heatlesssun
Extremely [H]
- Joined
- Nov 5, 2005
- Messages
- 44,154
Sigh...after years of fighting him I'm going to have to side with Heatless on this one.
I'm well known for my resentment of Win 8. So before any of you discount a thing I say, just remember that I fought Win 8 with a passion from the very first preview.
I think sometimes we forget that reasonable people can disagree, even much of time, and that no one is always right. Somethings I got wrong about Windows 8, such as the level of willingness and/or ability to pick up the new UI on traditional hardware. I still think it's not as bad as UI as you and others think on the desktop but clearly your side won. Somethings I think I got right, on the right hardware it's a very good hybrid OS and actually did help to push that category far enough that it even got Apple's interest.
Security - Now I'll be the first to state that I dislike the amount of "spying" that goes on in the background. And that they could certainly be quite a bit more upfront with it. However the base amount really isn't any different than what Windows would always do if you submitted an error report. Sure it takes a bit of knowledge to turn it all off beyond that and that is obviously difficult for some users. However at the same time there are lots of things that basic users can't do in any version of windows, so Ignorance comes at a price. Beyond that, I STILL Fully agree with windows updates being mandatory. I'm sorry but I've had to fix far too many shit boxes over the years that got that way because johnny jackass turned off their updates.
Are there privacy concerns with Windows 10? Yes. Are they any different from the countless mobile devices and online services and applications that billions each day use religiously? Even with older versions of Windows and potentially even Linux? No. I got a chuckle the other day reading the comments in an article about Microsoft's email policy when one of the posters mentioned how he was going to stick with Windows 7. I think these kinds of comments prove just how little some of the most vocal people on this issue really haven't thought it through and are just using it to bash Windows 10.
TLDR: This is what Win 8 Should have been and if it Had been would have been far better received.
Outside of the typical bubble in places like this, that has indeed been the case with Windows 10. Whatever the privacy issues are they are no where the visibility issues of Windows 8's UI. The free upgrade has been an overall positive thing. People will complain about security and the forced updates and this and that but overall Windows 10 seems to be doing what it needs to. Work well as a desktop OS and still be viable on tablets. That was thing this it HAD to do and I think there it's already succeeded. The other issues are secondary. The privacy stuff can be tweaked a bit if push comes to shove. The forced updates is a lot tougher one with an Agile process that's all about incremental improvements and updates. You pretty much break that process with skipped updates. Drivers could probably me more flexible.