of the original AMD and use their fab process (jointly developed by IBM) in Foundry Co. None if Intel's "secrets" are revealed.
 
I am pretty sure AMD consulted with lawyers before they made the decision to split.

As for Intel, they will do everything they can to destroy AMD.
 
Look how good splitting up the company worked for Palm. They were in a similar situation, split up, and now the company barely matters.
 
Look how good splitting up the company worked for Palm.
Or closer to fabbing, Freescale. :p And the x86 design business has a success rate of 0% (Transmeta).

I would also include IDT, but they were a big nothing. Can't exactly fail in any meaningful way if you never succeeded.
 
AMD isn't going anywhere, Intel can't afford to lose them... being a monopoly in the market isn't a good thing.
 
If this is true, Intel can push AMD as hard as they can, because they have nothing to lose.

Yes they do, they have enough anti-trust lawyers from governments breathing down their neck as it is. It's not impossible for them to go the way of Standard Oil with x86 rights blasted wide open if AMD is gone.
 
Didn't think I was going to post in this thread anymore, but what technologies (if any) does AMD lisense from Intel in their fab plants? The x86 liscense itself may be similar, but maybe AMD is going to make the case that Foundry Co does not liscense any Intel manufacturing processes. They keep the Intel architectural IP inside of the original AMD and use their fab process (jointly developed by IBM) in Foundry Co. None if Intel's "secrets" are revealed.

In order to manufacture a processor, you need access to its chip design, which obviously contains Intel's IP. There's no way to manufacture a processor without knowing how it's designed. Since a lot of validation most probably also happens at the manufacturing site, you'll need even more information on the CPU's inner workings.
So Intel has a good point there.
 
Yes they do, they have enough anti-trust lawyers from governments breathing down their neck as it is. It's not impossible for them to go the way of Standard Oil with x86 rights blasted wide open if AMD is gone.

With AMD gone, who's going to make x86 processors? Nobody else has a working x86 design, and it takes years and billions of dollars to design one from the ground up. Aside from that, nobody has the manufacturing capacity to even put a dent in Intel's marketshare. You can't compete if you can't build the processors, AMD found that out the hard way when their Athlons became successful.
So even if Intel loses the rights to x86, that doesn't mean any meaningful competition would ever emerge.
 
With AMD gone, who's going to make x86 processors? Nobody else has a working x86 design, and it takes years and billions of dollars to design one from the ground up. Aside from that, nobody has the manufacturing capacity to even put a dent in Intel's marketshare. You can't compete if you can't build the processors, AMD found that out the hard way when their Athlons became successful.
So even if Intel loses the rights to x86, that doesn't mean any meaningful competition would ever emerge.

there are still competitors in the embedded systems market which Intel's is only just starting to tap with Atom. If a company can use x86 as a selling point to help push chips they'll do it. The appeal of using existing x86 binaries is there. Much less messing with cross-compiling tool-chains etc etc.
 
there are still competitors in the embedded systems market which Intel's is only just starting to tap with Atom. If a company can use x86 as a selling point to help push chips they'll do it. The appeal of using existing x86 binaries is there. Much less messing with cross-compiling tool-chains etc etc.

Except that x86 doesn't mean anything in the embedded market. 68k and ARM are the most popular options there, and especially ARM has big advantages over x86 when it comes to compact and energy efficient chips.

Besides, you still didn't address the issue that only Intel and AMD have x86 designs, and the means to produce the chips. A company like FreeScale could not move to x86 production because that'd cut into their ARM output, which is their bread-and-butter.
 
"Rest assured – we plan to continue respecting Intel's intellectual property rights, just as we expect them to respect ours."

Is that hinting at x86-64 IP?
Other than that I don't think Intel wil be satisfied by just a "rest assured" from their biggest competitor.
 
Except that x86 doesn't mean anything in the embedded market. 68k and ARM are the most popular options there, and especially ARM has big advantages over x86 when it comes to compact and energy efficient chips.

Besides, you still didn't address the issue that only Intel and AMD have x86 designs, and the means to produce the chips. A company like FreeScale could not move to x86 production because that'd cut into their ARM output, which is their bread-and-butter.

If AMD does go down I can see them selling their implementation to someone else who will then try to shrink it. Point is if you can make money off x86 then someone out there will do it. And I believe there is money to be made if licence concerns are gone.

And there's always VIA, their track records not withstanding.
 
So x86-64 is the only AMD IP that Intel is interested with?

Can you think of any other major AMD tech that Intel uses?
Most tech in AMD processors is either not invented by AMD itself, not used by Intel (eg 3DNow!, SOI), or insignificant enough to be cancelled out by the truckload of patents that Intel has on processor technology.
 
If AMD does go down I can see them selling their implementation to someone else who will then try to shrink it.

Since the poor design of the Phenom is the main reason why AMD is going down the drain so quickly, I don't see how any other company can turn it around into a competitive part.

Point is if you can make money off x86 then someone out there will do it.

AMD can't, and I don't see any company better up for the task than AMD was.

And I believe there is money to be made if licence concerns are gone.

If you have a good chip design and manufacturing facilities, which nobody has.

And there's always VIA, their track records not withstanding.

VIA managed to find a niche market, but is now being threatened by Atom aswell. AMD is far larger than VIA, and while they (or whoever buys them out) could try to enter such a niche market and be successful, they'd still have to shrink down lots and make tons of losses in the process.
You can't sustain a company the size of AMD with a niche market like VIA has, especially not with Atom intent on taking over.
 
Scali2:
We all know your views on AMD and Intel, why go on and write about your emotional views in the AMD area? It doesn't matter what anyone says here, you will not change what you feel.
 
Scali2:
We all know your views on AMD and Intel, why go on and write about your emotional views in the AMD area? It doesn't matter what anyone says here, you will not change what you feel.

There's nothing emotional about what I wrote.
It's a fact that Phenom doesn't give AMD a good return on investment because it simply doesn't perform well enough to be competitive. AMD basically has to give the CPUs away, while Intel is raking in the cash on the high-end parts. Now you could disagree with that, but then you'd be in denial.
 
Back
Top