Steam Gifting Changes Crack down on Code Resellers

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Steam has just reduced the potential of their gifting system with two changes: sending another player a gift is only possible at the moment of purchase, and users will no longer be able to send a gift through email. These changes will make resellers’ lives more difficult, as well as those who practice giveaways. You can, however, schedule a gift so it can be delivered at a specific point in the future, and gifting across countries is still possible, assuming there is no large pricing difference between locales.

It's putting the Gift to E-mail and Gift to Inventory options out to pasture, replacing it with a system that directly exchanges games from buyer to receiver. It's most likely an action taken to curtail grey market trades, since resellers tend to buy several copies during sales to sell over time. However, that might also make it impossible for collectors to get old and rare titles. You can at least send gifts months in advance, though, in case you want your friend to receive the game on a special day. That said, things are now more complicated if you have a lot of friends abroad: the gaming platform says you won't be able send a gift if there's a large difference in pricing between countries.
 
It's all 'bout the money
It's all 'bout the dun dun du du du dum
 
You can still buy games from Humble, Gamersgate, etc. then just send your friend the key.
 
Whew, I buy a lot of bundles and always gift friends the extras and dupes.

Yeah ditto. I always wind up with stuff I don't want in the bundles and usually trade or give them away.

I'm all for clamping down on the shady grey market resellers which I won't name. But that doesn't (or shouldn't) have anything to do with gifting.
 
So this only affects stuff bought directly through Steam?

I wasn't aware that there was even the option to gift directly through Steam except right at purchase time.
 
So what about the rest of us sitting on tons of old sale bundles with 3+ copies of each? I still have a bunch of extra games in my inventory.
 
So what about the rest of us sitting on tons of old sale bundles with 3+ copies of each? I still have a bunch of extra games in my inventory.

Yeah, good question...I have some random games sitting around in my inventory, do those just sit there perpetually now?

I understand the reason behind this (and I would never buy a "gift only" key online anyway), but the implementation just seems kind of stupid. Hopefully they will only make this active going forward and allow existing gifts to be transferred.
 
Yeah, good question...I have some random games sitting around in my inventory, do those just sit there perpetually now?

Yeah it would be dumb if suddenly we can't use them. I bought them originally as part of 4 player bundles for games like Borderlands and Killing Floor. Just never got around to gifting them out.
 
Yeah it would be dumb if suddenly we can't use them. I bought them originally as part of 4 player bundles for games like Borderlands and Killing Floor. Just never got around to gifting them out.
Same here. I bought the Torchlight 2 four pack bundle and still have one left. So, am I going to lose that one?
 
I would assume if you already have the games in your inventory you can still gift them. You just can't buy future games that way.
 
So what about the rest of us sitting on tons of old sale bundles with 3+ copies of each? I still have a bunch of extra games in my inventory.

From what I understand from the support guys, you can still give anything already in your inventory just like normal.

If you go to buy anything else in the future though, you no longer have the "add to gift inventory" option.

I had to ask, since I'm in the same boat with about 2 pages of "gift" items in my inventory.
 
There's a huge black market of shady foreign key resellers that have been exploiting the gifting system. They're what's at the root of this change. Long overdue.
Not overdue, since it the right of people to be able to sell their property, such as their software licenses.
 
Not overdue, since it the right of people to be able to sell their property, such as their software licenses.
A software license isn't property, but this change doesn't affect people that already have unused keys in inventory.

This is about cracking down on the operations that are wholesale selling keys from cheap regions and exploiting the gifting system to make a profit.
 
Software license isn't property, but this doesn't affect people that already have unused keys in inventory.

This is about cracking down on the operations that are wholesale selling keys from cheap regions and exploiting the gifting system to make a profit.

Uh, what? Software licenses are personal property. When you buy a software license, which represents an instance of software, there is a transfer of ownership over that software license, and property rights fully apply to that software license.

Additionally, EU's highest court has ruled that it is a person's right to resell their software licenses:
https://www.itassetmanagement.net/2016/10/31/secondary-software-2016/


And banning everyone from driving vehicles could be about preventing drunk drivers, but it still unjustly impacts everyone.
 
Uh, what? Software licenses are personal property. When you buy a software license, there is a transfer of ownership over that software license, and property rights fully apply to that software license.

No, they don't. The specifics on transferring licenses are IN the license. And there's very few of them that will allow you to transfer ownership that easily.
 
Guess I've got to get my brother in law to finally open his Steam account. I've sitting on a dozen games I picked up at hella steals for him for Bday and Xmas.
 
No, they don't. The specifics on transferring licenses are IN the license. And there's very few of them that will allow you to transfer ownership that easily.

You're very wrong, and I don't know where you're getting that idea, but it's not based in anything substantiated in law or software history.

EULAs are not laws, but are business wishes and opinions, which are only binding to the extent that they can be found to conform to law, including those governing property rights. Businesses and corporations do not possess law-making powers.

EULAs sometimes, sometimes even often, contain terms that are non legally-defensible, and which fail the Reasonable Person test. A license itself is an item that is sold, and therefore is a possession, with ownership and decision-making authority that goes with ownership over it transferring at the time of transaction. If you sell your car to somebody, it's no longer your car, but is the person's to whom you sold it. The same is true of software licenses.

EULAs do not decide whether a person can sell a license or not - the authority over the license itself is sold along with the license. For a company to retain decision-making authority over a license after they have given it to somebody, they would have to rent the license, or offer it in a different capacity than a one-time sale of a persistent license, and then entirely different laws would apply to how they market their licenses.

Additionally, EU's highest court has ruled that it is a person's right to resell their software licenses: https://www.itassetmanagement.net/2016/10/31/secondary-software-2016/
 
Last edited:
You're very wrong, and I don't know where you're getting that idea, but it's not based in anything substantiated in law or software history.

EULAs are not laws, but are business wishes and opinions, which are only binding to the extent that they can be found to conform to law, including those governing property rights. Businesses and corporations do not possess law-making powers.

EULAs sometimes, sometimes even often, contain terms that are non legally-defensible, and which fail the Reasonable Person test. A license itself is an item that is sold, and therefore is a possession, with ownership and decision-making authority that goes with ownership over it transferring at the time of transaction. If you sell your car to somebody, it's no longer your car, but is the person's to whom you sold it. The same is true of software licenses.

EULAs do not decide whether a person can sell a license or not - the authority over the license itself is sold along with the license. For a company to retain decision-making authority over a license after they have given it to somebody, they would have to rent the license, or offer it in a different capacity than a one-time sale of a persistent license, and then entirely different laws would apply to how they market their licenses.

Additionally, EU's highest court has ruled that it is a person's right to resell their software licenses: https://www.itassetmanagement.net/2016/10/31/secondary-software-2016/

Most video game EULAs specifically state that the end user is not allowed to sell or transfer the ownership of the license to anyone else, at least in the US.

EULAs are not laws, but they are agreements. And those agreements DO discuss how and where the license can be transferred, at least in the US.

Steam has ZERO obligation to the users to make violation of the EULA easier. In fact, I'd bet they've been under pressure from game developers to stop this practice for some time.
 
Most video game EULAs specifically state that the end user is not allowed to sell or transfer the ownership of the license to anyone else, at least in the US.

EULAs are not laws, but they are agreements. And those agreements DO discuss how and where the license can be transferred, at least in the US.

Steam has ZERO obligation to the users to make violation of the EULA easier. In fact, I'd bet they've been under pressure from game developers to stop this practice for some time.

Virtually nosoftware licenses tell a person that they cannot resell the license. And since, while being contractual agreements, software licenses are subject to law, a stipulation that claims that a person cannot sell their possessed licenses would be legally indefensible.

A software developer or publisher can issue what the licenses they sell refer to in regard to their software, AKA which rights to the software the license includes, but they cannot make dictations over a license itself once they have sold it to someone, because the license is then no longer theirs to make decisions over. To do something like that, they would have to license their licenses. And if a company doesn't want to lose authority over its licenses, then they can't sell them to people - because authority over a thing naturally belongs to whoever owns and possesses that thing. It's the nature of selling something, and is the basis of legal rights over property.

Also, there is a matter of perpetual vs non-perpetual licenses. A perpetual license, which is stuff like non subscription-based games and applications (the typical type of license people buy for their software), works as I've described.
 
Not overdue, since it the right of people to be able to sell their property, such as their software licenses.
So you want steam to dramatically increase the price of games in poor countries? Because that's the only other solution. These guys were buying games in a place where a AAA title is a fraction of the price in the U.S. and then selling them for huge profit here and in other developed countries.
 
Most video game EULAs specifically state that the end user is not allowed to sell or transfer the ownership of the license to anyone else, at least in the US.

EULAs are not laws, but they are agreements. And those agreements DO discuss how and where the license can be transferred, at least in the US.

Steam has ZERO obligation to the users to make violation of the EULA easier. In fact, I'd bet they've been under pressure from game developers to stop this practice for some time.
While I'm OK with steam's change (though it really sucks if you're trying to buy a 4 pack and plan to sell the extra licenses off at a later date), you're wrong about selling a license. A steam key is essentially the same as buying a game at Best Buy and there's nothing that says you can't resell your unused copy of a game to someone else. A key is essentially a shrink wrapped copy of a game.
 
So you want steam to dramatically increase the price of games in poor countries? Because that's the only other solution. These guys were buying games in a place where a AAA title is a fraction of the price in the U.S. and then selling them for huge profit here and in other developed countries.

If Steam increased the prices in countries where people can't reasonably afford them, then people would just all the more purchase from other sources. And Steam already has tools for publishers to prevent what you're describing: software region settings. Steam licenses can be made purchaseable, giftable, tradable, playable, or nor, depending on region. So, if the goal is to prevent cross-region selling of Steam games, then that's already possible for developers and publishers. And like I mentioned, playability is also a configurable restriction for Steam license region: The latest CoD isn't even playable outside of the region the license is for - which means that there are no cheap key sources for people in North America.

CoD Infinite Warfare East Europe license configuration: https://steamdb.info/sub/102851/

The game already can't be bought from that region and sold to be played in other regions, because the application is only able to be run from those countries.

I also believe that trouncing peoples rights is not excusable by a highly dubious claim of saving some people some money.
 
Last edited:
Virtually no software licenses tell a person that they cannot resell the license. And since, while being contractual agreements, software licenses are subject to law, a stipulation that claims that a person cannot sell their possessed licenses would be legally indefensible.

A software developer or publisher can issue what the licenses they sell refer to in regard to their software, AKA which rights to the software the license includes, but they cannot make dictations over a license itself once they have sold it to someone, because the license is then no longer theirs to make decisions over. To do something like that, they would have to license their licenses. And if a company doesn't want to lose authority over its licenses, then they can't sell them to people - because authority over a thing naturally belongs to whoever owns and possesses that thing. It's the nature of selling something, and is the basis of legal rights over property.

Virtually every game license says exactly that. Some are enforceable, some are not, depending on the particulars of the license and the court that hears the case. You don't buy software, you buy the right to use the software in most cases. Regardless, Steam has no requirement to ALLOW that on their service.

It largely hinges on if you consider a license a software physical "thing" or an agreement. By definition it's simply an agreement between you and the company. You give them some money, they'll let you use their software. Most of them include LOTS of clauses on HOW you can use it, exactly contrary to what you just said. They can make all sorts of distinctions about how it can or can't be used, and they DO all the damn time. A piece of software on a disc is a "thing"...a "license" is just a contract, and that's a very different story.

Some of those distinctions are enforceable, some are not. Some are good ideas, some aren't. But regardless of if you personally agree or not, the courts in the US have not always agreed on the side of the buyer.
 
While I'm OK with steam's change (though it really sucks if you're trying to buy a 4 pack and plan to sell the extra licenses off at a later date), you're wrong about selling a license. A steam key is essentially the same as buying a game at Best Buy and there's nothing that says you can't resell your unused copy of a game to someone else. A key is essentially a shrink wrapped copy of a game.

I would imagine there'd be one of two answers to the first point...Either they won't sell 4-packs anymore, or they'll make an exception. I'd imagine they'd stop selling the 4 packs personally.

There's alllll sorts of things that prevent you from reselling used PC games. Some legal, some technical. Especially considering when you buy PC games these days, you're buying a plastic box with a key code, and you still need to d/l the entire game. Ever punched in a key and gotten the "that key has already been used" error? You're not buying the game at Best Buy, you're buying a license to assign that game to your Steam/EA/Uplay account, and that's very different than a physical copy of the game.
 
Virtually every game license says exactly that. Some are enforceable, some are not, depending on the particulars of the license and the court that hears the case.

If you look at a handful of software licenses right now to verify your comment, you're going to find that they don't actually say such things. They generally make no mention of transferability - and if one does, it's generally just a business' wet dream. Software EULAs are as much about psyching out people into conforming the behaviour that's desired as they are about anything - but when a publisher pulls such a move, they run the risk of having their entire terms legally void. Again, EULAs are not laws.

Also: http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=148be5c9-c0d4-4ff7-8dbd-d15884250729

You don't buy software, you buy the right to use the software in most cases.

'This software is licensed, not sold' means: The software IP is not sold, but licensed. The software licenses that represent instances of that software, however, are sold. The software (IP) is not sold, but the software (license) is sold.
 
Last edited:
I would imagine there'd be one of two answers to the first point...Either they won't sell 4-packs anymore, or they'll make an exception. I'd imagine they'd stop selling the 4 packs personally.

There's alllll sorts of things that prevent you from reselling used PC games. Some legal, some technical. Especially considering when you buy PC games these days, you're buying a plastic box with a key code, and you still need to d/l the entire game. Ever punched in a key and gotten the "that key has already been used" error? You're not buying the game at Best Buy, you're buying a license to assign that game to your Steam/EA/Uplay account, and that's very different than a physical copy of the game.
You can still sell the box and therefore you're selling the key. The EULA was designed to prevent you from selling a used copy of a game, not to keep you from gifting a game or selling an unused game to someone else.
 
Virtually every game license says exactly that. Some are enforceable, some are not, depending on the particulars of the license and the court that hears the case. You don't buy software, you buy the right to use the software in most cases. Regardless, Steam has no requirement to ALLOW that on their service.

It largely hinges on if you consider a license a software physical "thing" or an agreement. By definition it's simply an agreement between you and the company. You give them some money, they'll let you use their software. Most of them include LOTS of clauses on HOW you can use it, exactly contrary to what you just said. They can make all sorts of distinctions about how it can or can't be used, and they DO all the damn time. A piece of software on a disc is a "thing"...a "license" is just a contract, and that's a very different story.

Some of those distinctions are enforceable, some are not. Some are good ideas, some aren't. But regardless of if you personally agree or not, the courts in the US have not always agreed on the side of the buyer.
Hmm...if that's true, then I'm not sure what the grey market guys are doing.
 
Hmm...if that's true, then I'm not sure what the grey market guys are doing.

There's a reason it's called "grey market".

You can still sell the box and therefore you're selling the key. The EULA was designed to prevent you from selling a used copy of a game, not to keep you from gifting a game or selling an unused game to someone else.

If you haven't OPENED the copy yet and it's a new game, that's different, because you never accepted the EULA. In that case, it's perfectly legit to resell it. You accept the EULA on installation, not purchase, at least for physical copies.

If you look at a handful of software licenses right now to verify your comment, you're going to find that they don't actually say such things. They generally make no mention of transferability - and if one does, it's generally just a business' wet dream. Software EULAs are as much about psyching out people into conforming the behaviour that's desired as they are about anything - but when a publisher pulls such a move, they run the risk of having their entire terms legally void. Again, EULAs are not laws.

Also: http://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=148be5c9-c0d4-4ff7-8dbd-d15884250729

'This software is licensed, not sold' means: The software IP is not sold, but licensed. The software licenses that represent instances of that software, however, are sold. The software (IP) is not sold, but the software (license) is sold.

I agree, they're NOT laws, they're agreements or contracts. Businesses don't get to write laws. However they CAN enforce the terms of that contract via the court system, at least in the US. If they say "can't be sold/transferred", and you agree, you may be stuck. You may try to pass that CD or key to someone, and they won't be able to get it working because the key is marked as "already used". At that point, YOU have to take them to court to get the license transferred. And then you have to convince the court that your right of 1st sale defeats the EULA that you agreed to. In some places you might win that argument. In other places, you'd lose. Period.

EULAs are the software company trying to clearly define what they're selling you. Sometimes they're perfectly honest boilerplate to keep themselves from being sued. Sometimes they're trying to push the limits of their rights and boost their profits. But regardless, some courts consider them binding contracts in some cases.

This has happened to many people many times, and while I understand you don't agree with this fact (and honestly I don't either), it's still fact.
 
You can still transfer any gifts that are currently in your inventory. What steam is essentially doing is refusing sale if the transaction would violate their terms of use, which they have a right to do.
 
Well this is shit.

Whenever Trails in The Sky FC & SC go on sale. I buy both to gift someone.
(Because I am a bad bad Falcom fanboy.)

This will make this more difficult if I dont' already have someone who is interested lined up.
 
Back
Top