A New HTTP Status Code Has Been Proposed

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
A new HTTP code status has been proposed by Tim Bray to display a notice when a web site is closed for legal reasons. Bray, a co-inventor of XML and developer at Google, will submit a proposal to the IETF for the code, named 451, to include specific reasons for the shutdown of a website, to include illegal activities, censorship, or other reasons such as copyright infringement.

The number in the code is a reference to Ray Bradbury's "Farenheit 451," which describes a dystopian future in which book burnings and the censorship of unacceptable material is routine
 
Me gusta. If only for the reference.
 
Oh sweet irony. The inspiration for the code was about the anti-censorship book Fahrenheit 451, and the code will be used for websites that get censored. :rolleyes:
 
While I agree with the code number 451 and the spirit it's used in, I have to say that there are plenty of legitimate reasons to shut down websites that aren't remotely censorship.
 
Primarily stuff I don't agree with.

Sorry but you lost me. When I say that there are reasons to shut down websites that are not censorship related I mean sites that sell illegal materials, drugs, pr0n... stuff that isn't remotely capable of being called free speech.
 
Sorry but you lost me. When I say that there are reasons to shut down websites that are not censorship related I mean sites that sell illegal materials, drugs, pr0n... stuff that isn't remotely capable of being called free speech.

Maybe he still disagrees with you. I think people can have different sets of values.
 
Sorry but you lost me. When I say that there are reasons to shut down websites that are not censorship related I mean sites that sell illegal materials, drugs, pr0n... stuff that isn't remotely capable of being called free speech.

This would simply let us know the site has been censored. That some sites are censored, with the reason(s) not being free speech related, is irrelevant imho. The site has still been censored.
If it has been censored, I would prefer to know that it was censored due to legal reasons, rather than not know anything at all.


At best all this does is draw a trickle more attention to just how much various government decided what is and is not objectionable content.
 
Maybe he still disagrees with you. I think people can have different sets of values.

It is the law. If he thinks they're good and right he should work to change the law, not advocate illegal and harmful anarchy.
 
This would simply let us know the site has been censored. That some sites are censored, with the reason(s) not being free speech related, is irrelevant imho. The site has still been censored.
If it has been censored, I would prefer to know that it was censored due to legal reasons, rather than not know anything at all.


At best all this does is draw a trickle more attention to just how much various government decided what is and is not objectionable content.

It doesn't automatically mean it's being censored, just taken down for legal reasons. Censorship could be the reason or copyright infringement or any other legal reason.

The author of the proposal does state that "According to the 451 draft, responses using the code should indicate details about the pertinent legal restriction, which legal authority is behind it, and what class of resources the restriction applies to."

Which would clear up whether it was someone shutting the site down for illegal activity or simply shutting it up.
 
Sorry but you lost me. When I say that there are reasons to shut down websites that are not censorship related I mean sites that sell illegal materials, drugs, pr0n... stuff that isn't remotely capable of being called free speech.

Censorship at it's best :rolleyes:
 
Censorship at it's best :rolleyes:

So I suppose if you run out and rob a store or sell crack and get arrested doing it you're simply "being oppressed".

I have to say that people never cease to amaze me.
 
It doesn't automatically mean it's being censored, just taken down for legal reasons. Censorship could be the reason or copyright infringement or any other legal reason.

The author of the proposal does state that "According to the 451 draft, responses using the code should indicate details about the pertinent legal restriction, which legal authority is behind it, and what class of resources the restriction applies to."

Which would clear up whether it was someone shutting the site down for illegal activity or simply shutting it up.

In any case that would technically be censorship. The majority of us as a society have decided certain things are not protected speech but are criminal and should be censored. Libel and kiddy porn among other things are considered not okay and are censored. Just because everyone here agrees that this kind of censorship is good doesn't not change the fact that it is censorship.
 
Who gives a flying fuck about an error 451. Just 404 the shit and move on. Usually when people are on a site that involves copyright infringement get a 404 that's a "Duh... move on people, there's nothing to see here."
 
i have 0 problem with shutting down website for illegal activities.

Hell , a website hosted a video of a murder by the infamous Luka Rocco Magnotta . The guy actually murdered a chinese student with an icepick , and cut him up in pieces and sent them to various people in parcels. He filmed himself doing it for FXXK sake.... THe website owner told everyone its free speech and blah blah blah.

That would be a good reason.
 
It doesn't automatically mean it's being censored, just taken down for legal reasons. Censorship could be the reason or copyright infringement or any other legal reason.

The author of the proposal does state that "According to the 451 draft, responses using the code should indicate details about the pertinent legal restriction, which legal authority is behind it, and what class of resources the restriction applies to."

Which would clear up whether it was someone shutting the site down for illegal activity or simply shutting it up.


We should be happy that they are proposing to get this instated. It is not making it easier to shut down sites, but it is giving more information to the public in regards to viewing a site after it has been shut down.

I am not even sure why anyone would be opposed to more information being directly available to the public?
 
Sorry but you lost me. When I say that there are reasons to shut down websites that are not censorship related I mean sites that sell illegal materials, drugs, pr0n... stuff that isn't remotely capable of being called free speech.

That is censorship. If information is suppressed, then it is censored. Censorship by law just makes it government-imposed censorship, it doesn't make it special or exempt.

Society has created guidelines on subjective things like "good" and "evil" to determine what the population does not want to know or does not want others to know. Most (all?) people are conditioned to accept censorship of the unsavory as normal and write it off as "well no sane person wants to see that".
 
i have 0 problem with shutting down website for illegal activities.

Hell , a website hosted a video of a murder by the infamous Luka Rocco Magnotta . The guy actually murdered a chinese student with an icepick , and cut him up in pieces and sent them to various people in parcels. He filmed himself doing it for FXXK sake.... THe website owner told everyone its free speech and blah blah blah.

That would be a good reason.

so who gets to say whats "illegal" and where
some thing thats legal here in the US like buying firearms is illegal in say the UK
how does that work?

there may be things that are illegal in the US that are legal else where in the world
just because you dont like it doesnt mean you can say what some else can do
 
so who gets to say whats "illegal" and where
some thing thats legal here in the US like buying firearms is illegal in say the UK
how does that work?

there may be things that are illegal in the US that are legal else where in the world
just because you dont like it doesnt mean you can say what some else can do

murder and rape are not legal anywhere in democratic country afaik.
 
murder and rape are not legal anywhere in democratic country afaik.

Last I checked, the internet wasn't restricted to democratic countries. Using voip services in Ethiopia is illegal, and could be seen as something that should be censored. Does that mean it should be? Who gets to make that decision?
 
i have 0 problem with shutting down website for illegal activities.

Hell , a website hosted a video of a murder by the infamous Luka Rocco Magnotta . The guy actually murdered a chinese student with an icepick , and cut him up in pieces and sent them to various people in parcels. He filmed himself doing it for FXXK sake.... THe website owner told everyone its free speech and blah blah blah.

That would be a good reason.

There's a difference between "shutting down your website because you butchered another human being for publicity" and "shutting down your website because your corporate masters demanded your government do so".
 
oh yea, just think of all the crack selling, raping, and murdering sites that are being shut down. not like shutting sites down for file sharing is the current headliner these days.
 
That is censorship. If information is suppressed, then it is censored. Censorship by law just makes it government-imposed censorship, it doesn't make it special or exempt.

Society has created guidelines on subjective things like "good" and "evil" to determine what the population does not want to know or does not want others to know. Most (all?) people are conditioned to accept censorship of the unsavory as normal and write it off as "well no sane person wants to see that".

Tell a cop he's censoring you the next time you get pulled over for speeding. See how far that goes.
 
i have 0 problem with shutting down website for illegal activities.

Hell , a website hosted a video of a murder by the infamous Luka Rocco Magnotta . The guy actually murdered a chinese student with an icepick , and cut him up in pieces and sent them to various people in parcels. He filmed himself doing it for FXXK sake.... THe website owner told everyone its free speech and blah blah blah.

That would be a good reason.

Of course, the other side of the story you must already know :rolleyes: is that the people on the forum took his photo and with some work were able to determine who the guy was, gave that information to the cops hours after the murder had happened and thanks to them in part the cops almost caught him before he fled the country. Without the forum, the cops would have probably needed hours more and wouldn't have stood a chance of catching the guy so soon.

Having the cops on his trail could have even prevented Luka from performing a second murder in the meantime, etc.

Still, yes. Its morally objectional to post such videos online considering the family members might not want the murder of their daughter to be shared eveywhere and become infamous among gore-watchers. Albeit, it may have helped justice get served quicker for the family and save lives. Fair trade? maybe... maybe not...
 
Tell a cop he's censoring you the next time you get pulled over for speeding. See how far that goes.

Restricting information is censorship. Whether justly or unjustly it is still censorship.
Getting a ticket for speeding is not censorship. I suppose a ticket could be construed as a government censure, but the verbs censor, and censure, are two different things.

All code 451 does is tell us the site has been censored. I don't get how it can be considered a bad thing.
 
Crap. Got my tabs mixed up.

Meant to say that censorship in of itself can be a bad thing. That there is a specific code (with heavy references to the act of censorship ala Fahrenheit 451) can be a good thing as it draws attention to WHY the site is no longer accessible. Rather than hiding it under a generic 404 "Not Found."
 
Back
Top