AMD Breaking up

I was responding to what someone else posted, which as Nenu already explained, is what people do on a discussion forum.
Yuo don't respond, you just write and doesn't listen to what the others are saying if they don't agree with you. The discussion in this thread is a joke, just a lot of talking and it's all about feelings for you (the competition thing).
 
Yuo don't respond, you just write and doesn't listen to what the others are saying if they don't agree with you. The discussion in this thread is a joke, just a lot of talking and it's all about feelings for you (the competition thing).


Duby229...relax.
 
Yuo don't respond, you just write and doesn't listen to what the others are saying if they don't agree with you. The discussion in this thread is a joke, just a lot of talking and it's all about feelings for you (the competition thing).

Ridiculous, Scali2 is backing up every point he makes. The reason you think he "doesn't listen" is because very few other people seem interested in providing evidence for their opinions.

EDIT: As to the situation under discussion, concepts like absolutely right/wrong don't apply here. The only salient question we should be asking would be: Is AMD in an actionable position due to their violation of the cross licensing agreement?

Whether or not you believe AMD is right/wrong, the fact that this is actionable is pretty much indisputable at this point.
 
Whether or not you believe AMD is right/wrong, the fact that this is actionable is pretty much indisputable at this point.

Do you also think that competition can be bad for the consumer? :rolleyes:

It's okey if you have arguments that stick but reading arguments in this thread made me feel like there was childrens in the thread.
I know that there are a lot of people in this forum that thinks Intel is best in the world, they have probably not used AMD's.
 
Since the poor design of the Phenom is the main reason why AMD is going down the drain so quickly, I don't see how any other company can turn it around into a competitive part.



AMD can't, and I don't see any company better up for the task than AMD was.



If you have a good chip design and manufacturing facilities, which nobody has.



VIA managed to find a niche market, but is now being threatened by Atom aswell. AMD is far larger than VIA, and while they (or whoever buys them out) could try to enter such a niche market and be successful, they'd still have to shrink down lots and make tons of losses in the process.
You can't sustain a company the size of AMD with a niche market like VIA has, especially not with Atom intent on taking over.

The arabs think they can make the mumbo jumbo fly (they need it as oil is running out). I say we let them try. AMD's problems were due to bad management anyway. ATI should have been bought much sooner (say during the x800 times)

+Why was IBM and Intel able to sell inferior products?



*Does the Steve Balmer dance*
Marketing! Marketing!! Marketing!!!
 
+Why was IBM and Intel able to sell inferior products?

*Does the Steve Balmer dance*
Marketing! Marketing!! Marketing!!!

Yes, IBM was quick to find out that most people know nothing about computers, and just go for a name. IBM had that name (it already supplied typewriters, calculators and all that sort of stuff to many companies, some even used IBM mainframes, so their PC MUST be good!).
Microsoft just rode in on that wave.

Regardless, marketing is competition aswell, and it's that competition that robbed the consumer of superior alternatives. Apparently it created a world where people are completely dependent on binary compatibility, both of the CPU and the OS. I find the x86 lock-in a far more serious issue than the Windows lock-in. At least with Windows you're free to use whatever third-party software you like, and develop your own stuff. If Microsoft doesn't supply it, someone else will. With x86 you have no choice. And people are apparently under the impression that you shouldn't have this choice. They love to have competition with CPUs, but only if all CPUs are x86.
 
WOW life in the amd forum! To all that are giving up on amd cause of the investment from a middle eastern country awash with oil money; please report to the nearest serialization center. (aka walk threw a nuclear power core) For prompt processing if it was not for this deal amd would not survive the current market conditions. this gives them a future and with hector in charge and ppl form amd in place at this company. I can see a possible scenario like the at&t breakup and the baby bells well sbc got at&t back to its old self. if the foundry company could buy amd or amd could buy the fabs after everthing is retooled and built
 
ATI should never have been bought, ever. AMD was never qualified to manage it. The merger almost ran both companies into the ground.

Noop, they needed each other:

Team 1) Intel and... Intel GMA
Team 2) VIA and S3

With the merger Team 3) AMD + ATI AKA DAMMIT

Who's the odd man out? Nvdia!
Without a complete platform to call their own they are in a vulnerable position and this year we all saw how that bit them in the ass hard.
 
Noop, they needed each other:

Team 1) Intel and... Intel GMA
Team 2) VIA and S3

With the merger Team 3) AMD + ATI AKA DAMMIT

Who's the odd man out? Nvdia!
Without a complete platform to call their own they are in a vulnerable position and this year we all saw how that bit them in the ass hard.

At the time, nVidia was producing the best AMD chipsets. AMD didn't need ATI because they already had a viable platform with nVidia. ATI certainly didn't need AMD because they were already doing fine with their graphics business. Plus, it's not like AMD injected any money to help ATI with development considering their entire market cap at the moment is less than ATI was worth before the merger. With the way the merger was handled, both companies were almost wrecked, and it also had a pretty big impact on the production of R600, which is one of the reasons the HD2000 series sucked so badly. The only positive thing to come out of it was AMD's current chipset line, but that's a pretty small benefit compared to all the problems that were caused.
 
At the time, nVidia was producing the best AMD chipsets. AMD didn't need ATI because they already had a viable platform with nVidia. ATI certainly didn't need AMD because they were already doing fine with their graphics business. Plus, it's not like AMD injected any money to help ATI with development considering their entire market cap at the moment is less than ATI was worth before the merger. With the way the merger was handled, both companies were almost wrecked, and it also had a pretty big impact on the production of R600, which is one of the reasons the HD2000 series sucked so badly. The only positive thing to come out of it was AMD's current chipset line, but that's a pretty small benefit compared to all the problems that were caused.

I think this is part of the major problem that lead to this spin off amd paid way to much for ati that hurt them. Perhaps this has always been in the cards? REtooling their fabs today costs a lot more than it did in jerry's day. Now follow me on this,Basically amd got ati so it could get working with the different foundries and understand the processes behind the scenes that allowed ati to make its chips. This gave them some experience dealing with the bulk foundry process that they did not have before. Buying ati was as much for its IP as well as allowing amd to look at the bulk foundry process from the inside out.
 
I think this is part of the major problem that lead to this spin off amd paid way to much for ati that hurt them. Perhaps this has always been in the cards? REtooling their fabs today costs a lot more than it did in jerry's day. Now follow me on this,Basically amd got ati so it could get working with the different foundries and understand the processes behind the scenes that allowed ati to make its chips. This gave them some experience dealing with the bulk foundry process that they did not have before. Buying ati was as much for its IP as well as allowing amd to look at the bulk foundry process from the inside out.

I doubt the idea of spinning off the fabs into a separate company was even out there when AMD bought ATI. The only reason they're doing this is because they can't really afford not to, but when the purchase was made, AMD wasn't hurting for cash nearly as much as they are now (or they certainly wouldn't have put down $5.4 billion for ATI).
 
I doubt the idea of spinning off the fabs into a separate company was even out there when AMD bought ATI. The only reason they're doing this is because they can't really afford not to, but when the purchase was made, AMD wasn't hurting for cash nearly as much as they are now (or they certainly wouldn't have put down $5.4 billion for ATI).

well you do have to admit from the onset of the ati buyout amd was looking at how ati ran things and gained valuable insider experience in the bulk foundry world that is applying to this spin off
 
well you do have to admit from the onset of the ati buyout amd was looking at how ati ran things and gained valuable insider experience in the bulk foundry world that is applying to this spin off
The Foundry Company/ATIC will be using IBM's bulk Si process, which I have read is not very popular from IBM due to the costs. AMD had been paying IBM $100 million a year for that and SOI already. The ATI purchase had nothing to do with that.
 
The Foundry Company/ATIC will be using IBM's bulk Si process, which I have read is not very popular from IBM due to the costs. AMD had been paying IBM $100 million a year for that and SOI already. The ATI purchase had nothing to do with that.

you are not reading the simpleness of the post amd gained ati bulk contract experience this applies to current day decisions
 
You do try to look at the bright side. :p No, purchasing ATI did not prepare AMD to spin off manufacturing to a foundry using another company's process. :p

The extremely poor decision by Ruiz did force this situation though.
 
You do try to look at the bright side. :p No, purchasing ATI did not prepare AMD to spin off manufacturing to a foundry using another company's process. :p

The extremely poor decision by Ruiz did force this situation though.

Exactly. AMD bought ATI right before Intel released Core 2 and smashed AMD's entire lineup, which really devalued the company. The fact is, buying ATI was by no means a good idea and did hardly anything to benefit AMD. Had the buyout never happened, both companies would probably be in better positions right now.
 
the impact of ATI acquisition wouldn't be felt 1-2yrs after the deal. it takes time to design and validate new processors coming from that merger. one of those result is Fusion which I guess everyone should be somewhat familiar already.
 
I wonder though. Buying ATi didn't really benefit AMD. But you have to realize that ATi was bought around the time of the Radeon 2900-fiasco.
It could well be that ATi would not have survived the 2900-fiasco by itself, and would not have been able to turn things around by releasing the 3000 and now 4000-series. In fact, I don't see why ATi would have even sold out if they could.
 
Well from a consumer view, I see the buying of ATI as a good thing. I know I cannot wait for AMD to release Fusion. I have been playing with their Stream SDK program, and for some applications it totally surpases what any cpu can do. The one Stream program that most consumers would use alot is the video encoder program.
But as with everything else people will have their own opinion and even if they create new technology to do things faster, some will say it was a waste of money. For the most part I feel the merger was a great thing for both companies, I don't think we have yet seen all the benefits of the merger.
 
48xx may be the product of the year. It could be that AMD had knowledge of the potential of the new ATI chips when they bought the company, it just had to be developed and tuned to get return on the investment.
 
Back
Top