AMD Breaking up

Burn Out
Burn Out @ Oct 6th 2008 10:59PM

I'm lining up my Semprons, Turions, Durons, Opturons, Athlons, Phenoms, and Morons for a hell of a night. We're gonna fight for the right to party 'til we burn out. K,K, and K are gonna be there, as in...AMD K5, K6, and K7.

Intel's not invited.

lol
 
I hope it doesnt mess up future plans for PC kit.
 
Break up...break up of what; between who/what?

Sorry, haven't really been keeping along with the actual corporate business side of computer industry...
 
Sure, they're going to break up but I still think they're gonna have close relations after the breakup. No harsh feelings eh?
 
still is disappointing news though.

we need AMD to keep Intel on their toes. Hopefully this breakup gives AMD what they need to get back into the game.
 
AMD will still be the same ol' AMD; the only difference is that just like the spun off Spansion for flash memory, they are gonna spin this entity into a manufacturing company. The manufacturing entity will make AMD products as well as other product but AMD will have a pretty big stake at it as well.
 
I think this point was made a million times and refuted until now.
 
Break up...break up of what; between who/what?

Sorry, haven't really been keeping along with the actual corporate business side of computer industry...

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/07/technology/07chip.html?ref=worldbusiness

.... omfg what a pain to link to a page with href followed by an = sign. The forum butchers it.
 
Now we wait for Intel's response to AMD violating the x86 licensing terms.

Apparently this is the cross-license: http://contracts.corporate.findlaw.com/agreements/amd/intel.license.2001.01.01.html

I can see some things like "non-transferable", "without the right to sublicense" and "change-of-control" that are not 'compatible' with AMD splitting up.


i doubt intel will do much about it because if amd were to lose the x86 license then intel would probably have the justice dept. breathing down its neck and might even be broken up seeing as it would be the only x86 manufacturer.
 
i doubt intel will do much about it because if amd were to lose the x86 license then intel would probably have the justice dept. breathing down its neck and might even be broken up seeing as it would be the only x86 manufacturer.

if intel wanted to, it could....

it is not illegal to be the only supplier of something in america..... capitalism is a beauitful thing....

edit: and besides, there many are other microprocessor makers out there... so i really do not understand the idiotic statements frmo so many people saying that for some reason Intel would be sued if AMD died.... its just stupid....


IMHO.... the foreign stake in AMD makes them way less attractive to me as a consumer. Recently, I've bought: a 780G Motherboard, Athlon X2, Athlon BE, Sempron 3000, 2x HD 2400, and Radeon 4850 from AMD... really, i've "done my part" to help them out... but with a middle eastern company owning so much of them and their fabs I'd say that 4850 will end up being the last thing I ever directly or intentionally purchase from AMD....

Intel all the way now....
 
i doubt intel will do much about it because if amd were to lose the x86 license then intel would probably have the justice dept. breathing down its neck and might even be broken up seeing as it would be the only x86 manufacturer.

Firstly, there is no excuse for breaking license terms. So if AMD wants to split up before the current license runs out (in 2010 I believe), Intel is fully in its right to revoke the license.
At best the justice dept. can force Intel to renegotiate the x86 license with AMD (as they've done before, it never was Intel's idea to allow licensing of x86).

Secondly, what is the problem with there only being one x86 manufacturer? I can name many other CPU architectures that are (or were at one point) manufactured by only one company. We can also draw parallels with Microsoft, which is the only supplier of the Windows operating system. They were never even forced to license Windows to third parties, or open up the sourcecode or anything.
We really do NOT want a government to FORCE 'competition' by hampering Intel so much just so that poorly run companies like AMD have a shot at competing.
Anyone who thinks competition is something that HAS TO exist at all costs, because it is ALWAYS a good thing, is not thinking clearly. It seems that people have been brainwashed into this 'competition is good'-thing. But when it comes down to destroying the most powerful company to the level of its poor competitors, something is severely wrong.

The x86 license was quite fair, and for years AMD has been reasonably successful. It's not the fault of Intel or the x86 licensing that AMD now falls apart. That's AMD's own doing. Intel should not be punished for a competitor's mismanagement. It's not their fault that AMD messed up the Phenom product line, and paid way too much for the ATi acquisition, especially at a point where they didn't really have the financial health to make such an acquisition in the first place. AMD just wanted too much, too soon, and took on both Intel and nVidia at the same time.
 
It seems that people have been brainwashed into this 'competition is good'-thing.

I know your reputation, and I still try to read your posts with as much objectivity as I can muster anyway, but you lost me here.

Oh and by the way, I'm one of those guys who has been brainwashed into thinking competition is good. I suppose you like paying 2x-4x more for your CPUs.
 
if intel wanted to, it could....

it is not illegal to be the only supplier of something in america..... capitalism is a beauitful thing....

edit: and besides, there many are other microprocessor makers out there... so i really do not understand the idiotic statements frmo so many people saying that for some reason Intel would be sued if AMD died.... its just stupid....


IMHO.... the foreign stake in AMD makes them way less attractive to me as a consumer. Recently, I've bought: a 780G Motherboard, Athlon X2, Athlon BE, Sempron 3000, 2x HD 2400, and Radeon 4850 from AMD... really, i've "done my part" to help them out... but with a middle eastern company owning so much of them and their fabs I'd say that 4850 will end up being the last thing I ever directly or intentionally purchase from AMD....

Intel all the way now....

almost everything you use is made in china... when are u going to stop buying those products as well?
 
Firstly, there is no excuse for breaking license terms. So if AMD wants to split up before the current license runs out (in 2010 I believe), Intel is fully in its right to revoke the license.
At best the justice dept. can force Intel to renegotiate the x86 license with AMD (as they've done before, it never was Intel's idea to allow licensing of x86).

Secondly, what is the problem with there only being one x86 manufacturer? I can name many other CPU architectures that are (or were at one point) manufactured by only one company. We can also draw parallels with Microsoft, which is the only supplier of the Windows operating system. They were never even forced to license Windows to third parties, or open up the sourcecode or anything.
We really do NOT want a government to FORCE 'competition' by hampering Intel so much just so that poorly run companies like AMD have a shot at competing.
Anyone who thinks competition is something that HAS TO exist at all costs, because it is ALWAYS a good thing, is not thinking clearly. It seems that people have been brainwashed into this 'competition is good'-thing. But when it comes down to destroying the most powerful company to the level of its poor competitors, something is severely wrong.

The x86 license was quite fair, and for years AMD has been reasonably successful. It's not the fault of Intel or the x86 licensing that AMD now falls apart. That's AMD's own doing. Intel should not be punished for a competitor's mismanagement. It's not their fault that AMD messed up the Phenom product line, and paid way too much for the ATi acquisition, especially at a point where they didn't really have the financial health to make such an acquisition in the first place. AMD just wanted too much, too soon, and took on both Intel and nVidia at the same time.


i have no idea why microsoft wasn't broken up if you follow the anti-trust laws then it should've been broken up i can't say why it wasn't but really how can you be so foolish to say competition is bad? it might be bad for intel but i could care less about intel having a rough quarter if it means i get reasonably priced products because when you get down to it anti-trust laws are made to protect the consumer not the business entity.

and i can probably see intel having issues if it were to full on revoke the x86 license because the x86 processor is the de facto standard for every pc out there and i'm quite sure the govt. doesn't want to have only one supplier not to mention as the anti-trust laws read intel would be a monoply as being the only supplier in the world of pc processors.
 
I know your reputation, and I still try to read your posts with as much objectivity as I can muster anyway, but you lost me here.

Oh and by the way, I'm one of those guys who has been brainwashed into thinking competition is good. I suppose you like paying 2x-4x more for your CPUs.

seriously, where do you get the idea that intel would charge 2-4x more for CPUs?

THERE ARE OTHER CPU MANUFACTURERS OUT THERE.

Windows is NOT the be all and end all of the world, and Linux and OSX both run on different architectures and do so quite well....

Intel would be slitting its own wrists if it jacked up CPU prices while slowing innovation, because I assure you, IBM or any number of the ARM manufacturers would be licking their lips at the thought of breaking down the Windows wall and completely opening the personal computing space to processor instruction competition...

it is an idiotic assumption to think that a dead AMD means a slower pace of innovation + higher costs.... Intel is NOT the only company that makes microprocessors.....
 
i have no idea why microsoft wasn't broken up if you follow the anti-trust laws then it should've been broken up i can't say why it wasn't but really how can you be so foolish to say competition is bad? it might be bad for intel but i could care less about intel having a rough quarter if it means i get reasonably priced products because when you get down to it anti-trust laws are made to protect the consumer not the business entity.

and i can probably see intel having issues if it were to full on revoke the x86 license because the x86 processor is the de facto standard for every pc out there and i'm quite sure the govt. doesn't want to have only one supplier not to mention as the anti-trust laws read intel would be a monoply as being the only supplier in the world of pc processors.

Well MS doesnt make the onlu Operating system..nor do they own a license to prevent someone from making thier own operating system

thats the difference. If u dont like MS... you can run UBUNTU or PUPPY no problemo...

if INTEL pulls AMD's x86 License...then there is nothing but INTEL...full MONOPOLY

INTEL needs AMD to keep the break up from happening. They Wont pull the license...i can gurantee that
 
almost everything you use is made in china... when are u going to stop buying those products as well?

I have much less of a problem buying products made in china as I am buying from a company that is OWNED by a good amount by people from a part of the world I do not like much....

and yes, I do try to avoid buying products from chinese companies when I can....

key phrase... "when I can".... and in the case of PC equipment, perfectly acceptable and in fact, superior substitutes exist: Intel, Nvidia, IBM, etc....

yes, I know public companies can have shareholders throughout the world, but AMD's situation is different than most companies'
 
it is an idiotic assumption to think that a dead AMD means a slower pace of innovation + higher costs.... Intel is NOT the only company that makes microprocessors.....

How old are you?

And that is exactly what would happen, just as it has happened in the past. To assume OTHERWISE is idiotic.

People need to get over this silly "other CPU manufacturers" argument. Intel and AMD account for pretty much ALL of the desktop CPU market.

In any case, this whole argument is moot as AMD isn't "dead." Even "breaking up" sounds a bit sensationalist to me.
 
seriously, where do you get the idea that intel would charge 2-4x more for CPUs?

THERE ARE OTHER CPU MANUFACTURERS OUT THERE.

Windows is NOT the be all and end all of the world, and Linux and OSX both run on different architectures and do so quite well....

Intel would be slitting its own wrists if it jacked up CPU prices while slowing innovation, because I assure you, IBM or any number of the ARM manufacturers would be licking their lips at the thought of breaking down the Windows wall and completely opening the personal computing space to processor instruction competition...

it is an idiotic assumption to think that a dead AMD means a slower pace of innovation + higher costs.... Intel is NOT the only company that makes microprocessors.....

INTEL is no pulling AMD's license as they will face antitrust big time...dont even worry about it .....AMD isnt going anywhere
 
Well MS doesnt make the onlu Operating system..nor do they own a license to prevent someone from making thier own operating system

thats the difference. If u dont like MS... you can run UBUNTU or PUPPY no problemo...

if INTEL pulls AMD's x86 License...then there is nothing but INTEL...full MONOPOLY

INTEL needs AMD to keep the break up from happening. They Wont pull the license...i can gurantee that


if INTEL pulls AMD's x86 License... then there is nothing but INTEL.... and IBM, Nvidia, Texas Instruments, Marvell, etc

and... FYI... if x86 ceased to exist, Ubuntu, Puppy, OSX, BSD, WINDOWS, would go on living just fine.....
 
Oh and by the way, I'm one of those guys who has been brainwashed into thinking competition is good. I suppose you like paying 2x-4x more for your CPUs.

Exactly my point. Apparently you think that 'no competition' equals 'paying 2x-4x more for your CPUs'.
Sure, there is a possibility, but I can name many reasons why CPU prices will NOT increase that much. Firstly ofcourse the antitrust regulations... Secondly the fact that the lifetime of a CPU is well over 10 years, so a company like Intel gets its money from people upgrading their PCs, not by replacing defective parts. Simple rules of supply and demand dictate that if Intel doesn't offer CPUs that are cheap enough and/or a good enough upgrade, there will be no demand for new CPUs in a few years.
For the most part, Intel is competing against itself. This even goes for the current situation, since AMD only covers about 20% of the market. Which means that the majority of CPU sales are generated by people upgrading FROM Intel TO Intel. AMD is just a small factor in the margin (which also explains why Intel could survive the Netburst era without ever turning in a single quarterly loss).
 
People need to get over this silly "other CPU manufacturers" argument. Intel and AMD account for pretty much ALL of the desktop CPU market.

get over this silly argument? and you ask me how old I am? how exactly is that a silly arguement....

with the migration to web apps, the growing importance of netbooks, UNIX, and cell phones, how exactly is x86 the only player in town?

your naivete is amusing to say the least.....


edit: the only thing you x86 zealots have in your arsenal is Windows.... in it's current released state. But I would like to remind you that Windows has run on other architectures int he past... and if Intel *did* turn into a bunch of bastards, I'm sure MS wouldn't hesitate to release ports as soon as it could....

and once again, being a monopoly is *not* illegal! look it up, educate yourselves....
 
Now we wait for Intel's response to AMD violating the x86 licensing terms.

Apparently this is the cross-license: http://contracts.corporate.findlaw.com/agreements/amd/intel.license.2001.01.01.html

I can see some things like "non-transferable", "without the right to sublicense" and "change-of-control" that are not 'compatible' with AMD splitting up.

Unless you're assuming both entities will retain the rights to produce x86 products of their own (And I don't see why the foundry would have its own CPU line), I don't see the issue.
AMD has used Chatered Semiconductor to produce Opterons and similar x86 parts for several years now without Intel raising a problem. This would not be the first time AMD has sub-contracted the actual fabrication.
 
Unless you're assuming both entities will retain the rights to produce x86 products of their own (And I don't see why the foundry would have its own CPU line), I don't see the issue.
AMD has used Chatered Semiconductor to produce Opterons and similar x86 parts for several years now without Intel raising a problem. This would not be the first time AMD has sub-contracted the actual fabrication.

good point
 
get over this silly argument? and you ask me how old I am? how exactly is that a silly arguement....

I asked you how old you were because you're obviously not old enough to remember the days when Intel CPUs were the only real game in town and cost an arm and a leg, not to imply anything about your maturity. Sensitive much? :rolleyes:

with the migration to web apps, the growing importance of netbooks, UNIX, and cell phones, how exactly is x86 the only player in town?

Nice straw man. http://www.fallacyfiles.org/strawman.html in case you need help with that reference. In case you still don't get it, I'm talking about desktop PC CPUs only. Be sure and let me know when you find a TI-powered desktop at Best Buy. And no I don't mean the NIC or Firewire controller.

your naivete is amusing to say the least.....
The irony here is absolutely killing me.

edit: the only thing you x86 zealots have in your arsenal is Windows.... in it's current released state. But I would like to remind you that Windows has run on other architectures int he past... and if Intel *did* turn into a bunch of bastards, I'm sure MS wouldn't hesitate to release ports as soon as it could....

and once again, being a monopoly is *not* illegal! look it up, educate yourselves....

I would like to remind you that I said nothing about any of this, and also mention that you come across as amazingly daft. Yeah, MS is going to punish Intel to stick up for us little guys. Just wow.

No need for you to waste your time responding, I won't be checking this joke of a thread again.

@ Scali - sorry you don't get your own post, at least you made some reasonable points. I never said CPU prices would jump overnight, but history has shown us that Intel without real competition in the desktop space WILL charge whatever it wants.



Again, I have to point out that none of this matters, because AMD isn't dead.
 
i have no idea why microsoft wasn't broken up if you follow the anti-trust laws then it should've been broken up i can't say why it wasn't but really how can you be so foolish to say competition is bad?

Wrong. I never said competition is bad.
I said competition isn't always better.

and i can probably see intel having issues if it were to full on revoke the x86 license because the x86 processor is the de facto standard for every pc out there and i'm quite sure the govt. doesn't want to have only one supplier not to mention as the anti-trust laws read intel would be a monoply as being the only supplier in the world of pc processors.

Nothing wrong with being a monopoly. Microsoft has been doing it for years. You might break an anti-trust law here and there from time to time, but in the long run it's no big deal.
 
Unless you're assuming both entities will retain the rights to produce x86 products of their own (And I don't see why the foundry would have its own CPU line), I don't see the issue.
AMD has used Chatered Semiconductor to produce Opterons and similar x86 parts for several years now without Intel raising a problem. This would not be the first time AMD has sub-contracted the actual fabrication.

The license terms allow for a certain percentage of manufacturing to be outsourced (I believe it was 20%).
This is where Chartered came in.
But the current plans sound like 100% outsourcing and that is NOT in the terms of the current cross-license agreement.
 
Wait, what is the problem here? The x86 CPU design would still be done in house and the production will also be done in house through their daughter company, Foundry Co., which will produce chips for other manufacturer as well.
 
@ Scali - sorry you don't get your own post, at least you made some reasonable points. I never said CPU prices would jump overnight, but history has shown us that Intel without real competition in the desktop space WILL charge whatever it wants.

Got any proof?
I've been in the game since the 8086 processors, and I can't imagine a more expensive time for CPUs than when the Athlon FX series was top-dog, ironically enough at the height of the competition.
So I claim history speaks in my favour. AMD was never enough competition to really drive Intel's prices down significantly. The current state is that AMD simply doesn't matter for most of Intel's pricerange, since AMD cannot deliver the performance to enter those segments to begin with. Effectively there IS no competition, and hasn't been for over 2 years, except for the bargain-basement.
 
Wait, what is the problem here? The x86 CPU design would still be done in house and the production will also be done in house through their daughter company, Foundry Co., which will produce chips for other manufacturer as well.

The problem is that the x86 license can not be transfered down to a daughter company. A daughter company (or whatever other construction you might think of) simply cannot be seen as 'in house'.
Intel's legal department bolted that backdoor down quite well, for obvious reasons.
 
I asked you how old you were because you're obviously not old enough to remember the days when Intel CPUs were the only real game in town and cost an arm and a leg, not to imply anything about your maturity. Sensitive much? :rolleyes:

except AMD has been around since 1970..... so when was it exactly that Intel was the only game in town? because I guess I'm not THAT old....

besides... I do understand (in general terms) the wonderful world of process technology and the phenomenon of how electronics components continually get faster and cheaper with the passage of time. Even just a decade ago, your typical processor cost MUCH more than it cost to make one today.... and in the future, processors will be so cheap and low margin, that it really will take huge companies with incredible economies of scale to stay profitable....

So yea.... this mythical time when Intel jacked up prices just for the fun of it without competition? Please tell me when that was again? And was their process technology better than what they have today? Because I'm pretty sure that intel still sells $500+ processors on the market....

sure they have a low end now too... but a decade ago they had a low end also... and it *rocked*. Google it sometime, I think it was called the Celeron 300A...

Nice straw man. http://www.fallacyfiles.org/strawman.html in case you need help with that reference. In case you still don't get it, I'm talking about desktop PC CPUs only. Be sure and let me know when you find a TI-powered desktop at Best Buy. And no I don't mean the NIC or Firewire controller.

How old are you again? Because I'm sure anyone over the age of 14 understands how a free market operates. When there is a demand for something, supply will rise to meet that demand. And when there aren't any barriers to entry, competitors will enter a market and drive down price.

It might not happen *immediately*, but it would eventually if hypothetically AMD were to go out of business and Intel became a bunch of idiots and jacked up prices....

even Microsoft and Apple would have a huge stake in keeping x86 prices low, and if Intel didn't comply with their needs, they would go looking for someone else to help them with it...


I would like to remind you that I said nothing about any of this, and also mention that you come across as amazingly daft. Yeah, MS is going to punish Intel to stick up for us little guys. Just wow.

hah, that right there shows you have no idea wtf you are talking about.... because you are *so* right... MS doesn't need to protect it's revenue stream at all....
 
Wrong. I never said competition is bad.
I said competition isn't always better.



Nothing wrong with being a monopoly. Microsoft has been doing it for years. You might break an anti-trust law here and there from time to time, but in the long run it's no big deal.

The only reason its not a big deal is because when they get out of line, the government (US or EU) smacks their pee-pee with a ruler. And there are choices. Any monkey can come out with a new linux-flavor-of-the-month.

Creating a new CPU that can compete with Intel cant be done by a few nerds in the basement.
 
except AMD has been around since 1970..... so when was it exactly that Intel was the only game in town? because I guess I'm not THAT old....

AMD didn't sell x86 clones until 1991, when they released their Am386DX (after a long legal battle with Intel, resulting in the first x86 cross-license. It was renewed in 2001, and that one is still valid as far as I know).
AMD did produce x86 processors before that, but that was Intel outsourcing part of the 8086 and 80286 production because of a clause in the deal they made with IBM for their PC line (IBM insisted on having multiple suppliers for CPUs to reduce the risk). Obviously AMD didn't design these CPUs, but just manufactured them, and they were still sold under the Intel brand (although most of them do have AMD's name on them).
AMD didn't design the 386 and 486 they sold either, they reverse-engineered the Intel parts (Intel was never keen on outsourcing production and giving others their designs, they could get out of the deal with IBM in the 386 era when many alternative IBM PC-clones had arrived).
 
Back
Top