Linux, iTunes Coming to Microsoft's App Store

It's not unreasonable, nor the first time it's been done. "See you later 16-bit apps. We know you paid for them and did real business things with them, but you'll really want to buy the new version." They successfully went from DOS to Win9x, to the NT family, leaving a trail of unsupported software behind. With 90% market share, they can do it. Like has been said before, what's the alternative (for some of you)? Are you not going to continue to use their stuff?

Your examples are of technological advancements, not restrictions placed on the OS by Microsoft. I am sure you are aware that a 16 bit program could never be run in a 64 bit OS, right? Or that DOS existed right up until the end of Windows 98 Second Edition, right? Also, Windows XP had a command.com option and also, there is always DOSBox if needed. They went from DOS, the Win9X, that had DOS support, to XP based NT kernel, which had a command.com and also, much of the supposed unsupported software actually worked far beyond it actual shelf life. Heck, I see command line programs working in 32 bit OS which has 16 bit capabilities.

Your reasoning is not right in these instances so no, it is completely unreasonable.
 
With 90% market share, they can do it. Like has been said before, what's the alternative (for some of you)? Are you not going to continue to use their stuff?

If in the future all versions can only run Windows Store apps, I wouldn't be able to use their stuff because it wouldn't be able to run my stuff. A 30% from software sales in the Windows Store doesn't even come close to making up for what Microsoft would loose if they completely broke backwards compatibility in all versions of Windows.
 
If in the future all versions can only run Windows Store apps, I wouldn't be able to use their stuff because it wouldn't be able to run my stuff. A 30% from software sales in the Windows Store doesn't even come close to making up for what Microsoft would loose if they completely broke backwards compatibility in all versions of Windows.
What would you do? What would you (or even "the masses") transition to?
 
What would you do? What would you (or even "the masses") transition to?

Nothing, because there will never be a reason to need to switch to anything else. In fact I could go on Amazon, buy Star Trek: Bridge Commander, a game form 2002, install it on my Windows 10 64 bit computer and play it. Just would not be able to force it to 4k res since the game came out when not even 1080p was a thing. Heck, I can still play my Return to Castle Wolfenstein without issue, another 2002 game. :)
 
Nothing, because there will never be a reason to need to switch to anything else. In fact I could go on Amazon, buy Star Trek: Bridge Commander, a game form 2002, install it on my Windows 10 64 bit computer and play it. Just would not be able to force it to 4k res since the game came out when not even 1080p was a thing. Heck, I can still play my Return to Castle Wolfenstein without issue, another 2002 game. :)
So if they broke backwards compatibility, you'd just stay where you are now? You wouldn't hop onboard with that latest version of Windows?
 
What would you do? What would you (or even "the masses") transition to?

If Windows stopped running most of my software I could transition to just about anything. That's why I just don't see this happening. If Microsoft just broke compatibility of most software many people would stop using Windows. I would just because why would I use a product that just abandoned thousands of dollars of my software?
 
If Windows stopped running most of my software I could transition to just about anything. That's why I just don't see this happening. If Microsoft just broke compatibility of most software many people would stop using Windows. I would just because why would I use a product that just abandoned thousands of dollars of my software?
But they'd have new versions of your software ready for you to buy. Wouldn't you want the latest version? Surely there'd be some other factors to pull you along. New hardware support, new Halo game, improved authentication methods.
 
So if they broke backwards compatibility, you'd just stay where you are now? You wouldn't hop onboard with that latest version of Windows?

They are not going to break backwards compatibility at all. There is no evidence that they ever will since they have never done so in the past. On a different note for those programs that require a specific piece of software to run but will only run in 32 bit mode on a older version of Windows, that is exactly what I would install it on. What I said is not them breaking backwards compatibility because, some games or programs were designed to work with only specific setups or drivers, that the game manufacturer did not update for newer Operating Systems. (Or the Game OEM is out of business.)
 
Once again, I understand the concern Windows users have regarding the inclusion of a Window Store in Windows 10.

Who are all these extremely concerned users you keep talking about? They might want to know that the store has been around for more than 5 years and the world is still moving along, you know, just to ease their worries.
 
LOL! Not sure how being interested in VR/AR technology makes one a Microsoft shill.

You know what I am saying. MS now has their own VR offering... so you should stop using their competitions platform and hardware. I think I was clear... I'm glad you love VR, you should be overjoyed that you can now get your employee discount. ;) lol
 
They are not going to break backwards compatibility at all. There is no evidence that they ever will since they have never done so in the past. On a different note for those programs that require a specific piece of software to run but will only run in 32 bit mode on a older version of Windows, that is exactly what I would install it on. What I said is not them breaking backwards compatibility because, some games or programs were designed to work with only specific setups or drivers, that the game manufacturer did not update for newer Operating Systems. (Or the Game OEM is out of business.)
We're playing "what if" games here with the scenario that they are. (or at least I was)

So you get the latest Windows operating system. Try to run something designed for a previous version of the previous Windows operating system and it does not work. That is not breaking backwards compatibility? Granted there's always been a transitionary period. Win9x did 16 & 32bit. 7 got us to 32bit and 64bit, leaving 16bit behind. Each left software in its wake. If it weren't for external (non MS) initiatives like DOSBox, you wouldn't be able to run any of that era software on a Windows 10 install.
 
We're playing "what if" games here with the scenario that they are. (or at least I was)

So you get the latest Windows operating system. Try to run something designed for a previous version of the previous Windows operating system and it does not work. That is not breaking backwards compatibility? Granted there's always been a transitionary period. Win9x did 16 & 32bit. 7 got us to 32bit and 64bit, leaving 16bit behind. Each left software in its wake. If it weren't for external (non MS) initiatives like DOSBox, you wouldn't be able to run any of that era software on a Windows 10 install.

I am just not into the what if game at this time, sorry. On another note, the fact that a program was designed to work with only a specific set of variables and nothing else is not the fault of the OS manufacturer but the program OEM themselves. The advancement of the OS to support newer hardware is not and will never be an intentional effort to break backwards compatibility across the board. However, a program that requires a specific set of stuff can be used on the OS that it supports, no problem there.
 
I am just not into the what if game at this time, sorry. On another note, the fact that a program was designed to work with only a specific set of variables and nothing else is not the fault of the OS manufacturer but the program OEM themselves. The advancement of the OS to support newer hardware is not and will never be an intentional effort to break backwards compatibility across the board. However, a program that requires a specific set of stuff can be used on the OS that it supports, no problem there.
The advancement of the os would be for app security, speed, and Microsoft review. Could be sufficient reasons to unintntionally break backwards comparability with legacy softwares.
 
Wow, did you honestly not look in the mirror when you said that?

And you have the blatant nerve to accuse me of trolling when all you do in every thread is bait! You have a entire thread designed to bait, most of your comments are misinformed snide little baiting remarks that only you think are clever and you accuse me of trolling!

No, I don't look in any mirror, but I honestly think you should!

Awaiting pointless snide and mildly retarded remark in 3,2,1.....
 
Nothing, because there will never be a reason to need to switch to anything else. In fact I could go on Amazon, buy Star Trek: Bridge Commander, a game form 2002, install it on my Windows 10 64 bit computer and play it. Just would not be able to force it to 4k res since the game came out when not even 1080p was a thing. Heck, I can still play my Return to Castle Wolfenstein without issue, another 2002 game. :)

Yeah, you could because in most cases the code base of the games in question have been modified to maintain compatibility with newer operating systems, not the other way around. I've got the original disc of Return To Castle Wolfenstein here, doesn't work under Windows 10.

I have Doom 2 on disc here, it hasn't worked since Windows 98. I download Doom 2 off Steam and it works just fine under Windows 7.

Backwards compatibility is the reason Windows has such a laughable updater, along with the retarded idea of a registry. In itself backwards compatibility is not always a good thing, in most cases it simply results in slowed development.
 
If Windows stopped running most of my software I could transition to just about anything. That's why I just don't see this happening. If Microsoft just broke compatibility of most software many people would stop using Windows. I would just because why would I use a product that just abandoned thousands of dollars of my software?

Apple break compatibility with updates all the time, every time you update OSX/macOS a package breaks and you have to fork out for the newer version. People are used to it and they just pay, most of the time there's an upgrade fee involved instead of full retail. As long as Windows is forced onto the consumer presenting them with the illusion of a complete lack of choice, Microsoft can do whatever they want and with the exception of a few grumbles from enthusiasts life will go on.
 
But they'd have new versions of your software ready for you to buy. Wouldn't you want the latest version? Surely there'd be some other factors to pull you along. New hardware support, new Halo game, improved authentication methods.

But again, what about all the stuff that people already have that's working fine? There's no way that the majority of Windows software will ever make it into the store. The 30% cut from the store is simply no where near what Microsoft looses on dropping 3 decades of backwards compatibility. Sure, new stuff is great but for me it's always been under the context of close to 100% backwards compatibility. Without that backwards compatibility there's no point in using Windows to me.
 
Apple break compatibility with updates all the time, every time you update OSX/macOS a package breaks and you have to fork out for the newer version. People are used to it and they just pay, most of the time there's an upgrade fee involved instead of full retail. As long as Windows is forced onto the consumer presenting them with the illusion of a complete lack of choice, Microsoft can do whatever they want and with the exception of a few grumbles from enthusiasts life will go on.

You dramatically underestimating the importance of Windows backwards compatibility and the countless billions of dollars people have invested in Win32. There'll be a lot more than a few grumbles if millions are faced with chucking away that kind of money.
 
You know what I am saying. MS now has their own VR offering... so you should stop using their competitions platform and hardware. I think I was clear... I'm glad you love VR, you should be overjoyed that you can now get your employee discount. ;) lol

This doesn't make any sense. I've spent a good deal of money of the Vive and will continue to use it. I'm going to pick up one the Microsoft headsets as well. There's no need to pick one over the other, both can be used.
 
But again, what about all the stuff that people already have that's working fine? There's no way that the majority of Windows software will ever make it into the store. The 30% cut from the store is simply no where near what Microsoft looses on dropping 3 decades of backwards compatibility. Sure, new stuff is great but for me it's always been under the context of close to 100% backwards compatibility. Without that backwards compatibility there's no point in using Windows to me.

You seem to be under some illusion that MS makes money on software that isn't in their store or something. They don't. There is no royalty system setup where companies pay a cut to MS if they write a w32 capable program. You seem to think they care if you love your Vive.... they don't they make nothing from it. At the end of the day they are a company who's only responsibility is to make investors money. As far as backwards compatibility being the only reason to run windows... your contradicting yourself my friend. We have all read your arguments for windows 10 and UWP and -s in at least a couple hundred of your 40k+ posts by now. MS goal is to phase out w32 they have said so themselves so I'm not sure why you are arguing that isn't the long term plan.
 
This doesn't make any sense. I've spent a good deal of money of the Vive and will continue to use it. I'm going to pick up one the Microsoft headsets as well. There's no need to pick one over the other, both can be used.

So your going to pickup a MS headset that is = in spec to you Vive... that has access to no software you don't already have access to ?

Wait I know... your Amy Hood aren't you ? My suggestion Amy is to take the money and donate it to a soup kitchen or something and continue using your vive.
 
You dramatically underestimating the importance of Windows backwards compatibility and the countless billions of dollars people have invested in Win32. There'll be a lot more than a few grumbles if millions are faced with chucking away that kind of money.

It happens under OSX/macOS all the time, we already know the result of breaking backwards compatibility.

You dramatically over estimate the importance of Windows. They gave you an OS, you're indebted to them, they will come knocking eventually.
 
You seem to think they care if you love your Vive....

Here's the thing. If something like the Vive keeps people using Windows then you don't think that's to Microsoft advantage? Of course it is. You and others can keep going on and on about the 30% from the store but what I'm talking about is much more basic. Why use Windows if it doesn't support my hardware and software? There is none and wouldn't be for countless millions who would have lost countless billions in software that no longer works on that version of Windows.
 
Here's the thing. If something like the Vive keeps people using Windows then you don't think that's to Microsoft advantage? Of course it is. You and others can keep going on and on about the 30% from the store but what I'm talking about is much more basic. Why use Windows if it doesn't support my hardware and software? There is none and wouldn't be for countless millions who would have lost countless billions in software that no longer works on that version of Windows.

People will still use Windows, just because you have to download software via Microsoft approved channels doesn't in any indicate that people will not use Windows!

Android software installation is based mostly around the Play Store, and yet globally Android is the most popular OS available today and it doesn't have the advantage Microsoft has when they force their OS onto the consumer.
 
Here's the thing. If something like the Vive keeps people using Windows then you don't think that's to Microsoft advantage? Of course it is. You and others can keep going on and on about the 30% from the store but what I'm talking about is much more basic. Why use Windows if it doesn't support my hardware and software? There is none and wouldn't be for countless millions who would have lost countless billions in software that no longer works on that version of Windows.

Don't worry heatle you'll be able to install an old copy of Windows 7 or 8 when the day comes. lol

MS hasn't driven the market in a few years now and they are way to slow to react to changes. Its how they got booted from the mobile space... its how they got booted from the server space... its how they got booted from the net. Googles chromeos should have scared the tar out of them the second google announced it....cause as crazy as it sounds Chrome or its off spring is very likely going to be the dominate PC OS 4-5 years from now. MS best answer to that is to neuter a copy of windows and try and force people to a store ?

You really don't understand what software the majority of users and companies are using these days I guess. Windows isn't required when everything you do is in the cloud. (even programs you would point to and say they will always need windows for this... like say Photoshop isn't even true anymore. It now runs in the cloud with all the processing power being done by adobe servers. $5000 PC performance on a $300 chromebook.) The biggest threat to MS is internet infastructure improvements. Imagine in 3-4 years if google launches a game streaming service that puts insane high end PC gaming performance into a chromeos streaming game store.

MS sees all that coming if you don't.
 
People will still use Windows, just because you have to download software via Microsoft approved channels doesn't in any indicate that people will not use Windows!

Hard to use Windows when it doesn't run the software you want or need and paid good money for.
 
It's not an issue under OSX, I doubt very much it'll be an issue under Windows.

Windows has a 30 year legacy of backwards compatibility. Whatever problems Windows currently has a release of Windows where all versions are totally incompatible with existing Win32 software, from games to LibreOffice to Eclipse and god only can count that high, your bias is missing the just how big of deal this truly is.
 
Windows has a 30 year legacy of backwards compatibility. Whatever problems Windows currently has a release of Windows where all versions are totally incompatible with existing Win32 software, from games to LibreOffice to Eclipse and god only can count that high, your bias is missing the just how big of deal this truly is.

Applications are usually updated to maintain compatibility with newer versions of Windows, it's not just Windows itself maintaining backwards compatibility. I experience compatibility issues with software running under newer versions of Windows daily. The simple task of installing Office 2013 is made far harder than it needs to be due to Microsoft's persistent push to promote Office 365 and it's subscription based model over anything else under Windows 10. The signs are there that either a subscription based model or a Windows Store based model is on the cards for Windows, but you keep insisting it's not going to happen like some desperate plea to the powers that be to allow you to keep using their OS the way you want to use it. Whether you choose to accept that you're eventually going to have to pay for that OS or not won't change the outcome in any way whatsoever.
 
Applications are usually updated to maintain compatibility with newer versions of Windows, it's not just Windows itself maintaining backwards compatibility. I experience compatibility issues with software running under newer versions of Windows daily. The simple task of installing Office 2013 is made far harder than it needs to be due to Microsoft's persistent push to promote Office 365 and it's subscription based model over anything else under Windows 10. The signs are there that either a subscription based model or a Windows Store based model is on the cards for Windows, but you keep insisting it's not going to happen like some desperate plea to the powers that be to allow you to keep using their OS the way you want to use it. Whether you choose to accept that you're eventually going to have to pay for that OS or not won't change the outcome in any way whatsoever.

You're the one looking into a crystal ball trying to predict the future. If you're able to see the future you wouldn't be in this forum.
 
Back
Top