Linux, iTunes Coming to Microsoft's App Store

A classic desktop Linux argument. How many times have you said you don't care about people? How many times have you said you don't want desktop Linux to become mainstream? How many times in a yes, a PC gaming forum, PC gamers don't matter? You do that sort of thing like desktop Linux advocates have done over and over and over. Not one iota better than Microsoft.

I have never once stated that I personally want desktop Linux to become mainstream, in fact I have stated the polar opposite.

You are the one substantiating just why propitiatory software is bad, you're doing that all by yourself with your futile arguing.
 
LOL! Because I'm the only one that's paid for Windows software on planet Earth. You're getting comical. ;)

It....Is....Not....An....Issue.....Under....OSX.....Or.....MacOS.

And you wonder why people claim you're a paid shill!
 
- Windows 10 was free considering the handover of one's Windows 7 licence.
- Windows 10 has been classed as the last version of Windows by MS themselves.
- Therefore MS cannot make any more retail sales out of their OS once the masses have shifted 100% to the new platform.
- Office365 is being pushed heavily by MS as their subscription based office suite of choice.
- The Windows store is now being pushed heavily by MS under Windows 10 S.
- Bloody iTunes is now available under the Windows Store.
- The worlds most popular OS runs an app store based model with no issue.
- OSX/macOS usually requires people to repurchase software after a major update due to compatibility issues. This is rarely an issue, if it is what are you going to do about it?
- iOS runs an app based store with no issue.
- There are signs of Apple switching to an app store based platform under macOS.
- Gabe Newell predicted Microsoft's shift to a Windows Store based model years ago.

- You still owe MS for Windows 10.

Once again. I can understand why people are uncomfortable about the inclusion of a Windows Store in Windows 10. Most ignored the store under Windows 8/8.1 as most ignored 8/8.1 compleately, hence it was never a discussed concern in the past. The writing is on the wall in relation to MS shifting to either a subscription based product or a scenario where software can only be installed via MS approved channels only. Hell, such a situation would most defiantly rectify the issues surrounding infections under such a popular OS due to the fact it's forced onto the consumer.
 
It....would....be....A....HUGE...Issue.....Under....Windows.

Why I am a shill by pointing out the obvious?

Because you're the one making it out to be an issue when it's well known due to experiences under other operating systems that it's never an issue where you don't have a choice.
 
Because you're the one making it out to be an issue when it's well known due to experiences under other operating systems that it's never an issue where you don't have a choice.

This is basically gibberish. You don't even use much of what I do that's Win32 only.
 
And that's Office not an OS.

You mean the software they used to sell in a box... but now sell subscriptions for ? If we where to rewind time and have this conversation a few years back about office... I imagine you would still be using the exact same argument. They won't move to a subscription what about all these copies people have already bought. lmao

Whatever you guys are passing around in that dream world I think I may want in.
 
A classic desktop Linux argument. How many times have you said you don't care about people? How many times have you said you don't want desktop Linux to become mainstream? How many times in a yes, a PC gaming forum, PC gamers don't matter? You do that sort of thing like desktop Linux advocates have done over and over and over. Not one iota better than Microsoft.

Linux will never be main stream... we all know that and don't really care. It will always be here for us. For the masses I hate to say it but your all doomed to a future of ChromeOS, and if your lucky Google will at least make it a ChromeOS+ or add a really good steaming game service. MS has already lost.... they where far to slow realising the market was changing one them. Windows 10 is a oh crap we need to catch up product which is reason for all the heavy handed upgrade tactics and the free give away. MS needs to herd people into their store ecosystem before the "cloud" based offerings destroy them. They are in a race with the internet... as broadband improves, hot spots proliferate, and high speed cellular becomes the norm the chances of Google being able to step on their necks in the consumer market looms closer. Its only a matter of time before Google (not Linux) decides they should own all the boxes not just the ones in peoples hands.

At this point their is only a couple things they need to take MS out in less the then a few years. One they need to ship ChromeOS on some higher end hardware. ChromeOS+ with more internal storage, higher end hardware... and improved offline use of a handful of online google services. Other then that they need a game store. Now if they go the ChromeOS+ route its simple they ship those machines with a game store, either partnering with Valve or Sony, or just going their own way and signing up developers directly. (Partnering with Sony or Valve would make perfect sense... the PS4 and Sonys 3D APIs run on a BSD kernel Sony could easily provide the tools to convert PS4 games directly. Valve of course has been building the tools for SteamOS and adding some libraries to Chromes stripped down gentoo wouldn't be all that hard).

When (I don't think its an if really) Google decides on a path to take that market. I give windows a couple years tops. MS lost Windows 5 years back... when Google launched ChromeOS and MS ignored it until last week.
 
So wy hasn't Steam just taken away all the games that Windows users bought and said "Just get all your games on Linux." Right, corporate greed.

Valve seems to actually care about their customers... and yes if you buy a game with support for windows mac or linux you can download that game and play it on any or all supported operating systems.

Valve wasn't ready to replace all windows gaming the day they launched steamos... the entire point was to build an ecosystem of developers and tech. That is exactly what they have done. As I have said a few times what they have done isn't to entice a ton of ports. Yes we have gotten a bunch of great games... what is important is that they have laid the ground work to replace windows gaming if required. Frankly its looking more and more like gabe was very smart and we are ALL (everyone that enjoys gaming) going to be very glad he put the ball in motion 3 years ago. When Googles OS rises to destroy MS in the consumer market... you will still be able to install Linux and run steam Linux games. (assuming you don't opt into Googles game store anyway)
 
This is basically gibberish. You don't even use much of what I do that's Win32 only.

I am so sick of your assumption that I don't use Windows.

I am a PC tech, that's my job. Guess what? Most people run Windows, the fact they run windows implies nothing relating to this argument. However, it can literally be assumed that due to the nature of my job I may actually know more about the intricacies of Windows that you do [gasp]! So how about you let go of your false little ideology that I know nothing about Windows and that I don't use Windows, because the fact is survival would be pretty damn difficult if that was actually the case.

You act like a child sticking their fingers in their ears yelling "la,la,la!" so they don't have to hear the truth! It's a joke! And then you act all dazed and confused the second most of the [H] forums claim your a paid shill! They call you a paid shill because you act like a paid shill!

No, unlike yourself I can use literally anything, any OS. I can do that because I don't deliberately tie myself down to Microsoft products only like some bizarre MS groupie and I'm not afraid of learning something new. Bear in mind that I'm not assuming you know little about anything but Windows as you openly brag about using nothing but Windows. The few times you tried Linux, it was blatantly obvious you were totally lost considering what you were trying to achieve.

Your argument regarding Gabe forcing all developers on Steam to Linux is blatantly laughable and completely out of context to the argument at hand. You're talking about a complete platform shift from Windows to Linux, I'm talking about packaging win32 applications in sandboxed, secure containers for download only on the Windows store but still using the same platform! One option is completely realistic, the other is just plain stupid.

Pages of dribble all because I claimed to understand why Shotglass01 would be concerned about the inclusion of a Windows Store in Windows 10!

If you've got a problem with me, send it via PM, stop clogging up threads with your extreme bias.
 
Last edited:
Did you read what I said? Holly shit.

He never does. I finally gave up because I have more important things to do. I realized that he has zero effect on the future of Desktop and Windows based PC's and never will. More specifically, if OEM's thought this was a real threat, they would be doing everything they can to find something else to run their stuff on ASAP. Perhaps they know more than we do, including Gabe, who has not only ran Steam on Windows right from the beginning but also expanded it.
 
I am so sick of your assumption that I don't use Windows.

I am a PC tech, that's my job. Guess what? Most people run Windows, the fact they run windows implies nothing relating to this argument. However, it can literally be assumed that due to the nature of my job I may actually know more about the intricacies of Windows that you do [gasp]!

You don't use Windows the way I do. You've said repeatedly that you don't play AAA games for instance. You're saying that in the future Microsoft will create a release of Windows where all versions will be incompatible with virtually all AAA games ever created for Windows along with virtually all open source software that runs on Windows along with just about everything else. All just to make 30% from software in the Windows Store. And you say that people will continue to use Windows. But how do they if release comes along that doesn't run most or all of their software?

Anyone can make predictions but without a answer to this question I think this particular prediction is very unlikely.
 
You don't use Windows the way I do. You've said repeatedly that you don't play AAA games for instance. You're saying that in the future Microsoft will create a release of Windows where all versions will be incompatible with virtually all AAA games ever created for Windows along with virtually all open source software that runs on Windows along with just about everything else. All just to make 30% from software in the Windows Store. And you say that people will continue to use Windows. But how do they if release comes along that doesn't run most or all of their software?

Anyone can make predictions but without a answer to this question I think this particular prediction is very unlikely.

Nothing's going to be incompatible! They're Windows software applications running on the Windows platform!

Win32 is essentially legacy, it's been a legacy API for quite some time now and it's obvious that MS is doing their best to begin a transition to UWP while many other developers move to web based applications. At the end of the day, the gamers can cry all they like, they're a minority when it can be assumed that 80% of PC users don't play games on their PC. Besides, there's nothing to state that you can't enter a product key into the Windows Store, re download your game for free and continue on - Essentially no different to installing a retail game key under Steam now.

Geezus, I look at Microsoft's new 'Fluent Design' and all I see is a touch OS designed for fat fingers! Microsoft is slowly killing off the desktop PC as you know it today for what is essentially a touch OS, further substantiating that a move to Windows Store installs only is on the cards - Something that I'm surprised even bothers you as you're the one person on the [H] forums pushing for Windows to become a touch based OS, actively defending decisions to slowly phase out the control panel for the settings panel!

While Windows enthusiasts like to claim that virus/malware and recently worm issues are not a problem under Windows, the fact is Windows is a cesspool of infection and AV packages are failing to hold back the ocean of infection, with AV packages usually causing more issues than they resolve: Something has to give and a move to UWP installs via the Windows Store only would rectify this issue overnight. Believe what you want, the reality of the situation is that there's more evidence supporting a switch to Windows Store only installation than hanging onto a legacy Win32 API for the sake of backwards compatibility.

In my opinion, backwards compatibility is actually holding Windows back.

He never does. I finally gave up because I have more important things to do. I realized that he has zero effect on the future of Desktop and Windows based PC's and never will. More specifically, if OEM's thought this was a real threat, they would be doing everything they can to find something else to run their stuff on ASAP. Perhaps they know more than we do, including Gabe, who has not only ran Steam on Windows right from the beginning but also expanded it.

There is so many issues with this comment. It's childish, it's a blatant attack while you're the first one to pop up and cry victim, and it's so full of holes it's just not funny.

How about posting in a constructive manner every once in a while? Because as it stands now, I'd say 90% of your posts are no more than attacks on others.
 
Win32 is essentially legacy, it's been a legacy API for quite some time now and it's obvious that MS is doing their best to begin a transition to UWP while many other developers move to web based applications. At the end of the day, the gamers can cry all they like, they're a minority when it can be assumed that 80% of PC users don't play games on their PC. Besides, there's nothing to state that you can't enter a product key into the Windows Store, re download your game for free and continue on - Essentially no different to installing a retail game key under Steam now.

This is just about games, this is about virtually all existing Windows software.

While Windows enthusiasts like to claim that virus/malware and recently worm issues are not a problem under Windows, the fact is Windows is a cesspool of infection and AV packages are failing to hold back the ocean of infection, with AV packages usually causing more issues than they resolve: Something has to give and a move to UWP installs via the Windows Store only would rectify this issue overnight. Believe what you want, the reality of the situation is that there's more evidence supporting a switch to Windows Store only installation than hanging onto a legacy Win32 API for the sake of backwards compatibility.

Windows 10 so far is immune to WannaCry, the worm doesn't even try to attack Windows 10 systems because Windows Defender quarantines it even if hasn't received the SMBv2 patch. So sure I get what you're saying but no matter the OS if you don't maintain stuff properly you're going to get hit, period. We have to patch out Linux systems just as much as Windows.
 
This is just about games, this is about virtually all existing Windows software.



Windows 10 so far is immune to WannaCry, the worm doesn't even try to attack Windows 10 systems because Windows Defender quarantines it even if hasn't received the SMBv2 patch. So sure I get what you're saying but no matter the OS if you don't maintain stuff properly you're going to get hit, period. We have to patch out Linux systems just as much as Windows.

Once again, Win32 is now legacy code. You can cry all you want, the fact is if MS were to change to UWP installs only tomorrow you'd have no choice but to stick to Windows, MS knows this. Furthermore, a great many people have updates disabled on their Windows 10 machine due to a lack of control over the operation of the updater, these people are still targets, highlighting why a complete lack of control is a bad thing.
 
Once again, Win32 is now legacy code. You can cry all you want, the fact is if MS were to change to UWP installs only tomorrow you'd have no choice but to stick to Windows.

So you're saying I'd have to stick to Windows even if became incompatible with thousands of dollars in software? That literally makes no sense. How can anyone stick to something that brakes almost all of their software?
 
So you're saying I'd have to stick to Windows even if became incompatible with thousands of dollars in software? That literally makes no sense. How can anyone stick to something that brakes almost all of their software?

Dear god!

What makes you believe that your software is incompatible! It's just packaged differently, it's not incompatible!
 
Dear god!

What makes you believe that your software is incompatible! It's just packaged differently, it's not incompatible!

Yes, all existing Win32 programs would be incompatible and it'll be between now never before most of it ends up in the Windows Store. And that's not counting tons of custom applications.
 
Yes, all existing Win32 programs would be incompatible and it'll be between now never before most of it ends up in the Windows Store. And that's not counting tons of custom applications.

Riiiighto....

If you're incapable of reasoning I guess it's a matter of whatever makes you happy then....?

Bear in mind that the fact I don't get as involved in AAA gaming as I used to by no means indicates that I don't understand the process of installing software under Windows.

Change is inevitable.
 
Riiiighto....

If you're incapable of reasoning I guess it's a matter of whatever makes you happy then....?

Bear in mind that the fact I don't get as involved in AAA gaming as I used to by no means indicates that I don't understand the process of installing software under Windows.

Change is inevitable.

I get the reasoning and yes change is inevitable. But it's perfectly reasonable to question how this particular change is even possible. The benefit to Microsoft is 30% from all Windows software sales from the store versus the loss of the largest desktop software ecosystem.
 
I get the reasoning and yes change is inevitable. But it's perfectly reasonable to question how this particular change is even possible. The benefit to Microsoft is 30% from all Windows software sales from the store versus the loss of the largest desktop software ecosystem.

An ecosystem that makes them what money wise ?

Really think about it what do they gain from owning an ecosystem that pays them squat. They don't sell windows anymore... Their new cloud based subs like office don't care what OS your run. They make zero money from outside stores like steam. Seriously this big great ecosystem you speak of... how does it benefit MS ? I would be willing to bet MS makes more money on sales of MS software from the google play store then they do from their own store... how is windows paying their bills anymore ? Corporate site licences is all they have left and that is in serious danger if they can't sell windows -s to all the companies considering the move to chrome this year.
 
An ecosystem that makes them what money wise ?

It's a competitive advantage that makes them billions because you have to use Windows to access a lot of software. Without the software support there's no reason for many millions to use Windows.
 
I get the reasoning and yes change is inevitable. But it's perfectly reasonable to question how this particular change is even possible. The benefit to Microsoft is 30% from all Windows software sales from the store versus the loss of the largest desktop software ecosystem.

Well that's what happens when MS gives away their core product.
 
It's a competitive advantage that makes them billions because you have to use Windows to access a lot of software. Without the software support there's no reason for many millions to use Windows.

No different to iOS or Android....
 
It's a competitive advantage that makes them billions because you have to use Windows to access a lot of software. Without the software support there's no reason for many millions to use Windows.

Right sure great....

What does MICROSOFT make from that heatle.

New machines that ship with windows are both fewer and have lower licencing fees then ever and dropping every quarter. They are letting vendors ship windows -s for free. Windows -s for free makes sense... they get a 30% cut of the store. New machine sales are slowing, and licencing fees are down.

It makes zero sense for MS to be the only commercial operating system provider offering a product that allows OTHER companies to make billions selling software on the back of their work. AAA PC gaming really hasn't made Microsoft tons of money... it hasn't translated into console game sales as they have hoped. Third party stores like Valves Steam and Facebooks oculus stores make them ZERO.

MS financials are a pain to decipher as they love bundling up their divisions to hide losses. But the "more personal computing" reporting unit is being propped up by a combination of search revenue, patent licencing and staff liquidations. They are not making anything close to billion on end user windows licences anymore... the bulk of their Windows money is coming from long term licence deals. Even in their own Cryptic reports they clearly state commercial windows sales (site licences) are up slightly... end user windows sales are down.

FY17Q3 - "Search advertising revenue increased $81 million or 5%" - "General and administrative expenses decreased $50 million or 13%."
FY17Q2 - "Search advertising revenue increased $177 million or 12%." - "General and administrative expenses decreased $118 million or 31%"
FY17Q1 - "Search advertising revenue increased $409 million or 40%." - "Operating expenses decreased $438 million or 13%"

The take away from their "more personal computing" numbers... are End user sales, and OEM sales of windows are flat at best. Commercial Windows is seeing 1-5% increases in licences (which is likely pretty low considering how many companies should be upgrading from 7... I would expect their numbers to be higher then they are if that was the case). Xbox sales are dropping hard... and what keeps that division in the black. Is quickly growing search revenue, MS using the division to dump patent profits, and a draw down in staff and marketing costs.

Over the next few years something needs to change. They either need the xbox division to pull its weight.... so if scorpio scores that would be food for them. If it flops it will be a disaster. If search revenue stops growing that will likewise be a disaster, it has been show to be slowing only growing 5% this quarter if it flattens that won't be good. As for continuing to reduce operating costs every quarter... they likely still have lots of fat to trim from the Balmer years, still that can't continue to help underwrite weak sales forever.
 
Actually this isn't true. Windows licensing revenue has been holding pretty steady for a good while now, Windows OEM revenue was up 5% in Microsoft's latest financials. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/Investor/earnings/FY-2017-Q3/press-release-webcast

Your read the headline... dig deeper next time;
"Windows OEM revenue increased 5%. Windows OEM Pro revenue grew 10%, outperforming the commercial PC market, primarily due to a higher mix of premium licenses sold. Windows OEM non-Pro revenue declined 1%"

They have made more Money by selling more high end licences. Through a combination of sweetheart deals for a handful of large OEMs.... and by neutering further the versions of windows under pro. Looking at the numbers and this statement its clear the overall number of individual sales is down... dropping prices on pro for some OEMs allowed them to still show revenue increases.

I'm hard on MS on a lot of things... but massaging numbers for investors is something they have gotten very good at over the years.
 
I'd wait to see how restrictive the versions of Linux are, if/when they actually show up.

Microsoft won't let you change your search engine on their "Free" Windows, but they will let your Run Linux where you can just run any software/browser/search engine?

Somehow, I don't think that will work out.

As I suspected (early on page one before this turned into the standard Linux Fan vs Winodws Fan fight), There is was no chance this would be allowed to run on Windows S.

So just because something is in the store, doesn't mean it runs on the Store locked Windows S... What a confusing mess


https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline/2017/05/18/will-linux-distros-run-on-windows-10-s/

Will Linux distros run on Windows 10 S?
Many people have asked “You just announced that Linux distro’s are coming to the Windows Store – will they run on Windows 10 S?”

The answer is No!
 
Back
Top